What Is Mad About Men About?
The premise of Mad About Men in 260 words, with nothing given away. The full story follows below.
In the picturesque setting of Cornwall, where rugged cliffs meet the sea, schoolteacher Caroline Trewella discovers that her holiday will be anything but ordinary. A chance meeting reveals a startling family secret: a mermaid named Miranda who is her exact look-alike. The two women form a unique bond, leading to a playful scheme that allows Miranda to experience life on dry land while Caroline enjoys a brief escape from her daily routine. This delightful premise sets the stage for a charming comedy of errors, blending fantasy with the polite constraints of society.
To conceal Miranda’s aquatic nature, the duo crafts a clever cover story involving an accident that confines the “patient” to a wheelchair. With the help of the eccentric Nurse Carey, who is well-versed in Miranda’s unusual history, the ruse begins to take hold. The film thrives on the contrast between Caroline’s reserved demeanor and Miranda’s effervescent, flirtatious approach to human interaction. As the mermaid steps into her cousin’s shoes, she brings a splash of chaos to the quiet seaside town, challenging expectations and upending the social order with a wink and a smile.
However, the charade grows complicated as Miranda takes a keen interest in Caroline’s romantic future. Disapproving of Caroline’s fiancé, Ronald Baker, the mermaid sets her sights on improving her cousin’s prospects, openly flirting with other suitors and testing the boundaries of the deception. As the lines between pretense and reality blur, the story weaves a narrative of longing and self-discovery, asking how far one might go to find a life that truly feels like home.
What Happens in Mad About Men?
The complete story of Mad About Men, from the first scene to the last, in 452 words (about 2 minutes). Spoilers throughout. Names in the text link to 6 cast member pages.
Spoilers ahead
On holiday in Cornwall, the gymnastics school teacher Caroline Trewella encounters a striking doppelgänger who shares her exact appearance—her distant mermaid relative, Miranda. The two form a startling bond, and Miranda proposes a bold swap: Caroline will let Miranda take her place for a seaside break while Caroline heads off on a cycling excursion with a friend. To make the plan work, Caroline pretends to have an accident that will require a wheelchair for a few weeks, a ruse that softly masks Miranda’s unusual tail and aquatic nature. Into this arrangement enters Nurse Carey, who knows about Miranda and was even part of the previous film, hired to attend Miranda and keep the deception intact.
Caroline is engaged to Ronald Baker, but Miranda disapproves of him from the start. Seizing the chance to improve Caroline’s prospects, Miranda flirts openly with two eligible bachelors, Jeff Saunders and Colonel Barclay Sutton, right under Ronald’s nose. When Ronald reveals his work in the government sanitation department and his supportive stance on dumping garbage into the ocean, Miranda wastes no time in delivering a decisive rebuke—dousing him with a tureen of cold soup. The moment highlights Miranda’s sharp, fearless wit and her stubborn preference for a more exciting, compatible match for Caroline.
Meanwhile, Barbara Davenport, Barclay’s fiancée, instantly distrusts Miranda and quickly uncovers the secret behind Caroline’s sudden disappearance. She hatches a plan to lure Caroline back by arranging for Miranda to perform at a charity concert, hoping to expose the disguise and reclaim her own engagement. Caroline, upon reading about the concert, senses the trap and returns abruptly to reclaim her life, outsmarting Barbara and thwarting the scheme.
As the holiday drama unfolds, the two men intrigue Caroline anew. Jeff Saunders takes Caroline out on a boating outing, and the course of romance takes a delicate turn: he leans in to kiss her, she initially resists, then allows the moment to unfold, guided by a mix of curiosity and genuine feeling. All the while, a regretful Miranda watches the scene, quietly mourning the loss of the life she briefly stole from Caroline even as the bond between the two grows stronger.
Across the waves and shorelines, the film delves into friendship, identity, and the playful tensions of mistaken appearances. The Cornwall setting—with its windy cliffs, tranquil harbors, and sunlit mornings—frames a tale that blends light comedy with a gentle meditation on longing and belonging. As the sun sets on this curious swap, Caroline and Miranda navigate borders of love, loyalty, and self-discovery, leaving the audience with a nuanced sense of how far one might go for a chance at a better match, and what it means to choose a life that truly feels like home.
