Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Plot summary

The Pope of Greenwich Village (1984) Plot Summary & Timeline

The Pope of Greenwich Village (1984) movie poster

The Pope of Greenwich Village is a 1984 comedy and crime film directed by Stuart Rosenberg and Kevin Breslin, running 2 hours 1 minute. This page retells the whole story in 449 words (about 2 minutes to read) and covers 14 key events in order, 5 characters, where and when it is set and 3 themes. Looking for the cast, ratings and where to stream it? See the movie page for The Pope of Greenwich Village.

to read the plot summary
2 min
key events in the timeline
14
characters profiled
5
themes explained
3
Loading streaming availability…
The Pope of Greenwich Village (1984) movie poster
Released
Runtime
2h 1m
Genres
Comedy, Crime, Action
Original language
English
No spoilers

What Is The Pope of Greenwich Village About?

The premise of The Pope of Greenwich Village in 326 words, with nothing given away. The full story follows below.

In the winding streets of an Italian enclave in Greenwich Village, life hums between the clatter of cafe tables and the scent of freshly baked bread. The neighborhood is a tapestry of old‑world tradition and restless ambition, where every corner seems to whisper a promise of a better tomorrow while the shadows of the past linger just out of view. The film captures this contrast with a gritty, almost tactile realism, letting the city itself feel like a character that both nurtures and tests its inhabitants.

Charlie works as a maître d’ by night, polishing brass and smoothing over the frazzled nerves of diners, all while dreaming of one day owning his own restaurant. He balances the pressures of alimony, a pregnant girlfriend, and the ever‑present whisper of financial strain. Across the same street, Paulie flits between tables as a waiter, his mind constantly racing with schemes and shortcuts that promise quick relief from debt. Their friendship is a study in complementary desperation: Charlie’s cautious optimism tempers Paulie’s reckless ingenuity, and together they form a fragile partnership built on shared longing and mutual dependence.

The community around them swirls with unspoken codes and familiar faces—clock repairmen, neighborhood regulars, and the occasional glint of authority that watches from a distance. Beneath the cobblestones, an undercurrent of danger hints at larger forces ready to surface when the fragile balance tips. The characters navigate a world where loyalty is both a currency and a liability, and every choice carries the weight of consequence that could either lift them toward their dreams or pull them deeper into the street’s hardened grit.

As the story unfolds, the audience is drawn into the tension between aspiration and reality, feeling the pulse of a place where ambition collides with the unyielding rhythm of the city. The film balances dark humor with heartfelt yearning, leaving us wondering just how far Charlie and Paulie will go before the very streets they love demand a price.

Full plot

What Happens in The Pope of Greenwich Village?

The complete story of The Pope of Greenwich Village, from the first scene to the last, in 449 words (about 2 minutes). Spoilers throughout. Names in the text link to 4 cast member pages.

Spoilers ahead

In an Italian neighborhood of Greenwich Village, Charlie Moran, Mickey Rourke, a maître d’hôtel with aspirations of someday owning his own restaurant, and Paulie Gibonni, Eric Roberts, a bungling schemer who works as a waiter, live with expensive tastes but not much money. Paulie gets caught skimming checks, and both men are fired. Now out of work and in debt, Charlie must find another way to pay his alimony, support his pregnant girlfriend, Diane, Daryl Hannah, and try to buy a restaurant.

Paulie comes to Charlie with a seemingly foolproof robbery idea involving a large amount of cash in the safe of a local business. Charlie reluctantly agrees to participate, and they manage to recruit Barney, Kenneth McMillan, a clock repairman and locksmith, to help crack the safe. The plan gathers momentum as the trio pulls off the break, but it soon spirals into trouble, drawing in more dangerous players and setting off a chain of consequences that neither Charlie nor Paulie anticipated.

The operation goes sour when a police officer, Walter “Bunky” Ritter, is accidentally killed, and it turns out he had been secretly taping Bed Bug Eddie Grant. Charlie learns that the money they stole belongs to Eddie, a figure entrenched in the local mob world, and the realization pulls the friends deeper into a dangerous game. Eddie’s crew moves quickly, and Paulie finds himself stuck between loyalty to family and the brutal demands of the mob. The consequences are immediate: Eddie’s henchmen cut off Paulie’s left thumb as punishment, underscoring just how quickly missteps can become life-changing losses.

