Logo What's After the Movie

Test your knowledge of American Teen with our quiz!

Plot Summary

Read the complete plot summary and ending explained for American Teen (2008). From turning points to emotional moments, uncover what really happened and why it matters.


Documenting the intricate lives of four teenagers—a jock, the popular girl, the artsy girl, and the geek—the film unfolds in a small Indiana town as they navigate their senior year of high school. We witness the insecurities, cliques, jealousies, first loves, and heartbreaks, alongside the daunting task of making significant decisions about their futures. Over the course of ten months, filmmaker Nanette Burstein immerses herself in the daily lives of her subjects, yielding a film that transcends typical high school stereotypes to portray multifaceted young individuals seeking their paths to adulthood.

Among these teens is Hannah Bailey, an intelligent and striking misfit in her conservative high school. A liberal atheist in a traditional Christian community, she harbors dreams of moving to California post-graduation. Colin Clemens, the star of the high school basketball team—where basketball reigns supreme in Indiana—feels tremendous pressure as he strives to make his town, school, and father proud, all while aiming for a coveted college scholarship.

Then there’s Jake Tusing, a self-identified nerd. Despite his humorous and charming demeanor one-on-one, he grapples with crippling shyness in group situations. This senior year, he resolves that nothing will hinder his quest to find a girlfriend. Meanwhile, Megan Krizmanich, the Vice President of the student council and daughter of a renowned local surgeon, waits anxiously for news from Notre Dame University. Although affluent, attractive, intelligent, and popular, she wields significant power at her school—but not without consequences. When her authority comes under challenge from her peers, she feels compelled to take action, fully aware of the potential risks to her future.

Additionally, we meet Mitch Reinholdt, the charismatic varsity basketball jock with a softer side. As he risks his social standing by opting for dates with the artsy Hannah Bailey instead of his popular friends, he experiences the strains of maintaining his reputation while unearthing new dimensions of himself. This documentary captures not just the trials of adolescence but the journey toward self-discovery amid the turbulent yet formative years of high school.

Timeline

Follow the complete movie timeline of American Teen (2008) with every major event in chronological order. Great for understanding complex plots and story progression.


Introduction to the Four Teens

The film opens by introducing four central characters: the jock, the popular girl, the artsy girl, and the geek. Each of them represents a different facet of high school life in a small Indiana town, setting the stage for their intertwining narratives throughout their senior year.

Indiana

Hannah's Aspirations

We learn about Hannah Bailey, an intelligent misfit with dreams of moving to California after graduation. Her unique position as a liberal atheist in a conservative environment highlights her struggles with identity and belonging.

Indiana

Colin's Pressure

Colin Clemens, a standout basketball player, feels an immense weight on his shoulders. He aims to excel in sports to secure a college scholarship, which leads him to experience the pressures of living up to his family's and community's expectations.

High School Gymnasium

Jake's Journey to Confidence

Jake Tusing, the self-identified nerd, grapples with his shyness in social situations. Determined to change, he sets a resolution to find a girlfriend during his senior year, marking a proactive step towards overcoming his insecurities.

High School

Megan's Authority Challenged

Megan Krizmanich, Vice President of the student council, faces challenges to her authority. Despite her popularity and intelligence, she learns that power comes with its own set of complexities and risks, leaving her anxious about what lies ahead.

High School

Mitch's Social Dilemma

Mitch Reinholdt, the charismatic jock, makes a bold choice by dating Hannah instead of conforming to his friends' expectations. This decision not only puts his social standing at risk but also helps him explore new aspects of his personality.

High School

First Loves

As the year progresses, the teens experience their first loves and romantic entanglements. This phase introduces new emotions and complications, enriching their understanding of relationships and personal connections.

Various

Heartbreaks and Insecurities

The realities of heartbreak force the characters to confront their insecurities. Each teen faces unique challenges that test their resilience and self-worth, highlighting the emotional rollercoaster of adolescence.

