What Is How I Married My High School Crush About?
The premise of How I Married My High School Crush in 285 words, with nothing given away. The full story follows below.
In the quiet town of Willow Creek, teenage Sara Jacob has spent every school year nursing a secret crush on the charismatic quarterback, Brian Porterson. While classmates drift toward prom plans and college applications, Sara builds elaborate day‑dreams of a perfect wedding, convinced that destiny will someday bridge the gap between the girl who watches from the bleachers and the boy who barely notices her.
One ordinary afternoon, the sky darkens as a solar eclipse sweeps across the town, and a sudden, inexplicable wish twists the fabric of time. When the light returns, Sara and Brian find themselves standing on the very day they are supposed to exchange vows—seventeen years later, in a world that feels both familiar and utterly alien. Their bodies remain those of high‑school seniors, yet the surrounding adults move with the confidence and expectations of a life already lived.
The future they have landed in is a bustling blend of career ambitions, social obligations, and the quiet weight of responsibilities that Sara never imagined. Brian appears hardened by years of professional success, while Sara’s best friend, Kate Duncan, now an adult herself, offers a glimpse of the supportive ties that once anchored her teenage life. The couple must confront the stark contrast between youthful fantasies and the pragmatic realities of adulthood, all while the echo of their long‑held dream hangs in the air like a fragile promise.
Caught between nostalgia and the pressing demands of grown‑up life, Sara and Brian are compelled to navigate this bewildering new chapter together. Their shared journey hints at a deeper exploration of what it truly means to love, to grow, and to find a place where imagined futures might still hold a spark of possibility.
What Happens in How I Married My High School Crush?
The complete story of How I Married My High School Crush, from the first scene to the last, in 431 words (about 2 minutes). Spoilers throughout. Names in the text link to 3 cast member pages.
Spoilers ahead
From preschool, Sara Jacob has carried a fierce, unwavering love for the popular classmate Brian Porterson, a boy who has remained oblivious to her existence. She dreams of a fairytale wedding with him, imagining a future where their paths finally align.
Then a solar eclipse changes everything. Inexplicably, the two are ripped from their 1990 high school life and dropped onto the day of their wedding in 2007. In this strange jump through time, [Sara Jacob] is still seen as a seventeen-year-old by everyone around her, while [Brian Porterson] also appears older and more grown-up than his real age. The wedding feels real, yet the couple quickly discovers they are woefully unprepared for the demands and responsibilities of adulthood.
Now living in a world where the ceremony has technically happened, [Sara Jacob] finds herself navigating a very adult landscape. She becomes entangled in an election campaign for Lieutenant Governor, while [Brian Porterson] has transformed into a wealthy investment banker. His career is tainted by fraud at his firm, and he is involved in a troubling affair with his secretary. As Sara watches the receding line between dreams and reality, she realizes she has drifted into cruelty and detachment, losing touch with her family and her best friend Kate Duncan.
Determined to fix what went wrong, she decides the only way back is to return to the moment of the 1990 eclipse. She enlists help from Kate’s daughter to uncover the path to travel back in time. The plan hinges on locating the exact place and moment of the eclipse in 1990, a race against the consequences of having altered fate.
The journey back isn’t straightforward. When Brian is arrested for fraud and tax evasion, Sara must step into the courtroom as his lawyer, trying to navigate a high-stakes case. The twist deepens as Brian’s ex-girlfriend turns out to be the judge overseeing the trial, and the bail is set at $100,000, adding pressure to their precarious situation. Through these trials, the pair confronts the reality of their choices and the fragility of the life they chased.
In the end, they manage to return to the past, but the restoration comes with a caveat: the wedding and the marriage fade from memory, leaving them with a second chance and the quiet acknowledgment that some dreams were never meant to be kept as they were. The film leaves [Sara Jacob] and [Brian Porterson] with a renewed sense of how love, ambition, and timing intersect, and a reminder that growing up can mean letting go of certain fantasies to embrace a more honest future.
How I Married My High School Crush Timeline: Every Key Event in Order
12 key events in the order they happen, from “Sara's lifelong crush on Brian” to “Back to 1990: forget the marriage”. 12 events name a place, across 12 locations.
- 1
Sara's lifelong crush on Brian
Since preschool, Sara has been madly in love with Brian, imagining a future where they are married. In high school, Brian remains unaware of her existence and pursues popularity. That unrequited love shapes Sara's hopes and colors her choices for years to come.