Mad About Men Timeline: Every Key Event in Order
12 key events in the order they happen, from “Caroline arrives in Cornwall for a seaside holiday” to “Ending note”. 12 events name a place, across 2 locations.
- 1
Caroline arrives in Cornwall for a seaside holiday
Gymnastics teacher Caroline Trewella arrives at her family's home in Cornwall to enjoy a holiday. There she meets her distant mermaid relative Miranda, who looks exactly like her. The two discuss the possibility of Miranda trading places with Caroline so they can each live the other's life.
When:Start of holiday Where:Cornwall, England
- 2
Agreement to swap identities
Miranda proposes to swap places with Caroline so she can walk on land while Caroline enjoys life underwater. Caroline agrees to the swap and they plan how to manage the deception. The arrangement sets the stage for the coming weeks.
When:Early in the holiday Where:Cornwall, England
- 3
Caroline's wheelchair ruse
Caroline pretends to have an accident, convincing others that she will need a wheelchair for weeks. The ruse provides cover for Miranda's fish tail and the life swap. Miranda begins living as Caroline during the holiday.
When:Shortly after the agreement Where:Cornwall, England
- 4
Nurse Carey joins the plan
Carey, a nurse who knows about Miranda from the earlier film, is hired to attend to Miranda-as-Caroline and keep the deception intact. She helps maintain the illusion and attends to Miranda during her land-life phase. The support ensures the swap remains secret.
When:After the swap Where:Cornwall, England
- 5
Ronald arrives; Miranda flirts with others
Ronald Baker arrives as Caroline's fiancé, but Miranda, now inhabiting Caroline's life, dislikes him. She decides to improve Caroline's prospects by flirting with Jeff Saunders and Colonel Barclay Sutton, right in front of Ronald. The flirtations create tension around the engagement.
When:Soon after the swap Where:Cornwall, England
- 6
Soup dumped on Ronald
During an encounter with Ronald, Miranda learns he works in the sanitation department and supports dumping garbage into the ocean. In a bold gesture, she dumps a tureen of cold soup on his head. The moment underscores Miranda's defiance and disdain for Ronald.
When:During the same encounter Where:Cornwall, England
- 7
Barbara Davenport discovers the secret
Barbara Davenport, Barclay's fiancée, swims and unexpectedly uncovers Miranda's secret. She becomes determined to expose Miranda's true nature to everyone. Her discovery sets in motion a plot to reveal the disguise at the charity event.
When:Days after the soup incident Where:Cornwall, England
- 8
Barbara's concert plot
Barbara arranges for 'Caroline' to sing at a charity concert, hoping to reveal Miranda's true identity during the performance. The plan hinges on exposing the impostor's disguise without harming the engagement with Barclay.
When:Before the charity concert Where:Cornwall, England
- 9
Caroline learns of the plan and returns to stop Miranda
Caroline reads about the forthcoming concert and hurries back to take Miranda's place, aiming to foil Barbara's scheme. Her swift return interrupts the reveal and keeps Miranda's secret intact for the moment.
When:Before the concert Where:Cornwall, England
- 10
Charity concert proceeds; plan foiled
At the charity concert, Caroline as Miranda continues the performance and prevents Barbara's plan from succeeding. The identity swap remains secret for the moment, and Miranda's true nature stays hidden from the wider world.
When:During the concert Where:Cornwall, England
- 11
Boat ride and the kiss
After the concert, Jeff takes Caroline boating. He tries to kiss her; she resists at first, then gives in, deepening their romance. Miranda watches from a distance, a little sad about the unfolding romance.
When:Later in the holiday Where:Sea near Cornwall
- 12
Ending note
With the moment of closeness established, Caroline and Jeff's relationship moves forward while Miranda remains in the wings, contemplating the complex life she has chosen. The film ends on a note of emotional tension and unresolved truths.
When:End of holiday Where:Cornwall, England
Who Are the Main Characters in Mad About Men?
7 characters, among them Caroline Trewella, Miranda Trewella and Jeff Saunders: who each one is and the part they play in the story. Every profile links to the actor’s page.
- CT
Caroline Trewella
Played by Glynis Johns
Gymnastics school teacher who holidays at her family home in Cornwall. She agrees to Miranda trading places and pretends to be wheelchair-bound to cover the mermaid disguise. She tries to manage the romantic mess around her engagement to Ronald, and later accepts a kiss from Jeff on the boat.
