Serial (Bad) Weddings 2014

Beverly Sutphin appears to be an unassuming upper-middle-class housewife living with her dentist husband Eugene and their teenage children, Misty and Chip, in Towson, Maryland. In truth, she is a serial killer who murders people over trivial slights or offenses, a grim pattern that slowly unfurls as the film peels back the layers of her ordinary life. What starts as petty hostility toward a neighbor spirals into a series of bold, calculated acts that shock the town and pull her family into a dangerous spotlight.

One morning, detectives Pike and Gracey question the Sutphins about a vulgar telephone harassment campaign aimed at their neighbor, Dottie Hinkle. It is later revealed that Beverly is the perpetrator, and her harassment begins after Dottie took a parking space Beverly coveted. The sequence that follows shows Beverly’s chilling complacency as she moves from boorish annoyance to unflinching violence. Later that day, after a PTA meeting where a teacher condemns Chip’s interest in horror films, Beverly’s cold pragmatism erupts into outright violence when she runs over Chip’s math teacher, Mr. Stubbins, with her car. This act marks a turning point in the film, exposing the danger hidden beneath Beverly’s calm exterior.

Misty’s world is further unsettled when her crush, Carl, stands her up for a date. Beverly, observing Carl with another girl at a swap meet, fatally stabs him with a fire poker, a moment that underscores how fear and anger drive Beverly to act on impulse as well as plan. The intensity of the family’s fear grows as Eugene uncovers serial killer memorabilia beneath their mattress, including recordings from Ted Bundy in the week of his execution. This discovery deepens the sense that Beverly’s violent tendencies are not isolated incidents but part of a dangerous, deeply ingrained pattern.

During a tense dinner, Chip mentions his suspicions about Beverly, and the family collectively understands that Beverly could be targeting anyone who might threaten her secrets. Beverly leaves in the wake of this confession, and the family races to Scotty’s house after suspecting he might be next. Beverly’s plan is chillingly methodical: she intends to kill Ralph and Betty Sterner, a couple who had called Eugene for a toothache on a day when the family had planned to spend time birdwatching. Betty is stabbed with scissors, and Ralph is killed when an air conditioner is pushed from a window onto him. The family and police arrive at Scotty’s house to find him in a compromising moment, a scene that further complicates how the case is being perceived by the public.

The chase continues as the police track Beverly to a church where she is identified as the prime suspect in the Sterners’ murders. The service ends in chaos when Beverly sneezes, causing a scramble that allows her to slip away. She hides at the video store where Chip works, and a confrontation with a regular customer, Mrs. Jenson, escalates tensions. Beverly follows Mrs. Jenson to her home, and in a brutal moment, strikes her with a leg of lamb while she’s watching a film. Scotty witnesses the attack from afar, but Beverly spots him and pursues him to a heavy metal bar, where she ultimately immolates Scotty during a live rock concert. The Sutphins arrive just as Beverly is arrested, a moment that seems to promise an end to the nightmare but only signals the next phase of Beverly’s notoriety.

Beverly’s trial becomes a national sensation, and her defense strategy hinges on insanity. She initially contemplates insanity as a defense but ultimately chooses to represent herself, turning the courtroom into a stage for her cunning and manipulation. She painstakingly dismantles each witness’s credibility by exploiting personal vices or undermining testimony, a display that keeps jurors off balance. Luann Hodges, the only witness who actually saw her commit a crime, is intoxicated and thus unreliable, a factor Beverly weaponizes to her advantage. The atmosphere in the courtroom is further disrupted by the unexpected arrival of Suzanne Somers, cast to portray Beverly in a television film, a meta moment that Beverly uses to fuel her performance.

In a startling turn, Beverly is acquitted of all charges. As she walks free, she taunts juror #8 for wearing white shoes after Labor Day, a small act of scorn that reveals how she enjoys bending social norms to her will. The acquittal leads to a chilling postscript: Beverly follows juror #8 to a payphone alcove and fatally strikes her with the receiver, a finale that underscores the film’s bleak satire of justice and celebrity. The appearance of Somers during the aftermath intensifies Beverly’s contempt and culminates in a tense, cinematic confrontation. The juror’s body is discovered, and Beverly exchanges a knowing look with Somers, a final, eerie wink at the audience.

The film closes with a postscript noting that Beverly Sutphin refused to cooperate with the making of this film, a meta-commentary that dovetails with the movie’s themes about complicity, media sensationalism, and the blurred line between crime and entertainment. The result is a darkly comic, unnerving portrayal of a seemingly ordinary woman who transforms fear, anger, and vanity into a cascade of violence that cannot be neatly contained by law, family, or public opinion. The story lingers in the tension between Beverly’s outward civility and her relentless, merciless impulses, leaving the viewer with a stark reminder of the darker undercurrents that can run beneath everyday life.