Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Plot summary

What's Your Number? (2011) Plot Summary & Timeline

What's Your Number? (2011) movie poster

What's Your Number? is a 2011 comedy film directed by Mark Mylod, running 1 hour 46 minutes. This page retells the whole story in 587 words (about 3 minutes to read) and covers 15 key events in order, 3 characters, where and when it is set and 3 themes. Looking for the cast, ratings and where to stream it? See the movie page for What's Your Number?.

to read the plot summary
3 min
key events in the timeline
15
characters profiled
3
themes explained
3
Loading streaming availability…
What's Your Number? (2011) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 46m
Director
Mark Mylod
Genre
Comedy
Original language
English
No spoilers

What Is What's Your Number? About?

The premise of What's Your Number? in 273 words, with nothing given away. The full story follows below.

In bustling Boston, a city that hums with restless energy and quirky charm, a sharp‑tongued thirty‑something finds herself at a crossroads. After a recent breakup and an unexpected job loss, Ally Darling stumbles upon a cheeky magazine article that dares her to count the lovers she’s collected over the years. The premise—whether a tally of past romances can predict future happiness—sets the stage for a witty, self‑reflective comedy that balances humor with the universal search for meaning.

Compelled by the article’s provocation, Ally decides to take stock of her love life, treating each former flame like a clue in an ever‑expanding puzzle. The tone remains light‑hearted and slightly sarcastic, with a steady undercurrent of earnest yearning. Boston’s eclectic neighborhoods and its bustling subway serve as a lively backdrop, highlighting the protagonist’s feeling of being both lost and buoyed by the city’s perpetual motion.

Enter Colin Shea, an off‑beat musician next door whose own personal quirks make him an unlikely partner in Ally’s quest. Their tentative alliance is rooted in mutual need—she seeks a hand in navigating her tangled past, while he grapples with his own romantic entanglements. Their banter crackles with chemistry, and the film leans into their dynamic, offering a blend of comedic misadventure and heartfelt connection without revealing how their story unfolds.

The film promises a breezy, modern rom‑com atmosphere where introspection meets absurdity. As Ally revisits the ghosts of her dating history, the audience is invited to wonder whether counting past loves can truly guide one toward that elusive “one” — or if the answer lies somewhere in the unexpected moments that happen when old habits collide with new possibilities.

Full plot

What Happens in What's Your Number??

The complete story of What's Your Number?, from the first scene to the last, in 587 words (about 3 minutes). Spoilers throughout.

Spoilers ahead

In the vibrant city of Boston, we meet Ally Darling, a woman navigating her tumultuous 30s. After her boyfriend, Rick, breaks up with her following her request for him to attend her sister Daisy’s wedding, Ally is left in a vulnerable state. To make matters worse, she soon loses her job, leaving her feeling adrift. While riding the subway home, she stumbles upon a thought-provoking article in Marie Claire titled “What’s Your Number?” that suggests women with more than 20 past romances are less likely to find their ideal partner.

This revelation pushes Ally to take stock of her own romantic history, only to discover that she has been involved with 19 men. Determined to change her love life, she swears off romantic encounters until she can find the one who will truly make her heart race. However, after a wild evening at Daisy’s bachelorette party, she wakes up to an unexpected complication: a hangover and the realization that she has once again crossed the line with her former boss, Roger.

To dodge the impending embarrassment of facing Roger, Ally invites her neighbor, Colin Shea, a musician with his own issues, to assist her in getting rid of him. Unbeknownst to Ally, Colin is at her door for his own reasons—trying to shed a one-night stand who is beginning to take things too seriously.

As fate intervenes, Ally bumps into her past love, Disgusting Donald, who has transformed from the awkward, overweight guy she once knew into a confident and attractive man about to tie the knot. Disheartened by her own romantic misadventures, Ally resolves to contact her ex-boyfriends, hoping one of them will have matured into the man she dreams of marrying. She ropes in Colin to help with this quest, trading his digging skills for a place to crash after his escapades.

Among her exes, one stands out: Jake Adams, whom Ally perceives as her “one that got away.” However, as she reconnects with each of her past lovers, the encounters are filled with awkwardness and disappointments that reveal exactly why each relationship failed—ranging from one ex being stuck in a dead-end job to another wanting her to fake a British accent.

Feeling despondent after these failed reconnections, Ally’s spirits are lifted when she enjoys a night out with Colin, leading to a burgeoning connection between them. However, just as things appear to be blossoming, Ally hesitates, yet still chooses Colin as her date for Daisy’s wedding.

With whispers about Colin’s past romantic escapades spreading among their circle, doubts loom over any potential romance between him and Ally. The tension escalates when Ally discovers that Colin had secured Jake’s contact info without revealing it to her, stoking feelings of betrayal and jealousy between them.

