Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Plot summary

Cheats (2002) Plot Summary & Timeline

Cheats (2002) movie poster

Cheats is a 2002 comedy film directed by Andrew Gurland, running 1 hour 26 minutes. This page retells the whole story in 927 words (about 4 minutes to read) and covers 14 key events in order, 12 characters, where and when it is set and 3 themes. Looking for the cast, ratings and where to stream it? See the movie page for Cheats.

to read the plot summary
4 min
key events in the timeline
14
characters profiled
12
themes explained
3
Loading streaming availability…
Cheats (2002) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 26m
Director
Andrew Gurland
Genre
Comedy
Original language
English
No spoilers

What Is Cheats About?

The premise of Cheats in 330 words, with nothing given away. The full story follows below.

In a suburban high‑school where report cards feel more like commands than feedback, a young man named Handsome Davis treats grades as a subtle form of mind‑control. He resists the relentless tide of rote studying that swallows his peers, preferring instead a mischievous outlook that turns every test into a chance to question the system’s authority. The film opens with a tone that blends sly humor with an undercurrent of rebellion, inviting the audience to wonder how far a clever group will push the limits of academic convention.

Joining Handsome are his close‑knit crew of classmates, each bringing a distinct flair to the operation. Sammy Green is the loyal sidekick whose easygoing nature balances Handsome’s daring schemes. Victor Barone adds a touch of street‑wise savvy, always scouting the next angle to stay ahead of the rules. Finally, Jon Applebee—the resident cheat‑sheet virtuoso—provides the technical know‑how that keeps their plans one step ahead of any curriculum. Together they form a low‑key alliance that treats each quiz, midterm, and final exam as a playful battlefield rather than a solemn obligation.

The world of the film is a familiar classroom landscape rendered through a lens of witty subversion. Hallways echo with the murmurs of students caught between conformity and curiosity, while teachers unwittingly become the backdrop for a series of clever, low‑stakes gambits. The cinematography leans into bright, slightly exaggerated colors, underscoring the youthful energy and the almost‑comic daring of the protagonists. A tight, irreverent soundtrack underscores the sense that the school day is a stage for a quietly chaotic dance of intellect and ingenuity.

What drives the story is not just the act of outsmarting tests, but the subtle exploration of friendship, identity, and the desire to carve out personal agency in an environment that rewards compliance. As the group navigates the thin line between harmless mischief and deeper consequences, the audience is left with an enticing question: will their rebellious spirit ultimately rewrite the rules of the classroom—or simply rewrite themselves?

Full plot

What Happens in Cheats?

The complete story of Cheats, from the first scene to the last, in 927 words (about 4 minutes). Spoilers throughout. Names in the text link to 10 cast member pages.

Spoilers ahead

From kindergarten onward, Handsome Trevor Fehrman and Sammy Green Elden Henson lead a high-spirited but risky habit: they cheat on tests by pilfering keys, crib sheets, and quick hacks around rules. Their scheme starts off small but quickly grows into something bigger: a classroom-wide operation that preys on the trust of teachers and classmates alike. As the years pass, the duo finds a willing helper in Evan Rosengarten David Krumholtz, who does their homework for them in exchange for favors. The arrangement takes a troubling turn when Evan’s family becomes aware of the dynamic, and a family confrontation casts a shadow over their clever, if dangerous, hustle.

In middle school and into high school, Handsome and Sammy push their luck further. They recruit Victor Barone Matthew Lawrence and Jon Applebee Martin Starr to widen their network, securing a copy of the janitor’s master key and trading answers to earn money and favors from peers. This escalation draws the attention of Principal Stark Mary Tyler Moore, who publicly announces that the locks will be changed to combat the apparent epidemic of cheating. The group wants to prove they’re still in business, so they pursue bigger targets, including Teddy Blue Jewel Staite, offering a peek at a confidential file to keep their customers satisfied. The break-in strain tightens as Applebee hesitates to go along with the plan, risking exposure, but Handsome and Victor press ahead, and the team narrowly avoids capture when they manage to bluff their way out of a near-miss with the janitor.

