What Comes Around (2023): Cast, Ratings, Box Office & Ending
What Comes Around is a 2023 drama thriller directed by Amy Redford, starring Grace Van Dien as Anna, Kyle Gallner and Reina Hardesty. It runs 1 hour 23 minutes and earned $5,935 worldwide. It earned 1 award nomination, including Feature Micro Budget – Comedy or Drama at the Artios Awards 2024. Critics gave it 32% on Rotten Tomatoes, and IMDb users rate it 5.3/10.
- Released
- Runtime
- 1h 23m (83 min)
- Director
- Amy Redford
- Original language
-
English
- Studio
- IFC Films
- After the credits
- No No extra scene
What Is What Comes Around About?
The premise of What Comes Around without spoilers. The whole story and the ending explained are in the plot summary further down.
A passionate romance blossoms amidst a web of secrets and lies, quickly turning into a dangerous game of deception. As the relationship deepens, the characters find themselves entangled in a deadly dance where discerning truth from illusion becomes increasingly difficult. The consequences of their actions threaten everyone involved, leaving no one untouched by the unfolding drama.
What Comes Around Themes & Keywords
· 16 tags- young
- love
- older man young woman
- cell phone
- birthday
- cake
- friend
- adult man teenage girl relationship
- teacher student relationship
- older woman younger man relationship
- child abuse
- police officer
+4 more Show fewer
- revenge
- suicidal
- photo
- mature woman teenage boy relationship
What Comes Around Cast & Characters
Grace Van Dien leads the cast as Anna, with Kyle Gallner as Eric and Reina Hardesty as Brit. Directed by Amy Redford; 10 actors are credited in all.
- Director Amy Redford
-
Grace Van Dien as Anna -
Kyle Gallner as Eric - Reina Hardesty as Brit
- Summer Phoenix as Beth
Also Starring in What Comes Around
· 6 more- Jesse Garcia Tim
- Gabriel Monroe Eckert Leo
- Chase Voelker Open House Guest #2
- Indiana Affleck Denny
- Paul Tew Open House Guest
- Sierra Nicole Rose Ashley
More from Amy Redford
One more film directed by Amy Redford: The Guitar.
What Comes Around Reviews & Ratings
Critics gave What Comes Around 32% on Rotten Tomatoes, and IMDb users rate it 5.3/10. Our Echo Score gives it 55/100, strongest in character & emotion (65) and weakest in art & craft (45).
What Comes Around Echo Score Breakdown
What Comes Around elicits a divided response, with critics largely condemning its execution while several viewers praise its twists and performances. The film manages moments of intrigue through its premise and occasional atmospheric direction, yet it suffers from uneven storytelling and tonal missteps that undermine its impact. This tug-of-war between praise for specific elements and criticism of overall cohesion results in a middling overall impression.
Our own 0–100 rating, built from five aspects: art, character, story, the sensory experience and how well a film rewatches.
- Art & Craft 45
In terms of art and craft, the film shows flashes of competent direction, particularly in creating an unnerving atmosphere, but many reviewers note a lack of focus and clumsy staging. Critics highlight tactical missteps and contrived visuals, while a few users commend the director’s deft handling of mood. The mixed feedback leads to a below‑average assessment of the film’s artistic execution.
- Character & Emotion 65
When it comes to character and emotion, performances are a high point for many viewers, with several actors described as outstanding or award‑worthy. However, critics and some users point out unnatural dialogue and uneven chemistry that detract from authenticity. The overall sentiment leans positive due to strong individual portrayals, though inconsistency prevents a higher rating.
- Story & Flow 55
Story and flow receive a mixed appraisal; the plot’s twists and premise are praised for being engaging and unpredictable by some audience members. Conversely, numerous critics label the narrative as murky, contrived, and a dead‑end, while a few users criticize pacing and script quality. This balance of intrigue and narrative weakness yields an average story score.
- Sensory Experience 50
Sensory experience is split between commendations for an effective, suspenseful atmosphere and complaints about overly loud music and weak sound design. While a handful of reviewers appreciate the film’s mood‑setting elements, others find the audio distracts from dialogue and diminishes immersion. The divergent opinions result in a moderate sensory rating.
