Skip to content
What's After the Movie?
Plot summary

The Wrong Missy (2020) Plot Summary & Timeline

The Wrong Missy (2020) movie poster

The Wrong Missy is a 2020 comedy and romance film directed by Tyler Spindel, running 1 hour 30 minutes. This page retells the whole story in 445 words (about 2 minutes to read) and covers 13 key events in order, 4 characters, where and when it is set and 3 themes. Looking for the cast, ratings and where to stream it? See the movie page for The Wrong Missy.

to read the plot summary
2 min
key events in the timeline
13
characters profiled
4
themes explained
3
Loading streaming availability…
The Wrong Missy (2020) movie poster
Released
Runtime
1h 30m
Director
Tyler Spindel
Genres
Comedy, Romance
Original language
English
Studio
Netflix
No spoilers

What Is The Wrong Missy About?

The premise of The Wrong Missy in 263 words, with nothing given away. The full story follows below.

In the glossy world of a high‑stakes corporate merger, Tim has meticulously plotted a weekend‑long surprise on a sun‑drenched island, intending it to be the perfect setting for the biggest question of his life. The retreat promises sleek conference rooms, immaculate beaches, and a break from the endless spreadsheets that have come to define his days. Yet beneath the polished veneer of the tropical getaway, a subtle current of absurdity already hums, hinting that nothing here will stay tidy for long.

Enter Missy, a wildly unpredictable childhood acquaintance whose reputation for chaos precedes her. She is a force of unfiltered energy, a walking punchline who refuses to conform to the polished expectations of a corporate vacation. When Tim mistakenly invites her instead of the poised, career‑focused Melissa he’s been courting, the stage is set for a collision of worlds: meticulous ambition meets unbridled spontaneity, and the island’s serene backdrop becomes a playground for comedic pandemonium. Their dynamic is a constant push‑and‑pull, with Tim trying to keep a veneer of control while Missy effortlessly dismantles it, one outrageous moment at a time.

The film bubbles with a bright, raunchy humor that thrives on the tension between professional decorum and reckless fun. The tropical setting amplifies the sense of escapism, turning boardrooms into beaches and deadlines into daring mishaps. As Tim navigates the precarious line between salvaging his reputation and succumbing to the sheer unpredictability of Missy’s presence, the audience is left anticipating just how far the mayhem will spiral, all while rooting for the unlikely pair to find a rhythm in the delightful disorder.

Full plot

What Happens in The Wrong Missy?

The complete story of The Wrong Missy, from the first scene to the last, in 445 words (about 2 minutes). Spoilers throughout. Names in the text link to 7 cast member pages.

Spoilers ahead

Tim, played by David Spade, finds himself in a truly chaotic situation when he goes on a blind date with a woman named Melissa, humorously referred to as Missy, portrayed by Lauren Lapkus. From the very beginning, their date takes a nosedive when Missy, in a wild attempt to break the ice, causes a scene at the bar by confronting a man hitting on another pregnant woman. This outlandish behavior leads Tim to make a dramatic escape through a window, which results in him dislocating his ankle.

Fast forward three months, Tim’s workplace, Credit Of America, is undergoing a major merger, stirring up a host of complications in his life. At this critical moment, he encounters another Melissa, played by Molly Sims, at the airport. This new connection appears perfect, as they share similar interests and lifestyles, including a mutual aversion to drinking. Tim is ecstatic when she gives him her number, but his excitement is cut short when Missy unexpectedly re-enters his life on a flight to Hawaii.

“I was about to jump off a bridge when I got your text!” Missy humorously states, easing any immediate concern Tim may have thought he had regarding her well-being.

Missy’s antics escalate as she forcibly tranquilizes Tim on the flight and then exhibits bizarre behavior, such as gatecrashing a shark tank dive led by Rob Schneider, who portrays Komante, a somewhat eccentric guide. The lunacy doesn’t stop there; throughout the company retreat, Tim’s attempts to maintain professionalism are continually sabotaged by Missy’s unpredictable and oftentimes reckless behavior, including mistakenly trying to jump off a cliff and an incident involving a sea turtle.

While Tim grapples with the chaos Missy brings into his life at work, he also has to manage the fact that his ex-fiancée, Sarah Chalke, is now dating his colleague Rich, played by Chris Witaske. As Missy and Tim’s outrageous escapades unfold, including a wild talent show where underwhelming performances surprisingly garner managerial praise, Tim starts to see a different side of Missy that he can’t help but appreciate.

Unfortunately, jealousy rears its head when Tim’s competitor, Jess, played by Jackie Sandler, reveals the truth about which Melissa Tim was trying to date all along. This revelation leads Missy to feel betrayed and hurt, prompting her to leave Hawaii, while Tim’s crush on her deepens.

