The Scary of Sixty-First (2021): Cast, Ratings & Box Office
The Scary of Sixty-First is a 2021 mystery thriller starring Betsey Brown as Addie, Madeline Quinn and Dasha Nekrasova. It runs 1 hour 21 minutes and earned $56,158 worldwide. Critics gave it 54% on Rotten Tomatoes and 48 on Metacritic, and IMDb users rate it 4.5/10.
What Is The Scary of Sixty-First About?
The premise of The Scary of Sixty-First without spoilers. The whole story is in the plot summary further down.
While staying in a Manhattan duplex with a troubling past, college friends Noelle and Addie encounter a mysterious woman who insists the apartment once belonged to Jeffrey Epstein. As Noelle becomes increasingly preoccupied with the visitor, Addie experiences a disturbing descent into possession. Their investigation unravels a complex web of conspiracies, deceit, and unsettling secrets that challenge their understanding of reality.
The Scary of Sixty-First Themes & Keywords
· 50 tags- apartment
- lesbian sex
- gay interest
- possession
- occult
- pizzagate
- pentagram
- female topless nudity
- female rear nudity
- title directed by female
- roommate
- female nudity
+38 more Show fewer
- female full frontal nudity
- manhattan new york city
- terror
- quest
- tea spoon
- drug abuse
- being followed
- tarot cards
- sinister
- being watched
- search for the truth
- season greetings
- obsession
- insanity
- danger
- connections
- upper east side
- pedophile
- billionaire
- commemorative spoon
- british royal family
- pedophile network
- abuse of power
- trauma
- lolita express
- role playing
- alleged suicide
- occult symbol
- mk ultra
- mind control
- victim
- stabbing
- satanism
- dangerous behavior
- piano
- set up
- choking to death
- real estate agent
The Scary of Sixty-First Cast & Characters
Betsey Brown leads the cast as Addie, with Madeline Quinn as Noelle and Dasha Nekrasova as The Girl.
- Betsey Brown as Addie
- Madeline Quinn as Noelle
-
Dasha Nekrasova as The Girl -
Aaron Dalla Villa as Crystal Shop Customer
Also Starring in The Scary of Sixty-First
· 6 more- Jason Grisell Apothecary Clerk
- Ruby McCollister Mailroom Girl
- Stephen Gurewitz The Realtor
- Anna Khachiyan Ghislaine Maxwell Doppelgänger
- Michael M. Bilandic Greg's Boss
- Mark Rapaport
The Scary of Sixty-First Reviews & Ratings
Critics gave The Scary of Sixty-First 54% on Rotten Tomatoes and 48 on Metacritic, and IMDb users rate it 4.5/10. Our Echo Score gives it 52/100, strongest in sensory experience (65) and weakest in character & emotion (45).
The Scary of Sixty-First Echo Score Breakdown
In terms of the film as a whole, the consensus leans toward a mixed to negative assessment. Critics acknowledge occasional originality and bold visual choices, yet they frequently cite incoherent storytelling and uneven performances. User feedback mirrors this split, with a few praising the static cinematography and debut effort, while others express disappointment in the narrative payoff. The cumulative impression is that the movie offers sporadic moments of intrigue but fails to sustain them, resulting in limited lasting impact.
Our own 0–100 rating, built from five aspects: art, character, story, the sensory experience and how well a film rewatches.
- Art & Craft 55
Artistic execution displays a blend of promising visual elements and uneven directorial choices. Reviewers note the film’s static shots and hallucinatory style as moments of visual intrigue, yet many criticize the overall lack of cohesive craftsmanship and purposeful editing. This combination yields a modest artistic impression that falls short of a consistently polished work.
- Character & Emotion 45
Character work is marked by a stark inconsistency across performances. Some critics commend Nekrasova’s debut effort and occasional effective portrayals, while others label much of the acting as apathetic or outright atrocious. The emotional resonance consequently feels fragmented, limiting audience connection with the protagonists. Overall, character depth remains underdeveloped, detracting from the film’s intended impact.
- Story & Flow 50
Storytelling suffers from uneven pacing and a fragmented narrative structure. While a subset of reviewers appreciate the film’s audacious premise, unconventional twists, and occasional parody of conspiracy tropes, many criticize the lack of coherent resolution and perceived reliance on shock value. The resulting experience feels more like a series of provocative set‑pieces than a unified plot, diminishing overall engagement.
