What Is The Law in Her Hands About?
The premise of The Law in Her Hands in 298 words, with nothing given away. The full story follows below.
In the bustling streets of New York, two waitresses shuffle between tables and textbooks, dreaming of more than the clatter of silverware. After passing the bar exam, they step into a legal world that feels as cut‑and‑dry as the city’s skyline, yet is pulsing with the same restless energy that once powered the restaurant kitchens where they earned their keep. The film paints the city in a moody, almost noir palette—rain‑slicked avenues, cramped offices, and a courtroom atmosphere where ambition collides with tradition.
Mary Wentworth arrives with fierce intelligence and a determination to prove that a woman can command a courtroom as confidently as any man. Beside her, Dorothy Davis offers steady friendship and a pragmatic view of the challenges ahead. Their personal lives intrude on their professional aspirations: Robert Mitchell, a charming but conventional lawyer, doubts whether the law is a place for a woman like Mary and subtly urges her toward a more traditional path. The tension between loyalty, love, and the desire to break through a glass ceiling provides an undercurrent that hums louder than any gavel strike.
Just as the pair begins to lay the foundations of their own practice, the shadowy world of the city’s organized crime circles emerges, embodied by the charismatic and powerful mob boss Frank Gordon. He recognizes Mary’s talent and extends an invitation that could launch her career to unprecedented heights—but at a price. The allure of high‑stakes cases, the seductive promise of influence, and the moral quandaries of representing such clients create a volatile mix, forcing Mary to weigh her ambition against her principles, her love against her independence, and the unforgiving expectations of a male‑dominated profession. The story sets the stage for a compelling exploration of power, gender, and the choices that define a lawyer’s—and a woman’s—hand.
What Happens in The Law in Her Hands?
The complete story of The Law in Her Hands, from the first scene to the last, in 327 words (about 1 minute). Spoilers throughout. Names in the text link to 4 cast member pages.
Spoilers ahead
Two waitresses working in New York, Mary Wentworth and Dorothy Davis, pass the bar exam and embark on legal careers. Their employer Franz inadvertently photographs a gangster just before the man ignites a smoke bomb in the restaurant, and the incident is meant to coerce Franz into joining a protection racket run by crime boss Frank Gordon. The perpetrator is arrested, and the case is prosecuted by Robert Mitchell, who is Mary’s boyfriend.
At the trial, Gordon tries to shift blame by lining up witnesses who claim the defendant wasn’t at the restaurant, but Mary and Dorothy present the photograph as evidence. Gordon is impressed with Mary’s performance and offers her a job as his lawyer, but she declines, choosing to stay clear of underworld activities.
When a corrupt lawyer plants a bottle of liquor in a coat that Mary had entered into evidence, she loses her first case in court. Robert believes that the law is not a suitable profession for a woman, and he asks her to abandon her career in order to marry him. Mary asserts that she intends to overcome her first defeat and persevere in the law, but she will consider his request if she cannot find success within a year.
Hoping to discourage Mary, Robert suggests she represent a man who has already signed a confession. Later, Mary employs the same tactics and defeats Robert in court. She eventually accepts Gordon as a client, and the fledgling law firm becomes a great success with a large and busy office.
When Mary learns that Gordon’s gang was responsible for poisoning milk that caused multiple deaths, she changes her mind and refuses to continue to represent him. When Gordon forces her to defend him, she turns on him in court and accuses him of the crime, and Gordon is convicted. She later successfully appeals to be disbarred, and she informs Robert that she will abandon her law career in order to marry him.
The Law in Her Hands Timeline: Every Key Event in Order
13 key events in the order they happen, from “Two waitresses become lawyers” to “A final decision: marriage over a legal career”. 13 events name a place, across 6 locations.
- 1
Two waitresses become lawyers
Mary Wentworth and Dorothy Davis pass the New York bar exam and begin their careers as lawyers. They navigate a male-dominated field with determination, forming a rare collaborative partnership. Their relationship with their employer Franz provides the setting for the early days of their practice.
When:early 1930s Where:New York
- 2
Photo just before the smoke bomb
Franz inadvertently photographs a gangster moments before he ignites a smoke bomb in the restaurant. The attack is meant to intimidate Franz into joining a protection racket run by Frank Gordon. The photo becomes a crucial piece of evidence linking the gangster to the crime.
