Eating Out: All You Can Eat 2009

As the somber atmosphere surrounding the funeral of Marc and Kyle begins to fade, their lives become intricately woven with those of their loved ones in unforeseen ways. Helen, Kyle’s mother, played by Mink Stole, welcomes her nephew Casey, portrayed by Daniel Skelton. Casey is a charming but introverted young man whom Helen decides to introduce to Tiffani von der Sloot, a close friend and confidante of Kyle, depicted by Rebekah Kochan. This fateful meeting leads Casey to the local LGBT center, where he encounters Zack, a charismatic regular played by Chris Salvatore.

As Casey grows closer to the group, Tiffani and her friend create a deceptive online persona using the likeness of Ryan, her muscular ex-boyfriend, acted by Michael E.R. Walker. This ruse initially operates without a hitch until the real Ryan unexpectedly makes an appearance, pushing Tiffani to formulate a cunning plan to unite Casey and Zack.

With clever manipulation, Tiffani sets up a fake online profile showcasing Ryan’s charm, which entices Zack to agree to a date with “Ryan.” However, when the actual Ryan shows up, he complicates matters further by pretending to be gay just to provoke Tiffani. After ditching Zack, he comes to realize that both Casey and Zack have been less than honest about their intentions. Seizing this opportunity, Ryan collaborates with Tiffani to confine both Casey and Zack in a room, hoping they can resolve their misunderstandings.

Nevertheless, this forced interaction only escalates the tension, leading to a surprising twist where Ryan, despite being straight, chooses to partake in a threesome to help rekindle the connection between Casey and Zack. Through a series of bold escapades and colorful encounters, Casey must navigate these tangled relationships, all while receiving support from Aunt Helen and mentor Harry, played by Leslie Jordan. Ultimately, Casey’s journey becomes one of self-discovery as he strives to find love amidst the delightful chaos surrounding him.