Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Comedy drama

The Good Catholic (2017): Cast, Ratings, Box Office & Plot

The Good Catholic (2017) movie poster

The Good Catholic is a 2017 comedy drama directed by Paul Shoulberg, starring Zachary Spicer as Daniel, Wrenn Schmidt and Danny Glover. It runs 1 hour 36 minutes and earned $90,573 worldwide. Critics gave it 43% on Rotten Tomatoes and 46 on Metacritic, and IMDb users rate it 5.3/10.

IMDb rating
5.3/10
Rotten Tomatoes
43%
worldwide gross
$90.6K
Echo Score
48
Loading streaming availability…
The Good Catholic (2017) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 36m (96 min)
Director
Paul Shoulberg
Genres
Drama , Comedy
Original language
English
After the credits
No No extra scene
The story

What Is The Good Catholic About?

The premise of The Good Catholic without spoilers. The whole story is in the plot summary further down.

A young, idealistic priest named Daniel finds his faith tested when he encounters Jane, a captivating and mysterious woman. Torn between the guidance of his traditional mentor, Father Victor, and the more unconventional approach of Father Ollie, Daniel's beliefs are challenged. As he confronts Jane's influence and the complexities of his own emotions, he must re-examine his calling and face difficult choices about love, faith, and the true meaning of his vocation.

The Good Catholic Themes & Keywords

· 41 tags
  • priest
  • confessional
  • dying woman
  • writer director
  • singing
  • sermon
  • watching a basketball game
  • beer
  • montage
  • reference to mary kay
  • reference to hoosiers
  • reference to purdue boilermakers
+29 more
  • reference to kentucky wildcats
  • reference to blanche dubois
  • reference to ted talk
  • bacon
  • boring someone to sleep
  • marriage counseling
  • battleship game
  • reference to tempur pedic chair
  • reference to the oscars
  • cigarette smoking
  • running
  • morning routine
  • reference to oreo
  • earmuffs
  • singer
  • performer
  • choir
  • bingo
  • bible
  • reference to facebook
  • pizza delivery boy
  • last rites
  • dying man
  • reference to arby's
  • reference to little debbies
  • reference to twinkies
  • dinner
  • boy crying
  • pretending to be dying
Loading streaming availability…
Cast & crew

The Good Catholic Cast & Characters

Zachary Spicer leads the cast as Daniel, with Wrenn Schmidt as Jane and Danny Glover as Victor. Directed by Paul Shoulberg; 8 actors are credited in all.

Also Starring in The Good Catholic

· 4 more
From the director

More from Paul Shoulberg

More films directed by Paul Shoulberg: So Cold the River, Ms. White Light and Ms. White Light.

Full filmography
Ratings

The Good Catholic Reviews & Ratings

Critics gave The Good Catholic 43% on Rotten Tomatoes and 46 on Metacritic, and IMDb users rate it 5.3/10. Our Echo Score gives it 48/100, strongest in character & emotion (60) and weakest in rewatch factor (40).

48 /100

The Good Catholic Echo Score Breakdown

The Good Catholic delivers a mixed experience, balancing earnest performances with a conventional narrative structure. While critics and viewers praise the lead actor's commitment and the film’s thoughtful themes, weaknesses in direction and storytelling pacing limit its impact. Production elements are competently handled but rarely distinctive, and the emotional resonance fluctuates through schematic plotting. Overall, The Good Catholic offers modest engagement but falls short of becoming a standout in its genre.

Our own 0–100 rating, built from five aspects: art, character, story, the sensory experience and how well a film rewatches.

  • Art & Craft 45

    In terms of art and craft, the film’s direction and production design often feel uninspired. Critics note a bland visual style and telefilm aesthetic, with limited audiovisual innovation and occasional lapses in detail. While editing maintains basic coherence, the overall craft lacks distinctive flair. Consequently, The Good Catholic’s art direction registers as competent but unremarkable.

  • Character & Emotion 60

    In terms of character and emotion, the lead performance is sincere and engaging, providing depth where the script falters. Reviews commend the earnest portrayal that lends credibility to the protagonist’s crisis of faith, though some critics find emotional connections undercut by schematic dialogue. Overall, the film’s character work demonstrates moments of nuance amidst uneven resonance.