When:moments before the attack Where:New York restaurant
- 3
First prosecution led by Robert Mitchell
The gangster is arrested and the case goes to trial. Robert Mitchell, Mary's boyfriend, prosecutes the case while Mary and Dorothy contribute key evidence. The courtroom becomes a test of Mary’s budding legal skill against organized crime.
When:shortly after the bombing Where:Courtroom, New York
- 4
Mary and Dorothy prove the defendant's location
At the trial, Gordon seeks witnesses to deny the gangster’s presence at the restaurant. Mary and Dorothy present the photograph, establishing the defendant’s location and credibility. Gordon is impressed by Mary’s performance and later offers her a job.
When:during trial Where:Courtroom, New York
- 5
Mary declines Gordon's offer
Gordon offers to hire Mary as his lawyer, hoping to pull her into the underworld’s orbit. She declines the invitation, choosing to stay clear of Gordon's criminal activities. The moment marks a clear line between her integrity and Gordon’s influence.
When:after trial Where:Gordon's office / court corridor
- 6
Corrupt attempt and a woman's resolve
A corrupt lawyer plants a bottle of liquor in a coat that Mary had submitted as evidence, causing her to lose her first case. Robert Mitchell comes to believe that the law is not a suitable profession for a woman and asks Mary to abandon her career to marry him. Mary’s resolve begins to sharpen in response to this setback.
When:after the first defeat Where:Courtroom, New York
- 7
A pledge to persevere for a year
Mary declares that she will persevere in the law and not give up despite the setback. She sets a personal challenge: if she cannot find success within a year, she will consider marrying Robert as he wishes. Her vow signals a determination to prove herself.
When:within a year Where:New York
- 8
A test case and a courtroom victory against Robert
Robert suggests Mary take on a case involving a man who has already confessed as a trial of her abilities. Later, Mary uses a similar strategic move to challenge Robert in court and defeats him. The victory reinforces her growing reputation in the legal world.
When:soon after the vow Where:Courtroom, New York
- 9
Mary joins Gordon as a client; firm grows
Mary finally accepts Gordon as a client, joining the criminal enterprise in a professional capacity. Her involvement helps the fledgling law firm expand into a large, busy operation with substantial work. The partnership marks a turning point in her career trajectory.
When:shortly after the victory over Robert Where:New York
- 10
Milk poisoning case prompts a crisis of conscience
Mary learns that Gordon's gang was responsible for poisoning milk, causing multiple deaths. The revelation forces her to rethink remaining with Gordon’s side. She begins to doubt whether she can continue representing him without compromising her ethics.
When:before defending him in court Where:New York
Show the other 3 events of The Law in Her Hands Hide the last 3 events
- 11
Confronting Gordon in court
Gordon pressures Mary to defend him despite the poisoning case. In a pivotal courtroom moment, she turns on him, accusing him of the crimes and helping secure a conviction. The act solidifies her commitment to justice over loyalty to her client.
When:during trial Where:Courtroom, New York
- 12
Disbarment is pursued and won
Mary pursues an appeal to be disbarred and succeeds, choosing to sever her official ties with the bar. The disbarment symbolizes a formal break from the legal profession she had been building. It underscores the complexities of her relationship with law and morality.
When:after conviction Where:Bar association / court
- 13
A final decision: marriage over a legal career
Mary informs Robert that she will abandon her law career to marry him, closing the chapter on her remarkable rise in law. Her decision reflects the personal conflict between professional ambition and romantic partnership. The ending marks a bittersweet resolution to her journey.
When:after disbarment Where:Robert's home
Who Are the Main Characters in The Law in Her Hands?
5 characters, among them Mary Wentworth (Margaret Lindsay), Dorothy Davis (Glenda Farrell) and Robert Mitchell (Warren Hull): who each one is and the part they play in the story. Every profile links to the actor’s page.
- MW
Mary Wentworth (Margaret Lindsay)
Played by Margaret Lindsay
A determined waitress who passes the bar and becomes a lawyer, challenging gender norms in a male-dominated profession. She endures a difficult start, suffering a setback when a corrupt scheme undermines her first case. Mary uses sharp legal thinking to win cases and earns respect, even as she faces pressure to abandon the law for romance. She ultimately confronts Gordon's crimes, is disbarred on appeal, and decides to marry Robert, stepping away from her career.
