Unthinkable 2018

An American former Delta Force operator, Steven Younger, records a videotape that triggers a tense crisis in Los Angeles as the FBI closes in on the truth behind his claim. The team is summoned to a high school that has been repurposed as a black-site holding Yusuf Mohamed, a man who insists he has placed three nuclear bombs in major U.S. cities. As investigators dissect the tape, they are forced to confront a chilling scenario: three devices scheduled to explode in synchrony unless their demands are met.

In the shadow of the crisis, an aggressive interrogator known simply as H is brought in to extract every possible detail about the bombs’ locations. He makes his intent brutally clear by severing one of Yusuf’s fingers, a move that leaves FBI supervisor [Saunders] unsettled and Helen Brody deeply troubled. Brody, however, finds herself torn between moral responsibility and the urgency of preventing mass casualties. The dynamic unfolds with her assuming the role of the good cop, attempting to counterbalance H’s relentless brutality. The tension escalates as the government’s core premise—“ten million deaths”—looms over every choice.

“good cop”

Yusuf’s demands demand a political reversal: the President must publicly denounce support for puppet regimes and dictatorships in Muslim countries and announce a withdrawal of American troops from those regions. The team immediately rejects any notion of negotiating with terrorists, clinging to a policy built on non-negotiation with such actors, while the clock ticks toward catastrophe.

As the inquiry deepens, Yusuf reveals a disturbing ruse to test the moral fiber of the United States. He claims the bomb threat was a manipulation meant to provoke a response and to expose deep-seated flaws. He provides an address that appears to corroborate the fabrication, and the search leads them to a room matching the video—yet there is no bomb in sight. Then catastrophe strikes in another form: a soldier’s action—pulling Yusuf’s photo down—triggers a C-4 explosion at a nearby shopping mall, claiming the lives of 53 people. Brody’s outrage erupts as she confronts the brutal reality of what’s happened, and she confronts Yusuf directly, cutting his chest with a scalpel. Yusuf remains unfazed, arguing that the toll of American violence every day dwarfs any single act of terrorism.

The moral line between capture and coercion widens when Yusuf’s wife and children are detained. In a chilling sequence, H brings Yusuf’s wife before him and threatens to mutilate her right there. Brody and the others step back in horror as H slashes her throat, and she bleeds out in front of Yusuf. He endures the horror without breaking, insisting that he will not harm his children, even as the threat of torture is levied to extract the bombs’ locations. Yusuf’s resolve reaches a breaking point when the two children are brought in; the interrogator warns that he will torment them if the locations aren’t disclosed. The group moves to protect the children, but the coercion continues to press on.

In a twist linked to the volume of missing nuclear material—roughly eighteen pounds reported missing, with about 4½ pounds required per device—the possibility of a fourth bomb looms large. H argues that Yusuf could have anticipated the torture and planted a fourth device as a contingency. The officials demand more extreme measures, including torture of the children, and Brody refuses to trade two innocent lives for millions of potential victims. The moral clash peaks as Yusuf, realizing the endgame, seizes an opportunity: he grabs the official’s pistol, pleads with Brody to take care of his children, and then ends his own life. The crisis resolves with Brody walking out of the building, carrying Yusuf’s children to safety—an ending that leaves a lasting, unsettling impression about the human cost of extreme tactics in the name of national security.

Dr. Sherry Cooper, Vivica A. Fox, lends a clinical perspective during the escalating emergency, while other key figures step into experimental roles within the room’s claustrophobic drama. The ensemble of professionals and the relentless pressure of time illuminate the fragility of ethics when lives hang in the balance, and the film closes on a stark note: the line between justice and revenge is thin, and sometimes the hardest choice is to protect the innocent at the cost of complicating one’s own sense of right and wrong.

In an intertwined chorus of voices, the film grounds its tension in a complex network of individuals—Carrie Ingall, Dr. Brooks, Lucy Clark, Alana Williams, Mr. Joseph Stone, Ambassador Chris Williams, Miles Berg, Pharmacist Nilsson, Dr. Julien Drugov, Dr. Leigh Waters, and Jones Berg. Each name, a thread in a tapestry of fear, duty, and the uneasy ethics of interrogation.