- Sensory Experience 65
Sensory design offers several commendable moments, especially through its static framing and retro‑vibe soundscape. Critics highlight the film’s distinct visual palette and effective use of atmospheric sound to reinforce its unsettling tone. Nevertheless, other feedback points to inconsistent audio mixing and occasional visual clutter that distracts from immersion. On balance, the sensory components contribute positively but are unevenly executed.
- Rewatch Factor 55
Rewatch potential is mixed; some reviewers note the film’s bold premise and memorable visual style could invite repeat viewings, while others argue the uneven narrative and lack of lasting resonance diminish its appeal after the initial experience. Audience reactions echo this split, with a few expressing curiosity about further analysis and many citing disappointment that reduces motivation for a second viewing.
-
IMDb 4.5 /10
See on IMDb -
Rotten Tomatoes 54% Tomatometer
Popcornmeter 46%
See on Rotten Tomatoes -
Metacritic 48 Metascore
See on Metacritic -
TMDB 56% User score
See on TMDB -
Letterboxd 2.6 /5
20 ratings
See on Letterboxd -
Movie Insider 2.0 /5
See on Movie Insider
The Scary of Sixty-First Plot Summary
What happens in The Scary of Sixty-First from start to finish, spoilers included, with a timeline of 13 key events. The opening is below; the full summary is a 3-minute read.
Spoilers ahead
Noelle and Addie, two young adults, are on the lookout for an apartment in the bustling Upper East Side. Despite the strange features of the apartment—such as its abandoned furnishings and a rather suspicious realtor—they decide to make it their home. On their first night, Noelle stumbles upon a tarot card, while Addie becomes increasingly tormented by a series of nightmares.
Full summary
The whole story of The Scary of Sixty-First, scene by scene
The Scary of Sixty-First Box Office
The Scary of Sixty-First grossed $56,158 worldwide. $45,005 came from the US and Canada and $11,153 (20%) from the rest of the world.
Worldwide gross
$56.2K
- US & Canada
- $45K
- International
- $11.2K
The Scary of Sixty-First Trailers & Videos
3 videos: 2 trailers and 1 clip.
- Trailer Official Green Band Trailer
- Clip Holiday Tree
How Well Do You Know The Scary of Sixty-First?
10 questions about the story, each with a hint if you get stuck. Pick an answer to see whether you were right.
Question 1 of 10
- Question 1: not answered
- Question 2: not answered
- Question 3: not answered
- Question 4: not answered
- Question 5: not answered
- Question 6: not answered
- Question 7: not answered
- Question 8: not answered
- Question 9: not answered
- Question 10: not answered
Where is the apartment located?
The Scary of Sixty-First Also Known As
7 alternative titles, including “The Scary of Sixty-First Street” and “The Scary of 61st Street”.
- Also known as
-
- The Scary of Sixty-First Street
- The Scary of 61st Street
- Ужас на 61-й улице
- 스케어리 오브 식스티-퍼스트
- 六十一号的恐怖
- Жах на 61-й вулиці
- 租屋寓到鬼
Seen The Scary of Sixty-First?
Movies Like The Scary of Sixty-First
Films with a similar story, tone or audience, including Apartment 7A, Nocturne and 6:45.
The Scary of Sixty-First FAQ: Cast, Box Office & Runtime
Runtime, release date, cast, box office, ratings and post-credit scenes of The Scary of Sixty-First, each answered in a sentence.
How long is The Scary of Sixty-First?
The Scary of Sixty-First runs 1 hour 21 minutes (81 minutes).
When was The Scary of Sixty-First released?
The Scary of Sixty-First was released on December 3, 2021.
Who is in the cast of The Scary of Sixty-First?
The Scary of Sixty-First stars Betsey Brown as Addie, Madeline Quinn as Noelle and Dasha Nekrasova as The Girl, among 10 credited actors.
How much did The Scary of Sixty-First make at the box office?
The Scary of Sixty-First grossed $56,158 worldwide ($45,005 domestic, $11,153 international).
How is The Scary of Sixty-First rated?
The Scary of Sixty-First has 4.5/10 on IMDb, 54% on Rotten Tomatoes, 48 on Metacritic and 56% on TMDB.
Does The Scary of Sixty-First have a post-credit scene?
No. The Scary of Sixty-First has no extra scene during or after the credits.
Coming soon to your phone
The Plot Explained Movie Summary App
From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.
Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app