The tension shifts to the physics classroom, where Mr. Harkin Morris Panych is about to deliver a crushingly difficult midterm. Handsome uses a manipulative ruse to gain access to the key while Victor copies answers, and Applebee’s cautious reluctance to fully join breaks the alignment of the crew. Victor pushes for a split, insisting that Applebee be kept out of the midterm, which creates a rift that lingers well into the present chaos. The trio briefly reconciles, but the strain remains beneath the surface. Sammy, meanwhile, begins to form a genuine bond with a bright, upstanding classmate named Julie Merkel Maggie Lawson, who tutors him and subtly nudges him toward “doing the right thing.” Handsome, however, pressures Sammy to stay in the game, and the old habits threaten to eclipse the potential for real change.

As the school year progresses, world history teacher Mrs. Herman Barbara Tyson, known for keeping meticulous records in her famous “grade book,” becomes a new obstacle to their operation. Julie, frustrated by the unfair edge cheaters receive, convinces the other girls to stop sharing notes with the boys. Sammy begins to pull away from the cheating circle, yet Handsome remains determined to keep the machine running. Victor grows restless and cruelly pushes back on Herman’s family, but Handsome persuades him to seek a different path and to recruit a new set of accomplices. Rather than relying on crib sheets, the six of them improvise a memorization technique—an obscene song that helps them remember the answers. Principal Stark is misled into thinking the group has turned a new leaf, and she chooses not to punish them—an uneasy calm settles over the campus as they navigate the delicate line between reform and relapse.

Toward the end of their senior year, Mrs. Herman uses her grade book as leverage to test the students’ resolve as they chase college admissions. This pressure drives Handsome and Victor to steal and destroy her grade book, threatening the entire class’s future. Stark receives an anonymous note that pins Victor as the culprit, and she counts on Sammy—now a trusted member of the student court—to confirm the accusation. Suspicion swirls around Applebee as Handsome and Victor speculate about who authored the letter, and they scramble to ensure their roles aren’t exposed in the ensuing video depositions. Handsome attempts to intimidate Julie, insinuating that the graduating class will see her as a traitor, but Applebee testifies against the pair when the situation spirals out of control. The tension peaks as Sammy, using a clever gamble, offers Victor a plea: retake world history in summer school to still earn a diploma.

Victor accepts Handsome’s offer of a plea bargain, and Sammy steps in as a double agent, maneuvering to help his friends while protecting himself. The weight of the students’ misdeeds comes to a head at graduation, where Handsome is unexpectedly recognized with an achievement award in physics, a moment that the crowd greets with a chorus of jeers and mockery. As the credits roll, the film hints at the tangled consequences these actions have bred: the anonymous letter’s origin, the complexity of Victor’s background, and the way adults within the school system may have their own hidden motives—leaving the door open for interpretation about trust, accountability, and the line between cleverness and cruelty.

Overall, the story tracks a dangerous, escalating cycle of cheating and deception that begins with small acts and gradually tests loyalties, friendships, and futures. It balances moments of humor with stark reminders that actions in adolescence can echo far beyond the classroom, shaping how characters see themselves and each other as they face the consequences of their choices. The characters—Handsome [Trevor Fehrman], Sammy Green [Elden Henson], Evan Rosengarten [David Krumholtz], Jon Applebee [Martin Starr], Victor Barone [Matthew Lawrence], Julie Merkel [Maggie Lawson], Mrs. Stark [Mary Tyler Moore], Mr. Harkin [Morris Panych], Teddy Blue [Jewel Staite], and Mrs. Herman [Barbara Tyson]—each leave a mark on a campus where honesty and shortcuts collide, and where the line between ambition and ethics is tested in increasingly sharp relief.

Timeline

Cheats Timeline: Every Key Event in Order

14 key events in the order they happen, from “Beginnings of the cheating scheme” to “Graduation day and aftermath”. 14 events name a place, across 6 locations.

