Darby’s Rangers 1958

In the spring of 1942, the United States Army decides to form an elite strike force modeled after the celebrated British Commandos. Led by Major Darby, James Garner, a former staff officer, the 1st Ranger Battalion is created on June 19, 1942. He and Master Sergeant Saul Rosen, Jack Warden, the narrator of the story, recruit a diverse company of men who train under seasoned Commando units in Dundee, Scotland. Darby instills in his recruits a bold conviction: the Commandos are the best soldiers in the world, and given time, the Rangers will earn that distinction for themselves.

The American trainees live in Scottish homes, and the bonds they form off the battlefield begin to matter almost as much as the drills they endure. The unit’s training pairs off several Rangers with local women: Rollo Burns, Peter Brown, with Peggy McTavish, [Venetia Stevenson](/actor/venetia-stevenson, the daughter of the imposing yet good-humored Scottish Commando instructor Sergeant McTavish; and Hank Bishop, Stuart Whitman, with the prim and proper Wendy Hollister, Joan Elan. These relationships add human warmth to a program built on grit, discipline, and hard-won tactics, reminding the men that courage also includes loyalty, tenderness, and restraint.

As combat readiness builds, the Rangers prove their value in real-world campaigns. They contribute to Operation Torch, the Allied invasion of French North Africa, and the battle-tested unit expands with two more battalions. Darby earns a promotion to colonel, a testament to his decisive leadership and willingness to blend rigorous standards with an understanding of his men’s needs. The Rangers’ creed—tough, flexible, and lethal when needed—begins to define their identity, even as the bond between commander and troops grows more intricate.

Joining the Rangers is Second Lieutenant Arnold Dittmann, Edd Byrnes, a fresh West Pointer who approaches combat with a strict, by-the-book mindset. His strictures and quick learning put him at odds with some veterans, but his commitment to duty becomes an asset as the Rangers push into heavy, close-quarters fighting. Dittmann’s arc is punctuated by an intense personal connection with Angelina De Lotta, Etchika Choureau, a strong-willed woman whose presence in his life softens the hardness of front-line combat and humanizes him beyond his tactical focus.

The Rangers continue their ascent during the Sicily campaign, where the close-quarters battles demand both nerve and precision. Darby’s unit relies on speed, surprise, and audacious improvisation to outmaneuver opponents in unfamiliar terrain. The personal and professional lines blur as Dittmann grapples with the brutal realities of warfare, and the team’s devotion to one another becomes a lifeline in the chaos of war.

Amid the fires of war, Darby confides a troubling, recurring dream to Rosen: a vision of being struck by a train, a stark symbol of his fear that battle will claim him. The introspective moment underscores the human cost of leadership—how the burden of command weighs on a man who must lead others into peril again and again.

At Anzio, the Rangers, now operating in a broader, multi-battalion context, are deployed to a perilous mission that culminates in the Battle of Cisterna. The operation is costly and devastating: many soldiers do not return, and a heavy toll is taken on the ranks. Rollo Burns, who had pledged to marry Peggy McTavish if he came back alive, is among those who do not make it home. The losses are profound and unforgettable, shaking the Rangers to their core and foreshadowing the fragility of even the most meticulously planned campaigns. Sgt. McTavish, the legendary instructor, is also remembered in this grim chapter, his legacy living on through the veterans who carried his mentorship into the next battles.

In the aftermath of Cisterna, the Rangers are disbanded, their numbers reduced by casualties and strategic realignments. Yet the film follows brief vignettes that keep the human thread alive: Hank Bishop on leave with Wendy Hollister and her family, and Arnold Dittmann reuniting with Angelina De Lotta. These moments of respite serve as a counterbalance to the relentless strain of combat, illustrating how men carry the war with them into moments of quiet and reflection.

As the war progresses, Darby is called to report to Army Headquarters at the Pentagon, while Rosen bids him a final farewell at the Anzio beachhead. The ending scene is a quiet but poignant tableau: Darby walks along the shore toward a landing craft, saluting a new generation of Rangers as their patches catch the sun. The moment is both a victory and a reminder of the enormous human cost behind every tactical triumph. When the boarding ramp rises, the legacy of the Rangers—and the enduring spirit Darby embodied—remains.

A concluding postscript notes that the Rangers’ rugged, hard-hitting methods of training laid the groundwork for the techniques now employed by all fighting units of the United States Army. The film closes with a somber reflection on the cost of war and the ways in which leadership, courage, and ingenuity endure even in the darkest chapters of history.

In the years that followed, Major Darby returned to Italy and was killed in action in 1945, serving with the 10th Mountain Division just days before the war’s end. He was posthumously promoted to the rank of brigadier general, a final acknowledgement of a career defined by grit, strategic insight, and an unwavering commitment to those he led.