- ⚖️ Lawyer
- 💪 Determined
- 🎯 Strategic
- DD
Dorothy Davis (Glenda Farrell)
Played by Glenda Farrell
A fellow waitress-turned-lawyer who partners with Mary in pursuing justice. She supports Mary in presenting evidence and building courtroom cases, sharing the ambition to prove women can succeed in law. Dorothy demonstrates loyalty, resilience, and practical wit under pressure. Her collaboration helps push the legal arc forward and uphold ethical standards.
- 🧭 Partner
- 🧠 Sharp
- 🤝 Loyal
- RM
Robert Mitchell (Warren Hull)
Played by Warren Hull
Mary's boyfriend and prosecutor who believes the law is not a woman's field. He urges Mary to abandon her career in favor of marriage, creating tension as he competes with her in court. He undergoes a shift as Mary demonstrates competence and courage in the courtroom, though their relationship complicates her professional choices. His dynamic with Mary anchors the personal stakes of the story.
- 💬 Boyfriend
- 🧭 Perspective
- 🥊 Rival
- FG
Frank Gordon (Lyle Talbot)
Played by Lyle Talbot
A crime boss behind the protection racket and a poisoning scheme that drives the conflict. He manipulates witnesses to avoid accountability and maintains a menacing presence in Mary’s cases. Gordon's arrogance and criminal cunning are ultimately confronted in court, leading to conviction and a dramatic fall from power.
- 🧪 Criminal
- 🗡️ Villain
- 🕵️♂️ Manipulator
-
Thomas Mallon (Joseph Crehan)
Played by Joseph Crehan
The District Attorney associated with the film’s cases, interacting with Mary and the courtroom battles. He embodies the official legal apparatus and the pressures of prosecuting high-profile criminals within a political and public sphere.
- 🏛️ Authority
- 🗂️ Prosecutor
Where and When Is The Law in Her Hands Set?
The Law in Her Hands is set in New York (1930s). Here is why the time and place matter to the story.
When
1930s
Set in the 1930s, a period marked by organized crime, Prohibition's aftermath, and shifting social norms. The era frames the challenges faced by a woman entering the legal field and the public's suspicion of reformers. Courtroom drama and crime intersect against a backdrop of urban unrest.
Where
New York
The film unfolds in New York, starting in a bustling restaurant where two waitresses begin their path toward the legal profession. The city serves as a gritty, urban backdrop for courtroom battles and mob influence. It moves through the courts and police precincts, reflecting the era's criminal activity and reform tensions.
- 🏙️ Urban backdrop
- 🗽 Gangster era
What Are the Themes of The Law in Her Hands?
3 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Justice, Ambition and Integrity.
-
01
Justice
The film centers on pursuing fair outcomes in the face of crime and corruption. Mary uses clever legal strategies to secure convictions and expose wrongdoing, while juggling personal loyalties and ethical choices. The courtroom becomes a battleground where truth, not intimidation, prevails. The arc highlights the importance of due process and victim advocacy in a corrupt environment.
-
02
Ambition
Mary's ascent from waitress to lawyer showcases drive and perseverance in a male-dominated field. She confronts doubt from peers and the system, learning to leverage evidence and courtroom wit to win cases. Her ambition clashes with personal risk, yet she remains focused on establishing a legitimate, independent career. The theme underscores how grit can open doors once closed to women.
-
03
Integrity
Integrity guides Mary's decisions when she discovers her client’s crimes and the gang's corruption. She chooses to turn on Gordon and pursue truth in court, even at personal cost. The story portrays the strain of ethics in a system susceptible to bribery and manipulation. Her ultimate choice—disbarring herself rather than compromising—emphasizes the primacy of professional ethics.
What Kind of Film Is The Law in Her Hands?
Neutral in tone, with fast pacing and a straightforward story, going by the plot summary.
- Tone
- Neutral
- Pacing
- Fast
- Story
- Straightforward
- Intensity
- Medium
- Ending
- Happy
An energetic and brisk 1930s crime drama that follows a determined female lawyer navigating professional rivalries and moral choices, blending courtroom tension with lighthearted character dynamics.
- confident
- tenacious
- professional
- rivalrous
- mildly suspenseful
- lighthearted
- female lawyer
- crime boss
- courtroom drama
- professional ambition
Content notes: witness intimidation, poisoning.
Quiz
How well do you remember The Law in Her Hands? Test yourself on the story.
