Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Plot summary

Cry Baby Lane (2000) Plot Summary & Timeline

Cry Baby Lane (2000) movie poster

Cry Baby Lane is a 2000 drama and horror film directed by Peter Lauer, running 1 hour 9 minutes. This page retells the whole story in 586 words (about 3 minutes to read) and covers 12 key events in order, 6 characters, where and when it is set and 3 themes. Looking for the cast, ratings and where to stream it? See the movie page for Cry Baby Lane.

to read the plot summary
3 min
key events in the timeline
12
characters profiled
6
themes explained
3
Loading streaming availability…
Cry Baby Lane (2000) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 9m
Director
Peter Lauer
Genres
Drama, Horror
Original language
English
No spoilers

What Is Cry Baby Lane About?

The premise of Cry Baby Lane in 305 words, with nothing given away. The full story follows below.

In the quiet outskirts of a town that clings to its old folklore, the road known as Cry Baby Lane carries the whispers of the past like a restless wind. The community’s history is kept alive by the local undertaker, Mr. Bennett, whose nightly recounting of ghostly tales shapes the imagination of two restless teens. Andrew and his older brother Carl grow up with these stories threading through their everyday lives, turning ordinary evenings into haunted reveries. Their world feels both intimate and uncanny, a place where the boundary between legend and lived experience is perpetually thin.

The brothers’ fascination leads them to the unsettling legend of a farmer’s wife who bore Siamese twins—one bright‑hearted, the other malevolent. The tale, steeped in sorrow and secrecy, speaks of burial rites that split the twins’ fates, one resting in the town cemetery and the other in a shallow grave beside the eerie lane. The narrative’s tone is brooding and atmospheric, echoing the faint cries that supposedly drift over the field at night. As the boys contemplate the story’s implications, the town itself seems to hold its breath, its histories and superstitions coiled together like the roots of the ancient trees that line the road.

When Andrew and Carl gather a small group of friends for a séance at the cemetery, the adventure promises a night of thrilling curiosity, yet it also hints at forces that may be more than mere folklore. Around them, characters such as the skeptical yet uneasy assistant Gary and the sympathetic Kathy add layers of doubt and support, underscoring the brothers’ bond and the tight‑knit fabric of their community. The mood remains tense and suspenseful, inviting viewers to wonder how far the shadows of Cry Baby Lane will reach and what the night might reveal about the thin veil between myth and reality.

Full plot

What Happens in Cry Baby Lane?

The complete story of Cry Baby Lane, from the first scene to the last, in 586 words (about 3 minutes). Spoilers throughout. Names in the text link to 4 cast member pages.

Spoilers ahead

Two brothers, Andrew Jase Blankfort and his older brother Carl Trey Rogers, grew up on the ghost stories told by the town’s local undertaker, Frank Langella, who appears as Mr. Bennett. The tales are more than bedtime lore to them; they’re a doorway to something unsettled and real.

In Bennett’s telling, a local farmer’s wife gives birth to conjoined twins — one good-natured, the other unmistakably evil. The farmer, overwhelmed by shame, keeps the twins locked away. The twins’ fate takes a brutal turn when both die of a liver disease, and he dismembers them: he buries the good twin in a cemetery and the bad twin in a shallow grave near the house, at the edge of an old dirt road called Cry Baby Lane, a place where anyone out at night is said to hear the cries of the deceased twin. The legend grows with a warning: the cries grow louder where the twins’ graves lie.

When Andrew, Carl, and a handful of friends decide to hold a séance at the cemetery—where the good twin is supposedly laid to rest—the plan is simple, but the consequences are anything but. During the séance, a weed is cut near the grave, and a chilling, uncanny phenomenon sweeps through the town. Seeking answers, Andrew corners Mr. Bennett, who finally confesses a disturbing truth: when the twins were separated, the bodies were swapped. The good twin ended up buried in the field, the bad twin in the grave where the séance unfolds. Bennett implies that the cries of the good twin are a plea for help, not vengeance, and that the bad twin’s power reaches far enough to grip nearly everyone in Cry Baby Lane. With that revelation, a dire mission lands on Andrew’s shoulders: he must find a way to restore peace.

