Totally Killer 2023
Directed by
Nahnatchka Khan
Made by
Blumhouse Television
Plot Summary
Read the complete plot summary and ending explained for Totally Killer (2023). From turning points to emotional moments, uncover what really happened and why it matters.
In the quaint town of Vernon, a chilling series of events took place on the nights of October 27, 29, and 31 in 1987. On these fateful nights, three teenage girls—Tiffany Clark, Marisa Song, and Heather Hernandez—met a horrific end at the hands of the notorious Sweet 16 Killer, each brutally stabbed 16 times on their 16th birthdays.
Fast forward to the present day: teenager Jamie Hughes is looking forward to a Halloween concert with her friend Amelia Creston, while her mother Pam Hughes decides to stay back and hand out candy. Unbeknownst to Jamie, Pam shares a tragic connection with the victims, having been friends with them, and that very night, she becomes the killer’s next target, brutally slain in a shocking twist.
In her time of mourning, Jamie discovers a sinister message that Pam had hidden—a note from the killer reading, > “You’re next, one day.” Determined to alter fate, Jamie jumps into a time machine she and Amelia have been tinkering with, hoping to travel back to 1987. In a world where Pam and her friends were ostracized for their bullying, Jamie adopts the guise of an exchange student from Canada, seeking to change the course of history and save her mother.
As Jamie blends into the past, she seeks help from Lauren Creston, Amelia’s mother, and Doug Summers, who is now the principal of her school. Attempts to intervene at a party hosted by Tiffany fall short when the timeline unfolds tragically—Pam’s past reality connects with painful new experiences as Jamie struggles to protect her mother and her friends. Despite her best efforts, Heather becomes the latest victim, leading Jamie to realize the precarious nature of time and destiny.
On Halloween night, the tension escalates as they gather at an amusement park where Lauren is constructing a new time machine for Jamie’s return. Meanwhile, in the present day, Chris Dubasage assists Amelia in retrofitting their machine and uncovers the reality of shifting timelines. The group ingeniously lures the Sweet 16 Killer into a haunted house confrontation, where Kara Lim, the sheriff, impales the attacker with a scythe.
However, the real drama unfolds as Doug is unmasked as the initial killer, fueled by revenge for his girlfriend Trish’s demise—a tragedy linked to Pam. The narrative thickens when Jamie learns that Chris from the present is additionally entwined in this dark tale, having deceived everyone for the sake of his podcast ambitions. In a climactic battle, Jamie’s resourcefulness shines as she confronts Chris in the time machine, where she ultimately prevails, sending him spiraling into oblivion.
By the time Jamie returns to the present, she discovers that time has been rewritten in her favor. Pam lives, and the twist of fate has gifted Jamie, now Colette, with an older brother in a timeline long thought set in stone. The threads of past and present intertwine spectacularly, revealing the costs and consequences of tampering with time.
Timeline
Follow the complete movie timeline of Totally Killer (2023) with every major event in chronological order. Great for understanding complex plots and story progression.
The Murders Begin
In the town of Vernon, a series of brutal murders takes place on the nights of October 27, 29, and 31 in 1987. Three teenage girls, Tiffany, Marisa, and Heather, all meet a horrific end at the hands of the infamous Sweet 16 Killer, each murdered on their 16th birthday and stabbed 16 times.
The Halloween Concert
Fast forward to the present day, teenager Jamie Hughes is excited for a Halloween concert with her friend Amelia. Unbeknownst to her, her mother Pam is home passing out candy while harboring a tragic secret connected to the past murders.
Pam's Death
On the night of the concert, Pam Hughes, Jamie's mother, falls victim to the Sweet 16 Killer. The chilling twist reveals her tragic connection to the past, as she was friends with the murdered girls.
The Sinister Note
In her grief, Jamie discovers a chilling note hidden by her mother from the killer, reading, 'You’re next, one day.' This revelation sparks Jamie's determination to prevent her mother’s tragic fate.
The Time Machine
Together with Amelia, Jamie decides to use a time machine they've been working on. She hopes to travel back to 1987 to change the events that led to her mother’s death and save Pam from the killer.
A New Identity
To blend in with the past, Jamie adopts the identity of an exchange student from Canada. She navigates the social dynamics of the time, which reveals that the girls were ostracized due to their bullying.
Seeking Help
Jamie enlists the help of Lauren, Amelia's mother, and Doug, the current principal. With their assistance, she aims to prevent the unfortunate fate awaiting Pam and her friends at Tiffany's party.
Tragic Intervention
Despite Jamie's efforts to intervene during the party hosted by Tiffany, the tragedy unfolds as Pam's past intertwines with Jamie's present. Heather is brutally murdered, escalating Jamie’s fear of failure in her mission.
Amusement Park Showdown
On Halloween night, tensions rise as the group gathers at an amusement park where Lauren plans to build a new time machine. Jamie confronts the growing threat of the killer while grappling with the fragility of time.
Luring the Killer
The group devises a clever plan to attract the Sweet 16 Killer into a haunted house. During the confrontation, Sheriff Kara Lim bravely impales the attacker with a scythe, yet more surprises are in store.
The True Identity Revealed
In a shocking turn of events, Doug is revealed to be the initial Sweet 16 Killer as he seeks revenge for the death of his girlfriend, Trish. This revelation adds layers to Jamie's understanding of the dangers they face.
Chris's Betrayal
Jamie learns that Chris, who assists Amelia in the present timeline, has been manipulating the situation for his podcast. His betrayal complicates the already tense atmosphere as Jamie fights for her life.
Climactic Battle
In the ultimate showdown, Jamie confronts Chris within the time machine. Using her wits, she manages to outsmart him and send him into oblivion, preventing further chaos.
