The Boys in the Band 2020

In 1968, Michael gets ready for a birthday celebration for Harold at his Upper East Side apartment in Manhattan. Just as preparations are underway, he receives an unexpected call from his friend Donald, who arrives earlier than planned due to a canceled psychiatrist appointment. Once Donald is there, Michael reflects sadly on his aging and financially troubled situation. Then, Michael gets an emotional call from his former roommate from Georgetown, Alan, who seems distraught and expresses urgency to speak to Michael in person. Despite knowing Alan’s heterosexuality, Michael invites him to join the party, cautioning his guests about Alan’s unaware stance on Michael’s homosexuality.

As the day transitions into night, Emory arrives accompanied by his partners Hank and Larry, who are having their own relationship troubles. Bernard brings a stack of books for Donald and settles into the evening’s festivities. Just when it seems all is well, Alan calls from a payphone, announcing his decision to skip the party and meet Michael for lunch the next day. The mood shifts as Larry and Bernard start dancing to “Heat Wave,” joined by Emory and Michael.

To everyone’s surprise, Alan decides to show up at the party despite his earlier call. He witnesses Michael and his friends dancing, mistakenly identifying Hank as straight, while he grows uncomfortable with Emory’s overly expressive demeanor. When Michael attempts to take Alan aside for their urgent discussion, Alan skillfully avoids addressing the sensitive topics at hand.

The night also brings an unexpected twist when a hustler named Cowboy arrives sooner than intended, sparking a misunderstanding as he kisses Michael, thinking he is Harold. As the evening continues, Alan exits the upstairs bathroom and declares he is leaving, leading to friction with Emory, who criticizes him for being closeted. Their escalating argument results in Alan throwing a punch at Emory.

With a haze of marijuana, Harold finally arrives and receives Cowboy’s warm greeting. As Michael begins to indulge in drinking and smoking—despite having quit five weeks prior—tensions escalate between him and Harold, with harsh words exchanged. To lighten the mood, Emory brings out Harold’s birthday cake and gifts. However, an incoming thunderstorm forces everyone indoors, shifting the atmosphere.

Determined to keep the evening lively, Michael announces a party game involving phone calls to the people they truly love. Participants earn points based on the depth of their conversations. Bernard attempts to reconnect with a teenage crush leading to a disappointing 2 points, while Emory recalls a dentist he once liked, finishing with 3 points. Meanwhile, Hank decides to leave a message for Larry at home and earns 7 points for his effort. Tensions rise with Michael revealing his suspicions about Donald and Larry’s history. In an emotional exchange, Larry makes a heartfelt call to Hank, claiming his love and earning 10 points before the two head off upstairs.

Facing Alan again, Michael confronts him about their past, particularly a boy named Justin. Alan’s subsequent phone call reveals his true allegiance to his wife, Fran, rather than the past he shared with Michael. As he scores 10 points with his call, he chooses to leave, which leaves Michael feeling defeated.

Before departing, Harold delivers a blunt truth to Michael, reminding him that no matter what, he will always be a homosexual, akin to everyone else at the party. With that, he takes Cowboy and his presents and exits. Emory accompanies a distressed Bernard as they promise to find a way home. Michael, filled with frustration over his friends’ struggles with their identities, wishes aloud for a day when they could all stop internalizing their shame. He also confesses to Donald that he remains unaware of what Alan wished to reveal.

As midnight approaches, Michael finds solace in Mass at St. Malachy’s. Meanwhile, Donald settles onto Michael’s couch, engrossed in “The Golden Notebook.” The night continues with Harold and Cowboy in a taxi heading home, Emory and Bernard enjoying late-night coffee, Hank and Larry having a passionate moment in the bedroom, and Alan drowning his sorrows alone at a bar. When Michael’s Mass concludes, he steps outside, and in a sudden rush, breaks into a run down the street, embracing the night that lies ahead.