Bennett’s assistant Gary Gary Perez chimes in with a legendary caution of his own: weeds near graves are said to cradle a person’s soul, and cutting the weed can release that soul. The myth, which Gary both doubts and fears, becomes a crucial clue in the escalating danger. As the night deepens, the evil twin makes his move by seizing Carl, forcing him toward a violent breakthrough against his own brother. The hollow, threatening voice speaks through Carl, taunting Andrew and insisting that nothing can stop the cries now that the twins’ torment has a foothold in the town.

Andrew presses on, guided by the possibility that the good twin’s spirit persists in the field. He makes his way to the good twin’s grave and faces a grim task: he must cut a root that binds the good twin’s skeleton to regain the peace that was lost. The evil twin responds with a flurry of dirt, attempting to bury Andrew alive, but with resolve and courage, Andrew severs the root and releases the good twin from the tangle of fear. In a flash of light, the malevolent force dissolves, and the town begins to return to its ordinary rhythm.

The morning after, Andrew awakens outside the grave to find the good twin’s resting place adorned with flowers, a quiet sign that peace has been restored for the moment. He plucks a blossom and shares it with Kathy Sheri Drach as they walk away from Cry Baby Lane, a small, hopeful gesture that suggests the good twin has finally found respite. The legends linger, but for now, the town rests, the road behind them quiet, and the cries that haunted Cry Baby Lane fade into memory.

Timeline

Cry Baby Lane Timeline: Every Key Event in Order

12 key events in the order they happen, from “Mr. Bennett tells a ghost story” to “Dawn departure from Cry Baby Lane”. 12 events name a place, across 7 locations.

  1. 1

    Mr. Bennett tells a ghost story

    Mr. Bennett, the town's undertaker, sits with Andrew and Carl to tell a ghost story. He spins the legend of conjoined twins and a farmer who is ashamed of them. The tale foreshadows the eerie cries that some say emanate from Cry Baby Lane.

    When:Night Where:Bennett's shop

  2. 2

    The twins' tragedy and separation

    The farmer's tale centers on twins born split, one good and one evil. After a liver disease kills them, the farmer separates the bodies and buries the good twin in a cemetery while the bad twin lies in a shallow grave near the house along Cry Baby Lane. The lore warns that anyone who wanders there at night will hear the deceased twin's cries.

    When:Long ago Where:Farm, cemetery, Cry Baby Lane

  3. 3

    A séance at Cry Baby Lane

    Andrew, Carl, and a group of friends decide to hold a séance in the cemetery to contact the alleged good twin. They hope to glean the truth behind the whispers and perhaps calm the restless spirit. The gathering marks the beginning of the night’s terrifying events.

    When:Night Where:Cry Baby Lane cemetery

  4. 4

    Weed cuts the grave and strange phenomena begin

    During the séance, a weed is cut near the grave, triggering a sudden wave of creepy phenomena across town. Lights flicker, voices seem to echo from the earth, and a sense of foreboding grips everyone present. The boundary between the living and the dead begins to loosen.

    When:Night Where:Cry Baby Lane cemetery; town

  5. 5

    Bennett reveals the grave misplacement

    That night, Bennett admits the truth: when the twins were separated, the good twin was buried in the wrong grave. He explains that the good twin is crying for help, while the bad twin’s presence explains the rising menace around town. Andrew realizes the haunting is not vengeance but a desperate plea.

    When:Night Where:Bennett's shop

  6. 6

    Gary's legend about weeds and souls

    Gary, Bennett's assistant, shares a folk legend that weeds near graves contain the souls of the departed, released when the weed is cut. He treats it as superstition, but the idea lingers with Andrew. The legend casts a new light on the town’s strange disturbances.

    When:Night Where:Bennett's shop

  7. 7

    Evil twin possesses Carl

    Into Cry Baby Lane they go, where the evil twin seizes Carl and uses his voice to threaten Andrew. The possessed brother acts on the evil twin’s will, escalating the peril. Andrew must confront the danger head-on.

    When:Night Where:Cry Baby Lane

  8. 8

    Andrew escapes the possession

    Andrew manages to break free from the evil twin’s control and presses on toward the good twin’s grave. He fights through fear and darkness, determined to uncover the truth and protect his brother. The journey intensifies as the evil presence closes in.

