The Best of Enemies 1961

British Army Major Richardson is captured in 1941 during a march through the Ethiopian desert when the pilot of his reconnaissance plane crashes. The Italian detachment that takes him prisoner is led by Captain Blasi, who questions him but receives only the bare minimum: name, rank, and serial number. A British night attack is repelled, and with the death of Major Fornari, Captain Blasi finds himself in command. Over time, the two men grow tense and testy with one another, each sure of their own stubborn resolve.

Blasi decides to bluff his way out by letting Richardson and his squadron escape, hoping to force the British to conclude that his force is too weak to warrant continued pursuit. The plan is meant to signal that Blasi’s unit is not worth the trouble of a full-scale chase. Yet orders soon arrive to have Richardson organize a motorized squadron to hunt down Blasi’s forces. The pursuit leads them to a fort where the rest of Blasi’s men are rumored to be rallying, only to find empty, abandoned equipment. Moments later, Richardson’s armored cars roll into view, and the hunt becomes personal.

Under pressure from his friend Bernasconi, Blasi weighs surrender but resists what he sees as Richardson’s betrayal. He refuses the British terms and orders most of his African soldiers to stay behind, giving a tight one-hour deadline before surrender. The standoff escalates into a chase across the landscape as Richardson presses ahead, ignoring Captain Rootes’ cautions about the terrain and the risk.

Blasi’s decision to dismiss four African warriors for misbehavior loosens the tactical tension, and those men slip behind the British lines to set a forest fire that destroys armored cars and essential supplies. The resulting conflagration forces both sides to retreat and seek safety on a nearby lake’s island, turning the pursuit into a grueling march through harsh terrain where the Italians march as prisoners rather than aggressors.

As they cross the desert, the makeshift POW column grows more fragile. They arrive at a native village where the local headman, who has previously had dealings with Richardson, claims the allegiance of the local population and demands the confiscation of the Italians’ weapons and even the Italians themselves. Richardson refuses to part with either, maintaining a stubborn sense of duty and control. They pause in an abandoned village because a British officer is too ill to move, and there they find themselves surrounded by hostile natives led by the same headman. In the tense waiting period that follows, Richardson and Blasi begin to understand one another better, and Richardson privately contemplates arming the Italian troops.

A bold, volatile decision follows: Richardson resolves to arm the Italians, but discovers they left their ammunition behind. He proposes a risky escape plan in which everyone would slip away in six-person groups down a gully. The plan backfires, as the opening up of the escape route makes it easier for native forces to corral the fugitives. After their weapons and boots are taken, the Italians are allowed to leave, effectively handing the conflict back to the locals and forcing a harsh reality onto the two sides.

They eventually reach a road and Blasi is elated to see a sign indicating they are roughly 150 miles behind Italian lines. Seconds later, a British convoy appears on its way to a victory celebration, revealing that the Italians have been defeated. Blasi and his men are recaptured, and the two factions cross paths once more at a railway station. In a silent gesture of newfound mutual respect, Richardson orders his men to present arms, signaling a quiet reconciliation and a tempered understanding between the two former adversaries.