Hearts in Bondage 1936

Lieutenant James Dunn Reynolds and his good friend, fellow naval officer David Manners Jordan, head into a moment of light-hearted camaraderie as they ice-skate with their girls, all while anticipating the strain of looming war. The mood shifts quickly when Reynolds’ fiancée, Constance [Mae Clarke] Jordan, known as Connie and Raymond’s sister, accepts a marriage proposal from Reynolds, sealing a personal future amid the growing conflicts across the nation. A sense of duty collides with affection as personal vows intertwine with a nation preparing to split apart.

In a tense government war council, loyalty tests loom over the new Confederate question: two Virginia officials are pressed to declare where their loyalties lie. Captain [Henry B. Walthall] Buchanan resigns from the Navy to join the Confederacy, while Commodore [George Irving] Jordan remains in service, a symbol of the Union’s hold on tradition. A parallel moment unfolds for [David Manners] Jordan’s Raymond, who wrestles with the decision to leave his fiancé Julie Buchanan, portrayed by [Charlotte Henry], and join the Confederates in Virginia. The personal and political lines blur as Raymond’s choice starkly opposes Connie’s desire for a shared future with Reynolds.

Kenneth Reynolds stays loyal to the Union, and is put in charge of the ironclad USS Merrimack. When Confederate forces strike Gosport Navy Yard, Reynolds faces a brutal command decision: burn the ship to deny its capture, or sink her to preserve her hull and engines. He chooses to sink Merrimack, defying orders and sealing his fate with a dishonorable discharge. The betrayal he feels from peers and the social stigma of treason haunt him, leaving him unable to find work anywhere else, until a chance to aid his uncle—the famed inventor John Ericsson, played by Fritz Leiber—draws him back into the game of iron and steam.

The Union learns that the Confederates have salvaged Merrimack and refitted her as CSS Virginia, a threat that compels a new design. Reynolds urges his uncle to present a government-ready ironclad plan—the Monitor—with a unique revolving gun turret. While Bushnell’s plan is known, the presence of [Farragut] plugs a gap of diplomacy and clears the path for a unified push toward a decisive naval showdown. Despite a painful past, Reynolds is accepted back into service to face the newly formidable foe, and Raymond ascends to third in command aboard Virginia, shaping a bitter, personal rivalry that will cast a long shadow over Connie’s heart.

Connie learns that Reynolds will fight against her own brother, and the wound of this revelation runs deep. Yet their bond persists, and each yearns for a future free from the war’s cruelty. The stage is set for a defining clash, though the human cost weighs heavily on both sides.

The Battle of Hampton Roads erupts with Virginia unleashing its ferocity, sinking the USS Cumberland and USS Congress in the harbor. The next day, Virginia closes in on the USS Minnesota as Monitor engages in a tense duel. [David Manners] Jordan’s presence looms as the action intensifies, and Reynolds is handed command over the ship’s second gun after Worden is wounded. As fire rakes the water, Raymond proposes a audacious boarding move on Monitor; Reynolds faces a devastating moral blow as he spots Raymond at the head of the boarding party. Mustering his courage, Reynolds orders his crew to fire both guns, repulsing the boarding party and denying Virginia the opportunity to board. The clash leaves profound personal tolls: Raymond dies in the ensuing chaos, and Connie is left to confront the loss of her brother and the man she loves.

After the smoke clears and Reynolds enters civilian life with an honorable discharge, he seeks to rekindle his relationship with Connie. The couple’s walk along the Potomac River brings them into contact with President Abraham Lincoln, whose quiet counsel points toward a future built on peace rather than further bloodshed. The encounter gives Connie the strength to look to a hopeful horizon, and she resolves to renew her life with Reynolds, honoring both their love and the sacrifices made in war.

In the end, the human heart and the shared hope for peace carry more weight than the drumbeat of cannons. The story folds back onto the shore of a recovering Union, where memory of loss coexists with the promise of rebuilding—a reminder that, even amid iron and fire, the possibility of reconciliation remains.