What Is Out of Liberty About?
The premise of Out of Liberty in 330 words, with nothing given away. The full story follows below.
markdown Set against the stark, frozen landscape of the 1839 American frontier, Out of Liberty immerses viewers in a small Missouri town where the boundaries between civilization and chaos blur with every passing day. The film carries the grit and weight of a historical drama, painting frontier life in shades of gray rather than the bold contrasts of simpler Western tales. Every wooden plank, whispered conversation, and creaking door seems to hum with unease, hinting that the ordinary routines of this settlement are quietly unraveling.
At the heart of the story stands deputy jailer Samuel Tillery, a man caught in the uneasy space between duty and conscience. Tasked with guarding Missouri’s most wanted criminals, he is not a celebrated hero but a working man thrust into extraordinary circumstances. His responsibilities extend beyond locked doors, however, as he must also contend with the restless, volatile townspeople whose hunger for vengeance simmers just beyond the jail’s walls. This dual burden — keeping prisoners inside while keeping a mob outside — defines the moral tug-of-war at the center of the film.
The prisoners themselves, including the prominent Joseph Smith, bring their own weight and complexity to the story, their presence transforming a simple holding cell into a flashpoint for larger questions about law, faith, and justice. Tillery’s relationships with these men gradually shift the texture of the narrative, suggesting that guarding another person is never a one-sided act. The town watches with growing suspicion, and the tension between legal process and frontier vigilantism becomes the film’s beating pulse.
Tone and atmosphere carry as much narrative weight as dialogue, lending the story a contemplative, almost reverent quality befitting its historical foundations. The film draws its power from the slow accumulation of pressure rather than spectacle, inviting audiences to sit beside Tillery as he wrestles with the meaning of justice in a place where the rules are still being written. It’s a story about the cost of holding the line when no clear line exists.
What Happens in Out of Liberty?
The complete story of Out of Liberty, from the first scene to the last, in 428 words (about 2 minutes). Spoilers throughout.
Spoilers ahead
“On the American frontier, Joseph Smith and five other prisoners’ attempt to escape the dungeon of Liberty Jail as they are repeatedly thwarted by deputy jailer Samuel Tillery. While keeping the prisoners inside, Samuel is also busy keeping angry mobs outside from breaking in and killing the prisoners. As Samuel tries to keep the prisoners safely in jail until their day in court arrives, he begins to wonder whether or not justice might be given to them better in some other way.”
The film opens with Joseph Smith speaking with his lawyer Alexander Doniphan about his and his fellow prisoners’ upcoming trial. Below them, in the dungeon of the jail, the other five prisoners are planning an escape attempt. When the lawyer leaves, and the prisoners are brought up alongside Joseph, this first escape attempt fails, as Lyman Wight is too sick to make it out the door – and the prisoners decide they cannot leave without him.
The next day, before another escape attempt, the prisoners receive visitors – Porter Rockwell and Cyrus Daniels. This second escape attempt, like the first, fails when Tillery and his two guards fight against the prisoners and keep them locked inside. Hearing of this escape attempt, a mob from nearby Liberty comes for some frontier justice, to kill the prisoners for their escape attempt. The prisoners are defended by the jailer.
Rockwell later returns to give the prisoners tools with which they begin to tunnel out of jail – the beginning of a third escape attempt.
During the process of their tunneling out of jail, a court of inquiry is held in which it is decided if the prisoners will go to trial for treason. Court is held in a schoolhouse, as a mob intent on killing the prisoners prevented them from being brought into the courthouse, and the mob shows up to the courthouse to threaten the judge and the prisoners if the prisoners are to be let free. During the trial, Sidney Rigdon, representing himself, convinces Judge Turnham to let him free. The other prisoners return to jail.
It is discovered that the prisoners are tunneling out of jail, and their hole is filled in.
In a moment of despair, Smith prays for guidance, and receives comfort through revelation. This is the revelation later canonized in the Doctrine and Covenants scriptures.
