Serial (Bad) Weddings 2 2019

Beverly Sutphin appears to be an unassuming upper-middle-class housewife living with her dentist husband Eugene and their teenage children, Misty and Chip, in Towson, Maryland. On the surface, she embodies suburban calm, but beneath the routine lies something far more dangerous: a serial killer who targets people over trivial slights or offenses. In this stark contrast between image and impulse, the film invites us into a portrait of a woman who sees punishment as a daily necessity, delivered with chilling precision.

The trouble begins with a petty grievance against their neighbor, Dottie Hinkle, whose vulgar telephone harassment becomes the first crack in Beverly’s veneer. The tension escalates at a PTA meeting when Mr. Stubbins, Chip’s math teacher, condemns Chip’s fascination with horror films, prompting Beverly to enact a brutal and explicit retaliation. The family’s peace is further shattered when Misty’s heartbreak over a missed date leads Beverly to a cold, calculated act—she fatally stabs Carl with a fire poker after spotting him with another girl at a swap meet. As the murders accumulate, the man she shares her life with, Eugene, uncovers a cache of serial killer memorabilia beneath their mattress, including recordings from Ted Bundy made in the week of his execution, a discovery that intensifies the tension around their home and hints at Beverly’s long-standing complicity with violence.

Dinner that evening becomes a turning point, as Chip mentions his friend Scotty’s suspicions about Beverly. The family, already on edge, realizes Beverly may be willing to silence anyone who could expose her. Their fears are realized when she targets Ralph and Betty Sterner, a couple who had called Eugene for a toothache on a day Beverly and Eugene had planned to spend birdwatching. Beverly’s weapon of choice—scissors for Betty and an air conditioner hurled to strike Ralph—demonstrates a chilling mix of domestic normalcy and brutal immediacy. The police close in on Scotty’s home after discovering his suspicions, only to find him engaged in a disturbing scene, which Beverly uses to further manipulate and threaten those around her. The Sutphins converge on Scotty’s house, and Beverly sets a deadly course that ends with Scotty meeting a brutal end at a heavy metal bar, a moment that cements the sense that evil wears a familiar, everyday face.

As the net tightens, the Sutphins become central to a public spectacle when Beverly is named the prime suspect in the Sterners’ murders. A church service erupts into chaos as Beverly’s sneezes trigger panic, allowing her to slip away as law enforcement moves in. She hides at the video store where Chip works, and a tense encounter with a regular customer—who insults him for not rewinding tapes—reaffirms Beverly’s resolve to use others’ flaws against them. A new encounter with Mrs. Jenson leads Beverly to strike with a leg of lamb while she watches a film, pushing the envelopes of fear and control even further. Scotty, who observed the attack from nearby, is tracked down, and Beverly chases him to a heavy-metal venue, where she ultimately destroys him in a blaze of fury and flames.

The arrest becomes an abrupt, almost anticlimactic release of pressure for the family, as Beverly is apprehended and the Sutphins negotiate life under the shadow of their matriarch’s notoriety. The trial that follows becomes a sensational spectacle, with Beverly’s cunning and self-assertion turning the courtroom into a stage. Her strategy centers on dismantling each witness’s credibility by exposing their vices or casting doubt on their testimony. The key witness who actually saw a crime, Luann Hodges, is discredited when she appears intoxicated, while the courtroom is distracted by a surprising pop-culture moment when Suzanne Somers is cast to portray Beverly in a television film. Despite the jury’s initial unease, Beverly backs herself into a position of plausible insanity defense, and her legal team is quickly dismissed when she insists on representing herself.

Against this backdrop of theatrics and violence, Beverly manages to secure an acquittal, a conclusion marked by a sharp, almost gleeful contempt for the juror who wore white shoes after Labor Day—an act she notes with chilling satisfaction. The aftermath intensifies when Beverly tracks down that juror in a payphone alcove and ends her life with another brutal strike. The film’s capstone moment comes with a final, knowing exchange: Somers’s on-screen presence and Beverly’s icy glare seal a sense of almost gleeful deception that lingers with the audience. A postscript reveals that Beverly Sutphin resisted cooperation with the making of this film, leaving a marker on the story’s legacy and on the memory of what she represents for those who watch.

This is a dark comedy that blends suburban normalcy with shocking acts of violence, inviting viewers to examine the uneasy boundaries between civility and savagery, and between a mother’s love and a terrifying refusal to let anything—or anyone—interfere with her sense of order. The film maintains a steady, unsettling tone that leans into satire while never letting the horror dissolve into mere caricature, offering a fearless, unflinching look at a woman who turns everyday life into an arena for punishment and performance.