What Is What Comes Around About?
The premise of What Comes Around in 316 words, with nothing given away. The full story and the ending follow below.
In a quiet suburb where the rhythm of everyday life is punctuated by the glow of screens, a story of longing and hidden depths begins to unfold. The world feels both familiar and slightly off‑kilter, a place where poetry can be a secret language and a single message can turn a simple birthday into a moment of unexpected intensity. The tone hovers between tender romance and a subtle, unsettling undercurrent, inviting viewers to sense that something more lies beneath each whispered line.
Anna is a thoughtful seventeen‑year‑old whose love of Emily Dickinson draws her into an online connection that feels as intoxicating as it is mysterious. The voice on the other side belongs to Eric, a charismatic yet older figure whose literary gifts spark both excitement and doubt. Around them, Brit, a close friend with a protective streak, offers a grounded perspective, while at home, Beth and her fiancé Tim provide the backdrop of family expectations and the quiet pressure of adulthood. The characters each carry their own hopes and insecurities, setting the stage for a delicate dance of attraction and caution.
As the relationship deepens, the film paints a portrait of youthful yearning tangled with the complexities of age, secrecy, and the desire to be seen. The romance blossoms amid a web of unspoken questions, each text and shared poem hinting at a truth that remains just out of reach. The atmosphere is charged with the tension of what is said and what is left unsaid, making the audience feel the pull between trust and uncertainty.
The narrative promises a journey where love becomes a maze of concealed motives and emotional risk, all wrapped in an evocative, moody aesthetic. By the end of the opening act, viewers are left wondering how far the characters will go to protect what matters most, and what revelations might surface when the line between illusion and reality finally blurs.
What Happens in What Comes Around?
The complete story of What Comes Around, from the first scene to the last, in 525 words (about 2 minutes). Spoilers throughout. Names in the text link to 4 cast member pages.
Spoilers ahead
Anna finds herself entangled in a complicated relationship with a boy named Eric that she first met online. Engaging in discussions about the poetry of Emily Dickinson, Anna confides in her friend, Brit, about Eric, revealing that he is older than her. On the eve of Anna’s 17th birthday, she is surprised when Eric surprises her with a visit, gifting her a beautifully curated collection of Emily Dickinson’s poems along with a note that strikes a chord with her. Hand in hand, they stroll through the park, where Eric eventually discloses that he is actually 28, leading Anna to feel a mix of thrill and apprehension.
As the day progresses, Anna wakes up to find Eric beside her, only to realize that her friends are waiting to take her out for her birthday celebration. With no easy way for Eric to slip past her mother, Beth, and her mother’s fiancé, Tim, Anna makes him stay behind, leading to his eventual departure while she is out. When Anna returns home, Eric is nowhere to be found, and her anxiety builds as he does not reply to her texts.
In conversations with Brit, Anna is warned to tread carefully, yet, her connection with Eric deepens as they continue to text frequently. Things take a turn when Beth questions her about Eric’s age, quickly revealing her concern upon discovering that Anna has become sexually active. After finally introducing Eric to her family, Beth’s reaction is anything but warm, prompting a confrontation where underlying tensions mount—especially once Beth realizes Eric’s true identity, which is, in fact, Jesse.
Their history runs deeper than Anna could have imagined, as it is revealed that Jesse was once a student of Beth’s, and a troubling web of past emotions and misunderstandings comes to light. As Jesse’s presence grows increasingly unsettling, Beth’s desperation for Anna to stay safe escalates, leading to fierce confrontations. The tension sharpens when Beth learns that Jesse, under the guise of love, has been threatening not just her, but her entire family.
In a climactic moment, with their lives teetering on the edge, Jesse sneaks into Beth’s home, reigniting old memories that bubble to the surface. In the heat of a dramatic confrontation, Beth is forced to confront her past while Anna grapples with the truth about her relationship. As Anna prepares to leave with Jesse, a critical revelation breaks through the chaos—Beth and Jesse’s relationship was far more complicated, including confessions of love intertwined with regret.
As the evening of her engagement party unfolds, Anna and Beth reach a pivotal moment of resolution. With emotions running high and the threat of Jesse still looming, both women are left to navigate the aftermath of their shocking revelations. Anna reflects on their tumultuous journey, telling Beth candidly that the only thing she saved her from was possibly a future behind bars. The night culminates in a powerful statement of resilience as Anna steps out of the car, urging Beth to embrace the celebration that is her own.
This new summary retains all the essential plot elements while expanding on character motivations and thematic depth, providing a captivating overview for readers.
What Comes Around Timeline: Every Key Event in Order
14 key events in the order they happen, from “Anna Meets Eric Online” to “Empowerment and Resilience”. 9 events name a place, across 4 locations.
- 1
Anna Meets Eric Online
Anna first encounters Eric during an online interaction where they delve into the poetry of Emily Dickinson. This exchange marks the beginning of an intriguing, yet complicated relationship that will shape Anna's journey.