As the prisoners are being transported to another jail for trial there is a final showdown between the mob, the jailer, and the prisoners. After this showdown the prisoners are allowed to escape, by their jailer, Samuel Tillery.
Out of Liberty Timeline: Every Key Event in Order
13 key events in the order they happen, from “Discussing the Upcoming Trial” to “Tillery Lets Them Go”. 11 events name a place, across 4 locations.
- 1
Discussing the Upcoming Trial
Joseph Smith meets with his lawyer, Alexander Doniphan, to discuss his upcoming trial. They go over the legal situation while the other prisoners remain locked below. Doniphan eventually leaves, and the prisoners are brought up alongside Joseph.
Where:Liberty Jail
- 2
Planning the First Escape
Down in the jail dungeon, Joseph Smith's five fellow prisoners begin an escape attempt. Their hope is to break free of the jail before their trial can take place.
Where:Dungeon of Liberty Jail
- 3
First Escape Attempt Fails
The prisoners' first escape attempt collapses when Lyman Wight is found to be too sick to make it out the door. The group decides they cannot abandon him and leave without him. Their attempt is thwarted before it truly begins.
Where:Liberty Jail
- 4
A Day of Visitors
The following day, before a second escape attempt, the prisoners receive visitors at the jail. Porter Rockwell and Cyrus Daniels come to see the imprisoned men. The visit offers them encouragement and connection with the outside world.
When:The next day Where:Liberty Jail
- 5
Second Escape Attempt Fails
Taking advantage of the day's commotion, the prisoners make a second try at escaping. Deputy jailer Samuel Tillery and his two guards fight against the prisoners and manage to keep them locked inside. Once again, the escape ends in failure.
When:The next day Where:Liberty Jail
- 6
The Mob Comes for Justice
Word of the escape attempt reaches nearby Liberty, and an angry mob arrives intent on frontier justice. They want to break into the jail and kill the prisoners for trying to escape. Samuel Tillery stands his ground and defends the prisoners, keeping the mob outside at bay.
Where:Outside Liberty Jail
- 7
Tools for a Tunnel
Porter Rockwell returns to the jail and brings the prisoners tools. With these tools, they begin digging a tunnel out of the jail, launching a third escape attempt. The work is slow and must be done in secret.
Where:Liberty Jail
- 8
The Court of Inquiry
While the tunneling continues, a court of inquiry is held to decide whether the prisoners will go to trial for treason. Because a mob prevents the prisoners from being brought into the courthouse, the hearing is moved to a schoolhouse. The mob shows up there as well, threatening both the judge and the prisoners.
Where:Schoolhouse
- 9
Rigdon Walks Free
During the proceedings, Sidney Rigdon represents himself before Judge Turnham. He manages to convince the judge to let him go free. The remaining prisoners have no such luck and are returned to jail.
Where:Schoolhouse
- 10
The Tunnel Is Discovered
The prisoners' secret tunneling work is eventually discovered by the jailers. Their escape hole is filled in, destroying weeks of effort. The third escape attempt ends without the men ever leaving the jail.
Where:Dungeon of Liberty Jail
Show the other 3 events of Out of Liberty Hide the last 3 events
- 11
A Revelation in the Depths of Despair
In a moment of deep despair, Joseph Smith turns to prayer and asks God for guidance. He receives comfort and direction through revelation. This revelation would later be canonized in the Doctrine and Covenants scriptures.
Where:Liberty Jail
- 12
The Final Showdown
As the prisoners are being transported to another jail for trial, they face one last confrontation. A final showdown erupts between the mob, the jailer, and the prisoners. Tensions reach their peak as Samuel Tillery must once again choose where his loyalties lie.
- 13
Tillery Lets Them Go
After the showdown, something has changed in Samuel Tillery. He comes to believe that justice might be better served in another way than a trial. Tillery allows the prisoners to escape, freeing them from his custody at last.
Who Are the Main Characters in Out of Liberty?