Amidst this turmoil, Ally reignites her romance with Jake and invites him to her sister’s wedding. As the night unfolds, Colin performs with his band at another wedding, allowing Ally to savor joyful moments dancing with her father. However, during a dance with Jake, she confesses her past romances, which horrifies him, leading her to realize that her heart belongs elsewhere.

In a determined search for Colin at various weddings across the city, Ally finally admits her feelings to him, receiving an equally heartfelt response. The story culminates with Ally waking up next to Colin, only to receive an exuberant call from an old flame, confirming that Colin is indeed her 20th and final romance, closing a chapter in her life and opening a new one filled with love and connection.

Timeline

What's Your Number? Timeline: Every Key Event in Order

15 key events in the order they happen, from “Ally's Breakup” to “New Beginnings”. 7 events name a place, across 5 locations.

  1. 1

    Ally's Breakup

    In the city of Boston, Ally Darling faces heartbreak when her boyfriend, Rick, breaks up with her. This split occurs right after she asks him to attend her sister Daisy's wedding, leaving her feeling vulnerable and lost.

    Where:Boston

  2. 2

    Job Loss

    Shortly after the breakup, Ally loses her job, intensifying her feelings of being adrift in life. This dual loss of a boyfriend and a job drives her into a period of deep reflection.

  3. 3

    The Article Discovery

    While riding the subway, Ally discovers an article in *Marie Claire* titled 'What's Your Number?'. The article suggests that women with more than 20 past romances are unlikely to find their ideal partner, prompting Ally to assess her own romantic history.

    Where:Subway in Boston

  4. 4

    The Exes Revelation

    After counting her past relationships, Ally realizes she has been involved with 19 men. This shocking discovery motivates her to swear off romantic encounters until she finds 'the one' who will capture her heart.

  5. 5

    Bachelorette Party Shenanigans

    At her sister Daisy's bachelorette party, Ally indulges in a night of wild fun. The next day, she finds herself with a hangover and the stress of having crossed a line with her former boss, Roger.

    Where:Daisy's Bachelorette Party

  6. 6

    Colin's Arrival

    To avoid facing Roger, Ally invites her neighbor Colin Shea over for help. Colin is also dealing with his own complications from a one-night stand who is starting to get too attached.

  7. 7

    Reconnecting with Disgusting Donald

    An unexpected encounter with her past love, Disgusting Donald, surprises Ally as he has transformed into a confident man. His impending marriage makes Ally reflect on her romantic choices.

    Where:Boston

  8. 8

    The Quest to Find Exes

    Ally decides to contact her ex-boyfriends, hoping one might have matured and become the man of her dreams. With Colin's help, she aims to reconnect and explore her past relationships.

  9. 9

    Awkward Reunion Encounters

    As Ally reaches out to her exes, she is met with a series of awkward and disappointing reunions. These experiences highlight the reasons each past relationship ended, revealing a pattern of mismatched expectations.

  10. 10

    Bonding Night with Colin

    Ally and Colin share a pivotal night out, which begins to deepen their connection. Despite their growing bond, Ally grapples with her feelings and uncertainties about pursuing a romance with him.

Show the other 5 events of What's Your Number?
  1. 11

    Wedding Date Choice

    Ally ultimately chooses Colin as her date for Daisy's wedding, despite the rumors circulating about Colin's romantic past. This decision signifies her intent to move forward with their relationship.

    Where:Daisy's Wedding

  2. 12

    Tension Arises

    As Ally grows closer to Colin, tension escalates when she discovers that Colin had secured contact information for her ex, Jake, without telling her. This situation stirs feelings of jealousy and betrayal.

  3. 13

    Rekindling with Jake

    In the midst of her confusion, Ally rekindles her romance with Jake and invites him to her sister's wedding. The encounter becomes complicated when she reveals her past romances, shocking Jake and causing doubts.

    Where:Daisy's Wedding

  4. 14

    The Search for Colin

    After realizing her heart belongs with Colin, Ally embarks on a quest to find him. She searches through weddings across the city, determined to confess her feelings and set things right.

    Where:Various Weddings in Boston

  5. 15

    New Beginnings

    In a heartfelt moment, Ally admits her feelings to Colin, who reciprocates her emotions. The story culminates with Ally waking up next to Colin, marking a new chapter in her life filled with love.

Characters

Who Are the Main Characters in What's Your Number??

3 characters, among them Ally Darling, Colin Shea and Jake Adams: who each one is and the part they play in the story. 1 of them link to the actor’s page.

  • AD

    Ally Darling

    Ally Darling is a determined woman in her 30s who embarks on a quest to understand her romantic history and discover true love. Throughout the movie, she grapples with self-doubt and vulnerability, pushing herself to confront past relationships while learning valuable lessons about love and connection. Her journey showcases resilience and growth as she navigates the complexities of her heart.

