What Is Butterfly Kisses About?
The premise of Butterfly Kisses in 289 words, with nothing given away. The full story follows below.
In a restless suburb where the line between intimacy and exposure blurs, three young men grapple with the pressures of a world saturated by sex and pornography. Jake moves through this uneasy landscape while shouldering a secret that fuels his quiet anxiety, casting a shadow over his everyday interactions. Beside him, Kyle wrestles with his own desires and the expectations placed upon him, seeking validation in a culture that constantly commodifies connection. Jarred balances his loyalty to his friends with an inner turbulence that threatens to upend the fragile equilibrium they’ve built.
The film paints a gritty, almost tactile portrait of coming‑of‑age life in an environment where personal boundaries are constantly tested. Its tone is a blend of raw realism and understated tension, inviting viewers to feel the weight of each character’s unspoken doubts. The cinematography captures the stark contrast between dimly lit rooms buzzing with digital content and fleeting moments of quiet where the trio can breathe, hinting at the deeper currents pulling them apart.
Friendship serves as both anchor and catalyst, shaping the way each character confronts their inner demons. As Jake strives to protect his hidden truth, Kyle and Jarred each confront the ways the pervasive media landscape influences their sense of self, prompting subtle shifts in loyalty and self‑perception. The narrative lingers on the delicate dance of trust, the fear of exposure, and the yearning for authentic identity amid a culture that thrives on surface‑level allure.
Through nuanced performances and an immersive atmosphere, the story invites the audience to reflect on the complexities of modern masculinity, the silent battles fought behind closed doors, and the fragile bonds that hold these young men together as they search for a place they can truly call their own.
What Happens in Butterfly Kisses?
The complete story of Butterfly Kisses, from the first scene to the last, in 641 words (about 3 minutes). Spoilers throughout.
Spoilers ahead
In May 2015, Gavin York, a struggling wedding videographer and film school dropout, stumbles upon a dusty box of tapes labeled “Don’t Watch” hidden in the basement of his in-laws’ newly purchased home. Driven by curiosity, he watches the footage and drafts an edit on an aging laptop. The tapes appear to be fragments of a documentary shot in March 2004 by two film students, Sophia and Feldman, who are investigating a local urban legend about a figure called “Peeping Tom.” The legend promises that if you stare down the Ilchester Tunnel at midnight for a full hour without blinking, Peeping Tom can be summoned. Once summoned, he draws in closer with each blink, culminating in a lethal confrontation as he uses a fluttering eyelash gesture, a crude nickname they call butterfly kisses, to force the victim to blink before killing them.
The students set up a camera to film the tunnel, hoping the camera might act as a stand‑in for a human eye. When they review the footage, they notice Peeping Tom appearing in the tunnel’s frame, and soon he seems to manifest in other clips they shoot. As the recordings pile up, Peeping Tom’s influence appears to infest the camera itself; turning the camera on and off to simulate blinking seems to bring him closer. Feldman’s grip on reality begins to unravel, and he is eventually murdered by Peeping Tom, leaving Sophia to continue the project alone.
Seeing a potential path to a filmmaking breakthrough, Gavin hires a crew to document his discovery and his pursuit of the legend. Yet the team discovers no verifiable records of Sophia or Feldman, fueling suspicions that the footage could be fake. They also uncover that Sophia and Feldman had previously won an award for a documentary that employed an actor to portray a real person.
With little interest from news stations or local groups, Gavin releases the footage online and schedules an interview with a radio host to spark attention. The broadcast draws harsh reactions from callers, including The Blair Witch Project co‑director Eduardo Sánchez, who dismisses the project as a derivative sham. Gavin’s single‑minded obsession strains his family life, culminating in his wife leaving after learning he drained their son’s college savings to fund the film.
Gavin guides the crew to meet him outside the Ilchester Tunnel, where they find him attempting to recreate the Peeping Tom ritual with a camera. A tense dispute emerges among the crew about whether to seek psychiatric help for Gavin, and accusations fly that Erik is pushing him toward madness in pursuit of a sensational story. When they hear sounds that suggest Gavin is running through the tunnel, they hurry to intervene, only to find that he has vanished, taking the camera with him.
Nine days later, Erik receives a package containing a DVCam film, a smaller parcel addressed to Sophia, Gavin’s journal, and a hotel keycard. At a hotel room, the crew discovers Gavin’s corpse in the bathtub. After weighing their options, they decide not to involve the police and Erik resolves to continue the project, insisting he wants to refragment the film as the story of Gavin rather than of Peeping Tom—though he refuses to say aloud whether he believes the legend is real.
