Logo What's After the Movie
Blood on the Mountain

Blood on the Mountain 2016

Directed by

Jordan Freeman

Jordan Freeman

Made by

Abramorama

Abramorama

Test your knowledge of Blood on the Mountain with our quiz!

Blood on the Mountain Plot Summary

Read the complete plot summary and ending explained for Blood on the Mountain (2016). From turning points to emotional moments, uncover what really happened and why it matters.


As Drifter Jim Garry rides onto an Indian reservation at the request of his old friend Tate Riling, he quickly becomes ensnared in a web of deception and conflict. The cattle rancher, John Lufton, seeks Garry’s assistance in delivering an important message to his family, all the while being unaware that Riling has plotted a scheme to swindle him out of his cattle. Lufton’s suspicions intensify upon discovering that Garry is allegedly working for Riling.

Initially, Garry faces animosity from the Lufton family, especially from Lufton’s daughter, Amy, who remains suspicious of this newcomer meddling in her father’s affairs. Meanwhile, Riling, along with Indian agent Jake Pindalest, orchestrates a crafty plan to coerce Lufton into selling his herd for a pittance. Pindalest has declared Lufton’s cattle unsuitable for the reservation, presenting him with a week to either sell or face financial disaster.

Riling expertly manipulates the homesteaders into believing he is acting in their best interest, convincing them to obstruct Lufton’s attempts to move his herd. Facing dire circumstances and lacking alternatives, Lufton finds himself pressured to sell his cattle directly to Riling, who plans to benefit from a government buyout facilitated by Pindalest. In exchange for Garry’s cooperation, Riling entices him with a reward of $10,000.

Nevertheless, Lufton proves to be resourceful, cleverly outsmarting Riling and successfully relocating his herd without incident. When Garry delivers the message, his misstep leads Riling to assume that he has been deceived. Meanwhile, Lufton’s daughter, Carol, who harbors secret affections for Riling, informs him of her father’s strategy, allowing Riling and his men to stampede Lufton’s cattle back into the reservation.

As the clock ticks down, Garry is horrified by the senseless chaos of the stampede, resulting in the tragic injury of a young man. This pivotal moment drives Garry to abandon his role and join forces with the Luftons against Riling’s unscrupulous tactics. Despite Amy’s initial distrust, she gradually learns to trust and love Garry, especially when he intervenes to protect her father from Riling’s mercenaries.

In a moment of desperation, Garry devises a clever trick, hiding his rift with Riling from the unsuspecting Pindalest, and persuades him to send a message to the authorities as a final attempt to extend the deadline. With this temporary safety secured, Garry captures Pindalest, neutralizing a significant threat. Meanwhile, Riling and his vicious associates close in, intent on revenge.

Seeking refuge, Garry escapes to a secluded cabin belonging to Kris Barden, the heartbroken father of the young man who tragically died in the stampede. Here, he finds a brief solace with Amy, who is increasingly troubled by his unpredictable nature. However, their moment of peace is abruptly interrupted by a chaotic gunfight, leaving all involved battered and weary.

Despite his previous injuries, Garry takes advantage of the night to make a daring escape, swiftly silencing Pindalest with a decisive blow and eliminating Riling’s two loyal henchmen with calculated precision. As the confrontation escalates, Garry and Riling confront each other, their long-standing friendship hanging by a thread.

In the aftermath, Garry is overwhelmed by the consequences of his actions, leading him to realize that his wandering days are over. Amy’s elation at this revelation underscores the story’s poignant theme: even in the most challenging times, there is always a path to redemption and renewal.

Blood on the Mountain Timeline

Follow the complete movie timeline of Blood on the Mountain (2016) with every major event in chronological order. Great for understanding complex plots and story progression.


Jim Garry's Arrival

Drifter Jim Garry rides onto an Indian reservation at the request of his old friend, Tate Riling. His arrival sets the stage for unfolding deception and conflict among the local ranchers and their adversaries.

Indian Reservation

Garry's Mission

John Lufton, a local cattle rancher, approaches Garry to deliver an important message to his family. Unbeknownst to him, Lufton is becoming a pawn in Riling's scheme to swindle him out of his cattle.

Tension with the Luftons

Garry faces hostility from the Lufton family, especially from Lufton’s daughter, Amy, who is suspicious of his intentions. This tension adds to the mounting conflicts surrounding Lufton’s cattle deal.

Riling's Plan Unfolds

Riling, along with Indian agent Jake Pindalest, devises a plan to pressure Lufton into selling his cattle for a fraction of their worth. Pindalest declares Lufton's cattle unsuitable for the reservation, giving him a week to comply.

Manipulation of Homesteaders

Riling uses cunning manipulation to convince the local homesteaders that he is acting in their best interest. This leads to obstructing Lufton’s attempts to move his cattle, increasing his desperation.

Lufton's Resourcefulness

Despite the mounting pressure, Lufton cleverly outsmarts Riling by successfully moving his herd without incident. This act of defiance catches the attention of Riling, who begins to suspect betrayal.

Carol's Dilemma

Lufton's daughter, Carol, who secretly loves Riling, inadvertently informs him of her father’s strategy. This leads to Riling and his men orchestrating a stampede of Lufton’s cattle back into the reservation.

The Stampede Chaos

In the chaos of the stampede, a young man is tragically injured, shocking Garry to his core. This incident prompts Garry to abandon his initial role and unite with the Luftons against Riling's corrupt tactics.

Building Trust with Amy

Initially distrustful, Amy begins to see Garry in a new light as he steps in to protect her father from Riling's aggression. Their relationship evolves from animosity to budding romance as they face danger together.

