Squaring the Circle (The Story of Hipgnosis) 2023

Art & Craft

In terms of art and craft, the film benefits from Anton Corbijn's distinct black‑and‑white direction and careful editing of archive material. Reviewers highlight the visual elegance of the footage and the effective use of historic images, while acknowledging a conventional talking‑head format that limits creative flair. Overall, the production design and cinematography are solid, providing a pleasing visual foundation without breaking new ground.

Character & Emotion

When it comes to character and emotion, the documentary excels through vivid interview excerpts and personal stories from the designers and musicians they influenced. Critics note the poignant and occasionally humorous moments that reveal the personalities behind iconic covers. Viewers echo this sentiment, describing the emotional resonance of the anecdotes and the depth of interpersonal dynamics as a major strength of the film.

Story & Flow

Regarding story and flow, the narrative follows a straightforward chronological path that some find clear and accessible. However, reviewers also point out a lack of innovative structuring and a formulaic progression that can feel predictable. The pacing is generally measured, yet the ending is perceived as weaker, leaving the overall storytelling competent but not exceptionally compelling.

Sensory Experience

In the sensory experience domain, the film’s monochrome visual style and curated soundtrack reinforce its artistic focus. Critics and users appreciate the cohesive aesthetic that mirrors the era of the album art discussed. While the sound design is not heavily emphasized in reviews, the combination of music excerpts and visual presentation creates an immersive atmosphere that supports the documentary’s subject matter.

Rewatch Factor

The rewatch factor is high, as both critics and audiences describe the documentary as a satisfying repeatable experience for music and design enthusiasts. The wealth of anecdotes, iconic visuals, and behind‑the‑scenes insights offer new details on subsequent viewings. Enthusiastic user comments underscore its lasting appeal, making it a documentary many intend to revisit.