Circumstantial Evidence 1945

  They’ve got nothing on him–except MURDER!  A man waits on death row while his son and friend try to prove that he did not kill a grocer with an ax.

They’ve got nothing on him–except MURDER! A man waits on death row while his son and friend try to prove that he did not kill a grocer with an ax.

Does Circumstantial Evidence have end credit scenes?

No!

Circumstantial Evidence does not have end credit scenes. You can leave when the credits roll.

Meet the Full Cast and Actors of Circumstantial Evidence

Explore the complete cast of Circumstantial Evidence, including both lead and supporting actors. Learn who plays each character, discover their past roles and achievements, and find out what makes this ensemble cast stand out in the world of film and television.


Roy Roberts

Roy Roberts

Marty Hannon

William B. Davidson

William B. Davidson

Board of Appeals Chairman

Scotty Beckett

Scotty Beckett

Freddy Hanlon

James Flavin

James Flavin

Guard

Lloyd Nolan

Lloyd Nolan

Sam Lord

Charles Cane

Charles Cane

Andrews

Ray Teal

Ray Teal

Policeman

Dorothy Adams

Dorothy Adams

Bolger's wife

J. Farrell MacDonald

J. Farrell MacDonald

Jury Foreman

Franklyn Farnum

Franklyn Farnum

Courtroom Spectator (uncredited)

Ruth Ford

Ruth Ford

Mrs. Simms

John Davidson

John Davidson

Lawyer

Max Wagner

Max Wagner

Truck Driver

Byron Foulger

Byron Foulger

Bolger

Lee Phelps

Lee Phelps

Cop

Reed Hadley

Reed Hadley

Prosecutor

Michael Jeffers

Michael Jeffers

Boxing Match Spectator (uncredited)

Selmer Jackson

Selmer Jackson

Warden

Eddie Dunn

Eddie Dunn

Guard

John Larkin

John Larkin

Edward Earle

Edward Earle

Doctor

Edward Biby

Edward Biby

Boxing Match Spectator (uncredited)

Bob Reeves

Bob Reeves

Bailiff (uncredited)

Ben Welden

Ben Welden

Kenny

James Conaty

James Conaty

Juror (uncredited)

Ralph Dunn

Ralph Dunn

Cleary, the Cop

Brandon Beach

Brandon Beach

Juror (uncredited)

Kay Garrett

Kay Garrett

Juror (uncredited)

Ruth Clifford

Ruth Clifford

Bridge Player (uncredited)

Harry Strang

Harry Strang

Prison Guard

Emmett Vogan

Emmett Vogan

Bridge Player

Lester Dorr

Lester Dorr

Prisoner

King Lockwood

King Lockwood

Boxing Match Spectator (uncredited)

Paul Power

Paul Power

Boxing Match Spectator (uncredited)

Eric Alden

Eric Alden

Guard

Harry McKim

Harry McKim

Murray White

Thomas E. Jackson

Thomas E. Jackson

Detective

John Hamilton

John Hamilton

Gov. Hanlon

Sam Flint

Sam Flint

Prison Board Member

Sherry Hall

Sherry Hall

Court Clerk

Leon Tyler

Leon Tyler

Lefty

Lee Shumway

Lee Shumway

Guard

Philip Morris

Philip Morris

Guard

John Eldredge

John Eldredge

Judge White

Trudy Marshall

Trudy Marshall

Agnes Hannon

Lynn Whitney

Lynn Whitney

Kate Lord

Hugh Maguire

Hugh Maguire

Red

Ken Christy

Ken Christy

Guard

Eddie Hart

Eddie Hart

Guard

Nolan Leary

Nolan Leary

Undertaker

William Frambes

William Frambes

Pete

Eddie Marr

Eddie Marr

Mike Mulvey

Edward Rickard

Edward Rickard

Reporter (uncredited)

Frank Penny

Frank Penny

Undertaker's Assistant

Jimmy O'Gatty

Jimmy O'Gatty

Prisoner

Robert Locke Lorraine

Robert Locke Lorraine

Reporter (uncredited)