Diane makes a painful decision, leaving Charlie with his money and a future that suddenly looks uncertain, while Paulie is forced to work as a waiter for Eddie. He eventually names Barney to the mob, but at first refuses to identify Charlie as the third man involved. Under mounting pressure, Paulie does reveal the truth, Barney flees town, and Charlie mails him his share of the loot, clinging to a fragile thread of hope. As Charlie finally turns a small profit, making about $20,000 on a horse, the dream of stability flickers back into view.

With a tentative sense of control, Charlie prepares for a final confrontation, armed with a copy of the police tape that could expose Eddie. Yet in a twist of calculated desperation, Paulie adds a last-minute twist—lye in Eddie’s coffee—before both men walk away from Greenwich Village, leaving behind the wreckage of misjudged loyalties and a neighborhood forever haunted by what nearly happened. The film ends on a cautiously resilient note, as Charlie contemplates what it takes to chase a dream in a place where old ties pull just as hard as new ambitions.

Timeline

The Pope of Greenwich Village Timeline: Every Key Event in Order

14 key events in the order they happen, from “Fired and debted” to “The escape and ending”. 14 events name a place, across 7 locations.

  1. 1

    Fired and debted

    Charlie Moran, a maître d'hôtel, and his cousin Paulie Gibonni are fired after Paulie is caught skimming checks. The sudden loss of income leaves them with alimony to pay, a pregnant girlfriend Diane, and the dream of owning a restaurant still out of reach. They realize they must find a new, risky way to make money in their Greenwich Village neighborhood.

    When:immediately after firing Where:Greenwich Village

  2. 2

    The heist idea

    Paulie pitches a seemingly foolproof plan to rob a local business safe for a large cash payout. Charlie reluctantly agrees, hoping the score will solve their money troubles and secure their future.

    When:shortly after firing Where:Greenwich Village

  3. 3

    Enlisting Barney

    They recruit Barney, a clock repairman and locksmith, to help crack the safe. His specialized skills are crucial to bypass the security and get access to the stash.

    When:during planning Where:Greenwich Village

  4. 4

    The safe job goes wrong

    The team cracks the safe, but the plan spirals into tragedy when police officer Walter Ritter is accidentally killed after tapping Eddie Grant for information. The death reveals the operation's true stakes.

    When:during the robbery Where:Local business location in Greenwich Village

  5. 5

    The loot belongs to Eddie

    Charlie learns that the money they stole belongs to Eddie Grant, and the mob soon realizes Paulie's involvement. The theft becomes a target for Eddie and his crew.

    When:immediately after the shooting Where:Greenwich Village

  6. 6

    The mob closes in

    The mob figures out Paulie's role, and even Uncle Pete cannot shield him. Eddie's henchmen start applying pressure to recover the money and punish the culprits.

    When:soon after the murder Where:Greenwich Village

  7. 7

    Paulie's punishment

    Eddie's henchmen cut off Paulie's left thumb as punishment for his involvement. The brutal act disrupts Paulie's ability to participate in future schemes.

    When:shortly after discovery Where:Eddie's operation

  8. 8

    Diane leaves

    Diane leaves Charlie and takes the money to support their unborn child. Charlie's personal life crumbles as he loses both his partner and trust.

    When:after the punishment Where:Charlie's home in Greenwich Village

  9. 9

    Paulie on Eddie's payroll

    Paulie is forced to work as a waiter for Eddie Grant; he initially withholds Charlie's involvement from Eddie but later is pressured to name his cousin.

    When:after the thumb injury Where:Eddie's circle

  10. 10

    Betrayal and exposure

    Under pressure, Paulie rats on Charlie, exposing his role in the scheme. Barney, who had been involved with the loot, eventually leaves town.

    When:after Paulie's betrayal Where:Greenwich Village

Show the other 4 events of The Pope of Greenwich Village
  1. 11

    Barney vanishes and loot

    Barney leaves town, and Charlie mails him his cut of the loot, keeping his share while staying under the radar.