Deceptive Strategy against Pindalest

Garry devises a clever scheme to hide his alliance with the Luftons from Pindalest while securing a temporary reprieve from their deadline. He convinces Pindalest to contact authorities, providing them with crucial time.

Capturing Pindalest

With security temporarily assured, Garry successfully captures Pindalest, effectively neutralizing a major threat. However, Riling’s men are still closing in and revenge is on the horizon.

Seeking Refuge

Garry finds refuge at a secluded cabin belonging to Kris Barden, the grieving father of the young man who died in the stampede. He shares moments of solace with Amy, who grapples with her feelings for him.

Kris Barden's Cabin

Gunfight and Chaos

Their moment of peace is shattered when a gunfight erupts, leaving everyone battered and shaken. This confrontation highlights the dire stakes Garry faces and the choices he must make.

Garry's Decisive Actions

Despite being injured, Garry makes a daring escape during the night, taking down Pindalest and Riling's henchmen. This transition from passive observer to active participant emphasizes Garry’s growth throughout the film.

Garry's Redemption

Confronting Riling leads to a critical juncture in Garry's life, as he realizes that his wandering ways must end. With Amy’s joy signaling a new beginning, the film concludes on a hopeful note of redemption and renewal.

Blood on the Mountain Characters

Explore all characters from Blood on the Mountain (2016). Get detailed profiles with their roles, arcs, and key relationships explained.


Jim Garry

Jim Garry is a drifter who's drawn into a complex scheme involving ranchers and an Indian agent. His character transitions from a passive participant to an active defender of the Lufton family, showcasing resilience and a growing sense of morality as the stakes rise.

🏇 Drifter 💔 Protector ⚔️ Confrontational

Amy Lufton

Amy Lufton is skeptical of Garry at first, embodying the protective instincts of a daughter faced with external threats to her family's livelihood. As the plot unfolds, her character evolves to embrace love and trust, highlighting themes of growth in the face of adversity.

💪 Strong-willed ❤️ Love interest 🏠 Family

Tate Riling

Tate Riling is a cunning cattle rancher with manipulative schemes aimed at profiting from the Luftons' misfortune. His character represents the darker side of ambition, using deceit as a tool to achieve his goals, ultimately leading to his conflicts with Garry.

🦹‍♂️ Antagonist 💼 Schemer 💰 Greed

Blood on the Mountain Settings

Learn where and when Blood on the Mountain (2016) takes place. Explore the film’s settings, era, and how they shape the narrative.


Time period

The time period is set against the backdrop of the late 19th to early 20th century, a time marked by expansion into western territories and disputes over land ownership. This era often involved conflicts between ranchers and indigenous peoples, reflecting broader themes of displacement and survival.

Location

Indian reservation

The Indian reservation serves as a central backdrop for the movie, characterized by wide-open spaces and rugged terrain typical of the American West. It's known for its rich cultural history and the struggles of its inhabitants, particularly regarding land and resource management.

🏞️ Natural landscape 🚜 Ranching

Blood on the Mountain Themes

Discover the main themes in Blood on the Mountain (2016). Analyze the deeper meanings, emotional layers, and social commentary behind the film.


Redemption

Redemption is a central theme of the film as the protagonist, Garry, grapples with his choices and the repercussions of his actions. Through his journey, he learns the importance of standing up for others and finding his own place in the world, culminating in a moment of personal growth and resolution.

⚖️

Betrayal

Betrayal weaves its way through the narrative, highlighted by Garry's initial entanglements with Riling. The characters must navigate a landscape of trust and deceit, emphasizing how personal motives can lead to conflict and moral dilemma.

💔

Family Conflict

Family conflict plays a significant role in the storyline, particularly through the dynamics within the Lufton family. Amy's distrust of Garry and her father's struggles against external threats create a layered narrative of loyalty, love, and familial bonds amidst turmoil.

Blood on the Mountain Spoiler-Free Summary

Discover the spoiler-free summary of Blood on the Mountain (2016). Get a concise overview without any spoilers.


In the rugged hills of West Virginia, a storm of economic hardship and environmental neglect hangs over a tight‑knit community that clings to the remnants of its once‑prosperous past. The landscape itself feels like a living character, its rolling mountains and weathered farmlands echoing with stories of loss, resilience, and the quiet desperation of those who remain. A documentary‑style tone grounds the film in stark realism, letting the natural beauty contrast with the heavy weight of corporate influence that threatens to swallow the region’s fragile way of life.

At the heart of the story rides Jim Garry, a drifter whose reputation for getting on and off the trail at a moment’s notice precedes him. He arrives at the request of his old friend Tate Riling, stepping onto an Indian reservation fraught with unspoken tensions. There, Garry encounters John Lufton, a cattle rancher desperate to protect his herd and his family’s legacy against forces that seem both bureaucratic and personal. The atmosphere is thick with suspicion, as Lufton’s daughter Amy watches the newcomer with guarded eyes, unsure whether he is an ally or another complication in an already tangled web.

The film’s mood shifts between the quiet, contemplative moments of the mountains and the simmering undercurrent of conflict that threatens to erupt at any instant. Supporting figures such as the pragmatic Indian agent Jake Pindalest and the conflicted younger Lufton, Carol, add layers of intrigue, hinting at hidden motives and fragile alliances. Through measured pacing and an unflinching eye for detail, the story invites viewers to feel the weight of each decision, the pull of old loyalties, and the promise that even in the bleakest of landscapes, a path toward redemption may still be found.

Can’t find your movie? Request a summary here.

© 2025 What's After the Movie. All rights reserved.