What Is First Reformed About?
The premise of First Reformed in 272 words, with nothing given away. The full story and the ending follow below.
In the quiet town of Snowbridge, New York, the historic First Reformed Church stands as a relic of a once‑vibrant community, now struggling to find its footing in a world that feels increasingly indifferent. The atmosphere is hushed and reverent, yet a low‑grade anxiety hovers like winter fog, reflecting both the dwindling congregation and the looming specter of environmental uncertainty that presses on the region. The film’s tone is contemplative and austere, inviting viewers to linger in the spaces between prayer, doubt, and the harsh light of modern crises.
At the heart of this fragile setting is the solitary figure of Ernst Toller, a Dutch‑Reformed pastor whose years of service have left him both reverent and deeply conflicted. Haunted by personal loss—a son who died overseas—and by his own battles with addiction, he turns outward for solace, exploring theological works that span centuries and traditions. His quiet routine of journaling becomes a private sanctuary, a place where he wrestles with the weight of his calling and the growing sense that the faith he once taught may no longer answer the questions gnawing at his spirit.
The arrival of a young parishioner, Mary Mensana, and her environmentally‑engaged family injects a restless urgency into the reverend’s life. Their earnest pleas and stark concerns about a looming ecological disaster shake the foundations of his already fragile belief system, prompting him to confront the moral complexities of stewardship, hope, and despair. As the two characters navigate the delicate balance between pastoral duty and personal conviction, the film offers a meditative portrait of a man standing at the crossroads of faith, responsibility, and an increasingly uncertain world.
What Happens in First Reformed?
The complete story of First Reformed, from the first scene to the last, in 484 words (about 2 minutes). Spoilers throughout. Names in the text link to 2 cast member pages.
Spoilers ahead
Ernst Toller, portrayed by an unnamed actor, is the pastor of the historic First Reformed Church in Snowbridge, New York, grappling with a profound crisis of faith. The narrative begins with Toller documenting his thoughts in a journal, a project he intends to destroy after a year of reflection. This church, originally a pivotal stop on the Underground Railroad, now finds itself struggling with dwindling attendance under Toller’s guidance, having veered away from its roots in Calvinist theology to become primarily a tourist destination.
Haunted by the loss of his son, Joseph, who was a casualty of the Iraq War, Toller also battles his own alcoholism. His journey toward deeper spiritual comprehension leads him to explore the writings of Roman Catholic authors like G. K. Chesterton and Thomas Merton, alongside mystical texts such as The Cloud of Unknowing. In search of solace, he reaches out to Abundant Life, a prominent evangelical megachurch in Albany that oversees First Reformed.
His life takes a pivotal turn when he is approached by Mary Mensana, who seeks guidance for her husband, Michael, a fervent environmentalist. Michael’s radical views put Toller in a moral quandary as he reveals his desire for Mary to have an abortion, expressing his belief that bringing a child into a world devastated by climate change is cruel. When Mary finds a suicide vest belonging to Michael, Toller takes it, vowing to counsel him. Despite contemplating alerting the authorities, Toller hesitates, fearing it might exacerbate Michael’s fragile mental state.
Tragically, before their next session, Toller discovers Michael has taken his own life with a shotgun. In line with Michael’s last wishes, a memorial service is held at a local toxic-waste site, where his ashes are scattered. Meanwhile, preparations for First Reformed’s 250th anniversary service—a significant event featuring local dignitaries and Edward Balq, a financial supporter of the church with a stake in climate pollution—are underway. Toller and Balq clash over their differing stances on climate change, Toller advocating for Christian stewardship while Balq dismisses it as overly complex.
In the midst of personal turmoil, Toller seeks medical attention due to recurring physical pain, and tests hint at possible stomach cancer. He discovers Michael’s laptop, which he took to protect Mary from the consequences of Michael’s radical beliefs, and dives into research concerning Michael’s fears about Balq’s factory. One evening, Mary visits Toller in the church’s parsonage, where they share a moment of intimate connection reminiscent of Michael and Mary’s past.
As the anniversary service approaches, Toller implores Mary not to attend. In a drastic turn of events, he dons the explosive vest meant for Michael during the ceremony but ultimately substitutes it for barbed wire in a symbolic act of self-sacrifice. Just as he prepares to consume a glass of drain cleaner, a pivotal moment occurs—Mary interrupts him, and their passionate embrace leads to an abrupt and haunting conclusion as the screen fades to black.
First Reformed Timeline: Every Key Event in Order
14 key events in the order they happen, from “Toller Begins His Journal” to “A Haunting Conclusion”. 9 events name a place, across 5 locations.