- 2
The Gift on Anna's Birthday Eve
On the eve of her 17th birthday, Anna is surprised by a visit from Eric, who presents her with a curated collection of Emily Dickinson's poems. Along with the gift comes a heartfelt note that resonates deeply with Anna, setting an emotional tone for their relationship.
When:On the eve of her 17th birthday Where:Anna's home
- 3
Strolling in the Park
Hand in hand, Anna and Eric take a stroll through the park where Eric reveals his true age of 28. This shocking disclosure brings a mix of excitement and apprehension for Anna, as she grapples with the implications of this age gap.
Where:Local park
- 4
Anna's Birthday Celebration
Anna wakes up to find Eric beside her, but her friends are waiting to take her out for her birthday celebration. Unable to let Eric meet her mother, she asks him to stay behind, not knowing this would lead to his departure while she is out.
When:Morning of her 17th birthday Where:Anna's home
- 5
Anxiety Grows
After celebrating her birthday, Anna returns home to find that Eric is missing. Her growing anxiety intensifies when her texts to him go unanswered, leading to feelings of confusion and concern.
When:After her birthday celebration Where:Anna's home
- 6
Conversations with Brit
In discussions with her friend Brit, Anna is cautioned to be careful about her relationship with Eric. Despite the warning, her connection with Eric deepens as they continue to text frequently, highlighting the complexity of their bond.
- 7
Beth's Concerns
Anna's mother, Beth, questions her about Eric's age after she discovers Anna is becoming sexually active. This unexpected conversation reveals Beth's deep concerns for Anna's safety and well-being, causing tension in their relationship.
Where:Anna's home
- 8
Introduction to the Family
Upon introducing Eric to her family, Anna faces a cold reception from Beth. This encounter escalates into a confrontation, unearthing underlying tensions as Beth uncovers Eric's true identity—Jesse, a former student of hers, adding layers to their history.
Where:Anna's home
- 9
Jesse's Threatening Presence
As Jesse's presence becomes increasingly unsettling, Anna's mother, Beth, becomes desperate to protect her daughter at all costs. The escalating tensions culminate in fierce confrontations, underscoring the complexity of their relationships.
Where:Anna's home
- 10
Confrontation at Home
In a dramatic turn of events, Jesse sneaks into Beth's home, reigniting painful memories for all involved. This confrontation forces Beth to face her past while Anna is confronted with the truth about her relationship with Jesse.
Where:Beth's home
Show the other 4 events of What Comes Around Hide the last 4 events
- 11
Critical Revelation
As Anna prepares to leave with Jesse, a vital revelation emerges—Beth and Jesse share a complex history filled with love and regret. This realization forces both women to confront their emotional scars and the impact of their choices.
- 12
Engagement Party Tensions
During the evening of her engagement party, Anna and Beth navigate through the emotional fallout of their revelations. With Jesse's threat still looming, the two women attempt to find common ground amidst their shared turmoil.
Where:Engagement party venue
- 13
Final Reflections
As the night comes to a close, Anna reflects on the chaotic journey they've endured together. In a poignant moment, she tells Beth that the only thing she saved her from was potentially a future filled with regret and imprisonment.
- 14
Empowerment and Resilience
In a powerful culmination of their experiences, Anna steps out of the car after urging Beth to embrace her celebration. This act symbolizes newfound strength and resilience, marking a turning point in their relationship as they move forward.
Who Are the Main Characters in What Comes Around?
4 characters, among them Anna, Beth and Eric/Jesse: who each one is and the part they play in the story. 3 of them link to the actor’s page.
- A
Anna
Anna is a 17-year-old navigating the complexities of her first serious relationship, drawn to Eric despite the red flags. Her character embodies the naivety and romanticism of youth, coupled with the struggles of confronting uncomfortable truths. As she faces intense emotional challenges, her journey illustrates her growth from innocence to awareness.
- 👧 Young Adult
- 💕 Romantic
- ⚖️ Vulnerable
- B
Beth
Played by Summer Phoenix
Beth serves as both a protective mother and a character with a troubled past. Her relationship with Jesse brings forth fears and unresolved issues, adding depth to her character. As a mother, she embodies the struggle to protect her child while confronting her own mistakes and emotional baggage.
- 👩🦰 Protective
- 🥀 Troubled Past
- 🌪️ Conflict
-
Eric/Jesse
Played by Kyle Gallner
Initially presented as the charming older love interest, Eric transforms into Jesse, a character shrouded in deception and complexity. His dual identity reveals layers of manipulation and past connections with Beth, adding a chilling dynamic to the story. He represents both the allure and danger of relationships that seem too good to be true.
- 🧑🎤 Charming
- 🚨 Deceptive
- 🔄 Dual Identity
- B
Brit
Played by Reina Hardesty
Brit is Anna's close friend, providing a voice of caution amid the unfolding drama. Her concerns stem from a place of loyalty and love, serving as a warning for Anna to be cautious with Eric. Brit's character highlights the importance of friendship and support systems during turbulent times.
- 👭 Friends
- ⚡ Cautionary
- ❤️ Supportive
Where and When Is What Comes Around Set?
