Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Plot summary

What Happens Next (2011) Plot Summary & Timeline

What Happens Next (2011) movie poster

What Happens Next is a 2011 drama and romance film directed by Jay Arnold, running 1 hour 40 minutes. This page retells the whole story in 489 words (about 2 minutes to read) and covers 10 key events in order, 5 characters, where and when it is set and 2 themes. Looking for the cast, ratings and where to stream it? See the movie page for What Happens Next.

to read the plot summary
2 min
key events in the timeline
10
characters profiled
5
themes explained
2
Loading streaming availability…
What Happens Next (2011) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 40m
Director
Jay Arnold
Genres
Drama, Romance, Comedy
Original language
English
No spoilers

What Is What Happens Next About?

The premise of What Happens Next in 298 words, with nothing given away. The full story follows below.

In the sun‑lit suburbs of an affluent coastal town, a newly retired Paul Greco trades boardrooms for leisurely walks, his days suddenly punctuated by the soft jingle of a leash. His sister, the ever‑involved Elise, believes a dog will bring a measure of routine to his unstructured freedom, and the simple act of caring for another creature becomes the quiet catalyst for a shift in his carefully curated life. The film paints this transition with a light, breezy humor that hints at deeper questions beneath the polished surface.

Each morning at the local dog park, Paul encounters Andy Chance, a charismatic advertising professional whose confidence and openness contrast sharply with the billionaire’s more reserved demeanor. Their interactions blossom amid playful banter and awkward moments, framed by the rhythmic cadence of paw‑prints on gravel. The chemistry between a self‑made creative spirit and a seasoned philanthropist suggests a friendship—and perhaps something more—ripe with the possibility of self‑discovery, all delivered with a gently teasing tone that keeps the audience smiling.

Meanwhile, the familial web subtly weaves its own patterns. Elise wrestles with her own aspirations for her son, an artistic soul whose bohemian leanings clash with her expectations, while Andy’s adopted sister, Roz, an art‑gallery owner, watches the growing closeness with a mix of curiosity and protective concern. These peripheral relationships enrich the narrative, highlighting how love, loyalty, and expectation intersect across generations and social strata.

At its core, the story unfolds as a warm, witty meditation on the fluid nature of connection. The film’s atmosphere balances sophisticated charm with relatable, everyday moments, inviting viewers to consider how unexpected encounters can reshape identities and redefine what it means to truly belong. The tone remains optimistic and gently comedic, leaving the audience eager to see where the heart’s uncharted path might lead.

Full plot

What Happens in What Happens Next?

The complete story of What Happens Next, from the first scene to the last, in 489 words (about 2 minutes). Spoilers throughout. Names in the text link to 5 cast member pages.

Spoilers ahead

Paul Greco, a wealthy billionaire and socialite, appears to have everything he could ever desire—ample wealth, a successful career, and a life of comfort. However, after selling his lucrative business and moving into a period of retirement, Paul finds himself facing unexpected changes and new experiences that challenge his perceptions of his own life. His overbearing yet well-meaning sister, Elise, decides that the best way to introduce some structure into his life is by giving him a dog. This simple gesture sets off a chain of events that gradually alters Paul’s routine and personal outlook.

In the process of taking on the daily task of walking his new dog in the park, Paul encounters Andy Chance, a charismatic and self-employed advertising professional who is openly gay. Andy, played by Chris Murrah, also walks his dog at the same time every day, which makes these encounters unavoidable. What begins as innocent casual meetings between the two men slowly blossom into something more complicated and intriguing, blurring the lines between friendship, attraction, and the potential for something deeper.

Their interactions are characterized by a series of humorous and sometimes awkward situations, stemming from their contrasting personalities, backgrounds, and lifestyles. Paul, coming from an elite, philanthropic world filled with high society and elegant gatherings, faces unexpected feelings and uncertainties about his desires and identity. Meanwhile, Andy’s life as a self-made, confident man adds a different perspective, which creates a fascinating dynamic filled with both tension and connection.

The story becomes even more complex with the involvement of the women in their lives. Elise notices subtle changes in Paul’s behavior and personality but is preoccupied with her own struggles, especially concerning her artist son, Brian, played by Ariel Shafir, who is deeply involved in a bohemian lifestyle that clashes with her values. On the other hand, Andy’s adopted sister, Roz, a successful art gallery owner, begins to feel uncomfortable with Andy’s growing fascination with Paul—especially considering Paul’s straight identity and his position within the social elite.