  1. 1

    Beginnings of the cheating scheme

    Handsome Davis and Sammy Green start by stealing teachers' test answer keys to cheat on tests. As they move into middle school, they rely on a classmate named Evan to do their homework, paying him with illicit media obtained by Handsome's father.

    When:Kindergarten–Middle School Where:School

  2. 2

    Parental discovery and risk

    Evan's mother discovers that Handsome supplied her son with an inappropriate recording, triggering a major backlash at home. The incident threatens to bring the group's cheating operation to light.

    When:Middle School Where:Evan's home

  3. 3

    High school expansion of the operation

    In high school, Handsome and Sammy recruit Victor Barone and Jon Applebee, expanding their network and gaining access to a janitor's master key. They start trading answers for money and favors with other students.

    When:High School Where:School

  4. 4

    Lockdown stakes rise

    Principal Stark publicly announces that all school locks will be changed after the master key is stolen, heightening the danger for the cheating crew. The operation must adapt to increased surveillance and risk.

    When:High School Where:School

  5. 5

    Break-in and close call

    Handsome and his team attempt a break-in to access a psychologist's file about Teddy Blue; Applebee hesitates and is caught by the janitor, but the group lies their way out of trouble.

    When:High School Where:School

  6. 6

    Physics midterm heist

    To steal Mr. Harkin's physics key, Handsome feigns a personal confession while Victor copies the key. The plan leads them to decide to keep Applebee out of the upcoming midterm.

    When:High School Where:Physics classroom

  7. 7

    Tutor and temptation

    Sammy begins tutoring a principled classmate, Julie Merkel, and hints he might quit cheating. Handsome pressures him to stay involved in the scheme for the group's continued advantage.

    When:High School Where:School

  8. 8

    Physics midterm cheating exposed

    Handsome, Sammy, and Victor cheat on the physics midterm. Mr. Harkin confronts them, and Handsome delivers a dramatic denial while pulling off his shirt; Sammy and Victor are reprimanded.

    When:High School Where:Physics classroom

  9. 9

    Final exams and new memorization strategy

    Before the world history final, Sammy withdraws from cheating; Victor and Handsome recruit Greedy and Horny to memorize the material with a song rather than crib sheets. Principal Stark decides not to punish Sammy and Victor for the moment.

    When:High School Where:World History class

  10. 10

    Grading leverage and destruction

    Towards the end of senior year, Mrs. Herman uses her grade book to leverage students for college admissions. Handsome and Victor steal and destroy the grade book, risking the class's final grades.

    When:Senior Year Where:School

Show the other 4 events of Cheats
  1. 11

    Anonymous letter and double-dealing

    An anonymous letter blames Victor for stealing the grade book. Principal Stark asks Sammy, a student court member, to verify guilt while Handsome, Victor, and Sammy act as double agents.

    When:Senior Year Where:School

  2. 12

    Testimony and confrontation

    Handsome tries to intimidate Julie to suppress exposure; Victor pushes Applebee to testify, and Applebee ultimately names Victor, shaping the investigation's outcome.

    When:Senior Year Where:School

  3. 13

    Plea bargains and graduation

    Victor accepts a plea bargain to retake world history in summer school and still graduate, revealing Handsome's involvement. Sammy offers Handsome the same plea bargain, which Handsome accepts.

    When:Graduation Season Where:School / Summer

  4. 14

    Graduation day and aftermath

    At graduation, Mr. Harkin awards Handsome a physics achievement amid a skeptical crowd, and Handsome maintains he earned it without cheating. The credits reveal a series of after-effects and twists for the main players.

    When:Graduation Where:Graduation ceremony

Characters

Who Are the Main Characters in Cheats?

12 characters, among them Handsome Davis (Trevor Fehrman), Evan Rosengarten (David Krumholtz) and Sammy Green (Elden Henson): who each one is and the part they play in the story. Every profile links to the actor’s page.

