Ordinary Miracles 2005
Directed by
Michael Switzer
Made by
Larry Levinson Productions
Ordinary Miracles Plot Summary
Read the complete plot summary and ending explained for Ordinary Miracles (2005). From turning points to emotional moments, uncover what really happened and why it matters.
Kay Woodbury Jaclyn Smith is a powerful and tough judge who has not spoken to her father since he tried to involve her in a scam. At her latest case, she faces Sally Powell Lyndsy Fonseca, a troubled and rebellious teenager who has cycled through several foster homes. Feeling abandoned by her biological parents, she vents her anger at anyone who dares get close. After being dumped by her latest foster family and with no new placement in sight, she finds herself in juvenile prison.
Sympathetic to Sally’s plight, Kay decides to take the young woman into her home. Sally is initially wary of trusting Kay and goes as far as stealing some of Kay’s jewelry, pawning it to raise money to move to San Francisco with her boyfriend—who is the archetype of a bad boy. They manage to scrape together only about $200. As the days unfold, Kay and Sally begin to genuinely connect, and Kay is struck by Sally’s sharp intelligence and even her fondness for chess. Sally, in turn, seems to sense something hopeful in Kay and makes an effort to help her win over her ex-husband, Davis Corbin Bernsen, who is about to marry a much younger woman.
Meanwhile, Kay digs into Sally’s papers and discovers that Sally’s widowed biological father, James C. Thomas Howell, lives nearby and that his wife, Miranda Sarah Aldrich, has died. Kay reaches out to James to see if he can do some landscaping work, and the two quickly become friends. She keeps Sally’s existence from him at first, but when she finally reveals it, James reacts with anger and distancing—arguing that Kay would not accept him and that he can’t simply pretend Sally doesn’t exist. This revelation strains Kay’s trust and Sally feels betrayed, convinced that Kay never intended to include her in the family narrative.
Sally’s sense of hurt deepens as she sneaks back into Kay’s life and, in a burst of rebellion, steals more of Kay’s jewelry and runs off with her boyfriend. The pair doesn’t stop at pawning items this time; they rob a pawn shop, drawing Sally into a dangerous spiral without warning. After the heist, the boyfriend abandons her, leaving Sally to face the consequences. She returns home to find Kay waiting, and Kay welcomes her back with quiet, steady support.
In the end, a tentative, healing path unfolds. Sally ≈ decides to give her father a second chance, and the trio—Kay, Sally, and James—converge at Miranda’s grave to begin shaping a new, more hopeful future together.
Ordinary Miracles Timeline
Follow the complete movie timeline of Ordinary Miracles (2005) with every major event in chronological order. Great for understanding complex plots and story progression.
Judge meets troubled teen in court and decides to help
In court, Kay Woodbury confronts Sally Powell and sees the teen's desperate situation. Moved by Sally's vulnerability and potential, Kay resolves to take her into her home. This marks the start of a tentative guardian-ward relationship rather than a formal case.
Sally moves in; initial distrust leads to theft
Sally moves into Kay's home but remains wary of opening up. She sneaks into Kay's jewelry, pawns it to raise money to run away with her boyfriend. The early bond between them is fragile as trust begins to form under pressure.
The plan to escape with $200
Kay and Sally scrape together only about $200, highlighting their precarious financial situation. The plan to move to San Francisco with Sally's boyfriend shows Sally's longing for a fresh start. The duo clings to the possibility of a new life despite the obstacles.
Growing connection; Sally's intelligence and chess
As days pass, Kay and Sally begin to genuinely connect. Kay is struck by Sally's sharp intelligence and even her fondness for chess. Sally, in turn, senses hope growing in Kay and helps her navigate her relationships, including her ex-husband.
Kay uncovers Sally's family secret
While reviewing Sally's papers, Kay learns that Sally's widowed father James lives nearby and that Sally's mother died. This discovery broadens the family narrative and sets new stakes for Sally's future. Kay starts to consider how this secret could affect Sally's life.
Kay reaches out to James
Kay contacts James and asks if he can do landscaping for her home, sparking an unexpected friendship. The two quickly connect, providing a potential anchor for Sally's life. Kay also decides to keep Sally's existence discreet at first to avoid overwhelming James.
Revealing Sally; James's anger and distance
When Kay finally reveals Sally's existence to James, he reacts with anger and distance, arguing that Kay would not accept him and that he can't pretend Sally doesn't exist. The revelation strains Kay's trust and makes Sally feel rejected. The family thread appears fragile and uncertain.
Sally's rebellious relapse
Feeling betrayed, Sally sneaks back into Kay's life and escalates her rebellion by stealing more jewelry. She and her boyfriend push further when they rob a pawn shop to fund their escape. The danger of their choices becomes all too real.
The boyfriend abandons her
After the heist, Sally's boyfriend abandons her, leaving her to face the consequences alone. This moment intensifies Sally's crisis and tests Kay's capacity to stay supportive. Kay's calm, steady presence becomes a turning point.
Sally returns; Kay offers quiet support
Sally returns home to Kay, expecting judgment, but Kay welcomes her back with quiet, steadfast support. The moment marks a shift from guardianship to genuine care. Sally begins to feel a glimmer of belonging in the makeshift family Kay has built.
A choice to reconnect with her father
Sally starts to consider giving her father James a second chance, signaling a move toward healing. The trio—Kay, Sally, and James—begins shaping a future together. The tension of the earlier betrayals begins to ease as trust slowly returns.
Confronting Miranda's grave; a hopeful future
The three of them converge at Miranda's grave, acknowledging the past and choosing to move forward together. It marks a tentative, healing turning point for Sally, Kay, and James. They begin to envision a future built on family and forgiveness.