  • Story & Flow 50

    When it comes to story and flow, the narrative remains largely conventional and occasionally meanders through deliberate pacing. Critics observe uninspired plot developments that reinforce genre tropes and produce uneven engagement. Some find thematic inquiries into faith and love thoughtful, yet the schematic structure undermines sustained momentum. Ultimately, story execution yields moderate but inconsistent interest.

  • Sensory Experience 45

    In terms of sensory experience, the film offers basic auditory and visual elements but lacks distinctive style. Observers note a straightforward sound design and understated score that support scenes without enhancing mood. The visual palette remains muted and utilitarian, reflecting the film’s modest scale. As a result, sensory aspects feel serviceable but seldom striking.

  • Rewatch Factor 40

    When considering rewatch factor, the film’s modest scope and familiar structure limit repeat appeal. Elements that engage initially tend to lose impact on subsequent viewings, particularly due to schematic plotting and tempered emotional beats. While some viewers may appreciate thematic subtleties on a second watch, overall the film offers minimal incentive for revisiting.

Plot

The Good Catholic Plot Summary

What happens in The Good Catholic from start to finish, spoilers included, with a timeline of 13 key events. The opening is below; the full summary is a 2-minute read.

Spoilers ahead

In a charming rectory that houses three Catholic priests, the rhythms of daily life are often intruded upon by moments of deep reflection. Young Father Daniel is still coming to terms with the recent loss of his father, a heartache that lingers nearly a year later. In contrast, Father Ollie approaches life with exuberance, driven by his passion for food and his loyalty to Indiana University basketball. The eldest of the trio, Father Victor, finds peace in his faith, dedicating his time to preparing for mass, a time-honored routine that provides him with a meaningful sense of direction. Together, the priests balance their responsibilities, from scheduling baptisms to leading church services, while engaging in spirited conversations about Scripture, engaging homilies, and the profound mysteries that surround divine existence.

Full summary

The whole story of The Good Catholic, scene by scene

Read the full summary
Box office

The Good Catholic Box Office

The Good Catholic grossed $90,573 worldwide.

2017 box office

Worldwide gross

$90.6K

International
$90.6K
Quiz

How Well Do You Know The Good Catholic?

10 questions about the story, each with a hint if you get stuck. Pick an answer to see whether you were right.

Question 1 of 10

  1. Question 1: not answered
  2. Question 2: not answered
  3. Question 3: not answered
  4. Question 4: not answered
  5. Question 5: not answered
  6. Question 6: not answered
  7. Question 7: not answered
  8. Question 8: not answered
  9. Question 9: not answered
  10. Question 10: not answered

Who is the central character struggling with the loss of a loved one?

Cars

Cars in The Good Catholic

1 car on screen: the 1957 Lancia Aurelia Convertibile.

  • 1957 Lancia Aurelia Convertibile in The Good Catholic 1957 Lancia Aurelia Convertibile Important role
Details

The Good Catholic Also Known As

5 alternative titles, including “Хороший католик” and “El buen católico”.

Also known as
  • Хороший католик
  • El buen católico
  • Добрият католик
  • 더 굿 가톨릭
  • 好教徒

Seen The Good Catholic?

FAQ

The Good Catholic FAQ: Cast, Box Office & Runtime

Runtime, release date, director, cast, box office, ratings and post-credit scenes of The Good Catholic, each answered in a sentence.

How long is The Good Catholic?

The Good Catholic runs 1 hour 36 minutes (96 minutes).

When was The Good Catholic released?

The Good Catholic was released on September 8, 2017.

Who directed The Good Catholic?

The Good Catholic was directed by Paul Shoulberg.

More films by Paul Shoulberg

Who is in the cast of The Good Catholic?

The Good Catholic stars Zachary Spicer as Daniel, Wrenn Schmidt as Jane and Danny Glover as Victor, among 8 credited actors.

How much did The Good Catholic make at the box office?

The Good Catholic grossed $90,573 worldwide.

How is The Good Catholic rated?

The Good Catholic has 5.3/10 on IMDb, 43% on Rotten Tomatoes, 46 on Metacritic and 54% on TMDB.

Does The Good Catholic have a post-credit scene?

No. The Good Catholic has no extra scene during or after the credits.

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app