What Comes Around is set in Park and Home (Modern Day). Here is why the time and place matter to the story.
When
Modern Day
The narrative unfolds in contemporary times, where issues of age, consent, and family dynamics are brought to the forefront. This period is marked by complex relationships exacerbated by technology, highlighting the challenges of modern youth navigating emotional and physical intimacy. It reflects a society grappling with its views on love, safety, and the consequences of interpersonal connections.
Where
Park, Home
The park serves as a significant backdrop for Anna and Eric's initial connection, symbolizing innocence and the blossoming of their relationship. It is a place where intimate moments unfold, juxtaposed against the complications that arise from their age difference. The home is a space of familial tensions and revelations, where the dynamics between Anna, her mother, and Jesse culminate in dramatic confrontations.
- 🌳 Park
- 🏡 Home
What Are the Themes of What Comes Around?
3 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Love and Betrayal, Dangerous Relationships and Mother-Daughter Bonds.
-
01
Love and Betrayal
The film explores the theme of love intertwined with betrayal, particularly through Anna’s complicated relationship with Eric/Jesse. As their relationship develops, underlying secrets and past traumas surface, leading to emotional turmoil for both Anna and her mother. This dynamic sheds light on how love can be both a source of joy and a catalyst for deeper conflict.
-
02
Dangerous Relationships
Dangerous relationships are central to the plot, where the innocence of Anna's feelings becomes clouded by the unsettling truths about Eric’s true identity. The tension builds as she navigates her desires amidst warnings from her friends and the protective instincts of her mother. The film challenges viewers to consider the complexities and potential dangers that can lurk within seemingly genuine connections.
-
03
Mother-Daughter Bonds
The bond between Anna and her mother, Beth, illustrates the complexities of familial relationships, especially during adolescence. As Beth grapples with her protective instincts and past experiences, their relationship is tested by Anna's choices and the revelation of Jesse's intentions. This theme underscores the tension between love, care, and the need for independence in a young woman’s life.
How Does What Comes Around End?
The last act of What Comes Around and what it means, in 449 words. The ending lands as mixed. Big spoilers: read the plot summary first if you have not seen it.
The final act, in full
What Comes Around explores the devastating impact of past actions on future lives, illustrating how trauma and secrets can come back to haunt us. Throughout the film, we see how Beth, a single mother, hides a dark secret about her past relationship with Jesse, a troubled young man she once had a relationship with during her time as a teacher. This relationship ended in scandal, with Beth lying to protect herself, which left Jesse emotionally shattered and falsely accused him of imagining their affair. Jesse, feeling betrayed and misunderstood, spends years trying to find closure, convincing himself that revealing the truth will finally set him free.
As Jesse re-enters Beth’s life under the guise of reconnecting with her, he is driven by a desire for the truth—believing that knowing what truly happened between them will validate his feelings and give him peace. His approach is manipulative and emotional; he records conversations and confronts Beth with evidence that could ruin her, pressing her to confess the reality of their past affair. However, Jesse’s ultimate motive isn’t just revenge—he seeks closure so he can finally move on from his past pain, even if it means destroying Beth in the process.
In the film’s climax, Beth finally admits what Jesse needs to hear—that their relationship was real and not a figment of his mind. She reveals she destroyed her records and memories to hide the truth, fearing legal consequences if she confessed earlier, and shows her emotional vulnerability. Jesse’s confrontation ends with him choosing not to blackmail her; he leaves the recording on the table, signifying that he has decided to let go of revenge and accept the truth. Yet, before he leaves, he subtly hints that he will see Anna, Beth’s daughter, again—mirroring the words Beth once said to him—suggesting that Jesse’s love for Anna was genuine and that his final act was a form of poetic justice.
In the closing scenes, Beth and Anna drive away, heading to a wedding, but the damage is done. Jesse may have walked away, but his presence haunts the story—his emotional scars and unresolved feelings continue to influence the lives he touched. Anna, overwhelmed by the revelation, harbors resentment towards her mother for keeping secrets, and the cycle appears to repeat itself. The film closes with the understanding that life’s cycles of pain and retribution never truly end; what comes around eventually finds its way back, reminding us that secrets, pain, and the past can shape the present in ways we often don’t realize until it’s too late. Jesse’s final act, love intertwined with revenge, leaves a lasting mark that suggests life will keep turning, and justice, in its own mysterious way, always returns.
What Kind of Film Is What Comes Around?
Tense in tone, with steady pacing and a moderate story, going by the plot summary.
- Tone
- Tense
- Pacing
- Steady
- Story
- Moderate
- Intensity
- High
- Ending
- Mixed
A tense and psychologically dangerous thriller that steadily builds suspense around a manipulative online romance, creating an anxious and unsettling atmosphere as secrets unravel and threaten a family.
- anxious
- suspenseful
- dangerous
- betrayal
- desperate
- unsettling
- illicit relationship
- secrets and lies
- manipulation
- revenge
Content notes: child abuse, teacher student relationship, grooming, suicidal photo.
Quiz
How well do you remember What Comes Around? Test yourself on the story.