Marvin Davis

Marvin Davis

Fatso

Billy Cummings

Billy Cummings

Pat Reynolds

Mel Shubert

Mel Shubert

Prisoner

Dale Cornell

Dale Cornell

Boy (uncredited)

Kay Connors

Kay Connors

Secretary (uncredited)

Lynn Craft

Lynn Craft

Courtroom Spectator (uncredited)

Lester Hoyle

Lester Hoyle

Boy (uncredited)

Jerry Mickelsen

Jerry Mickelsen

Willie (uncredited)

Eddie Small

Eddie Small

Boy (uncredited)

Full Plot Summary and Ending Explained for Circumstantial Evidence

See more

Read the complete plot summary of Circumstantial Evidence, including all major events, twists, and the full ending explained in detail. Explore key characters, themes, hidden meanings, and everything you need to understand the story from beginning to end.


On a tense day in a small town, Joe Reynolds [Michael O’Shea] confronts Kenny [Ben Welden], a cantankerous baker who has confiscated his son’s toy hatchet; Kenny is killed in the scuffle. Three witnesses testify that they saw Joe raise the hatchet, and the court convicts him, sentencing Joe to death based on their testimony.

On death row, Sam Lord [Lloyd Nolan], the town mailman who coordinates youth activities, believes in Joe’s innocence and arranges a boys’ boxing match that includes Joe’s son, with the governor [John Hamilton] and a prominent judge [John Eldredge] in attendance. After the match, several of the boys stage a fake incident mirroring the murder to show how easily witnesses can misread what they see. The governor and judge are moved and indicate that Joe’s case deserves a review, granting a stay of execution.

Unaware of these developments, Joe seizes a chance to escape by forcing his way into the prison’s medical ward and secretly leaving on a ship with an assumed identity, aided by an accomplice. When he reaches town, he learns that clemency may be possible and is forced at gunpoint by Sam to slip back into the prison.

Just as capture seems likely, a visit from the doctor [Edward Earle] arrives, and the charges are dismissed, allowing Joe to be reunited with his son.

Uncover the Details: Timeline, Characters, Themes, and Beyond!

Mobile App Preview

Coming soon on iOS and Android

The Plot Explained Mobile App

From blockbusters to hidden gems — dive into movie stories anytime, anywhere. Save your favorites, discover plots faster, and never miss a twist again.

Sign up to be the first to know when we launch. Your email stays private — always.

Explore the mobile app

Discover Film Music Concerts Near You – Live Orchestras Performing Iconic Movie Soundtracks

Immerse yourself in the magic of cinema with live orchestral performances of your favorite film scores. From sweeping Hollywood blockbusters and animated classics to epic fantasy soundtracks, our curated listings connect you to upcoming film music events worldwide.

Explore concert film screenings paired with full orchestra concerts, read detailed event information, and secure your tickets for unforgettable evenings celebrating legendary composers like John Williams, Hans Zimmer, and more.

Concert Film CTA - Music Note
Concert Film CTA - Green Blue Wave

Circumstantial Evidence Themes and Keywords

Discover the central themes, ideas, and keywords that define the movie’s story, tone, and message. Analyze the film’s deeper meanings, genre influences, and recurring concepts.


sonb movieliefriendaccidental murdertrialwitnessessentenced to deathbasketballfeargovernornew trialfather son relationshipfriendshipescape from prisonreturn to the prisonacquitted of murderman
Movie Wiki CTA - Movie Book

Unlock the World of Movies with Our Comprehensive Wiki

Dive into our Movie Wiki for in-depth film encyclopedia entries, including cast biographies, production trivia, plot synopses, behind-the-scenes facts, and thematic analyses. Whether you’re researching iconic directors, exploring genre histories, or discovering hidden easter eggs, our expertly curated movie database has everything you need to fuel your cinematic passion.

Movie Wiki CTA - Green Blue Wave

Similar Movies To Circumstantial Evidence You Should Know About

Browse a curated list of movies similar in genre, tone, characters, or story structure. Discover new titles like the one you're watching, perfect for fans of related plots, vibes, or cinematic styles.


© 2026 What's After the Movie. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy