Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Thriller

Black Butterfly (2017): Cast, Ratings, Box Office & Plot

Black Butterfly (2017) movie poster

Black Butterfly is a 2017 thriller directed by Brian Goodman, starring Jonathan Rhys Meyers, Antonio Banderas and Piper Perabo. It runs 1 hour 33 minutes and earned $391,431 worldwide. Critics gave it 40% on Rotten Tomatoes and 43 on Metacritic, and IMDb users rate it 6.1/10.

IMDb rating
6.1/10
Rotten Tomatoes
40%
worldwide gross
$391.4K
Echo Score
59
Loading streaming availability…
Black Butterfly (2017) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 33m (93 min)
Director
Brian Goodman
Genre
Thriller
Original language
English
After the credits
No No extra scene
The story

What Is Black Butterfly About?

The premise of Black Butterfly without spoilers. The whole story is in the plot summary further down.

A reclusive writer named Paul, searching for inspiration, retreats to a remote mountain town where a series of unsettling abductions and murders have occurred. He offers shelter to a mysterious drifter, Jack, and their relationship quickly escalates into a dangerous and intense power struggle. As they vie for creative dominance, their encounter spirals into a deadly battle for control, blurring the lines between reality and imagination.

Black Butterfly Themes & Keywords

· 50 tags
  • writers block
  • writer
  • cabin
  • alcoholic
  • realtor
  • remake
  • rifle
  • held hostage
  • cabin in the woods
  • obsession
  • farmhouse
  • author
+38 more
  • screenwriter
  • success
  • successful author
  • unsuccessful author
  • literary
  • literature
  • loner
  • alone
  • mountainous
  • region
  • remote
  • isolated
  • seclusion
  • debt
  • creativity
  • secluded area
  • altercation
  • fight
  • diner
  • stranger
  • rescue
  • shotgun
  • car in a lake
  • hunter
  • taken in
  • drifter
  • vagabond
  • typewriter
  • script
  • heavy drinker
  • knife
  • pond
  • secret
  • trap
  • entrapment
  • interrogation
  • deal
  • murder play
Loading streaming availability…
Cast & crew

Black Butterfly Cast

Jonathan Rhys Meyers leads the cast, with Antonio Banderas and Piper Perabo. Directed by Brian Goodman; 10 actors are credited in all.

From the director

More from Brian Goodman

More films directed by Brian Goodman, best-rated first: Last Seen Alive and What Doesn't Kill You.

Full filmography
Ratings

Black Butterfly Reviews & Ratings

Critics gave Black Butterfly 40% on Rotten Tomatoes and 43 on Metacritic, and IMDb users rate it 6.1/10. Our Echo Score gives it 59/100, strongest in character & emotion (80) and weakest in rewatch factor (35).

59 /100

Black Butterfly Echo Score Breakdown

Black Butterfly presents an uneven thriller that elicits both praise and criticism. Its strong directorial moments and compelling central performances earn frequent commendation, while winding logic and a contentious final twist dilute its effectiveness. Viewers commend the suspenseful second act and atmospheric staging, yet many find the climax incoherent and frustrating. Overall, the film offers intermittent engagement through measured pacing and solid acting, but inconsistent plotting and the divisive ending hinder its lasting impact.

Our own 0–100 rating, built from five aspects: art, character, story, the sensory experience and how well a film rewatches.

  • Art & Craft 75

    In terms of art and craft, the film’s direction and production design exhibit moments of clarity and purpose. Critics note the tight framing and muscular staging, while some highlight the effective use of isolated mountain locations for atmosphere. However, occasional lapses in editing rhythm and empty-headed sequences reveal uneven craftsmanship. The balance of confident visual choices and awkward pacing results in a moderately accomplished but flawed aesthetic execution.

  • Character & Emotion 80

    When it comes to character and emotion, the lead performances by Antonio Banderas and Jonathan Rhys Meyers are frequently praised for their emotional intensity and chemistry. Several observers credit their portrayals with conveying panic, confusion, and sustained suspense that propels the narrative. While some lines lack depth, the actors’ nuanced reactions anchor many of the film’s key moments. Overall, the central casting delivers consistent empathy, elevating the film’s otherwise uneven elements.

  • Story & Flow 45

    In terms of story and flow, the film generates initial suspense through a multi-path narrative in the second act, offering several plausible twists. Many reviewers appreciate the fast-paced middle section and surprising revelations that keep viewers guessing. However, repeated criticisms point to incoherent logic, hacky twist layering, and a divisive final moment that feels tacked-on. The imbalance between promising setup and unsatisfying resolution yields an overall disjointed narrative experience.

  • Sensory Experience 60

    When considering sensory experience, Black Butterfly utilizes its chilly mountain setting to establish a cold, claustrophobic atmosphere, aided by restrained sound design. The soundtrack underscores tension without overwhelming the narrative, and the visual palette remains cohesive throughout most scenes. Despite these strengths, few moments stand out as particularly memorable, and the film lacks a distinctive auditory or visual signature. As a result, the sensory impact is serviceable but seldom striking.