Throughout the narrative, viewers are taken on a journey of discovery, misadventure, and revelation. The plot is rich with twists and turns, leading to moments of clarity and reconciliation that help both Paul and Andy understand themselves and each other better. The story tackles poignant themes such as the redefining of family, the true meaning of love, and the importance of accepting oneself. It emphasizes that relationships are fluid, shaped by attitude and human experience, and often fraught with humor and surprise.

The film explores the idea that love and connection can come from unexpected places and challenge societal expectations. As one character famously says, > “Sometimes, you just have to follow your heart, no matter where it leads.” Ultimately, What Happens Next presents a heartfelt, funny, and insightful look at how human relationships evolve and how understanding and acceptance can transcend conventional boundaries, making it a story about the ongoing adventure of discovering what truly defines us.

Timeline

What Happens Next Timeline: Every Key Event in Order

10 key events in the order they happen, from “Paul Greco's Retirement and Wealth” to “Resolution and New Beginnings”.

  1. 1

    Paul Greco's Retirement and Wealth

    Paul Greco, a wealthy billionaire and socialite, sells his lucrative business, marking the start of his retirement. He finds himself with more free time and money than he knows what to do with, leading to a change in his daily routine.

  2. 2

    Sister Elise Introduces a Dog

    Paul's overbearing sister, Elise, decides to introduce a dog into Paul's life, believing it will give him a new purpose. She hopes that caring for the dog will help Paul adjust to his retirement and start engaging more actively.

  3. 3

    Dog Walking in the Park

    Paul begins his daily routine of walking the dog in the park. He starts to enjoy the peaceful moments outside, which gradually leads to more social encounters and new interactions.

    Where:Park

  4. 4

    Meeting Andy Chance

    In the park, Paul encounters Andy Chance, a gay self-employed advertising professional, who also walks his dog on the same schedule. Their casual meetings hint at a developing friendship that goes beyond initial pleasantries.

    Where:Park

  5. 5

    Developing Relationship

    Over time, the interactions between Paul and Andy evolve into something more complicated and intimate, creating comedic and emotional moments as they navigate their differences.

  6. 6

    Concerns from Elise and Roz

    Elise notices changes in Paul's behavior and becomes curious about his personal life, while Andy's adopted sister Roz, a high-powered art gallery owner, becomes uncomfortable with Andy's fascination with Paul, highlighting tension between their worlds.

  7. 7

    Family Strains and Personal Conflicts

    Strains grow within their families—Elise is preoccupied with her son Brian's artistic lifestyle and their estranged relationship, adding pressure to Paul's personal journey.

  8. 8

    Revelation and Discovery

    Through a series of twists and revelations, the characters come to understand more about themselves, their relationships, and their true feelings, leading to moments of clarity and reconciliation.

  9. 9

    Themes of Love and Family

    The story explores the redefining of family, the nature of love, and human connection. The narrative emphasizes acceptance, self-discovery, and the surprises life can bring.

  10. 10

    Resolution and New Beginnings

    In the end, the characters achieve a sense of resolution, understanding their relationships more deeply and embracing new possibilities, culminating in hopeful new beginnings.

Characters

Who Are the Main Characters in What Happens Next?

5 characters, among them Paul Greco (Jon Lindstrom), Andy Chance (Chris Murrah) and Elise (Wendie Malick): who each one is and the part they play in the story. Every profile links to the actor’s page.

  • PG

    Paul Greco (Jon Lindstrom)

    Played by Jon Lindstrom

    A wealthy, retired socialite grappling with the shifts in his personal identity and relationships. His interactions with Andy spark a journey of self-discovery, as he navigates societal perceptions and his own desires. Paul embodies the theme of redefining traditional roles and expectations.

    • 💼 Wealthy
    • 🧠 Reflective
    • 🌹 Open-minded
  • AC

    Andy Chance (Chris Murrah)

    Played by Chris Murrah

    An independent, self-employed advertising professional who is comfortable with his sexuality and personality. He challenges societal norms with his open attitude and genuine nature. Andy's character highlights authenticity and the pursuit of happiness.

    • 🎨 Creative
    • 🏳️‍🌈 LGBTQ+
    • 🗣️ Confident
  • Wendie Malick as Elise (Wendie Malick) in What Happens Next

    Elise (Wendie Malick)

    Played by Wendie Malick

    Paul’s overbearing sister who is concerned about her brother's changing behaviors. Her protective instinct is rooted in her own life experiences and her relationship with her son. Elise represents familial concern and societal expectations.