    When:Night Where:Cry Baby Lane

  9. 9

    Deep into the good twin's grave

    Inside the good twin’s grave, Andrew finds a root wrapped around the skeleton. He realizes freeing the good twin requires severing the root, a risky move that could awaken the bad twin. He steadies himself and begins to cut.

    When:Night Where:Good twin's grave

  10. 10

    Burying attempt thwarted

    As the root loosens, the evil twin dumps dirt onto the grave, trying to bury Andrew alive. He continues cutting the root, managing to release the good twin from the choking grip of the bad. With a flash of light, the malevolent force vanishes.

    When:Night Where:Good twin's grave

  11. 11

    Peace returns to town

    The next morning, Andrew awakens outside the grave and finds the good twin's resting place peaceful, marked with flowers. The town returns to normal as the truth about Cry Baby Lane sinks in. The legend shifts from fear to a revelation about the twins.

    When:Next morning Where:Cry Baby Lane

  12. 12

    Dawn departure from Cry Baby Lane

    Andrew takes a flower from the good twin’s grave for Kathy as they depart Cry Baby Lane. The gesture signals the good twin’s peace and a quiet ending for their town. They walk away knowing the danger is behind them.

    When:Dawn Where:Outside the grave, Cry Baby Lane

Characters

Who Are the Main Characters in Cry Baby Lane?

6 characters, among them Andrew (Jase Blankfort), Carl (Trey Rogers) and Mr. Bennett (Frank Langella): who each one is and the part they play in the story. Every profile links to the actor’s page.

  • A(

    Andrew (Jase Blankfort)

    Played by Jase Blankfort

    Andrew is curious, brave, and skeptical of rumors. He relentlessly investigates the Cry Baby Lane mystery, seeking the truth behind the legends of the good and bad twins. He acts as the moral center of the group, driven to stop the haunting and restore peace by severing the ties between the twins’ spirits.

    • 🧠 Rational
    • 🕵️‍♂️ Determined
    • 👦 Teen
  • C(

    Carl (Trey Rogers)

    Played by Trey Rogers

    Carl is Andrew’s older brother who becomes momentarily possessed by the evil twin. He wrestles with conflicting impulses as the possession escalates, providing a foil to Andrew’s cautious courage. His arc underscores the stakes of the haunting and the danger the town faces when the spirits are disturbed.

    • 😨 Tormented
    • 🌀 Vulnerable
    • 👦 Teen
  • Frank Langella as Mr. Bennett (Frank Langella) in Cry Baby Lane

    Mr. Bennett (Frank Langella)

    Played by Frank Langella

    The local undertaker who tells the ghost stories and knows the truth behind the twins’ separation. He reveals that the bodies were misidentified, linking the town’s haunting to a buried past. Bennett stands as the bridge between lore and reality, guiding Andrew toward a possible resolution.

    • 🎭 Mentor
    • 🕰️ Old-fashioned
  • G(

    Gary (Gary Perez)

    Played by Gary Perez

    Gary is Bennett’s assistant who conveys the town’s legends and the idea that weeds at graves may hold souls. He serves as a skeptical counterpoint to the supernatural events, while ultimately aiding the investigation through shared local lore. His observations help ground the haunting in folklore rather than pure fantasy.

    • 🧭 Curious
    • 🧠 Observant
  • ET

    Evil Twin (Rob Newton)

    Played by Rob Newton

    The malevolent twin who possesses people in the town, pushing chaos and danger. He embodies the darkest force of the legend and tests Andrew’s resolve to protect his brother and the community. His presence escalates the threat until the good twin’s grave is reached and the root is cut to restore peace.

    • 👹 Villain
    • 🔒 Possession
  • K(

    Kathy (Sheri Drach)

    Played by Sheri Drach

    A member of the friend group who shares in the town’s eerie night and witnesses the strange events surrounding Cry Baby Lane. She participates in the shared experience of the haunting and represents the wider circle of townspeople affected by the legend.

    • 👭 Friend
    • 🤝 Loyal
Setting

Where and When Is Cry Baby Lane Set?

Cry Baby Lane is set in Cry Baby Lane and Cry Baby Lane Cemetery. Here is why the place matters to the story.

