Eating Out 2: Sloppy Seconds 2006

As tensions simmer beneath the surface, Kyle’s unexpected departure from Marc raises accusations of infidelity, leading to a significant rift between them. Meanwhile, a serendipitous encounter with Troy, a rugged farm boy from Illinois, sparks a surge of desire among Kyle, Tiffani, and Gwen. They find themselves entranced by Troy’s chiseled physique as he poses nude for their art class. As they develop a connection with Troy, he opens up about his experiences with both men and women, yet he hesitates to embrace his true identity. To help him confront his inhibitions, the group devises a plan where Kyle pretends to be an ex-gay dating Tiffani.

As Kyle and Troy start attending meetings of the campus ex-gay ministry, led by the charismatic Jacob, who boasts about his passage from homosexuality, Marc grows increasingly anxious about Kyle’s budding bond with Troy. Undaunted, Marc tries to seduce Troy during an explicit photo shoot with Gwen but is ultimately overwhelmed by his lingering emotions for Kyle. Troy, discovering their ruse, becomes consumed by a thirst for revenge.

Troy confronts Tiffani and Kyle, asserting they’ve reached an “arrangement” that enables Kyle to explore his desires with men. This clash culminates in a tumultuous threesome, where Troy coerces Kyle into performing cunnilingus first. In a dramatic twist, Gwen and Marc burst into Kyle’s home only to be reprimanded by Troy for their reckless pursuit of intimacy. As events unfold, Troy comes to terms with his bisexuality, and Kyle recognizes the grave mistake of abandoning Marc. Ultimately, the group reconciles, gaining a profound appreciation for the complexities of human relationships.

As they grapple with the aftermath of their actions, the group sets out to expose Jacob’s hypocrisy. They uncover that Jacob is secretly closeted and involved in an affair with Octavio, another member of the ministry, revealing how those like Jacob harm the LGBT community by pushing individuals back into the shadows. The group crafts a plan to out Jacob during one of his meetings, utilizing a portable toilet on wheels as the means of revelation. With Jacob finally out to his mother and fleeing with Octavio, Troy finds himself attracted to Tiffani, leading to the beginning of a romantic relationship between them.

In a heartfelt conclusion, Marc and Kyle mended their relationship as they express their rekindled feelings. Meanwhile, Gwen embarks on an exploratory romance with a woman, marking the dawn of a new chapter in her life.