    • 💪 Resilience
    • 💖 Romantic
    • 🎭 Self-Discovery
  • Chris Pratt as Colin Shea in What's Your Number?

    Colin Shea

    Played by Chris Pratt

    Colin Shea is a laid-back musician who becomes an unexpected ally in Ally's journey. While he initially seems to have his own romantic challenges, he offers support and friendship that gradually evolves into something deeper. Colin's easy-going nature contrasts with Ally's emotional struggles, highlighting the importance of companionship and understanding in matters of the heart.

    • 🎶 Musician
    • 🤝 Supportive
    • 💔 Complex
  • JA

    Jake Adams

    Jake Adams represents the idea of 'the one who got away' for Ally. As she reconnects with him, he reveals the disappointment of unfulfilled expectations and the complications of rekindled romance. His character serves as a catalyst for Ally's self-discovery and the realization of where her true feelings lie.

    • 🌅 Past Love
    • 🔄 Complexity
    • 😓 Disappointment
Setting

Where and When Is What's Your Number? Set?

What's Your Number? is set in Boston (Contemporary). Here is why the time and place matter to the story.

When

Contemporary

The movie takes place in a contemporary setting, reflecting the realities of modern relationships and the challenges that accompany navigating romance in one's 30s. This period highlights the pressures faced by individuals as they balance expectations of love, career, and personal fulfillment amidst societal norms.

Where

Boston

Boston is a vibrant city known for its rich history, cultural institutions, and beautiful waterfront. It is home to numerous universities and is a hub for innovation and education, making it a bustling urban environment. The city's unique blend of old-world charm and modernity creates an ideal backdrop for romantic adventures.

  • 🏙️ City
  • 🌊 Waterfront
Themes

What Are the Themes of What's Your Number??

3 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Love & Heartbreak, Self-Reflection and Friendship.

  1. 01

    Love & Heartbreak

    The film explores the intricacies of love and heartbreak as the main character, Ally, navigates her past relationships. It highlights the struggles of finding true love and the emotional toll that failed romances can take. Ultimately, it underscores the importance of self-discovery and recognizing genuine connections in the quest for love.

  2. 02

    Self-Reflection

    Self-reflection is a significant theme, as Ally assesses her romantic history in light of an article that impacts her worldview. Through her journey of reconnecting with past lovers, she learns vital lessons about herself and her needs in a relationship, leading her to find clarity and deeper connections.

  3. 03

    Friendship

    The bond between Ally and Colin exemplifies the importance of friendship in the search for love. Their dynamic is characterized by mutual support and understanding, which evolves into a romantic connection, emphasizing that sometimes the right relationship can blossom from a strong friendship.

Tone & mood

What Kind of Film Is What's Your Number??

Light in tone, with fast pacing and a straightforward story, going by the plot summary.

Tone
Light
Pacing
Fast
Story
Straightforward
Intensity
Medium
Ending
Happy

A fast-paced and witty romantic comedy that follows a woman's humorous journey through her ex-boyfriends, filled with comical mishaps and a growing connection with her charming neighbor.

  • humorous
  • romantic
  • lighthearted
  • playful
  • relatable
  • optimistic
  • self-discovery
  • romantic comedy
  • past relationships
  • finding true love

Quiz

How well do you remember What's Your Number?? Test yourself on the story.

Take the quiz
Loading streaming availability…
Read next

Movies Like What's Your Number? With a Plot Summary

2 films close to What's Your Number? in story and themes that have a full plot summary here: Numb (2007) and How to Be Single (2016).

All plot summaries

Missing a Movie Plot Summary?

Tell us which film you want explained next: the full story, the timeline, the characters and the ending.

Request a summary
FAQ

What's Your Number? Plot Questions

5 quick answers about What's Your Number?, taken from the plot summary, character guide and setting on this page and the film’s credits.

What is What's Your Number? about?

In bustling Boston, a city that hums with restless energy and quirky charm, a sharp‑tongued thirty‑something finds herself at a crossroads. After a recent breakup and an unexpected job loss, Ally Darling stumbles upon a cheeky magazine article that dares her to count the lovers she’s collected over…

Read the full plot summary

When and where does What's Your Number? take place?

What's Your Number? is set in Boston (Contemporary). The movie takes place in a contemporary setting, reflecting the realities of modern relationships and the challenges that accompany navigating romance in one's 30s.

The setting explained

Who are the main characters in What's Your Number??

The story follows Ally Darling, Colin Shea (played by Chris Pratt) and Jake Adams.

All the characters

What are the main themes of What's Your Number??

The summary picks out 3 themes: Love & Heartbreak, Self-Reflection and Friendship.

The themes explained

Who directed What's Your Number??

What's Your Number? (2011) was directed by Mark Mylod and runs 1 hour 46 minutes.

Mark Mylod’s films

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app