In additional footage, Sophia, feverishly resisting the urge to blink, recalls a dream in which she could stare at the tunnel for the entire hour, only to realize the dream was real and that she had actually summoned Peeping Tom. She later claims that Peeping Tom is right in front of her, and in a shocking moment, she shatters a glass picture frame with a hammer and uses the shards to slice off her eyelids.
In a mid‑credits scene, Sophia, now in an insane asylum, appears to caress Peeping Tom’s face, leaving the fate of the legend ambiguously unresolved.
Butterfly Kisses Timeline: Every Key Event in Order
13 key events in the order they happen, from “Gavin discovers a box labeled Don't Watch” to “Mid-credits: Sophia's asylum”. 13 events name a place, across 12 locations.
- 1
Gavin discovers a box labeled Don't Watch
In May 2015 Gavin York, a struggling wedding videographer, finds a box of tapes labeled Don't Watch in his in-laws' basement. He watches them and edits one of the tapes on an old laptop, realizing they're part of a longer documentary. The tapes tease a mystery surrounding a local legend.
When:May 2015 Where:In-laws' basement
- 2
The Peeping Tom legend is introduced
The tapes recount the urban legend of Peeping Tom, summoned by staring into the Ilchester Tunnel at midnight for an hour without blinking. When the target blinks, Tom draws closer and kills them. Sophia and Feldman set up a camera to act as a human eye to test the myth.
When:March 2004, midnight Where:Ilchester Tunnel
- 3
The camera becomes a conduit
As they review footage, Peeping Tom begins to appear in the tunnel shots and then in other scenes. The presence seems to infest the camera itself, as turning the camera on and off simulates blinking and brings him closer. Feldman's grip on reality begins to slip under this pressure.
When:March 2004 Where:Filming locations
- 4
Feldman is murdered
Feldman's mental state deteriorates under the haunting presence, and he is eventually murdered by Peeping Tom. Sophia is left to continue the project alone, carrying the fear of the legend's reach. The documentary risks becoming a one-woman fight against a malevolent presence.
When:March 2004 Where:Ilchester Tunnel / filming locations
- 5
Gavin decides to capitalize on the mystery
Seeing potential for a filmmaking breakthrough, Gavin hires a crew to document his discovery and attempt to prove Peeping Tom's existence. He struggles to find any legitimate records of Sophia or Feldman, suggesting the tapes' origins may be questionable. His ambition drives the new documentary in a different direction.
When:May 2015 Where:Gavin's home / studio
- 6
Crew doubts the footage's authenticity
The crew grows skeptical as they search for provenance and find hints that Sophia and Feldman had previously used an actor to portray a real person in an award-winning documentary. This history fuels doubts that the footage is fake or manufactured by Gavin himself. Erik Kristopher Myers leads the group as they push back against the project.
When:May 2015 Where:Studio / meeting room
- 7
Gavin promotes the project publicly
With no press outlets interested, Gavin posts the footage online and arranges a radio interview to promote it. Callers, including Eduardo Sánchez, dismiss the film as derivative and mock his obsession. The public chatter deepens the tension around the project.
When:2015 Where:Radio studio / online
- 8
Family costs and personal sacrifice
Gavin's obsession strains his personal life, and his wife leaves him after discovering he used their son's college savings to fund the project. The stakes rise as his financial and emotional commitments spiral.
When:2015 Where:Family home
- 9
The tunnel re-creation leads to disappearance
Gavin directs the crew to meet him outside Ilchester Tunnel to recreate the ritual with a camera. The group argues over whether to seek psychiatric help, and tensions flare as Gavin appears to run toward the tunnel. When they reach the scene, he has vanished along with the camera.
When:Night, May 2015 Where:Ilchester Tunnel
- 10
The package arrives
Nine days after Gavin's disappearance, Erik receives a package containing a DVCam film, a separate letter to Sophia, Gavin's journal, and a hotel keycard. The materials prompt the crew to reconsider what they are making and why.
When:Nine days after disappearance Where:Erik's studio
Show the other 3 events of Butterfly Kisses Hide the last 3 events
- 11
Gavin's body is found
In a hotel room, the crew discovers Gavin's corpse in the bathtub. They decide not to alert the police and debate what the footage means for their project. Erik resolves to continue, reframing the story around Gavin rather than Peeping Tom.