High School

Decision-Making for the Future

As graduation approaches, the characters wrestle with crucial decisions that will shape their futures. The pressure to perform academically, choose a college, and ascertain personal aspirations creates a pivotal moment in their lives.

High School

Self-Discovery Journey

Throughout the documentaries, the quartet embarks on a journey of self-discovery. They navigate the trials and tribulations of adolescence, learning more about who they are and who they want to become.

During Senior Year Indiana

Facing the Future

As the film nears its conclusion, the characters reflect on their high school experiences and what lies ahead for them. The blend of excitement and trepidation showcases the bittersweet nature of leaving behind the familiar.

End of Senior Year Graduation Ceremonies

Conclusion of the Documented Year

The documentary wraps up by encapsulating the shared experiences of the teens. Their individual and collective growth signifies the bridge from adolescence to adulthood, chronicling a significant chapter in their lives.

Indiana

Characters

Explore all characters from American Teen (2008). Get detailed profiles with their roles, arcs, and key relationships explained.


Hannah Bailey

Hannah is an intelligent and striking misfit who challenges the norms of her conservative high school. Her liberal values and aspirations to move to California set her apart, and she embodies the struggle of a teenager seeking acceptance while remaining true to herself.

💫 Misfit 🎨 Artsy

Colin Clemens

Colin is the star of the basketball team, embodying the pressure to succeed in a sport revered in Indiana. His determination to impress his family and secure a college scholarship reflects the weight of expectations placed on young athletes.

🏀 Athlete 🎓 Ambition

Jake Tusing

Jake is a self-identified nerd who juxtaposes humor and shyness, particularly in social situations. His year-long quest to find a girlfriend highlights the struggle many face while navigating teenage relationships and self-confidence.

🤓 Nerd ❤️ Romance

Megan Krizmanich

Megan, the Vice President of the student council, wields significant influence in her school but faces challenges to her authority. As she navigates the complexities of being popular and affluent, she learns valuable lessons about leadership and responsibility.

👩‍🏫 Leader 💼 Power

Mitch Reinholdt

Mitch is a charismatic varsity basketball player who struggles to balance his social standing with his personal desires. His choice to date Hannah reveals a softer side and a desire to break away from peer expectations.

🏆 Jock ❤️ Complexity

Setting

Learn where and when American Teen (2008) takes place. Explore the film’s settings, era, and how they shape the narrative.


Time period

Modern Day

The events take place in contemporary times, reflecting the current societal dynamics among teenagers. This period highlights the anxieties of youth regarding college applications, societal pressures, and the complex relationships formed during one's high school years.

Location

small Indiana town

The movie is set in a small Indiana town, known for its tight-knit community and the importance of high school sports, particularly basketball. This backdrop provides a relatable yet challenging environment for the teenagers navigating their senior year, facing pressures from peers and societal expectations.

🏡 Community 🎓 High School

Themes

Discover the main themes in American Teen (2008). Analyze the deeper meanings, emotional layers, and social commentary behind the film.


💔

Heartbreak

Heartbreak is a prevalent theme as the characters grapple with first loves and the emotional fallout of their relationships. The film delves into the complexities of teenage romance, illustrating how love and loss shape their paths to adulthood.

🤔

Self-Discovery

Throughout the documentary, the theme of self-discovery emerges as each teenager navigates their identity and aspirations. From Hannah's ambitions to escape to California to Mitch's struggles with social perceptions, each character's journey reflects the search for personal truth within the confines of societal expectations.

👥

Cliques

The film explores the dynamics of high school cliques, showcasing how they impact friendships and individual growth. It highlights the challenges of breaking free from stereotypes and the influence of peer pressure on personal decisions.

Movies with Similar Twists and Themes

Uncover films that echo the narrative beats, emotional arcs, or dramatic twists of the one you're exploring. These recommendations are handpicked based on story depth, thematic resonance, and spoiler-worthy moments — perfect for fans who crave more of the same intrigue.


© 2025 What's After the Movie. All rights reserved.