4 characters, among them Joseph Smith, Samuel Tillery and Lyman Wight: who each one is and the part they play in the story. Every profile links to the actor’s page.
- JS
Joseph Smith
Played by Brandon Ray Olive
Joseph Smith, a charismatic leader and prophet, embodies the struggle for faith and perseverance in the face of adversity. His deep sense of purpose drives him to seek freedom not only for himself but for his fellow prisoners. Smith’s reliance on prayer and revelation highlights his spiritual strength during dire circumstances.
- 🙇♂️ Faith
- 🗣️ Leadership
- ST
Samuel Tillery
Played by Jasen Wade
Samuel Tillery is portrayed as a conflicted deputy jailer who grapples with his duties and the emerging moral dilemmas of justice. Though tasked with keeping the prisoners confined, his actions suggest a struggle between his loyalty to the law and his growing sympathy towards the prisoners. Tillery's character evolution raises questions about justice and humanity.
- 🤔 Morality
- ⚖️ Justice
- LW
Lyman Wight
Played by Morgan Gunter
Lyman Wight is one of the prisoners whose loyal friendship adds depth to the group dynamic. His illness during the escape attempts underscores the sacrifices made for loyalty and kinship. Wight's tenacity, even in sickness, reflects the collective struggle for freedom among the prisoners.
- 🤝 Friendship
- 🙌 Sacrifice
- SR
Sidney Rigdon
Played by Brock Roberts
Sidney Rigdon serves as a pivotal character advocating for the prisoners’ cause. His determination to represent himself during the trial shows his resilience and unwavering belief in justice despite external pressures. Rigdon's cunning and intelligence amplify the narrative's tension surrounding law and order.
- 🎓 Intelligence
- 🗡️ Advocacy
Where and When Is Out of Liberty Set?
Out of Liberty is set in Liberty Jail and American frontier (19th century). Here is why the time and place matter to the story.
When
19th century
The 19th century was marked by significant westward expansion in America, alongside conflicts arising from cultural and religious differences. This period saw the rise of new religious movements, including the Latter Day Saint movement led by Joseph Smith, which faced opposition and persecution. Events typically unfolded against a backdrop of tension between settlers and mobs, revealing the complexities of justice and liberty.
Where
Liberty Jail, American frontier
Liberty Jail is a historical site known for its harsh conditions and significant role in American religious history. Located on the American frontier, it symbolizes the struggle for justice and freedom. The surrounding wilderness represents both the beauty and danger of frontier life during this tumultuous period.
- 🏞️ Wilderness
- ⚖️ Justice
What Are the Themes of Out of Liberty?
2 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Freedom and Conflict.
-
01
Freedom
The quest for freedom is a central theme in the film as the prisoners, led by Joseph Smith, seek to escape unjust imprisonment. Their struggle against both physical confinement and societal oppression highlights the innate desire for liberty. This theme resonates deeply with the historical context of the American frontier and the hardships faced by many seeking religious and personal freedoms.
-
02
Conflict
Conflict serves as a key theme throughout the narrative, manifesting in the struggles between the prisoners and the jailers, as well as the mobs outside. This tension provides insight into the larger social conflicts of the era, particularly regarding law, order, and justice. The dynamic between Samuel Tillery and the prisoners reveals complexities in human morality amidst chaos.
What Kind of Film Is Out of Liberty?
Tense in tone, with variable pacing and a moderate story, going by the plot summary.
- Tone
- Tense
- Pacing
- Variable
- Story
- Moderate
- Intensity
- High
- Ending
- Bittersweet
A claustrophobic frontier drama steeped in religious persecution and survival, where constant threats of mob violence and repeated escape attempts create a heavy, tense atmosphere anchored by one jailer's moral struggle.
- tense
- claustrophobic
- anxious
- oppressive
- gritty
- suspenseful
- religious persecution
- imprisonment
- mob justice
- escape
Content notes: threats of execution, mob violence, religious persecution, imprisonment, physical altercation.
Quiz
How well do you remember Out of Liberty? Test yourself on the story.
