November 2005

The film opens with a devastating scene: the death of Hugh, played by a Michael Ealy, who is shot outside a corner store in Los Angeles. The story unfurls through a series of flashbacks that reveal the intertwined lives of the protagonist, Sophie Jacobs, and Hugh, as well as the events leading up to his tragic demise. Sophie, portrayed by a talented actress, is an LA photographer haunted by this traumatic event, which is triggered when she and Hugh stop at a local store for a quick candy bar. As the story progresses, viewers are taken through a complex web of relationships and secrets that surround Sophie and her circle.

The narrative examines Sophie’s life with her boyfriend Hugh, who is a lawyer. Their relationship seems stable at first, but as the story develops, it becomes evident that things are more complicated. Sophie begins an affair with Jesse, a co-worker and photography instructor at what appears to be a community college. Jesse’s character, played by a compelling actor, introduces tension and suspicion into the plot. The relationship ends abruptly after a conflict, leaving behind questions about Jesse’s possible involvement in Hugh’s death.

Throughout the film, flashbacks provide deeper insights into Sophie’s past and her current mental state. She regularly visits her mother, with whom she shares lunches, and a psychiatrist, who has been prescribing medication to her. It later emerges that Sophie may have been consulting her psychiatrist even before Hugh’s death, hinting at underlying mental health struggles. These scenes also reveal her confessions, including an admission to sleeping with Jesse and details about her relationship with Hugh, which seem to carry more weight than initially apparent.

A significant twist involves the discovery of a slideshow from November 7—the day of Hugh’s shooting. During a class presentation, a student displays a slide of a photo of Sophie outside the grocery store just moments before the shooting, although the student claims it’s not their own work. Later, another slide appears, showing Sophie in her car on the same day, raising suspicions about who might have planted these images. There are hints that Jesse could be behind the setup, possibly orchestrating the shooting to eliminate Hugh, although evidence remains ambiguous.

Sophie’s interactions with her family and her increasing reliance on alcohol, which she confesses to her mother during their lunches, add further layers to her character. The film subtly hints at her possibly being a victim of abuse—there’s a scene where Hugh seemingly assaults her without her memory of the event afterward. This, coupled with Hugh’s odd behavior—such as counting her pills and trying to control her medication—raises questions about his true nature.

As the plot unfolds, investigators and Sophie herself begin to question her memories and motives. The storyline evolves into a whodunit, where everyone becomes a suspect. Motives for Hugh’s murder are examined, especially in light of the suspicious slides that suggest someone might have wanted him out of the picture. Sophie’s lack of memory regarding certain events, her drug use, and the mysterious circumstances point toward a complex narrative of deception, mental health struggles, and hidden agendas. Ultimately, the film keeps the viewer guessing as the true story behind Hugh’s death slowly comes to light, revealing the dark secrets lurking beneath seemingly ordinary lives.