Black Butterflies 2024

In a small seaside shack by the coast, Ingrid and Anna Jonker grow up under the care of their elderly grandmother, a fragile beginning shadowed by a harsh, political world outside their door. One stormy night, Anna rushes into the bedroom with a haunting report: their grandmother is not breathing. The moment is etched in their memory, foretold by the appearance of Abraham Jonker, a powerful politician who arrives with quiet shock at the sight that the girls have no shoes to welcome him. His unsettling reply to Anna’s question about what to call him lands in the air with a cold bluntness: “Call me ‘Pa.’” The father’s blunt warmth and the family’s vulnerability set a tone that will echo through Ingrid’s life for years to come.

Decades slip by, and the film shifts to 1960, where an adult Ingrid swims against a relentless current near Clifton in Cape Town. A man on the shore dives into the water to pull her to safety, introducing himself as the novelist Jack Cope. Ingrid’s gratitude is sudden and fierce; she tells him that his novel saved her life, a sentiment that startles him into self-awareness. This chance encounter marks the beginning of a relationship that will fuse art, love, and a turbulent defiance of the era’s censorship. Ingrid, whose life has been shaped by her father’s political power and the stifling climate around her, reveals herself as a poet under the spell of literature that has warned, comforted, and saved her in equal measure.

Jack’s arrival in Ingrid’s late-’50s world draws her into a bohemian circle of writers. A fragile trust forms between them, blossoming into a passionate, complicated romance. They share creative dreams, each fueling the other’s work, while the political climate—where a censorship board and a white-supremacist party shape every facet of life—casts a long, oppressive shadow. When a black writer laments the confiscation of his manuscript and the censorship that has silenced a generation, the weight of such censorship lands on Ingrid as a personal accusation and a political duty at once. The writer’s lament points to a broader injustice: the man who governs the state’s gatekeeping machinery also happens to be Ingrid’s own father, Abraham Jonker, a figure who embodies the chilling intersection of authority and heartbreak.

Ingrid and Jack’s bond intensifies as they explore art, love, and the destructive grip of a political system that leaves no room for dissent. Ingrid writes a poem in honor of Jack, a small act of poetry that becomes a catalyst for a larger, more dangerous love. As their relationship deepens, Jack proposes a future that would include Ingrid and her daughter, refusing to marry out of fear or a desire for stability that would quash their creative tensions. Jack’s hesitation becomes a quiet crisis, and when he opts to leave to finish his own work, Ingrid faces a brutal choice between waiting and moving on. She ultimately experiences a secret abortion, a painful private decision that she carries with her, even as she continues to write.

Time moves on, and Ingrid’s hunger for connection leads her into new creative landscapes. She meets Eugene Maritz, a fan of Afrikaans literature who is celebrated as a future hope by contemporaries such as Uys Krige. The dynamic of loneliness, longing, and a desperate need for validation drives Ingrid to make a fateful, impulsive choice: she seduces Maritz. When Jack returns to find Maritz’s shoes in his closet, the emotional rupture erupts with dramatic force, and Ingrid is cast out. The film’s emotional geometry—desire, jealousy, and the ache of estrangement—unfolds against the backdrop of state violence, with Ingrid and Jack witnessing the police shoot at a car and kill a black child. This moment becomes a turning point: it galvanizes Ingrid to write her most famous poem, Die Kind, a work that carries a quiet prophecy about the end of Apartheid and the price of truth.

Abraham Jonker is portrayed as a stern, controlling father who withholds warmth and validation from his daughter. He grows enraged by Ingrid’s political dissent, her friendships with dissident writers whose work he bans, and her unflinching poetry. When Ingrid asks him to read her anti-apartheid poem Die Kind, he reads only part of it and tears the work apart, a moment that crystallizes the power struggle between a father’s authority and a daughter’s conscience. The film follows Ingrid through a storm of personal turmoil: her troubled relationship with her father, her love triangle, and the spiral into depression and psychosis that leads to hospitalization at Valkenberg.

In the hospital, Jack visits and learns a painful secret: Ingrid had a secret termination of her unborn child. She reveals that the hospital took all her poems, yet she still carries them in her head. Jack discovers a pocketbook of Ingrid’s poems, takes them, and works with Uys Krige to assemble them into a book titled Rook en Ochre (Smoke and Ochre). After her release, the book is published and earns positive reviews, earning Ingrid a measure of recognition that prompts a triumphant return to Europe. She plans to travel, hoping for a passport to accompany her, but Jack is unable to secure one due to his own political entanglements, and travel becomes a problem.

Ingrid’s Europe trip, with Eugene joining her, becomes a crucible for new emotional conflicts. A crisis erupts when Eugene discovers Ingrid’s lingering affection for Jack and the poems she has written about him. His anger leads him to return home early, while Ingrid endures another abortion, this time in Paris, a decision and a medical procedure that leaves her physically fragile and emotionally raw. The hospital calls for electroconvulsive therapy, and her father grants consent for the treatment. The consequences of this sequence reverberate through Ingrid’s life: upon returning to Cape Town, she finds herself unable to write and unable to smile, a haunting turn in a life defined by verse and voice.

In the final chapters, Ingrid returns to her relationship with Jack, presenting him with an AFB medal and a Walt Whitman poem as a symbolic confession of her love. Yet the bond cannot be repaired, and Ingrid walks away, choosing a solitary, tragic exit by walking into the sea. A devastated Jack watches from a distance as her body is recovered, a stark reminder of the cost of a life dedicated to poetry and truth. The film closes with a reflective, sea-washed panorama, and a recording of Jack Cope and Uys Krige’s English translation of Ingrid Jonker’s poem Die Kind is read aloud by Nelson Mandela, whose own political arc would soon redefine the country’s future. The text that follows underscores the film’s enduring message: a woman’s voice, forged through immense pain and defiance, helped illuminate the path toward the end of Apartheid, even as the personal losses along the way remained deeply sorrowful and real.