Logo What's After the Movie

Critic’s Choice 1963

Parker Ballantine, a respected New York theater critic, faces a personal dilemma when his wife writes a new stage play. As the debut nears, he must choose whether to recuse himself from reviewing it to protect his marriage, or betray his professional integrity. The story humorously examines the clash between art, criticism and marital loyalty.

Parker Ballantine, a respected New York theater critic, faces a personal dilemma when his wife writes a new stage play. As the debut nears, he must choose whether to recuse himself from reviewing it to protect his marriage, or betray his professional integrity. The story humorously examines the clash between art, criticism and marital loyalty.

Does Critic’s Choice have end credit scenes?

No!

Critic’s Choice does not have end credit scenes. You can leave when the credits roll.

Meet the Full Cast and Actors of Critic’s Choice

Explore the complete cast of Critic’s Choice, including both lead and supporting actors. Learn who plays each character, discover their past roles and achievements, and find out what makes this ensemble cast stand out in the world of film and television.


Marie Windsor

Marie Windsor

Sally Orr

Stephen Coit

Stephen Coit

Waiter at Sardi's (uncredited)

Rip Torn

Rip Torn

Dion Kapakos

Lucille Ball

Lucille Ball

Angela Ballantine

Lurene Tuttle

Lurene Tuttle

Mother in "Sisters Three"

Jim Backus

Jim Backus

Dr. William Von Hagedorn

Leon Alton

Leon Alton

Audience Member (uncredited)

Joan Shawlee

Joan Shawlee

Marge Orr

Stanley Adams

Stanley Adams

Bartender

Richard Davies

Richard Davies

Spectator (uncredited)

Ahna Capri

Ahna Capri

Daughter (uncredited)

John Alban

John Alban

Audience Member (uncredited)

Jessie Royce Landis

Jessie Royce Landis

Charlotte Orr aka Charlie

Jerome Cowan

Jerome Cowan

Joe Rosenfield

John Dehner

John Dehner

S.P. Champlain

Walter Bacon

Walter Bacon

Audience Member (uncredited)

Grace Lee Whitney

Grace Lee Whitney

Minor Role

Richard Deacon

Richard Deacon

Harvey Rittenhouse

Tex Brodus

Tex Brodus

Audience Member (uncredited)

Paul Bradley

Paul Bradley

Audience Member (uncredited)

Bob Hope

Bob Hope

Parker Ballantine

Marilyn Maxwell

Marilyn Maxwell

Ivy London

Leoda Richards

Leoda Richards

Lady On Airport Escelator

Bill Baldwin

Bill Baldwin

Man on the Radio (voice) (uncredited)

Pamela Austin

Pamela Austin

Daughter (uncredited)

Robert Buckingham

Robert Buckingham

Spectator (uncredited)

Joe Brooks

Joe Brooks

Catcher (uncredited)

Dorothy Green

Dorothy Green

Mrs. Margaret Champlain

Brandon Beach

Brandon Beach

Audience Member (uncredited)

Harry Denny

Harry Denny

Spectator (uncredited)

Bud Cokes

Bud Cokes

Audience Member (uncredited)

Roy Damron

Roy Damron

Audience Member (uncredited)

George DeNormand

George DeNormand

Party Guest (uncredited)

Russell Custer

Russell Custer

Audience Member (uncredited)

Beulah Christian

Beulah Christian

Audience Member (uncredited)

Paul Cristo

Paul Cristo

Audience Member (uncredited)

Mary Benoit

Mary Benoit

Woman (uncredited)

Oliver Cross

Oliver Cross

Audience Member (uncredited)

Ivan Browning

Ivan Browning

Audience Member (uncredited)

Charles Cirillo

Charles Cirillo

Audience Member (uncredited)

Kathy Bennett

Kathy Bennett

Daughter (uncredited)

Lillian Culver

Lillian Culver

Woman (uncredited)

Dick Cherney

Dick Cherney

Audience Member (uncredited)

Willie Bloom

Willie Bloom

Audience Member (uncredited)

Mimi Dillard

Mimi Dillard

Maid (uncredited)

Ricky Kelman

Ricky Kelman

John Ballantine

Nesdon Booth

Nesdon Booth

Man (uncredited)

Gordon Carveth

Gordon Carveth

Spectator (uncredited)

Donald Losby

Donald Losby

Geoffrey Von Hagedorn

Joseph Gallison

Joseph Gallison

Philip "Phil" Yardley

Ernestine Wade

Ernestine Wade

Thelma

Theona Bryant

Theona Bryant

Beauty Operator (uncredited)

Michael Cirillo

Michael Cirillo

Spectator (uncredited)

Judy Cannon

Judy Cannon

Spectator (uncredited)

Louis Cavalier

Louis Cavalier

Little League Rooter (uncredited)

Richard Durham

Richard Durham

Robert DeMartin (uncredited)

It appears Critic’s Choice does not have a summary available yet. Please consider requesting one.

Mobile App Preview

Coming soon on iOS and Android

The Plot Explained Mobile App

From blockbusters to hidden gems — dive into movie stories anytime, anywhere. Save your favorites, discover plots faster, and never miss a twist again.

Sign up to be the first to know when we launch. Your email stays private — always.

Discover Film Music Concerts Near You – Live Orchestras Performing Iconic Movie Soundtracks

Immerse yourself in the magic of cinema with live orchestral performances of your favorite film scores. From sweeping Hollywood blockbusters and animated classics to epic fantasy soundtracks, our curated listings connect you to upcoming film music events worldwide.

Explore concert film screenings paired with full orchestra concerts, read detailed event information, and secure your tickets for unforgettable evenings celebrating legendary composers like John Williams, Hans Zimmer, and more.

Concert Film CTA - Music Note
Concert Film CTA - Green Blue Wave

Critic’s Choice Themes and Keywords

Discover the central themes, ideas, and keywords that define the movie’s story, tone, and message. Analyze the film’s deeper meanings, genre influences, and recurring concepts.


theater criticplaywrightbroadway manhattan new york citybased on playstepgrandmother stepgrandson relationshipstepmother stepson relationshipreference to tennessee williamsreference to mary mary the playreference to bluebeardreference to abie's irish rose the playtheater directormother son relationshipmother daughter relationshipsister sister relationshipactressfemale playwrightback rubfoodeatingtelephone calltelephonebarbartenderex actorwatching tvhotelbackstageopening nightrestaurantbrother in law sister in law relationshipslapstick comedyshowerman in a showertaxitaxi driveranimated opening creditshope and ballattending a playcharacter's picture appears in a newspaperreading a newspaperreference to mickey mantlereference to princeton universityreference to the library of congresscroquetreference to william shakespearereference to shakespeare's hamletreference to the kitty hawkwifeplaytheater
Movie Wiki CTA - Movie Book

Unlock the World of Movies with Our Comprehensive Wiki

Dive into our Movie Wiki for in-depth film encyclopedia entries, including cast biographies, production trivia, plot synopses, behind-the-scenes facts, and thematic analyses. Whether you’re researching iconic directors, exploring genre histories, or discovering hidden easter eggs, our expertly curated movie database has everything you need to fuel your cinematic passion.

Movie Wiki CTA - Green Blue Wave

Similar Movies To Critic’s Choice You Should Know About

Browse a curated list of movies similar in genre, tone, characters, or story structure. Discover new titles like the one you're watching, perfect for fans of related plots, vibes, or cinematic styles.


© 2025 What's After the Movie. All rights reserved.