What Happens in Mayor Pete?
The complete story of Mayor Pete, from the first scene to the last, in 210 words (about 1 minute). Spoilers throughout. Names in the text link to 2 cast member pages.
Spoilers ahead
Following the economic decline of South Bend after the Studebaker factory closed in the early 1960s, the city saw a shift in leadership when Pete Buttigieg became mayor. This film provides an intimate look at his journey as he campaigns for the President of the United States, striving to become the first openly gay person to hold the office.
The narrative begins a year before the 2020 Iowa caucuses, documenting the highs and lows of the campaign trail. Key moments include a press conference in Harlem with Al Sharpton, where they addressed systemic homophobia, and a challenging interview with Rachel Maddow regarding the racial demographics of the South Bend police force.
Throughout the film, Pete Buttigieg engages with “religious left” leaders to discuss how faith is sometimes used as a weapon, while also sharing personal reflections on his coming-out story and his marriage to Chasten Buttigieg.
Although he made history as the first openly gay candidate to participate in a presidential debate and win a primary—specifically the 2020 Iowa Democratic presidential caucuses—he eventually exited the race following Joe Biden’s victory in South Carolina. The story concludes in 2021, when Pete Buttigieg achieved another milestone by becoming the first confirmed gay cabinet member in U.S. history as the Secretary of Transportation.
Mayor Pete Timeline: Every Key Event in Order
12 key events in the order they happen, from “The Studebaker Factory Shuts Down” to “Confirmed as Secretary of Transportation”. 6 events name a place, across 5 locations.
- 1
The Studebaker Factory Shuts Down
The Studebaker factory closes in South Bend, Indiana, dealing a devastating blow to the local economy. The closure marks the beginning of decades of decline for the city. South Bend struggles for years until a new generation of leadership emerges to reverse its fortunes.
When:Early 1960s Where:South Bend, Indiana
- 2
Buttigieg Becomes Mayor of South Bend
Pete Buttigieg takes office as mayor of South Bend, a city that has been in decline since the factory shutdown. His tenure becomes a defining part of his political identity and later his presidential pitch. His mayoral record, however, will also face scrutiny on the national stage.
Where:South Bend, Indiana
- 3
The Presidential Campaign Begins
The film begins one year before the 2020 Iowa caucuses as Buttigieg launches his bid for the presidency. He campaigns to become the country's first openly gay president. The documentary offers a glimpse into the hard realities of life on the campaign trail.
When:2019
- 4
Press Conference with Al Sharpton
Buttigieg holds a press conference with the Reverend Al Sharpton at Sylvia's Restaurant of Harlem. Sharpton states that the country has to deal with homophobia in all communities, including the black community and the faith community. The event highlights Buttigieg's efforts to reach out to black voters.
When:April 2019 Where:Sylvia's Restaurant of Harlem, New York City
- 5
Rachel Maddow Interview on Police Diversity
Rachel Maddow questions Buttigieg about the racial makeup of the South Bend police force during a television interview. She notes that the force is 6% black in a city that is 26% black and asks why it has not improved over his two terms as mayor. The exchange puts his mayoral record under a national spotlight.
When:July 2019
- 6
Conversations on LGBT Parenting
Buttigieg and his husband Chasten sit down to discuss LGBT parenting together. Their conversations offer an intimate look into their marriage and their hopes for the future. These personal moments ground the political narrative in the candidate's private life.
- 7
Meeting the Religious Left
Buttigieg meets with liberal Jewish and Christian leaders whom he terms the religious left. Together they discuss using faith as a weapon in political discourse. The meetings reflect his ongoing effort to reconcile his faith with his identity and his campaign.
- 8
First Openly Gay Candidate in a Presidential Debate
Buttigieg makes history as the first openly gay candidate to take part in a United States presidential debate. His presence on the debate stage marks a major milestone for LGBT representation in American politics. The moment becomes one of the defining achievements of his campaign.
When:2019
- 9
Winning the Iowa Caucuses
Buttigieg wins the 2020 Iowa Democratic presidential caucuses, marking the peak of his presidential campaign. The victory makes him the first openly gay candidate to win a primary contest. Momentum from the win briefly positions him as a leading contender for the nomination.
When:February 2020 Where:Iowa
- 10
South Carolina Primary and Exit from the Race
Joe Biden delivers a landslide victory in the 2020 South Carolina Democratic primary. Buttigieg is nonetheless forced to exit the presidential race shortly afterward. The setback brings his historic campaign to an end.
When:February 2020 Where:South Carolina
- 11
Reflections on His Coming Out Story
Throughout the film, Buttigieg reflects on his coming out story and the personal journey behind it. He shares what it meant to embrace his identity as a gay man in public life. These reflections connect his private history to his broader political message.
- 12
Confirmed as Secretary of Transportation
In 2021, Buttigieg becomes the first confirmed gay cabinet member in United States history as Secretary of Transportation. The confirmation represents another historic milestone following his presidential campaign. The film closes on this new chapter in his political career.
When:2021 Where:Washington, D.C.
Quiz
How well do you remember Mayor Pete? Test yourself on the story.