Ordinary Miracles Characters
Explore all characters from Ordinary Miracles (2005). Get detailed profiles with their roles, arcs, and key relationships explained.
Judge Kay Woodbury - Jaclyn Smith
A powerful and tough judge who chooses to take Sally in, Kay uses her authority to create space for care and growth. Her stern exterior masks a capacity for warmth and stubborn resolve to protect vulnerable young people. She navigates tension with her ex-husband while trying to keep Sally from slipping back into danger. Her willingness to redefine family drives much of the film's hopeful arc.
Sally Powell - Lyndsy Fonseca
A bright but troubled teenager cycling through foster care, Sally uses wit and chess to cope with abandonment and frustration. Her initial distrust gives way to loyalty as she connects with Kay and begins to see a possible, stable future. Her rebellious streak leads to risky choices, testing the limits of care and accountability. She ultimately seeks belonging and a second chance with her father and Kay.
Jim Powell - C. Thomas Howell
Sally's biological father, Jim Powell, is a widowed man who lives nearby and is wary of Kay's involvement. He reacts with anger and distancing when told about Sally, revealing his own grief and protective instincts. Over time he starts to connect with Kay and Sally, becoming part of a fragile but growing family circle. His presence anchors Sally's sense of possibility and reconciliation.
Davis Woodbury - Corbin Bernsen
Kay's ex-husband, a successful figure who is about to remarry a younger woman, adding friction to Kay's empathy for Sally. He embodies a complicated, adult world where love, pride, and consequence intersect. His reactions and choices influence Kay's sense of duty and Sally's options for the future. He remains a realistic, nuanced foil rather than a simple antagonist.
Miranda Powell - Sarah Aldrich
The late wife of Jim Powell and Sally's mother figure in legacy terms; her grave becomes a focal point for the newly forming family. Though absent in life, her memory anchors the trio's commitment to a hopeful future and serves as a symbolic space for healing and reconciliation.
Ordinary Miracles Settings
Learn where and when Ordinary Miracles (2005) takes place. Explore the film’s settings, era, and how they shape the narrative.
Location
San Francisco, California, Kay's Home, Juvenile Detention Center
The film unfolds in a contemporary California urban setting, weaving between a juvenile detention facility, the judge’s home, and city streets. San Francisco serves as a backdrop for Sally’s attempts to move toward independence while Kay offers a steady, nurturing alternative. The locations underscore themes of accountability, care, and the possibility of rebuilding family ties.
Ordinary Miracles Themes
Discover the main themes in Ordinary Miracles (2005). Analyze the deeper meanings, emotional layers, and social commentary behind the film.
🌱
Redemption
A chance for personal transformation drives the narrative as Sally is pulled from a cycle of trouble into a structured, caring home. Kay's unlikely decision to take Sally in reveals how trust can grow from patience and consistency. The relationship shows that past mistakes can become turning points when someone offers support and belief. The final healing moment at the grave marks a new start for both of them.
🤝
Family
The film centers on building a family out of broken pieces: a judge, a troubled teen, and a widowed father. Kay, Sally, and Jim navigate complicated loyalties and shared histories to form a united front. The trio's presence at Miranda's grave becomes a symbol of chosen family and commitment to a hopeful future. The story suggests that family is earned, not given by blood alone.
🧭
Trust
Trust is tested by secrets and past hurts—Sally's initial wariness, Kay's guarded loyalties, and Jim's guarded reactions. Small, steady actions—like Kay opening her home and Jim confronting his anger—rebuild belief in each other. The characters learn to rely on honest communication and consistent care rather than fear. The evolving trust ultimately catalyzes Sally's decision to give her father another chance.
Ordinary Miracles Spoiler-Free Summary
Discover the spoiler-free summary of Ordinary Miracles (2005). Get a concise overview without any spoilers.
In a city where the weight of the law often feels as cold and unyielding as the stone of the courthouse, a lone judge confronts the personal emptiness that lingers beyond the courtroom. The legal world is polished and procedural, yet the streets whisper of broken families and children slipping through the cracks of a system meant to protect them. Against this backdrop, the film settles into a thoughtful, bittersweet tone that balances quiet drama with moments of unexpected warmth.
Kay Woodbury is a formidable figure on the bench, renowned for her sharp rulings and ironclad resolve. Beneath her professional armor lies a lingering resentment toward a father who once pulled her into a fraudulent scheme, a betrayal that has left her emotionally guarded and estranged from her own family history. Her life is a study in contrasts: the authority she commands in the courtroom clashes with a deep, unspoken yearning for connection and redemption.
Enter Sally Powell, a teenage girl whose tumultuous journey through a series of foster homes has forged a fierce independence tempered by a palpable sense of abandonment. Intelligent and quick‑witted, she finds solace in unexpected places—such as the strategic calm of a chessboard—while her rebellious spirit masks a yearning for stability and belonging. Her presence introduces a ripple of uncertainty into Kay’s orderly world, challenging both women to confront long‑held fears.
When Kay decides to open her home to Sally, a tentative partnership begins, rooted in mutual need and guarded hope. Their evolving relationship is underscored by a subtle quest to bridge the gap between past wounds and future possibilities, while the lingering mystery of a distant, widowed father adds an undercurrent of intrigue. The story unfolds in a space where compassion and resilience intersect, inviting viewers to wonder how two unlikely allies might navigate the fragile terrain of trust, family, and second chances.
Featured on this page
What's After the Movie?
Not sure whether to stay after the credits? Find out!
Explore Our Movie Platform
New Movie Releases (2026)
Famous Movie Actors
Top Film Production Studios
Movie Plot Summaries & Endings
Major Movie Awards & Winners
Best Concert Films & Music Documentaries
Movie Collections and Curated Lists
© 2026 What's After the Movie. All rights reserved.