Too Many Girls 1940

Tycoon Harvey Casey is exasperated by his daughter, Connie Casey, continuously slipping past her hired bodyguards. Fresh from finishing school in Italy, she returns to the United States with a determined plan: enroll at Pottawatomie College in Stop Gap, New Mexico, and pursue life on the campus—despite her father’s insistence on protecting her. Harvey worries not only about her safety but also about the college’s future, and he hatches a discreet solution.

He turns to a quartet of young men—Clint Kelly, a Princeton football star; Jojo Jordan; Manuelito Lynch; and Al Terwilliger—to serve as Connie’s bodyguards while she studies. The men sign contracts that include an almost comical “anti-romance” clause, designed to keep their cover intact and keep Connie from knowing they’re watching over her. With the money from their salaries, they practically bankroll the team, contributing to a campus already feeling the bite of financial strain.

Meanwhile, the college’s fortunes hinge on the help of the student leaders, including Eileen and Pepe, who work to raise funds to stave off debt. As the newcomers arrive, Connie befriends these two spirited students, while also keeping a wary eye on anyone who might be tailing her. The boys quickly win favor on campus, and they use their presence to lift the football program from mediocre to formidable, drawing praise—and even more attention—from everyone around them.

[Bev]erly Waverly, the British playwright who has become part of the campus chatter, becomes a focal point for Connie’s intrigue. Clint soon uncovers a surprising twist: Connie didn’t come to study alone—she came to chase Beverly Waverly, a revelation that complicated everyone’s feelings and threatened the fragile balance the men had established at Pottawatomie.

As the season unfolds, the dynamic among the players shifts. While the football team’s success brings fame and pressure, it also tempts the young men to bend their rules for the sake of the women who pursue them, even as the “anti-romance” clause continues to loom over their unusual arrangement. Harvey leverages his influence to extend the team’s reach, complicating loyalties and testing each man’s commitment.

Connie’s feelings for Clint grow clearer, and the tension between professional obligation and personal desire becomes harder to ignore. When Connie finally reveals who she is, Clint openly shares the truth about their protected arrangement and the team’s secret contracts. The revelation pushes Connie to a dramatic decision: she leaves Pottawatomie, insisting the boys come back east with her.

The student body, defiant and desperate to keep the football heroes, stages a bold stand—taking the team hostage as leverage. The plan backfires in a tense showdown; Manuelito is captured, and the others narrowly escape. Beverly intervenes, persuading Connie to allow the quartet to return and continue playing. Clint initially resists, but Connie’s arrival and confession of love breaks through the guard he had built around his heart.

In the end, the big game arrives, and the team delivers a hard-fought victory. The campus erupts in celebration, and the couple—Clint and Connie—share a dance that seals their bond and the college’s renewed sense of hope. The story closes on a note of reunion and triumph, underscored by the choices each character made along the way and the understanding that protection can take many forms, even when it means risking a little romance to preserve something larger than themselves.