Blue Jay 2016

Drama

Box Office

$22K

Runtime

80 min

Language

English

Directed by

Alexandre Lehmann

Made by

Orchard, The

Test your knowledge of Blue Jay with our quiz!

Blue Jay Plot Summary

Read the complete plot summary and ending explained for Blue Jay (2016). From turning points to emotional moments, uncover what really happened and why it matters.

Jim Henderson, Mark Duplass returns to his hometown in California with the intention of renovating and selling his late mother’s house. While shopping at a supermarket, he bumps into his former high school girlfriend Amanda, Sarah Paulson. They greet each other, but Jim says he does not want to stop her from whatever she was up to.

They run into each other again in the parking lot and decide to grab coffee at Blue Jay. Over coffee, they catch up on the years since they last saw one another. Amanda has since married and become the stepmother to two children, while Jim works alongside his uncle on renovating old houses and is considering turning his late mother’s house into a new project. The contrast between their fulfilled lives and Jim’s unsettled feelings becomes clear as they walk to her car, passing a liquor store they used to frequent. Amanda bets the owner will remember them; Jim is skeptical, but the owner does recognize them and teases their famous hometown romance, offering free beer and jelly beans while they half-joke about still being a couple after all this time.

A lakeside conversation deepens their nostalgia, and Jim leaves feeling discontent after hearing about Amanda’s seemingly accomplished life. Back at his mother’s house, they sift through old memorabilia, fueling more memories. Amanda finds a letter addressed to her from years past and discovers tape recordings of Jim and her roleplaying their imagined middle-aged selves. They listen and laugh at how awkward they were, and Jim suggests they recreate the moment—pretending to be a married couple celebrating their 20th anniversary.

That night grows intimate, and Amanda reveals she has been on antidepressants and hasn’t cried in years. They kiss, but the moment shifts when Jim tells her he loves her. The truth comes out that Amanda had an abortion during high school, the source of their breakup, triggering a painful confrontation that ends with Jim breaking down on the floor.

The next morning, Jim walks Amanda to her car, and she explains her decision. He asks her to read the letter he never sent, the one in which he hoped to confess keeping the baby. Amanda begins to cry for the first time in five years, and then they share a fragile, mutual understanding. They laugh through the tears, exchanging a quiet, shared breath as the screen fades to black.

Blue Jay Timeline

Follow the complete movie timeline of Blue Jay (2016) with every major event in chronological order. Great for understanding complex plots and story progression.

Jim returns to his hometown to renovate his mother's house

Jim Henderson returns to his California hometown with the plan to renovate and eventually sell his late mother's house. He begins assessing the property and reconnects with the memories tied to the place. The visit sets the stage for a complex reconnection with his past.

Hometown, California

First bump and rekindled interest

While shopping at a supermarket, Jim bumps into his former high school girlfriend Amanda and they exchange a brief, cautious greeting. He makes it clear he doesn't want to intrude on whatever she's got going on. The chance encounter plants the seed for a longer, more honest conversation later.

Supermarket, California

Coffee reunion at Blue Jay

They meet again in the parking lot and decide to go for coffee at Blue Jay. They exchange updates about their lives since high school—Amanda is married and a stepmother, while Jim renovates old houses with his uncle. The conversation reveals both pride and underlying dissatisfaction with where they are.

Blue Jay Coffee Shop, California

Passing the liquor store and memories

On the way to Amanda's car, they pass a liquor store from their younger days. Amanda bets the owner will recognize them, and Jim is skeptical, but the owner does remember them as the 'famous lovebirds.' The moment underscores how their past romance still lingers in the present.

Liquor store, California

Lakefront confidences and Jim's discontent

They spend time at a lakeside where Amanda shares aspects of her life that seem impressive, while Jim feels a twinge of envy at what she has. His reaction turns to tears as he confronts his own sense of unfulfillment. The emotional contrast deepens their complicated connection.

Lakeside, California

Nostalgia at Jim's mother's house

Back at Jim's mother's house, they search through old memorabilia and reminisce. Amanda discovers a letter addressed to her from years past and keeps it, hinting at what might have been. The moment deepens the sense of shared history between them.

Jim's mother's house, California

Tape recordings and a plan to recreate

Amanda finds tape recordings of Jim and her roleplaying their middle-aged lives. They listen, laugh at their younger selves, and then decide to recreate the tape as if they were a married couple celebrating a 20th anniversary. The playful plan rekindles a private intimacy between them.

Jim's mother's house, living room

Love confession, abortion reveal, and heartbreak

That night, they begin to recreate their taped personas and kiss passionately, but Amanda stops when Jim says he loves her. It is revealed that she had an abortion in high school, the event that helped drive their breakup. They lash out at each other and Jim collapses, crying on the floor.