- 1
Toller Begins His Journal
Ernst Toller, the pastor of First Reformed Church, initiates a journal to document his inner thoughts over the course of a year. This exercise is not just a reflection but also a way to confront his deepening crisis of faith and understanding of his life.
Where:First Reformed Church, Snowbridge, New York
- 2
Church's Diminishing Role
The historic First Reformed Church, once a key site on the Underground Railroad, has seen a decline in attendance and spiritual purpose. Under Toller's guidance, it has shifted from its Calvinist roots to become more of a tourist attraction than a place of worship.
Where:Snowbridge, New York
- 3
Toller's Inner Struggles
Haunted by the loss of his son, Joseph, in the Iraq War, Toller confronts his own battles with alcoholism. This personal turmoil propels him towards a deeper exploration of faith and spirituality, seeking wisdom in religious texts and teachings.
- 4
Connection with Mary Mensana
Toller meets Mary Mensana, who comes seeking help for her husband, Michael, an environmental activist. Their conversation reveals Michael's distressing thoughts about parenthood in a world ravaged by climate change, pushing Toller into a complex moral landscape.
Where:First Reformed Church
- 5
Michael's Suicidal Ideation
During their discussions, Michael expresses his wish for Mary to have an abortion, failing to see hope for the future. The situation escalates when Toller finds a suicide vest belonging to Michael, prompting his internal conflict regarding intervention and the potential fallout.
- 6
Tragic Loss
Before Toller can meet Michael again, he learns devastating news: Michael has taken his own life. This tragedy weighs heavily on Toller, as he feels responsible and haunted by his inability to prevent it.
- 7
Memorial Service for Michael
A memorial service is held at a local toxic-waste site, reflecting the environmental issues Michael was passionate about. His ashes are scattered in a poignant ceremony that emphasizes the grim reality of climate change.
Where:Local toxic-waste site
- 8
Conflict with Edward Balq
As the church prepares for its 250th anniversary service, tensions rise between Toller and Edward Balq, a financial supporter with vested interests in pollution. Toller advocates for responsible stewardship of the Earth, while Balq dismisses these concerns, viewing them as excess complicity.
Where:First Reformed Church
- 9
Health Concerns Arise
Toller seeks medical help due to persistent physical pain, leading to testing that suggests potential stomach cancer. His mounting health issues add another layer of stress as he grapples with personal and pastoral responsibilities.
- 10
Discovering Michael's Laptop
In a bid to understand Michael's profound fears regarding Balq's factory, Toller uncovers Michael's laptop. This exploration provides insight into the activist's mindset and the societal threats that preoccupied him, making Toller question the broader implications of their discussions.
Show the other 4 events of First Reformed Hide the last 4 events
- 11
Intimacy with Mary
In a moment of vulnerability, Mary visits Toller, and they share a deep emotional connection, reminiscent of her bond with Michael. This meeting signifies the intertwining of loss and affection, revealing the complex relationships at play.
Where:Church's parsonage
- 12
Contemplating a Dangerous Act
As the anniversary service approaches, Toller grapples with his own despair, leading him to consider using the explosive vest meant for Michael. This drastic decision symbolizes his inner turmoil and desperation to make a statement.
Where:First Reformed Church
- 13
Last Moment of Decision
On the day of the anniversary service, Toller prepares to carry out his plan, but in a critical moment, he substitutes the vest for barbed wire. This act of self-sacrifice is laden with meaning, as he seeks to draw attention to the grave issues at hand.
Where:First Reformed Church
- 14
A Haunting Conclusion
Just as Toller is about to consume drain cleaner, a pivotal moment occurs when Mary interrupts him. Their passionate embrace prevents him from following through, culminating in an abrupt yet profound end to the film.
Where:First Reformed Church
Who Are the Main Characters in First Reformed?
3 characters, among them Mary Mensana, Ernst Toller and Edward Balq: who each one is and the part they play in the story. 2 of them link to the actor’s page.
-
Mary Mensana
Played by Amanda Seyfried
Mary is a complex character grappling with her husband's radical beliefs and the moral implications of bringing a child into a troubled world. She exemplifies resilience and compassion, seeking guidance and grappling with sorrow after Michael's tragic death. Her relationship with Toller brings a poignant exploration of love, loss, and the search for hope.
- 💔 Grief
- 🤝 Support
- 🌱 Growth
- ET
Ernst Toller
Toller is a deeply flawed yet relatable pastor, entangled in personal grief and a crisis of faith. His character evolves as he confronts his past, challenges societal norms, and seeks moral clarity amidst turmoil. Toller embodies the struggle between religious duty and personal belief, ultimately reflecting on his role as a guide and his own need for salvation.
