Where Angels Fear to Tread 1991

Recently widowed and eager to escape the meddling in-laws, free-spirited Lilia Herriton Helen Mirren travels to the hillside Tuscan town of Monteriano with her young friend Caroline Abbott Helena Bonham Carter, under the guise of being her chaperone, while leaving her young daughter in the care of her grandparents. There she falls in love with both the countryside and Gino Carella Giovanni Guidelli, a handsome young villager, and she decides to stay.

Appalled by her behavior and concerned about Lilia’s future, Mrs. Herriton dispatches her own son Philip Herriton Rupert Graves to Italy to persuade her to return home, but by the time he arrives Lilia and Gino have wed. He and Caroline return home, unable to forgive themselves for not putting an end to what they see as a clearly unsuitable marriage.

Lilia is startled to discover her desire for independence is at odds with Gino’s traditional values, and she is shocked when he becomes physical to clarify his position. Their relationship becomes less volatile when Lilia becomes pregnant, but she dies in childbirth, leaving her grieving husband with an infant son to raise with the help of his ageing mother.

When word of Lilia’s death reaches England, Caroline decides to return to Monteriano to save the boy from what she believes will surely be a difficult life. Not wanting to be outdone, or considered any less moral or less concerned than Caroline for the child’s welfare, Lilia’s mother-in-law sends Philip and his priggish spinster sister Harriet Judy Davis to Monteriano to obtain custody of the infant and bring him back to Sawston, where he can receive what she perceives to be a proper upbringing and education. Everything about the journey—especially the heat, the uncomfortable accommodations, and her difficulty communicating with the locals—distresses repressed and xenophobic Harriet; but Philip and Caroline both begin to find themselves attracted to everything Tuscan that had appealed to Lilia. Philip and Caroline also begin to sympathise with Gino and his loving relationship with his son, but though Philip says he ‘understands everyone’, he vacillates to even broach the subject of getting custody of the boy to Gino. Harriet is left to take matters into her own hands and makes a decision that leads to tragic consequences.

In contrast to the novel, the film adds an upbeat ending to the changes in the story, by hinting that love between Caroline and Philip may be possible.