Jim's mother's house, bedroom

Morning explanations and a quiet truth

The next morning, Jim walks Amanda to her car and she explains her decision. He asks her to read the letter he didn't send, confessing he would have kept the baby. Amanda cries for the first time in five years, then they share a quiet laugh as they acknowledge the unresolved tension between them.

Outside Amanda's car, California

A final, bittersweet fade

They sigh at one another and the scene fades to black, leaving their future unresolved but emotionally connected. The ending emphasizes the pull between memory, longing, and the choices they have to make.

Driveway outside Amanda's car, California

Blue Jay Characters

Explore all characters from Blue Jay (2016). Get detailed profiles with their roles, arcs, and key relationships explained.

Jim Henderson (Mark Duplass)

A quiet, introspective man who prefers practical work renovating houses but is emotionally unsettled by his past and Amanda's seemingly successful life. He carries a sense of longing and vulnerability, often masking it behind dry humor and practical focus on his mother's house. His emotional honesty surfaces in his tears and willingness to revisit old memories.

🧭 Reflective 🛠️ Hands-on 😔 Vulnerable

Amanda (Sarah Paulson)

Amanda is married with two stepchildren and a life that sounds rewarding but leaves her emotionally guarded. She reveals hidden sadness and the anti-depressants she uses, showing a capacity for vulnerability beneath a composed exterior. Her candor about past choices and present life drives the emotional tension of the reunion.

💬 Open 🧭 Reflective 🛡️ Guarded

Blue Jay Settings

Learn where and when Blue Jay (2016) takes place. Explore the film’s settings, era, and how they shape the narrative.

Location

Blue Jay, California

Blue Jay is a quiet California town where Jim returns to renovate his late mother's house. The film stages its conversations in familiar places—a lakeside setting, the local liquor store, and the old childhood haunts—creating a sense of memory and place. The town's ordinary streets and shops become the backdrop for a tense, intimate reconnection between two former lovers.

🏡 Small town 🏞️ Lakefront setting 🛍️ Familiar haunts

Blue Jay Themes

Discover the main themes in Blue Jay (2016). Analyze the deeper meanings, emotional layers, and social commentary behind the film.

🕰️

Nostalgia

The story hinges on revisiting a shared past, digging up memories that feel both sweet and painful. Time has changed the characters, yet the old moments echo in their current choices and conversations. Nostalgia surfaces through their dialogue, objects, and the letter they never sent.

💬

Honesty

Another central theme is truth-telling between two people who never fully understood what they meant to each other. They confront painful secrets—like the abortion and unspoken feelings—without the safety net of pretenses. The film uses candid conversations to test the durability of their bond.

💭

Regret & Acceptance

Jim and Amanda grapple with decisions that shaped their lives, weighing what could have been against what is. The narrative moves toward a fragile, shared vulnerability—crying, apologizing, and choosing to move forward together in a more honest way. Acceptance arrives not as a perfect ending, but as a compassionate reconciliation.

Coming soon on iOS and Android

The Plot Explained Mobile App

From blockbusters to hidden gems — dive into movie stories anytime, anywhere. Save your favorites, discover plots faster, and never miss a twist again.

Blue Jay Spoiler-Free Summary

Discover the spoiler-free summary of Blue Jay (2016). Get a concise overview without any spoilers.

In the sleepy town of Crestline, California, Jim finds himself back among familiar streets after the loss of his mother, tasked with sorting through the remnants of her life and the house that once anchored his childhood. The town’s quiet cadence and understated scenery provide a gentle backdrop for a journey that feels both personal and universal—a quiet return to roots that stirs memories long left untouched. The atmosphere is intimate, brushed with the soft melancholy of unfinished chapters and the subtle promise of new ones.

When Jim crosses paths with his former high‑school sweetheart, the encounter is both ordinary and charged, set against the modest charm of a local coffee shop called Blue Jay. Their conversation drifts effortlessly between the years that have passed and the places that still hold echoes of their youthful days, each shared glance and lingering thought hinting at a connection that has never truly faded. Though their lives have taken divergent paths, the shared history creates a delicate tension, inviting them—and the audience—to wonder how the past and present might intertwine.

The film moves with a measured, contemplative rhythm, allowing the small‑town setting to breathe life into themes of love, loss, and the inexorable passage of time. Its tone is wistful yet hopeful, inviting viewers to linger over ordinary moments that carry extraordinary weight. Through nuanced performances and an understated visual palette, the story explores how revisiting the places we once called home can illuminate the lingering emotions that shape who we become, leaving a lingering sense of curiosity about what might emerge from this quietly rekindled bond.

Can’t find your movie? Request a summary here.

Movies with Similar Twists and Themes

Uncover films that echo the narrative beats, emotional arcs, or dramatic twists of the one you're exploring. These recommendations are handpicked based on story depth, thematic resonance, and spoiler-worthy moments — perfect for fans who crave more of the same intrigue.