  • HD

    Handsome Davis (Trevor Fehrman)

    Played by Trevor Fehrman

    Charismatic, calculating student who orchestrates the cheating operation across years. He recruits others, rationalizes unethical acts, and maintains a confident front even as the scheme grows more dangerous. His arc centers on control, loyalty, and the eventual cost of manipulation.

    • 🎭 Antagonist
    • 🧠 Calculated
    • 💥 Impulsive
  • David Krumholtz as Evan Rosengarten (David Krumholtz) in Cheats

    Evan Rosengarten (David Krumholtz)

    Played by David Krumholtz

    A reluctant classmate who does others’ homework in exchange for porn videos. He becomes a pawn in the scheme, exploited by Handsome and friends. The dynamic exposes vulnerability and the moral cost of coercive peer networks.

    • 🎭 Exploited
    • 🧠 Vulnerable
  • SG

    Sammy Green (Elden Henson)

    Played by Elden Henson

    A smart, well-meaning student who tutors peers but is drawn into the cheating under pressure. He struggles with loyalty and integrity, eventually taking on a double role to try to redeem himself. His arc centers on moral dilemma and personal growth.

    • 🧭 Moral
    • 🌱 Growth
  • VB

    Victor Barone (Matthew Lawrence)

    Played by Matthew Lawrence

    Ambitious partner who helps expand the cheating operation. He pushes for bigger risks, clashes with others, and faces the consequences of his actions in the end. His arc highlights ambition entwined with moral compromise.

    • 🔥 Ambition
    • 🌀 Turbulence
  • Martin Starr as Jon Applebee (Martin Starr) in Cheats

    Jon Applebee (Martin Starr)

    Played by Martin Starr

    The expert crib sheet maker who contemplates cutting ties with the plan. He hesitates during a break-in and later testifies, seeking to minimize personal risk. He represents the push-pull between cleverness and conscience.

    • 🎯 Strategist
    • 🧭 Cautious
  • JM

    Julie Merkel (Maggie Lawson)

    Played by Maggie Lawson

    A perceptive classmate who tutors Sammy but resents Tufts waitlist pressures. She becomes a target of intimidation as the cheating scheme expands. Julie provides a moral counterweight and resilience amid the chaos.

    • 🎓 Student
    • 💪 Resolve
  • MH

    Mrs. Herman (Barbara Tyson)

    Played by Barbara Tyson

    World history teacher nicknamed 'the grade book' for meticulous daily records. She is central to the plot when her grade book is stolen, triggering a chain of disciplinary actions and strategic maneuvers. Her role underscores how data can be used as leverage.

    • 📚 Authority
    • 📝 Rule-bound
  • MH

    Mr. Harkin (Morris Panych)

    Played by Morris Panych

    Physics teacher who represents the high-stakes environment of exams and keys. He suspects cheating, yet the story twists around his eventual recognition of student achievement alongside controversy. His presence links academic rigor with the pitfalls of circumvention.

    • 🧪 Teacher
    • 🎯 Precision
  • PS

    Principal Stark (Mary Tyler Moore)

    Played by Mary Tyler Moore

    School administrator who publicly acts on the key theft and later faces the consequences of anonymous accusations. She maintains order, enforces policy, and embodies the authority structure of the school. Her decisions shape the narrative’s escalation and resolution.

    • 🏢 Administrator
    • 📜 Authority
  • TB

    Teddy Blue (Jewel Staite)

    Played by Jewel Staite

    A classmate who becomes entangled as the break-in unfolds, and is offered access to a psychologist’s file. Her presence illustrates how far-reaching the cheating web extends into students’ lives. Teddy embodies the vulnerability of those caught in the crossfire.

    • 🎨 Curious
    • 🧭 Target
  • G(

    Greedy (Dixon Cohee)

    Played by Dixon Cohee

    One of the two adopted sons involved in the final reveal, whose demands contribute to the tension surrounding theft and payoff. His actions reflect the darker consequences of opportunism within a family dynamic central to the plot.

