Trial by Fire (2019): Cast, Ratings, Box Office & Where to Watch
Trial by Fire is a 2019 biographical drama directed by Edward Zwick, starring Jack O'Connell as Todd, Laura Dern and Emily Meade. It runs 2 hours 7 minutes and earned $148,504 worldwide. Critics gave it 63% on Rotten Tomatoes and 51 on Metacritic, and IMDb users rate it 7.1/10. Stream it on Fandango at Home Free and Howdy, or rent or buy it on Amazon Video and Apple TV Store.
- Released
- Runtime
- 2h 7m (127 min)
- Director
- Edward Zwick
- Original language
-
English
- Studio
- Roadside Attractions
- After the credits
- No No extra scene
What Is Trial by Fire About?
The premise of Trial by Fire without spoilers. The whole story and the ending explained are in the plot summary further down.
This is the gripping true story of Cameron Todd Willingham, a death row inmate, and Elizabeth Gilbert, a Houston mother who forms an unexpected bond with him. As they work against all odds to investigate the circumstances of his conviction for a triple homicide, they expose flaws within the Texas justice system. Their fight for the truth reveals the challenges of proving innocence and the potential for profound injustice.
Trial by Fire Themes & Keywords
· 23 tags- based on newspaper article
- male nudity
- male objectification
- brief male nudity
- pubic hair
- male pubic hair
- trial
- house burning
- lawyer
- fire
- court
- justice
+11 more Show fewer
- brief male frontal nudity
- reference to a zodiac sign
- reference to aries the constellation
- astrology
- reference to astrology
- whodunnit mystery
- true crime
- murder mystery
- whodunit
- based on true story
- based on magazine article
Where to Watch Trial by Fire
Stream it on Fandango at Home Free and Howdy, or rent or buy it from Amazon Video and Apple TV Store. US availability and prices from JustWatch.
Stream 6
Trial by Fire Cast & Characters
Jack O'Connell leads the cast as Todd, with Laura Dern as Elizabeth and Emily Meade as Stacy. Directed by Edward Zwick; 19 actors are credited in all.
-
Director Edward Zwick
-
Jack O'Connell as Todd -
Laura Dern as Elizabeth -
Emily Meade as Stacy -
Chris Coy as Daniels
Also Starring in Trial by Fire
· 15 more- Jeff Perry Hurst
- Jason Douglas Jackson
- Rhoda Griffis Darlene
- Wayne Pére George
- Joshua Mikel
- Jade Pettyjohn Julie
- Carlos Gómez Vasquez
- Blair Bomar Sandy
- Katie McClellan Margaret
- Darren Pettie Horton
- William Tokarsky
- Elle Graham
- Helen Abell
- Anniston Price
- Tinsley Price
Trial by Fire Reviews & Ratings
Critics gave Trial by Fire 63% on Rotten Tomatoes and 51 on Metacritic, and IMDb users rate it 7.1/10. Our Echo Score gives it 60/100, strongest in character & emotion (80) and weakest in rewatch factor (40).
Trial by Fire Echo Score Breakdown
Trial by Fire offers strong performances but is hindered by uneven pacing and limited sensory impact. The acting is widely praised for its conviction, particularly in the depiction of emotional stakes on death row. However, the narrative structure often dwells in exposition, which diminishes momentum and engagement. Visually, the film is competently assembled but rarely achieves moments of striking style. While the central dynamic resonates, the overall blend of strengths and weaknesses yields a moderately engaging but imperfect viewing experience.
Our own 0–100 rating, built from five aspects: art, character, story, the sensory experience and how well a film rewatches.
- Art & Craft 65
In terms of direction and visual construction, Trial by Fire is competently assembled with careful attention to production detail. Reviewers noted the film’s precise framing and deliberate editing choices, although occasional pacing lulls undermine its momentum. The technical elements cohere without significant faults, but they stop short of generating a truly distinctive style. Overall, the film’s craft feels solid but conservative.
- Character & Emotion 80
When it comes to character depth, Trial by Fire excels through committed performances and nuanced emotional interplay. Observers admired the leading portrayals for their authenticity and the subdued chemistry that conveys the prisoners’ psychology. The narrative allows for moments of genuine resonance as the characters confront their circumstances. These strong performances anchor the drama and leave a memorable emotional impact.
- Story & Flow 50
In terms of plot coherence and pacing, Trial by Fire exhibits an uneven narrative flow. The early sections rely heavily on expositional setups that delay the film’s central tension, and some narrative devices feel overtly didactic. While the story builds urgency near the conclusion, the prolonged preamble can undercut engagement. This mixed structural approach results in intermittent narrative momentum.
- Sensory Experience 60
When viewed for sensory impact, Trial by Fire presents a restrained audiovisual experience. The sound design and musical motifs support the film’s sober tone without drawing attention to themselves, and the visual palette remains subdued. Though the craftsmanship is competent, it rarely achieves moments of vivid or immersive style. The film’s sensory elements work reliably but lack pronounced flare.