  • Rewatch Factor 35

    In terms of rewatch factor, the film’s moderate suspense and strong lead performances provide occasional incentive for a repeat viewing. The atmospheric staging and measured pacing in the second act retain some appeal. However, the convoluted plot logic and especially the controversial closing twist diminish the likelihood of a satisfying second experience. The unresolved narrative flaws and abrupt final beat reduce the film’s lasting appeal, making repeated viewings less compelling.

Plot

Black Butterfly Plot Summary

What happens in Black Butterfly from start to finish, spoilers included, with a timeline of 15 key events. The opening is below; the full summary is a 4-minute read.

Spoilers ahead

Paul, Jonathan Rhys Meyers, a reclusive writer, sits at his typewriter repeating the words “I’m stuck” as if the tension between creativity and isolation could be trapped on the page. The hush of his farmhouse is broken when Laura, the real estate agent, arrives with prospective buyers for his house and farm. Laura’s visit nudges Paul toward ordinary errands and a planned lunch, a rare thread of human contact in his secluded life. As he heads into town, a tense moment with a truck driver interrupts his routine, a confrontation that bleeds into the day’s small dramas.

Full summary

The whole story of Black Butterfly, scene by scene

Read the full summary
Box office

Black Butterfly Box Office

Black Butterfly grossed $391,431 worldwide.

2017 box office

Worldwide gross

$391.4K

International
$391.4K
Videos

Black Butterfly Trailers & Videos

2 videos: 2 trailers.

Black Butterfly Trailer #1 (2017) | Movieclips Trailers
  • Trailer Black Butterfly - 2017 Thriller Movie - Official Trailer HD
Quiz

How Well Do You Know Black Butterfly?

10 questions about the story, each with a hint if you get stuck. Pick an answer to see whether you were right.

Question 1 of 10

  1. Question 1: not answered
  2. Question 2: not answered
  3. Question 3: not answered
  4. Question 4: not answered
  5. Question 5: not answered
  6. Question 6: not answered
  7. Question 7: not answered
  8. Question 8: not answered
  9. Question 9: not answered
  10. Question 10: not answered

Which actor plays the reclusive writer Paul?

Cars

Cars in Black Butterfly

13 cars on screen, including the 1981 Jeep CJ-7 and the 1998 Land-Rover Freelander Series I.

All 13 cars
  • 1981 Jeep CJ-7 in Black Butterfly 1981 Jeep CJ-7 Important role
  • 1998 Land-Rover Freelander Series I in Black Butterfly 1998 Land-Rover Freelander Series I Important role
  • 1995 Ford Explorer in Black Butterfly 1995 Ford Explorer Minor role
  • 1993 Ford Mondeo MkI in Black Butterfly 1993 Ford Mondeo MkI Minor role
Details

Black Butterfly Also Known As

24 alternative titles, including “ブラック・バタフライ” and “Black Butterfly: Der Mörder in mir”.

Also known as
  • ブラック・バタフライ
  • Black Butterfly: Der Mörder in mir
  • Borboleta Negra
  • Черная бабочка
  • Mariposa negra
  • Séquestré
  • Qara Kəpənək
  • Black Butterfly - Der Mörder in mir
  • Чорний метелик
  • Μαύρη Πεταλούδα
  • פרפר שחור
  • 블랙 버터플라이
+12 more
  • Fekete pillangó
  • Černý motýl
  • Czarny Motyl
  • 黑蝴蝶
  • Letras de un Crimen
  • 黑蝶殺機
  • Црни лептир
  • 黑蝶
  • Fluturele negru
  • Juodasis drugelis
  • Giăng Bẫy
  • Черна пеперуда

Seen Black Butterfly?

FAQ

Black Butterfly FAQ: Cast, Box Office & Runtime

Runtime, release date, director, cast, box office, ratings and post-credit scenes of Black Butterfly, each answered in a sentence.

How long is Black Butterfly?

Black Butterfly runs 1 hour 33 minutes (93 minutes).

When was Black Butterfly released?

Black Butterfly was released on May 26, 2017.

Who directed Black Butterfly?

Black Butterfly was directed by Brian Goodman.

More films by Brian Goodman

Who is in the cast of Black Butterfly?

Black Butterfly stars Jonathan Rhys Meyers, Antonio Banderas and Piper Perabo, among 10 credited actors.

How much did Black Butterfly make at the box office?

Black Butterfly grossed $391,431 worldwide.

How is Black Butterfly rated?

Black Butterfly has 6.1/10 on IMDb, 40% on Rotten Tomatoes, 43 on Metacritic and 62% on TMDB.

Does Black Butterfly have a post-credit scene?

No. Black Butterfly has no extra scene during or after the credits.

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app