Skip to content
What's After the Movie?

Jump to
What's After the Movie?
Jesse Metcalfe, actor
Actor · Best movies

The Best Jesse Metcalfe Movies, Ranked

27 credits from 2003 to 2025, ranked by the Movie Echo Score — a blend of critic reviews, audience ratings and lasting impact. Christmas Under the Stars (2019) comes out on top with a score of 72. The biggest box office hit is John Tucker Must Die (2006) with $68.8M worldwide. Below: the best films by genre and by decade, the most awarded and the newest releases.

Full Jesse Metcalfe profile & filmography

Ranked by Movie Echo Score

Top Rated Jesse Metcalfe Movies

The 10 highest-rated films Jesse Metcalfe is credited on. Christmas Under the Stars (2019) leads with 72, followed by Harmony From The Heart (2022) at 69. The Movie Echo Score blends critic reviews, audience ratings, cultural impact and how well a film holds up.

Worldwide gross

Biggest Jesse Metcalfe Box Office Hits

Jesse Metcalfe's films have made $112M worldwide in total. John Tucker Must Die (2006) is the biggest hit at $68.8M, ahead of God's Not Dead 2 (2016) ($24.5M). Lifetime grosses, with each film's domestic share.

All-time box office
  1. 1 John Tucker Must Die (2006) movie poster John Tucker Must Die 2006 · Comedy $68.8M $41M dom.
  2. 2 God's Not Dead 2 (2016) movie poster God's Not Dead 2 2016 · Drama $24.5M $20.8M dom.
  3. 3 Escape Plan 2: Hades (2018) movie poster Escape Plan 2: Hades 2018 · Thriller $17.6M
  4. 4 The Other End of the Line (2008) movie poster The Other End of the Line 2008 · Comedy $508K $116K dom.
  5. 5 Hard Kill (2020) movie poster Hard Kill 2020 · Action $112K
  6. 6 Fortress: Sniper's Eye (2022) movie poster Fortress: Sniper's Eye 2022 · Action $69.1K
  7. 7 Fortress (2021) movie poster Fortress 2021 · Action $52.2K
One pick per genre

The Best Jesse Metcalfe Movie in Every Genre

The best-rated film in each genre Jesse Metcalfe has worked in, the genres with the most films first. Drama leads with 6 films, and On a Wing and a Prayer (2023) is the pick of them.

One pick per decade

The Best Jesse Metcalfe Movie of Each Decade

One pick per decade of Jesse Metcalfe's career, newest decade first: the best-rated film of each ten years, from 2000s to 2020s.

Newest first

The Latest Jesse Metcalfe Movies

The most recent films Jesse Metcalfe is credited on, newest first — starting with The Comic Shop (2025). Open any of them for the cast, ratings, box office and where to watch.

New movie releases
FAQ

The Best Jesse Metcalfe Movies: Questions & Answers

The best-rated, highest-grossing, most awarded and newest Jesse Metcalfe films, answered from the rankings on this page.

What is the best Jesse Metcalfe movie?

Christmas Under the Stars (2019) is the best-rated Jesse Metcalfe film, with a Movie Echo Score of 72, ahead of Harmony From The Heart (2022) (69) and A Beautiful Place to Die: A Martha’s Vineyard Mystery (2020) (66). The Movie Echo Score blends critic reviews, audience ratings and how well a film has lasted.

Christmas Under the Stars: cast, ratings & box office

What is the highest-grossing Jesse Metcalfe movie?

John Tucker Must Die (2006) made the most at the box office, with $68.8M worldwide, followed by God's Not Dead 2 (2016) with $24.5M. Together, Jesse Metcalfe's films with box office figures have made $112M.

What is the best Jesse Metcalfe drama movie?

On a Wing and a Prayer (2023) is the best-rated of Jesse Metcalfe's drama films, with a score of 31. In other genres: Fortress (action), Christmas Under the Stars (tv movie) and Clear Cut (thriller).

What is the newest Jesse Metcalfe movie?

The newest film on Jesse Metcalfe's filmography is The Comic Shop (2025), with Jesse Metcalfe as Mike.

Keep browsing

More Movie Rankings & Collections

Best-of lists by year, decade and genre, all-time box office records and the films on the trending list.

All collections

Best-Rated Movie Rankings

Best-rated, biggest and most-awarded

New Movies & Top Genres

New releases, popular films and the best of every genre