    • 🙋‍♀️ Sister
    • 🧭 Overprotective
    • 🎭 Dramatic
  • R(

    Roz (Natalia Cigliuti)

    Played by Natalia Cigliuti

    Andy’s adopted sister and a successful art gallery owner. She becomes uneasy about Andy’s growing interest in Paul, reflecting the tensions between personal desires and social perceptions. Roz embodies ambition and the complexities of familial loyalty.

    • 🎨 Art Lover
    • 💼 Professional
    • 😟 Tense
  • B(

    Brian (Ariel Shafir)

    Played by Ariel Shafir

    Elise’s son, an artist involved in alternative lifestyles, representing a contrast to his mother's conservative views. His character explores themes of artistic freedom and generational differences.

    • 🎭 Artist
    • 🧬 Alternative Lifestyle
    • 💡 Creative
Setting

Where and When Is What Happens Next Set?

What Happens Next is set in City Park and Socialite circles (Contemporary era). Here is why the time and place matter to the story.

When

Contemporary era

The movie is set in the present day, capturing current social dynamics and lifestyle topics. It portrays contemporary attitudes towards sexuality, family, and societal expectations, emphasizing modern values and cultural shifts relevant to today's society.

Where

City Park, Socialite circles

The story primarily takes place in a city park where Paul and Andy meet regularly, serving as a neutral ground for their developing relationship. The park reflects a communal space for leisure, social interaction, and personal reflection. Additionally, scenes involving high-society events and art galleries highlight the upscale social environment surrounding the characters.

  • 🌳 Park
  • 💃 Socialite
  • 🎨 Art Scene
Themes

What Are the Themes of What Happens Next?

2 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Love & Identity and Family & Relationships.

  1. 01

    Love & Identity

    The film explores the fluidity of love and the importance of authentic self-expression. It delves into various forms of relationships beyond traditional norms, emphasizing acceptance and understanding. The characters' journeys highlight personal discovery and redefining familial bonds.

  2. 02

    Family & Relationships

    The story examines the complexity of familial ties, including estranged relationships and chosen families. It emphasizes communication, acceptance, and the nuanced ways love manifests within and outside biological connections. The characters face challenges in reconciling their personal identities with societal expectations.

Tone & mood

What Kind of Film Is What Happens Next?

Light in tone, with steady pacing and a straightforward story, going by the plot summary.

Tone
Light
Pacing
Steady
Story
Straightforward
Intensity
Low
Ending
Happy

A heartfelt and humorous story that explores an unexpected friendship and personal growth with a gentle, uplifting pace focused on connection and acceptance.

  • heartfelt
  • humorous
  • uplifting
  • reflective
  • comforting
  • hopeful
  • friendship
  • self-discovery
  • family dynamics
  • social expectations

Quiz

How well do you remember What Happens Next? Test yourself on the story.

Take the quiz
Loading streaming availability…

Missing a Movie Plot Summary?

Tell us which film you want explained next: the full story, the timeline, the characters and the ending.

Request a summary
FAQ

What Happens Next Plot Questions

5 quick answers about What Happens Next, taken from the plot summary, character guide and setting on this page and the film’s credits.

What is What Happens Next about?

In the sun‑lit suburbs of an affluent coastal town, a newly retired Paul Greco trades boardrooms for leisurely walks, his days suddenly punctuated by the soft jingle of a leash.

Read the full plot summary

When and where does What Happens Next take place?

What Happens Next is set in City Park and Socialite circles (Contemporary era). The movie is set in the present day, capturing current social dynamics and lifestyle topics. It portrays contemporary attitudes towards sexuality, family, and societal expectations, emphasizing modern values and…

The setting explained

Who are the main characters in What Happens Next?

The story follows Paul Greco (Jon Lindstrom) (played by Jon Lindstrom), Andy Chance (Chris Murrah) (played by Chris Murrah), Elise (Wendie Malick) (played by Wendie Malick) and Roz (Natalia Cigliuti) (played by Natalia Cigliuti); the character guide covers 5 characters in all.

All the characters

What are the main themes of What Happens Next?

The summary picks out 2 themes: Love & Identity and Family & Relationships.

The themes explained

Who directed What Happens Next?

What Happens Next (2011) was directed by Jay Arnold and runs 1 hour 40 minutes.

Jay Arnold’s films

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app