When:1990 Where:Hometown, high school
- 2
The eclipse and the time jump to 2007
A solar eclipse abruptly transports Sara and Brian from their 1990 life to 2007, the day of Sara's dream wedding. They arrive as older versions of themselves, with Sara appearing as a thirty-something to others. The sudden shift forces them to confront a future they did not expect.
When:2007 Where:Same place as eclipse, town
- 3
The wedding dream becomes reality
In 2007, the dream marriage Sara chased seems real, yet the reality of adult life presses in. They discover that love alone cannot fix ambition, wealth, and complicated relationships. The wedding day shines as a symbol, but real-life responsibilities quickly intrude.
When:2007 Where:Wedding venue, 2007
- 4
Sara enters the Lieutenant Governor campaign
Sara is pulled into a political campaign for Lieutenant Governor, thrusting her into the public eye. The campaign demands strategic choices and public image, straining personal relationships. Her new life feels powerful but increasingly distant from who she once was.
When:2007 Where:Campaign offices / campaign trail
- 5
Brian's world as a powerful investment banker
Brian has become a wealthy investment banker, moving in circles of influence. Behind the success, he is tied to fraud at his firm and faces mounting legal and ethical trouble. His affair with a secretary adds another layer of complication to his life.
When:2007 Where:Investment firm office
- 6
Sara's disillusionment grows
Sara realizes she has become cruel and unreasonable in her pursuit of dreams, losing touch with her family and her best friend Kate. The lavish fantasy of their future has fractured important relationships. The sense of loss drives her to reconsider her choices.
When:2007 Where:Sara's home / family life
- 7
Decision to go back in time
Feeling the damage of her choices, Sara decides she must go back to fix what happened. She resolves to return to 1990 and set things right, even if it means risking more instability in her life. The plan hinges on mastering the conditions that allowed the time shift.
When:2007 Where:Present-day town
- 8
Kate's daughter helps unlock the method
To learn how to travel back, Sara enlists Kate's daughter for help in uncovering the method to return to 1990. They search for the precise conditions needed to recreate the eclipse moment. The collaboration deepens the tie between Sara's fate and Kate's family.
When:2007 Where:Town / Kate's home
- 9
Preparing to return to 1990
Sara discovers that returning requires being in the exact place and time of the 1990 eclipse. She plans to recreate that moment so she can slip back to the past. The knowledge sets the stage for the final journey through time.
When:1990 (planned return moment) Where:Eclipse location in town
- 10
Brian's arrest and Sara acts as his lawyer
In the present timeline, Brian is arrested for fraud and tax evasion, and Sara steps in as his lawyer to support him. The case forces them to confront their tangled past and present, complicating their relationship further. Sara's role adds pressure as memories resurface.
When:2007 Where:City courthouse
- 11
The trial twist and bail
During the trial, Sara and Brian learn that Brian's ex-girlfriend is the judge presiding over the case. They plead not guilty as the bail is set at 100,000, raising the stakes in a courtroom where past and present collide. The courtroom becomes a focal point for the unresolved tensions between them.
When:2007 Where:Courtroom
- 12
Back to 1990: forget the marriage
Ultimately, Sara travels back to 1990 and awakens to a life in which she and Brian are not married. The magical reunion dissolves, and the memory of their wedding fades as time rewinds itself. The story ends with a quiet sense that some dreams vanish when time circles back.
When:1990 Where:Eclipse location / hometown, 1990
Who Are the Main Characters in How I Married My High School Crush?
7 characters, among them Sara Jacob (Katee Sackhoff), Tina Landers (Elyse Levesque) and Brian Porterson (Sage Brocklebank): who each one is and the part they play in the story. Every profile links to the actor’s page.
-
Sara Jacob (Katee Sackhoff)
Played by Katee Sackhoff
A 17-year-old in 1990 who hopes for a dream wedding with Brian. In 2007 she confronts the consequences of her actions, realizes her capacity for ruthlessness, and embarks on a time-loop effort to fix the past while rediscovering her true self.
- 🎯 Ambition
- 💫 Naivety
- 🧭 Growth
- TL
Tina Landers (Elyse Levesque)
Played by Elyse Levesque
Kate’s daughter who helps Sara figure out how to return to 1990. Practical and quick-thinking, Tina serves as the crucial bridge between the time-travel dilemma and the plan to restore the timeline.
