Too Many Girls 1940

Music

Comedy

Runtime

85 mins

Language

English

Directed by

George Abbott

Made by

RKO Radio Pictures

Where to Watch Too Many Girls

See current US streaming, rental, and purchase options for Too Many Girls (1940) via JustWatch.

TCM

Amazon Video

Apple TV Store

Fandango At Home

Google Play Movies

YouTube

Streaming availability powered by

Test your knowledge of Too Many Girls with our quiz!

Too Many Girls Plot Summary

Read the complete plot summary and ending explained for Too Many Girls (1940). From turning points to emotional moments, uncover what really happened and why it matters.

Tycoon Harvey Casey is exasperated by his daughter, Connie Casey, continuously slipping past her hired bodyguards. Fresh from finishing school in Italy, she returns to the United States with a determined plan: enroll at Pottawatomie College in Stop Gap, New Mexico, and pursue life on the campus—despite her father’s insistence on protecting her. Harvey worries not only about her safety but also about the college’s future, and he hatches a discreet solution.

He turns to a quartet of young men—Clint Kelly, a Princeton football star; Jojo Jordan; Manuelito Lynch; and Al Terwilliger—to serve as Connie’s bodyguards while she studies. The men sign contracts that include an almost comical “anti-romance” clause, designed to keep their cover intact and keep Connie from knowing they’re watching over her. With the money from their salaries, they practically bankroll the team, contributing to a campus already feeling the bite of financial strain.

Meanwhile, the college’s fortunes hinge on the help of the student leaders, including Eileen and Pepe, who work to raise funds to stave off debt. As the newcomers arrive, Connie befriends these two spirited students, while also keeping a wary eye on anyone who might be tailing her. The boys quickly win favor on campus, and they use their presence to lift the football program from mediocre to formidable, drawing praise—and even more attention—from everyone around them.

[Bev]erly Waverly, the British playwright who has become part of the campus chatter, becomes a focal point for Connie’s intrigue. Clint soon uncovers a surprising twist: Connie didn’t come to study alone—she came to chase Beverly Waverly, a revelation that complicated everyone’s feelings and threatened the fragile balance the men had established at Pottawatomie.

As the season unfolds, the dynamic among the players shifts. While the football team’s success brings fame and pressure, it also tempts the young men to bend their rules for the sake of the women who pursue them, even as the “anti-romance” clause continues to loom over their unusual arrangement. Harvey leverages his influence to extend the team’s reach, complicating loyalties and testing each man’s commitment.

Connie’s feelings for Clint grow clearer, and the tension between professional obligation and personal desire becomes harder to ignore. When Connie finally reveals who she is, Clint openly shares the truth about their protected arrangement and the team’s secret contracts. The revelation pushes Connie to a dramatic decision: she leaves Pottawatomie, insisting the boys come back east with her.

The student body, defiant and desperate to keep the football heroes, stages a bold stand—taking the team hostage as leverage. The plan backfires in a tense showdown; Manuelito is captured, and the others narrowly escape. Beverly intervenes, persuading Connie to allow the quartet to return and continue playing. Clint initially resists, but Connie’s arrival and confession of love breaks through the guard he had built around his heart.

In the end, the big game arrives, and the team delivers a hard-fought victory. The campus erupts in celebration, and the couple—Clint and Connie—share a dance that seals their bond and the college’s renewed sense of hope. The story closes on a note of reunion and triumph, underscored by the choices each character made along the way and the understanding that protection can take many forms, even when it means risking a little romance to preserve something larger than themselves.

Too Many Girls Timeline

Follow the complete movie timeline of Too Many Girls (1940) with every major event in chronological order. Great for understanding complex plots and story progression.

Harvey hatches Connie's bodyguard plan

Tycoon Harvey Casey laments Connie's constant escapes from her guards and decides to hire a discreet team to protect her at Pottawatomie College. He specifically aims to enlist Princeton star Clint Kelly and three fellow players to serve as her guards while she studies. The plan is designed to keep Connie safe without drawing attention to their identities.

