The Best Andrew Erwin Movies, Ranked
9 credits from 2012 to 2026, ranked by the Movie Echo Score — a blend of critic reviews, audience ratings and lasting impact. I Can Only Imagine (2018) comes out on top with a score of 75. The biggest box office hit is I Can Only Imagine (2018) with $86.1M worldwide. Below: the best films by genre and by decade, the most awarded and the newest releases.
Top Rated Andrew Erwin Movies
The 5 highest-rated films Andrew Erwin is credited on. I Can Only Imagine (2018) leads with 75, followed by American Underdog (2021) at 68. The Movie Echo Score blends critic reviews, audience ratings, cultural impact and how well a film holds up.
-
#1 Movie Echo Score: Score 75 I Can Only Imagine 2018 · Drama -
#2 Movie Echo Score: Score 68 American Underdog 2021 · Biography -
#3 Movie Echo Score: Score 66 I Can Only Imagine 2 2026 · Drama -
#4 Movie Echo Score: Score 66 The Jesus Music 2021 · Documentary -
#5 Movie Echo Score: Score 55 I Still Believe 2020 · Biography
Biggest Andrew Erwin Box Office Hits
Andrew Erwin's films have made $179M worldwide in total. I Can Only Imagine (2018) is the biggest hit at $86.1M, ahead of American Underdog (2021) ($26.5M). Lifetime grosses, with each film's domestic share.
- 1 I Can Only Imagine 2018 · Drama $86.1M $83.5M dom.
- 2 American Underdog 2021 · Biography $26.5M $26.5M dom.
- 3 I Can Only Imagine 2 2026 · Drama $18.7M $18.6M dom.
- 4 I Still Believe 2020 · Biography $16.1M $9.87M dom.
- 5
Woodlawn 2015 · Drama $14.4M $14.4M dom. - 6
Moms' Night Out 2014 · Comedy $10.5M $10.4M dom. - 7
October Baby 2012 · Drama $5.4M $5.36M dom. - 8 The Jesus Music 2021 · Documentary $1.02M $1.02M dom.
The Best Andrew Erwin Movie in Every Genre
The best-rated film in each genre Andrew Erwin has worked in, the genres with the most films first. Drama leads with 4 films, and I Can Only Imagine (2018) is the pick of them.
The Latest Andrew Erwin Movies
The most recent films Andrew Erwin is credited on, newest first — starting with I Can Only Imagine 2 (2026). Open any of them for the cast, ratings, box office and where to watch.
The Best Andrew Erwin Movies: Questions & Answers
The best-rated, highest-grossing, most awarded and newest Andrew Erwin films, answered from the rankings on this page.
What is the best Andrew Erwin movie?
I Can Only Imagine (2018) is the best-rated Andrew Erwin film, with a Movie Echo Score of 75, ahead of American Underdog (2021) (68) and I Can Only Imagine 2 (2026) (66). The Movie Echo Score blends critic reviews, audience ratings and how well a film has lasted.
I Can Only Imagine: cast, ratings & box office What is the highest-grossing Andrew Erwin movie?
I Can Only Imagine (2018) made the most at the box office, with $86.1M worldwide, followed by American Underdog (2021) with $26.5M. Together, Andrew Erwin's films with box office figures have made $179M.
What is the best Andrew Erwin drama movie?
I Can Only Imagine (2018) is the best-rated of Andrew Erwin's drama films, with a score of 75. In other genres: American Underdog (biography), The Jesus Music (documentary) and Moms' Night Out (comedy).
What is the newest Andrew Erwin movie?
The newest film on Andrew Erwin's filmography is I Can Only Imagine 2 (2026), directed by Andrew Erwin.
More Movie Rankings & Collections
Best-of lists by year, decade and genre, all-time box office records and the films on the trending list.
Best-Rated Movie Rankings
Best-rated, biggest and most-awarded
New Movies & Top Genres
New releases, popular films and the best of every genre