- Rewatch Factor 60
Rewatch factor is generally favorable among viewers who cite the film’s twists, suspense, and strong performances as reasons to return. Critics, however, question its lasting appeal due to narrative flaws and fatigue in the second half. The prevailing view among users suggests a decent replay value, offset by some reservations, leading to a slightly above‑average score.
-
IMDb 5.3 /10
See on IMDb -
Rotten Tomatoes 32% Tomatometer
Popcornmeter 46%
See on Rotten Tomatoes -
TMDB 56% User score
See on TMDB -
Letterboxd 2.4 /5
6343 ratings
See on Letterboxd
What Comes Around Plot Summary & Ending Explained
What happens in What Comes Around from start to finish, spoilers included, with a timeline of 14 key events and the ending explained. The opening is below; the full summary is a 3-minute read.
Spoilers ahead
Anna finds herself entangled in a complicated relationship with a boy named Eric that she first met online. Engaging in discussions about the poetry of Emily Dickinson, Anna confides in her friend, Brit, about Eric, revealing that he is older than her. On the eve of Anna’s 17th birthday, she is surprised when Eric surprises her with a visit, gifting her a beautifully curated collection of Emily Dickinson’s poems along with a note that strikes a chord with her. Hand in hand, they stroll through the park, where Eric eventually discloses that he is actually 28, leading Anna to feel a mix of thrill and apprehension.
Full summary
The whole story of What Comes Around, scene by scene, with the ending explained
What Comes Around Box Office
What Comes Around grossed $5,935 worldwide.
Worldwide gross
$5.9K
- US & Canada
- $5.9K
What Comes Around Awards & Nominations
What Comes Around earned 1 award nomination, including Feature Micro Budget – Comedy or Drama at the Artios Awards 2024.
1 nomination1 ceremony
-
Artios Awards 2024 1 nomination- Nominated Feature Micro Budget – Comedy or Drama
What Comes Around Trailers & Videos
4 videos: 1 trailer and 3 clips.
- Clip Official Clip - "Who's Eric?"
- Clip Official Clip - "Birthday Surprise"
- Clip Official Clip - "He Wants to Meet You"
How Well Do You Know What Comes Around?
10 questions about the story, each with a hint if you get stuck. Pick an answer to see whether you were right.
Question 1 of 10
- Question 1: not answered
- Question 2: not answered
- Question 3: not answered
- Question 4: not answered
- Question 5: not answered
- Question 6: not answered
- Question 7: not answered
- Question 8: not answered
- Question 9: not answered
- Question 10: not answered
What gift does Eric surprise Anna with?
What Comes Around Also Known As
9 alternative titles, including “Roost” and “루스트”.
- Also known as
-
- Roost
- 루스트
- Intrusion sentimentale
- Red de venganza
- 栖息
- מי שמחפש צרות
- My Secret Life
- Teia de Vingança
- Роковая ошибка
Seen What Comes Around?
Movies Like What Comes Around
Films with a similar story, tone or audience, including What About Love, A Family Affair and The Air I Breathe.
What Comes Around FAQ: Cast, Box Office & Awards
Runtime, release date, director, cast, box office, ratings, awards and post-credit scenes of What Comes Around, each answered in a sentence.
How long is What Comes Around?
What Comes Around runs 1 hour 23 minutes (83 minutes).
When was What Comes Around released?
What Comes Around was released on August 4, 2023.
Who directed What Comes Around?
What Comes Around was directed by Amy Redford.
More films by Amy Redford Who is in the cast of What Comes Around?
What Comes Around stars Grace Van Dien as Anna, Kyle Gallner as Eric and Reina Hardesty as Brit, among 10 credited actors.
How much did What Comes Around make at the box office?
What Comes Around grossed $5,935 worldwide.
How is What Comes Around rated?
What Comes Around has 5.3/10 on IMDb, 32% on Rotten Tomatoes, 56% on TMDB and 2.4/5 on Letterboxd.
Was What Comes Around nominated for any awards?
What Comes Around received 1 nomination across 1 ceremony.
Does What Comes Around have a post-credit scene?
No. What Comes Around has no extra scene during or after the credits.
Coming soon to your phone
The Plot Explained Movie Summary App
From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.
Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app