- 🙏 Faith
- 🍷 Alcoholism
- 🌪️ Turmoil
-
Edward Balq
Played by Cedric the Entertainer
Balq represents corporate interests and the moral complexities surrounding climate change. As a supporter of the church, his dismissive attitude towards environmental stewardship contrasts sharply with Toller's convictions. His character serves as a catalyst for Toller’s moral dilemmas and internal conflicts regarding the church's role in contemporary issues.
- 💼 Corporate
- 🌫️ Pollution
- ⚠️ Conflict
Where and When Is First Reformed Set?
First Reformed is set in Snowbridge, New York, First Reformed Church and Albany. Here is why the place matters to the story.
When
The events of the film unfold in contemporary times, capturing a modern crisis of faith and societal issues. It explores the impacts of climate change and personal loss within the current cultural landscape. The backdrop reflects modern-day struggles, including mental health and environmental activism.
Where
Snowbridge, New York, First Reformed Church, Albany
Snowbridge, New York is a small town marked by its historical significance and charm. The First Reformed Church, once a key stop on the Underground Railroad, now faces challenges as it has shifted from its religious roots to a more commercial role as a tourist spot. Nearby Albany is a thriving city known for its rich history and as home to Abundant Life, a major evangelical megachurch.
- 🏛️ Church
- 🌆 City
- 📍 Location
What Are the Themes of First Reformed?
3 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Ethical Dilemmas, Faith and Redemption and Environmentalism.
-
01
Ethical Dilemmas
The movie delves into complex ethical questions, particularly surrounding life, death, and moral responsibility. Toller faces moral quandaries regarding abortion and the lengths to which one should go for their beliefs. The theme resonates deeply with the characters' struggles and decisions, especially through Michael's radical views and ultimate fate.
-
02
Faith and Redemption
Central to Toller’s journey is the search for faith and understanding in a seemingly indifferent world. His internal battle with alcoholism and grief stems from a profound crisis of faith, highlighting the struggle for redemption. Through interactions with Mary and contemplation of Christian stewardship, the theme explores the possibility of renewal amidst despair.
-
03
Environmentalism
Environmental concerns play a pivotal role in the narrative, represented by Michael's fervent activism and the church's relationship with local pollution. The film critiques modern apathy and corporate neglect regarding climate issues, inviting audiences to question their own responsibilities. This theme is woven through the personal stories and the broader community’s challenges.
How Does First Reformed End?
The last act of First Reformed and what it means, in 219 words. The ending lands as ambiguous. Big spoilers: read the plot summary first if you have not seen it.
The final act, in full
The ending of First Reformed deliberately shatters narrative convention, leaving the fate of Reverend Ernst Toller suspended in a moment of radical ambiguity. Just as Toller prepares to drink a glass of drain cleaner to end his suffering, Mary enters his room, and the two share a sudden, passionate embrace before the screen cuts to black. This abrupt shift forces the viewer to navigate two conflicting realities: one where Toller is physically saved by an act of grace or love, and another where the entire interaction is a dying hallucination—a final, comforting vision as the poison takes hold.
This duality is the very point of the finale, reflecting the film’s earlier meditation on the nature of wisdom. Ethan Hawke has described the scene as a cinematic representation of holding two opposing thoughts at once, creating a “continuity of opposites” where life and death, or reality and illusion, exist simultaneously. Paul Schrader treats the ending not as a puzzle to be solved, but as a bell meant to vibrate within the audience long after the credits roll. Whether one interprets the finale as a literal miracle of survival or a spiritual transcendence through death, the power of the moment lies in its refusal to provide a definitive answer, ensuring the film’s themes of despair and redemption resonate with unanswerable intensity.
What Kind of Film Is First Reformed?
Dark in tone, with slow pacing and a moderate story, going by the plot summary.
- Tone
- Dark
- Pacing
- Slow
- Story
- Moderate
- Intensity
- High
- Ending
- Ambiguous
A slow-burning, intensely somber character study of a pastor grappling with profound grief and faith in the face of environmental doom, creating a claustrophobic and morally complex viewing experience.
- somber
- anxious
- claustrophobic
- meditative
- despairing
- morally ambiguous
- crisis of faith
- environmental activism
- clergy as protagonist
- grief and loss
Content notes: suicide, self harm, terminal illness.
Quiz
How well do you remember First Reformed? Test yourself on the story.
