The Best Max Casella Movies, Ranked
23 credits from 1991 to 2026, ranked by the Movie Echo Score — a blend of critic reviews, audience ratings and lasting impact. Allswell in New York (2024) comes out on top with a score of 78. The biggest box office hit is A Turtle’s Tale 2: Sammy’s Escape from Paradise (2012) with $49.3M worldwide. Below: the best films by genre and by decade, the most awarded and the newest releases.
Top Rated Max Casella Movies
The 7 highest-rated films Max Casella is credited on. Allswell in New York (2024) leads with 78, followed by Paper Spiders (2021) at 76. The Movie Echo Score blends critic reviews, audience ratings, cultural impact and how well a film holds up.
-
#1 Movie Echo Score: Score 78 Allswell in New York 2024 · Comedy -
#2 Movie Echo Score: Score 76 Paper Spiders 2021 · Drama -
#3 Movie Echo Score: Score 74 Lake George 2024 · Crime -
#4 Movie Echo Score: Score 65 Late Night 2019 · Drama -
#5 Movie Echo Score: Score 56 The Tender Bar 2021 · Drama -
#6 Movie Echo Score: Score 55 Wonder Wheel 2017 · Drama -
#7 Movie Echo Score: Score 50 The Rhythm Section 2020 · Action
Biggest Max Casella Box Office Hits
Max Casella's films have made $153M worldwide in total. A Turtle’s Tale 2: Sammy’s Escape from Paradise (2012) is the biggest hit at $49.3M, ahead of Sgt. Bilko (1996) ($38M). Lifetime grosses, with each film's domestic share.
- 1
A Turtle’s Tale 2: Sammy’s Escape from Paradise 2012 · Adventure $49.3M - 2
Sgt. Bilko 1996 · Comedy $38M $30.4M dom. - 3 Late Night 2019 · Drama $22.4M $15.5M dom.
- 4 Wonder Wheel 2017 · Drama $15.9M $1.4M dom.
- 5
Trial and Error 1997 · Comedy $14.6M $13.6M dom. - 6
Wild Card 2015 · Action $6.74M - 7 The Rhythm Section 2020 · Action $5.99M $5.44M dom.
- 8
Christmas Eve 2015 · Comedy $165K $91.3K dom. - 9 Lake George 2024 · Crime $16.2K $14.7K dom.
- 10 Paper Spiders 2021 · Drama $11.7K $2.99K dom.
The Best Max Casella Movie in Every Genre
The best-rated film in each genre Max Casella has worked in, the genres with the most films first. Comedy leads with 6 films, and Allswell in New York (2024) is the pick of them.
- Comedy 6 films Allswell in New York 2024 · as Tim Movie Echo Score: 78
- Drama 6 films Paper Spiders 2021 · as Gary Movie Echo Score: 76
- Action 2 films The Rhythm Section 2020 Movie Echo Score: 50
- Crime 1 film Lake George 2024 · as Harout Movie Echo Score: 74
- Adventure 1 film A Turtle’s Tale 2: Sammy’s Escape from Paradise 2012 · as Seagull (voice) (uncredited)
The Best Max Casella Movie of Each Decade
One pick per decade of Max Casella's career, newest decade first: the best-rated film of each ten years, from 1990s to 2020s.
The Latest Max Casella Movies
The most recent films Max Casella is credited on, newest first — starting with Jimmy (2026). Open any of them for the cast, ratings, box office and where to watch.
-
Jimmy 2026 · Frank Capra -
Nobody Wants to Shoot a Woman 2026 · Eddie - Lake George 2024 · Harout
- Allswell in New York 2024 · Tim
- The Tender Bar 2021 · Chief
-
That Cold Dead Look in Your Eyes 2021 · Horror -
Scenes from an Empty Church 2021 · Paul - Paper Spiders 2021 · Gary
- The Rhythm Section 2020 · Action
- Late Night 2019 · Burditt
- Wonder Wheel 2017 · Fishing Buddy
-
Sea Oak 2017 · Freddie
The Best Max Casella Movies: Questions & Answers
The best-rated, highest-grossing, most awarded and newest Max Casella films, answered from the rankings on this page.
What is the best Max Casella movie?
Allswell in New York (2024) is the best-rated Max Casella film, with a Movie Echo Score of 78, ahead of Paper Spiders (2021) (76) and Lake George (2024) (74). The Movie Echo Score blends critic reviews, audience ratings and how well a film has lasted.
Allswell in New York: cast, ratings & box office What is the highest-grossing Max Casella movie?
A Turtle’s Tale 2: Sammy’s Escape from Paradise (2012) made the most at the box office, with $49.3M worldwide, followed by Sgt. Bilko (1996) with $38M. Together, Max Casella's films with box office figures have made $153M.
Which Max Casella movie won the most awards?
The Tender Bar (2021) is the most decorated Max Casella film, with 1 win from 3 nominations across the Oscars, Golden Globes, BAFTA and the other ceremonies in the awards database.
What is the best Max Casella comedy movie?
Allswell in New York (2024) is the best-rated of Max Casella's comedy films, with a score of 78. In other genres: Paper Spiders (drama), The Rhythm Section (action) and Lake George (crime).
What is the newest Max Casella movie?
The newest film on Max Casella's filmography is Jimmy (2026), with Max Casella as Frank Capra.
More Movie Rankings & Collections
Best-of lists by year, decade and genre, all-time box office records and the films on the trending list.
Best-Rated Movie Rankings
Best-rated, biggest and most-awarded
New Movies & Top Genres
New releases, popular films and the best of every genre