Harvey Casey's office

Connie returns to the United States with plans for Pottawatomie

Connie finishes school in Italy and comes back to the United States intent on attending Pottawatomie College in Stop Gap, New Mexico. Harvey's fears about her safety rise as she resumes her accustomed independence. Her arrival sets the stage for the bodyguard arrangement.

Stop Gap, New Mexico

The four players sign on as Connie's discreet bodyguards

Clint Kelly and his three teammates accept the unusual assignment to protect Connie at the college. They accept the contracts that will keep their identities hidden from her. Their new roles align with Harvey's plan to shield Connie while combining their athletic talents with campus life.

Pottawatomie College, Stop Gap, NM

Anti-romance clause signed

The players sign contracts that include an 'anti-romance' clause to conceal their protective roles from Connie. The clause foreshadows the romance tension that will complicate their mission. This legal safeguard becomes a recurring obstacle as emotions rise.

Pottawatomie College

Finance scramble on campus

With the college in debt trouble, student leaders Eileen and Pepe organize a fundraising drive to raise $300. The four players contribute their salaries to help the cause. The gesture underscores how the guards’ presence unexpectedly strengthens the team's finances and morale.

Pottawatomie College campus

The guards arrive and boost the football team

Clint, Jojo, Manuelito, and Al arrive and use their leadership to revitalize Pottawatomie's football program. The team quickly becomes one of the country’s strongest, and the guards become campus celebrities. Their success broadens Connie's circle of influence on campus.

Pottawatomie College football field

Connie's motive revealed to Clint on the bus

Clint learns that Connie's visit is tied to pursuing a relationship with Beverly Waverly, not just protection. He notices Connie delivering a letter to an Indian man, addressed to Beverly, while they ride the bus together. The revelation marks the first major crack in the guards' arrangement.

Bus ride to Stop Gap

Clint withdraws as fans pursue the others

As Connie and the others win popularity, the other three guards draw attention from female students, while Clint withdraws to focus on his studies and job. The social dynamics on campus push him into a more isolated role. The internal pressure signals where their relationships are headed.

Pottawatomie College

Harvey uses his connections to bolster the team

Harvey leverages his influence to expand the team's reach and resources beyond the campus. The guards’ presence is stretched to new opportunities, heightening the stakes for their secret arrangement. The dynamic blurs lines between school life, athletics, and private loyalty.

Pottawatomie College

Connie pursues Clint; romance blossoms

Connie begins pursuing Clint, and he grows to care for her despite the anti-romance clause. Their evolving romance threatens to derail the original purpose of the disguise. The couple's emotions complicate their obligations and their place on the team.

Pottawatomie College

Connie reveals her identity; Clint reveals the truth

Connie finally tells Clint who she really is and what the guards are. In response, Clint and the other guards confess their true positions and the anti-romance clause. The truth dismantles the protective cover and tests their loyalties.

Pottawatomie College

Connie forces the guards to return East

Devastated by the revelation, Connie drops out of Pottawatomie and orders the guards to come back East with her. The student body reacts as the football stars face relocation and questions about their futures. The campus feels the impact of losing the team’s guardians.

Pottawatomie College

Hostage crisis and escape

The student body stages a hostage situation to pressure the guards to stay, capturing Manuelito while the others escape. The crisis exposes the campus’s willingness to go to extremes for the players. Beverly's involvement helps untangle the situation.

Pottawatomie College campus

Beverly intervenes and the guards return to play

Beverly Waverly convinces Connie to allow the guards to return and play. Clint initially refuses but Connie persuades him and confesses her love. The team reconciles with the plan to compete and the guard's duties resume.

Pottawatomie College

Big game triumph and celebratory dance

The team wins the big game, validating the guards’ unlikely alliance and Connie’s daring choice. Clint and Connie share a dance as the campus celebrates the victory and the romance that survived the season. The crowd cheers as the college joyfully commemorates the success.