Return to the Present
After successfully altering the timeline, Jamie returns to the present. In a shocking twist, she finds that Pam is alive and learns she now has an older brother, a ripple effect from her actions in the past.
The Consequences of Time
The saga concludes as the threads of the past and present intertwine. Jamie grapples with the profound costs and unforeseen consequences of tampering with time, leaving her with a new, altered life.
Characters
Explore all characters from Totally Killer (2023). Get detailed profiles with their roles, arcs, and key relationships explained.
Jamie Hughes, Colette
Jamie is a resourceful and determined teenager driven by grief and the desire to save her mother. Her experience in the past challenges her to confront her family's history and the dark legacy of the Sweet 16 Killer. Adopting the persona of Colette, she navigates the complexities of friendship and loss, ultimately revealing her strength and resilience.
Pam Hughes
Pam is Jamie's mother and a pivotal figure entwined with the past victims of the Sweet 16 Killer. Her character represents the struggle of friendship and the impact of childhood choices that haunt the present. Pam's tragic fate catalyzes Jamie's journey, illustrating the layers of maternal love and sacrifice that thread through their story.
Doug Summers
Doug serves as the principal and an unexpected ally in Jamie's quest. His character evolves from a supportive figure to an antagonist as the truth of his motivations comes to light. This transformation adds tension to the narrative, revealing how past wounds can corrupt and drive individuals towards vengeful paths.
Setting
Learn where and when Totally Killer (2023) takes place. Explore the film’s settings, era, and how they shape the narrative.
Time period
1987, Present Day
The events of the movie oscillate between the year 1987, a time marked by innocence and brutal tragedy, and the present day, where technology and contemporary issues collide with the past. In 1987, three teenage girls experience a horrifying fate, while the present day sees their connected fates unravel through Jamie's desperate attempts to change history. The contrast of these two eras highlights the consequences of actions over time.
Location
Vernon, Amusement Park
Vernon is a quaint town that serves as the backdrop for a chilling tale of horror and time travel. Known for its picturesque setting, this town becomes the site of a series of tragic events that stem from the infamous Sweet 16 Killer. The amusement park, a key location for the climactic confrontation, evokes both nostalgia and fear, making it a pivotal point in the storyline.
Themes
Discover the main themes in Totally Killer (2023). Analyze the deeper meanings, emotional layers, and social commentary behind the film.
⏳
Time Travel
The theme of time travel underpins the narrative as Jamie endeavors to alter the tragic fate of her mother and friends. This exploration reveals the fragility of time and the complex consequences that ripple through different timelines. Jamie's journey demonstrates how meddling with the past can lead to unforeseen outcomes, ultimately reshaping the characters' destinies.
💔
Loss
Loss permeates the storyline, as Jamie grapples with the grief of her mother's murder and the haunting history of the Sweet 16 Killer. Each character's relationship with loss provides depth to their motivations and actions, showcasing how tragedy shapes their lives. The emotional weight of their experiences illustrates the lasting impact of violence and the desperate yearning to reclaim what has been lost.
🔍
Secrets
Secrets play a crucial role in the unfolding drama, particularly as Jamie uncovers the hidden truths about her mother's past and the killer's identity. The revelations about friendships, betrayals, and unspoken ties add layers of intrigue to the plot, making the journey to uncover these secrets a central aspect of the film. This theme emphasizes the importance of honesty and the consequences of deceit.
Totally Killer Ending Explained
Unravel the ending of Totally Killer (2023) with our detailed explanation. Understand the final scenes, character fates, and unresolved questions.
Totally Killer ends with a twist that reveals the true identity of the killers and explains the chain of events leading to the murders. It turns out that the original serial killer was Doug Summers, a former student who was deeply scarred by the death of his girlfriend, Trish, caused by the bullying and drunken accident orchestrated by the three girls. Doug donned the mask and began killing in revenge, targeting those responsible for Trish’s death. When Jamie uncovers this, she pulls off the killer’s mask to reveal Doug as the main murderer. However, just as she thinks the case is closed, a second killer appears: Chris Dubasage, the true mastermind behind the killing spree. Chris had been inspired by the murders to boost his podcast career and had killed Pam Hughes—Jamie’s mother—in 2023 to stir up further publicity. His motives were purely selfish and driven by a desire to profit from the chaos his crimes created.
Finally, Jamie manages to kill Chris and travel back to 2023, erasing his influence from the timeline. In the altered world, many things have changed: Pam and Blake are now older, with an extra child named Jamie; the original Jamie is called Colette, and her father is now an older Blake. The killer Doug is dead, and Randy has become the principal rather than the coach. Meanwhile, Chris’s new reality is a monastery in India, indicating he is now disconnected from the murders he once orchestrated. Ultimately, the ending underscores how manipulating the past can drastically alter the present, and justice is served when the true perpetrators are revealed and stopped. The twisted chain of revenge, deception, and obsession is finally broken, leaving the story with a morally satisfying conclusion.
Movies with Similar Twists and Themes
Uncover films that echo the narrative beats, emotional arcs, or dramatic twists of the one you're exploring. These recommendations are handpicked based on story depth, thematic resonance, and spoiler-worthy moments — perfect for fans who crave more of the same intrigue.
Featured on this page
What's After the Movie?
Not sure whether to stay after the credits? Find out!
Explore Our Movie Platform
New Movie Releases (2025)
Famous Movie Actors
Top Film Production Studios
Movie Plot Summaries & Endings
Major Movie Awards & Winners
Best Concert Films & Music Documentaries
© 2025 What's After the Movie. All rights reserved.