Where

Cry Baby Lane, Cry Baby Lane Cemetery

Cry Baby Lane is a secluded rural town centered around an old cemetery and a neglected dirt road. The cemetery and surrounding fields become the focal point of supernatural disturbances after a séance is attempted by a group of friends. Local legends tie the cries of a good twin to buried secrets, creating an eerie history beneath the surface.

  • ❄️ Haunted
  • 👻 Supernatural
  • 🏚️ Rural town
Themes

What Are the Themes of Cry Baby Lane?

3 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Good vs Evil, Folklore and Trust and Family.

  1. 01

    Good vs Evil

    A central conflict in Cry Baby Lane is the struggle between the benevolent good twin and the malevolent bad twin. The good twin’s cries demand help from the living, while the bad twin’s influence drives people to acts of fear and possession. Andrew’s quest to separate truth from superstition becomes a test of courage and compassion. The resolution rests on restoring balance and letting the good twin rest.

  2. 02

    Folklore

    The town’s legends provide the framework for the haunting, with Mr. Bennett recounting the tale of the two twins. The idea that graveyard weeds hold souls adds a tactile superstition that shapes characters’ beliefs. The séance pushes these stories from rumor into a tangible danger or warning. Folklore here serves as both explanation and warning, blurring lines between myth and reality.

  3. 03

    Trust and Family

    Family ties motivate Andrew to confront the past and protect his brother from the evil that escaped the grave. The community’s willingness to believe or dismiss legends tests trust among friends. As the good twin seeks peace, the characters must cooperate to free themselves from the curse. The film ultimately suggests that compassion and teamwork are stronger than fear.

Tone & mood

What Kind of Film Is Cry Baby Lane?

Dark in tone, with steady pacing and a straightforward story, going by the plot summary.

Tone
Dark
Pacing
Steady
Story
Straightforward
Intensity
Medium
Ending
Happy

A creepy and atmospheric ghost story that steadily builds tension through local legend and a misguided séance, culminating in an urgent supernatural battle to restore peace to a haunted town.

  • creepy
  • foreboding
  • atmospheric
  • tense
  • supernatural
  • urgent
  • ghost story
  • possession
  • brotherhood
  • legend

Content notes: child endangerment, possession, dismemberment of corpses.

Quiz

How well do you remember Cry Baby Lane? Test yourself on the story.

Take the quiz
Loading streaming availability…
Read next

Movies Like Cry Baby Lane With a Plot Summary

5 films close to Cry Baby Lane in story and themes that have a full plot summary here: Cries in the Night (1980) and Cry for the Strangers (1982) lead. 2 of them come with the ending explained.

All plot summaries

Missing a Movie Plot Summary?

Tell us which film you want explained next: the full story, the timeline, the characters and the ending.

Request a summary
FAQ

Cry Baby Lane Plot Questions

5 quick answers about Cry Baby Lane, taken from the plot summary, character guide and setting on this page and the film’s credits.

What is Cry Baby Lane about?

In the quiet outskirts of a town that clings to its old folklore, the road known as Cry Baby Lane carries the whispers of the past like a restless wind. The community’s history is kept alive by the local undertaker, Mr.

Read the full plot summary

When and where does Cry Baby Lane take place?

Cry Baby Lane is set in Cry Baby Lane and Cry Baby Lane Cemetery. Cry Baby Lane is a secluded rural town centered around an old cemetery and a neglected dirt road. The cemetery and surrounding fields become the focal point of supernatural disturbances after a séance is attempted by a…

The setting explained

Who are the main characters in Cry Baby Lane?

The story follows Andrew (Jase Blankfort) (played by Jase Blankfort), Carl (Trey Rogers) (played by Trey Rogers), Mr. Bennett (Frank Langella) (played by Frank Langella) and Gary (Gary Perez) (played by Gary Perez); the character guide covers 6 characters in all.

All the characters

What are the main themes of Cry Baby Lane?

The summary picks out 3 themes: Good vs Evil, Folklore and Trust and Family.

The themes explained

Who directed Cry Baby Lane?

Cry Baby Lane (2000) was directed by Peter Lauer and runs 1 hour 9 minutes.

Peter Lauer’s films

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app