    When:after betrayal Where:Barney's departure

  2. 12

    A glimmer of hope

    Charlie makes 20,000 dollars by betting on a horse, a moment of financial optimism that briefly shifts his fortunes.

    When:after the windfall Where:local racetrack

  3. 13

    Showdown plan forms

    Charlie prepares for a final confrontation with Eddie, armed with a copy of the police tape that captured Eddie's operation. He plans to use the evidence to settle the score.

    When:before the showdown Where:Greenwich Village

  4. 14

    The escape and ending

    In the final twist, Paulie pours lye into Eddie's coffee, then he and Charlie casually walk away from Greenwich Village. The immediate threat is removed, but the future remains uncertain for both men.

    When:final scene Where:Greenwich Village

Characters

Who Are the Main Characters in The Pope of Greenwich Village?

5 characters, among them Charlie Moran (Mickey Rourke), Paulie Gibonni (Eric Roberts) and Diane (Daryl Hannah): who each one is and the part they play in the story. 4 of them link to the actor’s page.

  • Mickey Rourke as Charlie Moran (Mickey Rourke) in The Pope of Greenwich Village

    Charlie Moran (Mickey Rourke)

    Played by Mickey Rourke

    A restaurant hopeful and street-smart maître d'hôtel who dreams of owning his own place. His desperation to support his alimony and pregnant girlfriend Diane pulls him into a dangerous heist. He remains pragmatic and protective, balancing ambition with a rough-edged sense of loyalty.

    • 🍽️ Ambition
    • 🧭 Pragmatism
    • 💔 Romantic Loyalty
  • Eric Roberts as Paulie Gibonni (Eric Roberts) in The Pope of Greenwich Village

    Paulie Gibonni (Eric Roberts)

    Played by Eric Roberts

    A bungling yet cunning waiter whose schemes kick off the heist. His fear of debt and family pressures push him into risky choices, and he ultimately agrees to rat on Charlie under mob pressure. He is pragmatic but self-preserving, often acting as the glue and the liability of the plan.

    • 💰 Greed
    • 🤐 Deception
    • 👨‍👦 Family ties
  • Daryl Hannah as Diane (Daryl Hannah) in The Pope of Greenwich Village

    Diane (Daryl Hannah)

    Played by Daryl Hannah

    Charlie's pregnant girlfriend who supports him but grows wary of crime. She ultimately takes the money to secure their unborn child's future, catalyzing Charlie's shift from partner in crime to defender of escape. Her departure marks the emotional cost of their choices.

    • 💞 Love
    • 🤰 Pregnancy
    • 💔 Breakup
  • Kenneth McMillan as Barney (Kenneth McMillan) in The Pope of Greenwich Village

    Barney (Kenneth McMillan)

    Played by Kenneth McMillan

    A clock repairman and locksmith who helps crack the safe, becoming a key link in the group's plan. His skills and street-smarts tie the crew together, but he, too, is drawn into consequences that force an exit from town. He embodies the practical, resourceful side of the crew.

    • 🗝️ Locksmith
    • 🤝 Loyalty
    • 💼 Crime Link
  • BB

    Bed Bug Eddie Grant

    The mob boss whose stolen money the crew supposedly acts against. He wields power and violence to enforce debt and discipline, and his crew is quick to exact punishment when things go wrong. The confrontation with Eddie's world underscores the brutality behind every clever theft.

    • 💥 Power
    • 🕵️‍♂️ Control
Setting

Where and When Is The Pope of Greenwich Village Set?

The Pope of Greenwich Village is set in Greenwich Village and New York City. Here is why the place matters to the story.

Where

Greenwich Village, New York City

The film unfolds in the gritty, immigrant-heavy streets of Greenwich Village, a working-class enclave known for family-owned businesses and vibrant nightlife. Its cafés, tenements, and social clubs form the backdrop against which Charlie and Paulie chase a restaurant dream and a dangerous shortcut to money. The neighborhood's close-knit atmosphere amplifies loyalty, ambition, and the consequences of crime.