Pottawatomie College stadium

Too Many Girls Characters

Explore all characters from Too Many Girls (1940). Get detailed profiles with their roles, arcs, and key relationships explained.

Connie Casey (Lucille Ball)

An impulsive, strong-willed heiress who returns from finishing school intent on attending college. She arrives with a plan to hire discreet bodyguards to keep her safe and free to pursue her dreams at Pottawatomie. Her flirtatious personality clashes with the anti-romance clauses and draws Clint into a complicated romance. As her schemes unfold, she learns to balance independence with genuine affection.

🎀 Heiress 🕊️ Independent 🎭 Entertainer

Clint Kelly (Richard Carlson)

A Princeton football star who becomes Connie's protector and eventual love interest. He is disciplined and focused on his studies and the team, initially keeping his distance because of the contract. His feelings for Connie complicate the anti-romance clause and test his priorities. He must choose between duty and desire as the romance deepens.

🏈 Athlete 🎯 Focused 💬 Reserved

Jojo Jordan (Eddie Bracken)

A fellow football player and comedic foil who brings camaraderie and levity to the group. He supports the plan to guard Connie while keeping up team spirit and school pride. His presence helps drive the film's lighthearted humor. He remains a loyal teammate throughout the upheaval.

🎭 Comic 👫 Loyal ⚽ Teammate

Manuelito Lynch (Desi Arnaz)

A witty, charismatic member of the bodyguard group who adds charm and resourcefulness. He helps navigate the group’s financial and logistical needs while keeping spirits high. Manuelito contributes to the team dynamic with humor and quick thinking. His allyship strengthens the trio's efforts to protect Connie and the college.

🎷 Charmer 🗺️ Resourceful 🤝 Loyal

Beverly Waverly (Douglas Walton)

A British playwright who becomes the object of Connie's romantic interest and a foil to the college's plans. His presence introduces a literary and cultured angle to the campus comedy. He embodies a refined charm that contrasts with the scrappy, athletic energy of the students. His role amplifies the theme of unexpected romance on campus.

🎩 Playwright 🕊️ Romantic 🧭 Foreign charm

Al Terwilliger (Hal Le Roy)

One of the football players and a key member of the group providing protection and camaraderie. He contributes to the team's dynamic and the film’s infectious energy. His presence helps fuel the athletic and comedic beats that drive the story. He stands as a reliable ally to Clint and Connie's evolving relationship.

⚽ Teammate 🎶 Entertainer 🕺 Lively

Harvey Casey (Harry Shannon)

Connie's protective tycoon father who uses his influence to support the football program and keep his daughter safe. He is wary of Connie's plans and manipulates connections to influence the college's fate. His protective stance sets up the central tension between freedom and control. His actions propel the plot toward a resolution that reconciles family ambition with love.

🧔 Tycoon 🛡️ Protective 🕵️ Strategic

Eileen Eilers (Frances Langford)

A student leader who helps raise funds to keep the college afloat and energizes campus activism. She forms part of the community rallying to save Pottawatomie through student efforts. Her leadership provides a counterpoint to Connie's impulsive plans, grounding the campus in collective action. She and Pepe symbolize student agency in the film.

🎤 Activist 🗳️ Fundraiser 💃 Charismatic

Pepe (Ann Miller)

A fellow student leader and performer who rounds out the fundraising efforts and campus performances. She adds to the musical and social energy of the campus scenes. Pepe’s participation underscores the communal spirit of the film's college setting. She complements Eileen in driving student-led solutions.

🎭 Performer 👫 Friend 💃 Entertainer

Too Many Girls Settings

Learn where and when Too Many Girls (1940) takes place. Explore the film’s settings, era, and how they shape the narrative.

Time period

1940

Set in the early 1940s, the film captures a prewar American college atmosphere filled with song and dance. The era shapes fashion, humor, and social expectations that drive the romantic plot. The college grapples with funds and reputation while the football team and campus life provide the energy of the period.

