Kept Husbands 1931

Richard Brunton, played by Joel McCrea, is a proud and ambitious man working under the watchful eye of his employer, steel tycoon Arthur Parker, portrayed by Robert McWade. Parker is a wealthy and influential figure who takes pride in showcasing his moral judgment by sharing a story about a heroic act. The story revolves around a young man—whose bravery caught everyone’s attention—who risked his life to save two of Parker’s fellow workers during a dangerous incident at the steel plant.

When Parker offers the young hero, named Dick Brunton, a reward of a thousand dollars, he surprisingly refuses, displaying humility and integrity. His refusal to accept monetary compensation leaves Parker, and his family, including Parker’s wife Henrietta, played by Dorothy Mackaill, and his daughter Dorothea “Dot” Helen Parker Brunton, played by Dorothy Mackaill, intrigued. Dot is especially captivated by the hero and expresses her desire to meet a man like Dick. To her father’s delight, Parker assures her that she will have her chance that very evening, as Dick is invited to their dinner gathering.

The dinner setting sparks a romantic attraction between Dot and Dick. Dot, spirited and flirtatious, quickly makes a bet with her father, claiming she can persuade Dick to marry her within just four weeks. Parker, confident in his daughter’s charm and her determination, accepts the challenge. To everyone’s amazement, Dot succeeds in winning Dick’s heart and convinces him to marry her before the deadline, despite the reservations he initially feels about their vastly different social standing.

Following their wedding, Parker generously sends the newlyweds on an extravagant honeymoon to Europe, symbolizing the start of their luxurious new life. Upon returning, they settle into a lavish home provided by Parker, and Dick is promoted within the company. However, the rapid shift to a life of affluence begins to affect Dick. He starts to lose interest in his work, feeling emasculated and out of place among the social elites. Dot indulges in the vapid social scene of bridge, cocktail parties, and passive leisure, which further distances him from his earlier values and ambitions.

Discontented and restless, Dick is offered an opportunity to prove himself with a new position in St. Louis. He eagerly accepts this new challenge, hoping to find fulfillment and regain his sense of purpose. Yet, Dot is less enthusiastic about the move, unwilling to leave her social circle and friends behind. Her reluctance causes a rift between the couple, and Dick decides to go to St. Louis, with or without her. This decision deeply troubles Dot, who struggles with her feelings for him and her desire to maintain her social standing.

Seeking advice, Dick approaches his mother, who encourages him to resolve his issues with Dot before departing. Meanwhile, Dot, feeling conflicted, meets with her former beau, Charles Bates, who attempts to seduce her. When she returns home the next morning, Dick confronts her about her whereabouts. Sensing her deception, he becomes furious, especially after realizing she was with Bates the previous evening. Feeling betrayed, he declares that their marriage is over and considers resigning from Parker’s company altogether.

As tensions escalate, Dot finally recognizes her love for Dick. She seeks him out at the railway station just as he prepares to leave for St. Louis. Convinced of their love and the importance of their union, Dick changes his mind and decides to take Parker’s new opportunity after all. The couple reconciles, with Dot agreeing to live within the financial limits of Dick’s salary, marking a turning point in their relationship from superficial social ambition to genuine mutual respect and understanding.

Throughout this story, themes of class distinctions, personal integrity, love, and the true meaning of success are explored in a nuanced way. The characters’ journeys reflect a deep examination of what it means to find happiness—not through wealth or social status, but through honesty, love, and staying true to one’s values. The film ultimately portrays how genuine connection and humility can overcome societal barriers and material pursuits, emphasizing that true worth lies beyond superficial appearances.