  • 🗽 New York City
  • 🏙️ Urban Neighborhood
  • 🍝 Italian-American Culture
Themes

What Are the Themes of The Pope of Greenwich Village?

3 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Crime & Consequences, Loyalty & Betrayal and Survival & Morality.

  1. 01

    Crime & Consequences

    A seemingly foolproof heist spirals into a web of betrayals. Greed and miscalculation pull Charlie, Paulie, and Barney deeper into danger as the plan unravels. The police, mobsters, and rival loyalties collide, showing how one risky choice can ruin many lives. The film uses the heist to expose character flaws and the price of crime.

  2. 02

    Loyalty & Betrayal

    The cousins' bond drives their decisions, even as fear and pressure fray their trust. Diane's loyalty tests Charlie's priorities when she takes the money for their unborn child. Paulie's readiness to name Charlie under mob pressure reveals how quickly loyalty can tilt toward self-preservation. The story threads together familial ties with cold-blooded consequences.

  3. 03

    Survival & Morality

    Desperation pushes ordinary people toward illegal shortcuts, forcing them to weigh survival against ethics. Each character calculates risk, hoping for a better future while ignoring the creeping costs. The climactic choice to drink away the danger — or to walk away with a slice of the loot — tests their moral limits. The ending underscores that survival sometimes means letting go.

Tone & mood

What Kind of Film Is The Pope of Greenwich Village?

Tense in tone, with fast pacing and a moderate story, going by the plot summary.

Tone
Tense
Pacing
Fast
Story
Moderate
Intensity
Medium
Ending
Mixed

A gritty, tense crime drama that follows two desperate cousins as their small-time heist spirals into dangerous conflict with the mob, creating an atmosphere of anxiety and inevitable consequences set against a harsh New York City backdrop.

  • gritty
  • anxious
  • claustrophobic
  • desperate
  • melancholic
  • streetwise
  • crime caper
  • misjudged loyalties
  • mob retribution
  • getting in over your head

Content notes: severed thumb, police death, mob violence.

Quiz

How well do you remember The Pope of Greenwich Village? Test yourself on the story.

Take the quiz
Loading streaming availability…
Read next

Movies Like The Pope of Greenwich Village With a Plot Summary

6 films close to The Pope of Greenwich Village in story and themes that have a full plot summary here: The Pope’s Toilet (2007) and The Pope Must Die (1991) lead.

All plot summaries

Missing a Movie Plot Summary?

Tell us which film you want explained next: the full story, the timeline, the characters and the ending.

Request a summary
FAQ

The Pope of Greenwich Village Plot Questions

5 quick answers about The Pope of Greenwich Village, taken from the plot summary, character guide and setting on this page and the film’s credits.

What is The Pope of Greenwich Village about?

In the winding streets of an Italian enclave in Greenwich Village, life hums between the clatter of cafe tables and the scent of freshly baked bread. The neighborhood is a tapestry of old‑world tradition and restless ambition, where every corner seems to whisper a promise of a better tomorrow while…

Read the full plot summary

When and where does The Pope of Greenwich Village take place?

The Pope of Greenwich Village is set in Greenwich Village and New York City. The film unfolds in the gritty, immigrant-heavy streets of Greenwich Village, a working-class enclave known for family-owned businesses and vibrant nightlife.

The setting explained

Who are the main characters in The Pope of Greenwich Village?

The story follows Charlie Moran (Mickey Rourke) (played by Mickey Rourke), Paulie Gibonni (Eric Roberts) (played by Eric Roberts), Diane (Daryl Hannah) (played by Daryl Hannah) and Barney (Kenneth McMillan) (played by Kenneth McMillan); the character guide covers 5 characters in all.

All the characters

What are the main themes of The Pope of Greenwich Village?

The summary picks out 3 themes: Crime & Consequences, Loyalty & Betrayal and Survival & Morality.

The themes explained

Who directed The Pope of Greenwich Village?

The Pope of Greenwich Village (1984) was directed by Stuart Rosenberg and Kevin Breslin and runs 2 hours 1 minute.

Stuart Rosenberg’s films

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app