- 💪 Determined
- 💖 Romantic
- 🎭 Deception
- MT
Miranda Trewella
Played by Glynis Johns
Caroline's distant mermaid cousin who swaps places with her. Miranda enjoys Caroline's life, flirting with eligible bachelors and testing social boundaries, all while hiding her tail under the disguise. She has a coy, unapologetic approach to romance and revels in the freedom of the new life.
- 🧜 Mermaid
- 🎭 Disguise
- 💃 Flirtatious
- JS
Jeff Saunders
Played by Donald Sinden
One of the eligible bachelors who is drawn to Caroline while Miranda is in her place. He becomes the apparent romantic interest and shares a boat outing with Caroline, where he attempts to kiss her.
- 💫 Charming
- 💘 Romantic
- CB
Colonel Barclay Sutton
Played by Nicholas Phipps
A suitor and fiancé to Barbara Davenport, he is targeted by Miranda's flirtations. He participates in the social flirtations that drive the plot and provide a contrast to Barbara's defense of propriety.
- 🪖 Military
- 🎭 Romantic
- BD
Barbara Davenport
Played by Anne Crawford
Barabara Davenport is Barclay Sutton's fiancée who dislikes Miranda and schemes to reveal the mermaid secret. Her actions add tension and a sense of social jeopardy to the affair-focused plot.
- 💍 Fiancé
- 🎭 Rival
- RB
Ronald Baker
Played by Peter Martyn
Caroline's fiancé who works in the government sanitation department and holds a view about dumping garbage into the ocean. He becomes the subject of Miranda's schemes and is humiliated when soup is dumped on his head.
- 💼 Government
- 👀 Target
-
Nurse Carey
Played by Margaret Rutherford
Nurse who knows about Miranda and was in the earlier film. She is hired to tend to Miranda during the switch and navigates the crossover knowledge of both women.
- 🩺 Caregiver
- 👀 Knowledgeable
Where and When Is Mad About Men Set?
Mad About Men is set in Cornwall. Here is why the place matters to the story.
Where
Cornwall
Caroline's holiday unfolds at her family's home in Cornwall, a coastal region by the sea. The country house and nearby waterside setting provide the backdrop for light-hearted meddling and social misadventures. The Cornwall location situates the comedy in a quaint, sun-soaked holiday locale where two lives briefly collide.
- 🏖️ Coastal Cornwall
- 🏡 Family home
- 🗺️ Seaside town
What Are the Themes of Mad About Men?
3 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Identity swap, Romantic deception and Mermaid secret.
-
01
Identity swap
The story turns on a deliberate swap of identities: Miranda takes Caroline's place, while Caroline pretends to be wheelchair-bound to cover the mermaid disguise. This setup drives the plot and pushes characters to confront desires, reputations, and social expectations. The switching of roles reveals how appearance and position shape relationships and choices.
-
02
Romantic deception
Miranda uses Caroline's romantic opportunities to flirt with Jeff Saunders and Colonel Barclay Sutton, testing their interest and Caroline's engagement to Ronald. Barbara Davenport senses danger and schemes to expose the secret, turning courtship into a playful battleground. The tangled romances propel the comedy toward a resolution that reconciles affection with truth.
-
03
Mermaid secret
Miranda’s true nature as a mermaid is hidden beneath the masquerade, with a fish tail acting as a literal secret. The disguise requires Caroline to navigate social waters while Miranda enjoys the freedom of a new life. The mermaid angle blends myth with light satire of propriety and matchmaking.
What Kind of Film Is Mad About Men?
Whimsical in tone, with steady pacing and a straightforward story, going by the plot summary.
- Tone
- Whimsical
- Pacing
- Steady
- Story
- Straightforward
- Intensity
- Low
- Ending
- Bittersweet
A charming and whimsical romantic comedy featuring a playful mermaid's antics on land, creating a light-hearted atmosphere with a touch of wistful longing and feisty humor.
- whimsical
- playful
- flirtatious
- fantastical
- feisty
- romantic
- switching places
- mermaid mythology
- forbidden love
- female friendship
Where to Watch Mad About Men
. US availability and prices from JustWatch.
Streaming availability in the US, powered by 