When:Shortly after discovery Where:Hotel room
- 12
Sophia's dream and revelation
In more footage, Sophia recalls a dream where she could stare at the tunnel for the full hour and believes she summoned Peeping Tom. She claims Tom is in front of her and describes a way to defeat him, before dramatically severing her own eyelids with a shattered frame's glass.
When:During additional footage Where:Documentary footage
- 13
Mid-credits: Sophia's asylum
In the mid-credits scene, Sophia appears in an insane asylum and seems to caress Peeping Tom's face. The film ends with the implication that the line between fiction and reality has shattered. The audience is left with questions about who truly created the danger.
When:Mid-credits scene Where:Insane asylum
Who Are the Main Characters in Butterfly Kisses?
4 characters, among them Gavin York, Sophia and Feldman: who each one is and the part they play in the story.
- GY
Gavin York
A struggling wedding videographer who stumbles onto a box of tapes and becomes fixated on proving the Peeping Tom legend. His obsession drives a documentary project that strains his finances and his family life. He increasingly treats the story as his path to recognition.
- 🎭 Protagonist
- 🧰 Filmmaker
- S
Sophia
A determined film student who helps chase the myth. As the project unfolds, she confronts the ethical and personal costs of pursuing sensational footage. Her persistence highlights the lure and danger of groundbreaking work.
- 🎓 Student
- 🕵️ Investigator
- F
Feldman
Sophia's partner in the documentary whose mental state deteriorates under the weight of the investigation. His decline illustrates how fear and pressure can erode judgment and stability.
- 🧭 Peer
- 🧠 Deterioration
- EK
Erik Kristopher Myers
Leads Gavin's film crew and becomes skeptical about the tapes' authenticity. He aims to shape the material into a compelling narrative while wrestling with the truth of what they're documenting.
- 🎥 Director
- 🧭 Skeptic
Where and When Is Butterfly Kisses Set?
Butterfly Kisses is set in Ilchester Tunnel, Gavin's in-laws' basement and hotel room (2004–2015). Here is why the time and place matter to the story.
When
2004–2015
The embedded documentary is set in March 2004, while the present-day investigation unfolds in May 2015 when Gavin finds the tapes and pursues them. The film juxtaposes early-2000s indie filmmaking aesthetics with a mid-2010s online-released mystery driven by found footage. It traces a decade of escalating obsession, investigation, and unraveling truth.
Where
Ilchester Tunnel, Gavin's in-laws' basement, hotel room
The story largely unfolds around the Ilchester Tunnel, a local landmark tied to the Peeping Tom legend. Key scenes take place in the basement of Gavin York's in-laws' home where the discovered tapes are edited, and later in a hotel room where the crew encounters more clues. The settings frame a documentary-driven mystery that probes the boundary between reality and enactment.
- 🗺️ Urban legend site
- 🏚️ British setting
- 🎬 Found-footage vibe
What Are the Themes of Butterfly Kisses?
4 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Obsession, Madness and Truth vs Fiction.
-
01
Obsession
Gavin York's drive to prove the Peeping Tom legend consumes his life, risking finances and family stability. The film examines how the pursuit of a breakthrough story can distort judgment and push boundaries. It shows how a single fixation can redefine a creator's priorities and identity.
-
02
Madness
The investigation strains the minds of those involved as reality and footage bleed into one another. Feldman's deteriorating state mirrors the growing fear around the legend. Sophia's mounting tension demonstrates how fear and fixation can erode perception.
-
03
Truth vs Fiction
Found-footage format raises questions about authenticity and manipulation. The crew uncovers inconsistencies and suspects that Gavin may be fabricating material. The narrative questions whether the project documents truth or manufactures it for entertainment.
-
04
Surveillance
The camera acts as a window into the terror, with Peeping Tom allegedly appearing in footage. Filming becomes a ritual that makes observers complicit in the haunting. The theme explores the modern gaze and how media can prey on viewers as well as subjects.
What Kind of Film Is Butterfly Kisses?
Dark in tone, with steady pacing and a complex story, going by the plot summary.
- Tone
- Dark
- Pacing
- Steady
- Story
- Complex
- Intensity
- High
- Ending
- Bleak
A deeply unsettling and paranoid descent into obsession, this film uses a layered found-footage structure to build a palpable sense of dread around a cursed urban legend, culminating in madness and bleak fates.
- unsettling
- paranoid
- claustrophobic
- obsessive
- fatalistic
- gritty
- found footage
- urban legend
- descent into madness
- psychological horror
Content notes: graphic self-harm, murder, psychological torment, corpse discovery.
Quiz
How well do you remember Butterfly Kisses? Test yourself on the story.