- 🧭 Helpfulness
- 🧠 Resourcefulness
- 🤝 Collaboration
- BP
Brian Porterson (Sage Brocklebank)
Played by Sage Brocklebank
A wealthy investment banker whose fraud and extramarital affair create the crisis that drives the plot. His evolving relationship with Sara tests loyalty, ambition, and the costs of wealth.
- 💼 Wealth
- 💔 Infidelity
- ⚖️ Legal trouble
- OT
Older Tim (Stephen Huszar)
Played by Stephen Huszar
An older version of Tim who appears through the time-travel arc, offering a contrast between youth and the consequences of aging within the same narrative.
- ⏳ Time-shift
- 🧭 Guide
- KD
Kate Duncan (Kim Poirier)
Played by Kim Poirier
Sara’s best friend who accompanies and challenges her journey. Kate’s presence grounds the story in friendship and the realities of adulthood as Sara navigates love, trust, and time.
- 🤝 Friendship
- 🌟 Support
- 🧭 Guidance
- JD
Jonathan Daley (Rob van Meenen)
Played by Rob van Meenen
A supporting character who interacts with the main cast during the escalating events, contributing to the complexity of the plot and the courtroom setting.
- 🧩 Supporting
- 🗂️ Plot device
- DB
Daniel Bock (Tommy Lioutas)
Played by Tommy Lioutas
Another key figure whose involvement shapes the legal and personal stakes for Sara and Brian, influencing how the timeline shifts and resolves.
- 🕵️♂️ Mystery
- 🧭 Navigating loyalties
Where and When Is How I Married My High School Crush Set?
How I Married My High School Crush is set in High School (1990), Wedding Venue (2007) and Courthouse (2007) (1990, 2007). Here is why the time and place matter to the story.
When
1990, 2007
Events unfold across two eras: the 1990s high school years and the mid-2000s wedding era. 1990 frames Sara's youthful infatuation and innocence, while 2007 places them in a world of campaigns, corporate crime, and adult responsibilities. The eclipse triggers the journey between these times, forcing hard choices about love, truth, and identity.
Where
High School (1990), Wedding Venue (2007), Courthouse (2007)
The story shifts between a 1990 high school setting and the 2007 venues surrounding the wedding and a courtroom. In 1990, Sara dreams of marrying Brian, while by 2007 the couple faces adulthood, politics, and a fraud scandal. The solar eclipse time-travel catalyst anchors scenes to key locations where vows, investigations, and decisions about their future unfold.
- 🎓 High School
- 🏛️ Courtroom
- 💍 Wedding
What Are the Themes of How I Married My High School Crush?
3 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Time Travel, Love Consequences and Legal Drama.
-
01
Time Travel
A solar eclipse becomes the mechanism that transports Sara and Brian to a future wedding day. The plot examines whether knowledge of a future can alter the present and if returning to the past can truly repair broken bonds. It also questions whether growing up in a hurry can erode genuine self-understanding.
-
02
Love Consequences
Sara’s fixation on a dream marriage drives her to overlook family and friends, revealing how desire can distort judgment. The narrative tracks the emotional cost of chasing a perfect union and the tension between romance and loyalty. Ultimately, choices must balance personal happiness with accountability.
-
03
Legal Drama
Brian’s fraud and tax evasion land the couple in legal peril, turning romance into a courtroom ordeal. Sara unexpectedly acts as his lawyer, complicating loyalties when the judge is his ex-girlfriend. The sequence tests ethics, influence, and the toll of ambition on justice.
What Kind of Film Is How I Married My High School Crush?
Whimsical in tone, with variable pacing and a moderate story, going by the plot summary.
- Tone
- Whimsical
- Pacing
- Variable
- Story
- Moderate
- Intensity
- Medium
- Ending
- Happy
A whimsical and lighthearted fantasy comedy that uses time travel to explore the gap between teenage dreams and adult reality, offering a playful yet reflective look at destiny and personal growth.
- whimsical
- nostalgic
- romantic
- reflective
- lighthearted
- fantastical
- time travel
- second chance
- coming of age
- high school crush
Content notes: infidelity, financial fraud.
Quiz
How well do you remember How I Married My High School Crush? Test yourself on the story.