    • 💰 Greed
    • 🧱 Dominant
  • H(

    Horny (Lachlan Murdoch)

    Played by Lachlan Murdoch

    The other adopted son whose participation fuels the later stages of the scheme. His presence, marked by impulsivity, underscores how peer- and status-driven behavior can escalate misconduct. He is part of the credits’ reveal about the group’s actions.

    • ⚡ Impulsivity
    • 🧨 Rebellion
Setting

Where and When Is Cheats Set?

Cheats is set in High School (Early 2000s). Here is why the time and place matter to the story.

When

Early 2000s

The events span multiple school years—from kindergarten through senior year—placing the action in a contemporary timeframe. The era features pre-smartphone classroom dynamics and a reliance on physical media and school bureaucracy. This period defines the social stakes and the mechanics of cheating depicted in the story.

Where

High School

Set in a contemporary suburban American high school, the story unfolds within classrooms, hallways, and the administration offices. The school environment is a pressure cooker where grades and reputation drive risky schemes. The world of physics and world history classes, the janitor’s key, and the principal’s office anchor the action.

  • 🏫 High School
  • 🗺️ Suburban Setting
Themes

What Are the Themes of Cheats?

3 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Cheating Culture, Peer Pressure and Consequences.

  1. 01

    Cheating Culture

    The central thread is academic dishonesty and how a group ethic of cheating takes hold. The narrative follows how key players justify shortcuts, trade favors, and manipulate others to secure grades. It explores the erosion of trust, the consequences for reputations, and the fragility of academic integrity.

  2. 02

    Peer Pressure

    Peer dynamics propel the characters to escalate their schemes from crib sheets to elaborate breaches. Friends persuade, bully, or enable one another to stay in the inner circle. The pressure blurs lines between friendship and exploitation, pushing individuals toward riskier choices.

  3. 03

    Consequences

    The film foregrounds fallout—from broken confidences to disciplinary actions and damaged relationships. Tensions culminate in admissions, betrayals, and a graduation-day reckoning. It questions whether cleverness can truly justify unethical behavior.

Tone & mood

What Kind of Film Is Cheats?

Light in tone, with steady pacing and a straightforward story, going by the plot summary.

Tone
Light
Pacing
Steady
Story
Straightforward
Intensity
Medium
Ending
Bittersweet

A mischievous and lighthearted high school comedy that follows a group of friends as their escalating cheating schemes test their loyalties, blending youthful rebellion with a cautionary tone about consequences.

  • mischievous
  • rebellious
  • lighthearted
  • youthful
  • cautionary
  • nostalgic
  • academic dishonesty
  • coming of age
  • friendship
  • rebellion against authority

Quiz

How well do you remember Cheats? Test yourself on the story.

Take the quiz
Loading streaming availability…

Missing a Movie Plot Summary?

Tell us which film you want explained next: the full story, the timeline, the characters and the ending.

Request a summary
FAQ

Cheats Plot Questions

5 quick answers about Cheats, taken from the plot summary, character guide and setting on this page and the film’s credits.

What is Cheats about?

In a suburban high‑school where report cards feel more like commands than feedback, a young man named Handsome Davis treats grades as a subtle form of mind‑control.

Read the full plot summary

When and where does Cheats take place?

Cheats is set in High School (Early 2000s). The events span multiple school years—from kindergarten through senior year—placing the action in a contemporary timeframe.

The setting explained

Who are the main characters in Cheats?

The story follows Handsome Davis (Trevor Fehrman) (played by Trevor Fehrman), Evan Rosengarten (David Krumholtz) (played by David Krumholtz), Sammy Green (Elden Henson) (played by Elden Henson) and Victor Barone (Matthew Lawrence) (played by Matthew Lawrence); the character guide covers 12 characters in all.

All the characters

What are the main themes of Cheats?

The summary picks out 3 themes: Cheating Culture, Peer Pressure and Consequences.

The themes explained

Who directed Cheats?

Cheats (2002) was directed by Andrew Gurland and runs 1 hour 26 minutes.

Andrew Gurland’s films

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app