Joshua Then and Now 1985

Joshua Shapiro, a successful writer and pundit, lies in a hospital room, seemingly separated from his wife and entangled in a sex scandal. He searches for meaning by tracing his life from youth to the present, hoping to piece together what went wrong and what his future might still hold.

He grew up as a Jew in the working‑class quarter of Montreal known as St. Urbain Street, where his childhood was anything but conventional. His father was a boxer who had turned to a gentle, even sly, form of crime, while his mother worked as a strip‑tease dancer. In a scene that mirrors the strange twists of his life, she even performs for his Bar Mitzvah party. This father figure is presented as someone who views life, sex, and religion through an idiosyncratic lens, leaving a lasting impression on Joshua’s outlook.

A journey to Spain during his youth becomes the spark that launches his path as a journalist and writer. Later, while in England, he engages in a momentary lapse of judgment, forging letters about a (fake) homosexual affair with a British writer to sell to an American university archive. The ruse reveals his willingness to bend truth for a strategic gain, a trait that shadows his later choices.

His path takes him into the circles of high society when he meets an upper‑class Canadian woman who is married to a poseur of a communist. He persuades her to become his wife, a move that propels him into a social world he once looked down on. She is described as the daughter of a Canadian senator, helping Joshua gain access to a level of society and influence that further complicates his sense of identity.

Meanwhile, Joshua’s childhood friends have carved out successful lives of their own, and some become targets of his pranks as he settles various scores. The dynamics of friendship, rivalry, and guilt weave through the narrative, adding layers of tension and consequence to his retrospective reckoning.

A pivotal strand involves his conceited brother‑in‑law, whose insecurity and vulnerability come into sharper focus as the story unfolds. The close-knit, wealthy cottage community around Lake Memphremagog becomes a pressure cooker, guiding Joshua toward decisions that pull him into treacherous territory. As past indiscretions come back to haunt him, he must confront a life that has spiraled into shambles, forcing a reckoning with who he has become and what he is willing to admit or change.

In the end, the film threads together themes of memory, ambition, deception, and the fragile line between achievement and moral cost, leaving Joshua to face the consequences of choices that shaped his ascent and haunted his retreat from a life he once imagined. The narrative maintains a steady, reflective tempo, inviting viewers to weigh the allure of power against the burden of truth, all while keeping a compassionate, human focus on a man who tries to understand the motives behind his own very public fall from grace.