Location

Pottawatomie College, Stop Gap, New Mexico, United States

The story unfolds on the campus of Pottawatomie College in Stop Gap, New Mexico, a small school facing financial trouble. The setting mixes campus life, football enthusiasm, and musical numbers as students rally to save the college. Stop Gap serves as a backdrop where college pride, romance, and schemes collide.

🎓 College town

Too Many Girls Themes

Discover the main themes in Too Many Girls (1940). Analyze the deeper meanings, emotional layers, and social commentary behind the film.

💘

Romance

Connie's arrival and her pursuit of independence spark a romance that challenges the anti-romance clause. Clint's measured, steady nature contrasts with Connie's impulsiveness, creating tension and growth for both. The film uses lighthearted miscommunications and musical moments to explore how love can disrupt plans. Ultimately, genuine affection overrides restrictions, guiding the pair toward a hopeful union.

🏈

Football

The football team evolves from a losing squad to a success, driven by the enthusiasm of the players. Football becomes a vehicle for saving the college from debt, drawing attention and funds. The team’s popularity spills into campus life, creating excitement and chaos alike. The climactic game ties school pride to personal relationships and communal victory.

🕵️

Secrecy

The anti-romance clause and the assignment of bodyguards create constant concealment and intrigue. Contracts, disguises, and secret agendas turn the campus into a stage for mistaken identities and comic misdirection. Connie and Clint navigate rules that force hidden feelings and hidden roles. The reveal brings honesty and closure amid the film’s playful energy.

Coming soon on iOS and Android

The Plot Explained Mobile App

From blockbusters to hidden gems — dive into movie stories anytime, anywhere. Save your favorites, discover plots faster, and never miss a twist again.

Explore the mobile app

Too Many Girls Spoiler-Free Summary

Discover the spoiler-free summary of Too Many Girls (1940). Get a concise overview without any spoilers.

In the sun‑baked town of Stop Gap, New Mexico, Pottawatomie College teeters on the brink of financial collapse, its modest campus humming with the quiet hopes of a close‑knit student body. Against this backdrop, Connie Casey returns from a European finishing school with a single, determined goal: enroll at the college and carve out a life of her own, oblivious to the protective web her father has woven around her. Harvey Casey, a self‑made tycoon, worries both for his daughter’s safety and for the school’s dwindling purse strings, prompting him to devise a discreet solution that blends paternal concern with a dash of entrepreneurial flair.

Enter a quartet of charismatic young men recruited to serve as Connie’s unseen guardians. Clint Kelly, a Princeton‑trained quarterback, leads the group alongside Jojo Jordan, Manuelito Lynch, and Al Terwilliger. Their contracts include a tongue‑in‑cheek “anti‑romance” clause, ensuring the arrangement stays strictly professional while they officially join the varsity squad. The infusion of talent and cash breathes new life into the football program, turning a struggling team into a surprising powerhouse and injecting a spirited, almost playful energy into campus life.

Clint quickly becomes the focal point of a subtle, growing tension. As a natural leader on the field and a reluctant protector off it, he finds himself drawn to Connie’s confidence and independence, even as the very role that brings them together demands secrecy. Their interactions ripple through the college’s social currents, hinting at a delicate balance between duty, desire, and the unspoken rules that govern both sport and romance.

When Connie eventually uncovers the true nature of her “protectors,” the revelation sets her on a path away from the dusty plains of New Mexico, urging her toward an uncertain future to the east. The four guardians, bound by loyalty and a shared sense of purpose, choose to follow, leaving the once‑thriving football squad behind. Their departure promises both comedic misadventures and heartfelt reckonings, leaving the campus perched on the edge of change and the promise of new beginnings.

Can’t find your movie? Request a summary here.

Movies with Similar Twists and Themes

Uncover films that echo the narrative beats, emotional arcs, or dramatic twists of the one you're exploring. These recommendations are handpicked based on story depth, thematic resonance, and spoiler-worthy moments — perfect for fans who crave more of the same intrigue.