- Rewatch Factor 40
As a viewing to revisit, Trial by Fire offers limited replay value. The strength of the performances may warrant a second look for those interested in the central dynamic, but the deliberate pacing and predominantly expository structure are unlikely to encourage frequent replays. The film’s modest stylistic choices and straightforward tone reduce its lasting appeal for repeat viewing.
-
IMDb 7.1 /10
See on IMDb -
Rotten Tomatoes 63% Tomatometer
Popcornmeter 75%
See on Rotten Tomatoes -
Metacritic 51 Metascore
User score 6.8
See on Metacritic -
TMDB 70% User score
See on TMDB -
Letterboxd 3.4 /5
17 ratings
See on Letterboxd -
Movie Insider 3.0 /5
See on Movie Insider
Trial by Fire Plot Summary & Ending Explained
What happens in Trial by Fire from start to finish, spoilers included, with a timeline of 13 key events and the ending explained. The opening is below; the full summary is a 3-minute read.
Spoilers ahead
On December 23, 1991, Cameron Todd Willingham wakes to a house ablaze and, despite his frantic efforts, cannot save his three daughters. The tragedy becomes a public case as the prosecution frames the fire as deliberate arson, pointing to gasoline spread in a pentagram shape and a refrigerator moved to block the kitchen door. At the trial, witnesses portray a violent man, and a former cellmate, Johnny Webb, testifies that Willingham claimed the fire had been set on purpose. Despite Willingham and his wife Stacy insisting on his innocence, he is sentenced to death.
Full summary
The whole story of Trial by Fire, scene by scene, with the ending explained
Trial by Fire Box Office
Trial by Fire grossed $148,504 worldwide.
Worldwide gross
$148.5K
- US & Canada
- $148.5K
Trial by Fire Trailers & Videos
The trailer of Trial by Fire.
How Well Do You Know Trial by Fire?
10 questions about the story, each with a hint if you get stuck. Pick an answer to see whether you were right.
Question 1 of 10
- Question 1: not answered
- Question 2: not answered
- Question 3: not answered
- Question 4: not answered
- Question 5: not answered
- Question 6: not answered
- Question 7: not answered
- Question 8: not answered
- Question 9: not answered
- Question 10: not answered
How many daughters did Cameron Todd Willingham lose in the 1991 house fire?
Cars in Trial by Fire
5 cars on screen, including the 1978 Chevrolet Camaro and the 1989 Toyota Cressida.
-
1978 Chevrolet Camaro Important role -
1989 Toyota Cressida Important role -
1986 Chevrolet Caprice Minor role -
1980 Datsun 510 Wagon Minor role
Trial by Fire Also Known As
26 alternative titles, including “Испытание огнём” and “Изпитание чрез огън”.
- Also known as
-
- Испытание огнём
- Изпитание чрез огън
- El caso Willingham
- Chrzest Ogniem
- 疑惑の炎
- L'épreuve du feu
- Zkouška ohněm
- Испытание огнем
- Огнено изпитание
- Justiça em Chamas
- 火的審判
- Feuerprobe: Die wichtigsten Beweise
+14 more Show fewer
- Willingham: Prueba de fuego
- La verità negata
- 凭火决狱
- משפט האש
- Ateşle imtihan
- Випробування вогнем
- Procesul infernal
- 烈火審判
- Tűzkeresztség
- 炎の裁き
- ट्रायल वाय फ़ायर
- Thử thách trong lửa dữ
- Skúška ohňom
- Sudegusi tiesa
Seen Trial by Fire?
Movies Like Trial by Fire
Films with a similar story, tone or audience, including Trial by Fire, Trial by Fire and The Life of David Gale.
Trial by Fire FAQ: Where to Watch, Cast & Box Office
Runtime, release date, director, cast, where to watch, box office, ratings and post-credit scenes of Trial by Fire, each answered in a sentence.
How long is Trial by Fire?
Trial by Fire runs 2 hours 7 minutes (127 minutes).
When was Trial by Fire released?
Trial by Fire was released on May 17, 2019.
Who directed Trial by Fire?
Trial by Fire was directed by Edward Zwick.
More films by Edward Zwick Who is in the cast of Trial by Fire?
Trial by Fire stars Jack O'Connell as Todd, Laura Dern as Elizabeth and Emily Meade as Stacy, among 19 credited actors.
Where can I watch Trial by Fire?
In the US, Trial by Fire is streaming on Fandango at Home Free, Howdy and Kanopy and available to rent or buy on Amazon Video, Apple TV Store and Fandango At Home (availability from JustWatch).
How much did Trial by Fire make at the box office?
Trial by Fire grossed $148,504 worldwide.
How is Trial by Fire rated?
Trial by Fire has 7.1/10 on IMDb, 63% on Rotten Tomatoes, 51 on Metacritic and 70% on TMDB.
Does Trial by Fire have a post-credit scene?
No. Trial by Fire has no extra scene during or after the credits.
Coming soon to your phone
The Plot Explained Movie Summary App
From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.
Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app