In a heartfelt climax, the actual Melissa arrives, while Tim experiences a moment of self-realization, deciding to distance himself from the life he was leading. After quitting his job and mending his relationship with Missy through a sincere apology, he finally expresses the admiration he has developed for her, leading to a sweet kiss that signifies their evolving relationship.

Timeline

The Wrong Missy Timeline: Every Key Event in Order

13 key events in the order they happen, from “Blind Date Gone Awry” to “A Sweet Kiss”. 13 events name a place, across 6 locations.

  1. 1

    Blind Date Gone Awry

    Tim goes on a blind date with a woman named Melissa, affectionately called Missy. The date spirals out of control when Missy confronts a man who is bothering a pregnant woman, causing a scene and forcing Tim to escape through a window, ultimately dislocating his ankle.

    When:Night Where:Bar

  2. 2

    Three Months Later: Merger Chaos

    After three months, Tim is faced with turmoil at his workplace due to a major merger happening at Credit Of America. This stressful situation adds to his personal life complications, setting the stage for new encounters.

    When:Day Where:Credit Of America

  3. 3

    Perfect Connection at the Airport

    While at the airport, Tim meets another woman named Melissa, who seems to be his ideal match. Their shared interests and lifestyle make Tim excited about the potential of a new relationship, especially when she gives him her number.

    When:Day Where:Airport

  4. 4

    Missy Returns

    Just as Tim is enjoying his new connection with Melissa, Missy unexpectedly appears on the same flight to Hawaii. Her comical statement about almost jumping off a bridge lightens the mood but sets the stage for more chaos.

    When:Day Where:Flight

  5. 5

    Tranquilized on the Flight

    Things take an absurd turn when Missy tranquilizes Tim during the flight. This bizarre behavior foreshadows the chaotic adventures that await them once they land in Hawaii.

    When:Day Where:Flight

  6. 6

    Shark Tank Madness

    After landing in Hawaii, Missy gatecrashes a shark tank dive led by Komante, an eccentric guide played by Rob Schneider. Her unpredictable antics continue to disrupt the retreat and embarrass Tim.

    When:Day Where:Shark Tank

  7. 7

    Company Retreat Sabotage

    During the company retreat, Tim's attempts to act professionally are continuously thwarted by Missy’s reckless behavior. Whether it’s trying to jump off a cliff or causing chaos around a sea turtle, Tim's patience is tested.

    When:Day Where:Beach Resort

  8. 8

    Facing Jealousy

    Tim struggles with jealousy as he learns that his ex-fiancée is now dating his colleague, Rich. This complication adds emotional depth to his chaotic relationship with Missy as they navigate their affection for one another.

    When:Day Where:Beach Resort

  9. 9

    Unexpected Revelations

    Tim’s competitor Jess exposes his intentions concerning the two Melissas. This revelation deeply hurts Missy, who feels betrayed, leading her to distance herself from Tim as he contemplates his feelings.

    When:Day Where:Beach Resort

  10. 10

    Melissa's Arrival

    The actual Melissa arrives in Hawaii, complicating everything for Tim. Amidst the confusion, Tim starts realizing that his feelings for Missy might just be stronger than he initially thought.

    When:Day Where:Beach Resort

Show the other 3 events of The Wrong Missy
  1. 11

    Tim's Self-Realization

    In a moment of clarity, Tim decides to leave his old life behind. He recognizes the value of what Missy has brought into his life and resolves to make amends.

    When:Day Where:Beach Resort

  2. 12

    The Apology

    Tim apologizes sincerely to Missy for the chaos and confusion that has transpired. This heartfelt moment allows them to reconnect and express their true feelings.

    When:Day Where:Beach Resort

  3. 13

    A Sweet Kiss

    The timeline culminates with Tim and Missy sharing a sweet kiss, symbolizing their evolving relationship. This moment marks the transition from chaos to a more loving and understanding connection.

    When:Day Where:Beach Resort

Characters

Who Are the Main Characters in The Wrong Missy?

4 characters, among them Tim Morris (David Spade), Missy (Lauren Lapkus) and Melissa (Molly Sims): who each one is and the part they play in the story. Every profile links to the actor’s page.

  • David Spade as Tim Morris (David Spade) in The Wrong Missy

    Tim Morris (David Spade)

    Played by David Spade

    Tim is a man caught in a whirlwind of romantic chaos, initially seeking a perfect relationship. He embodies a mix of ambition and vulnerability, struggling with the unpredictable nature of Missy's personality while also dealing with workplace pressures. As the story evolves, Tim's character undergoes significant growth as he learns to embrace love and spontaneity.

    • 👨‍💼 Office Worker
    • 💔 Heartbroken
    • 😂 Comedic
  • Lauren Lapkus as Missy (Lauren Lapkus) in The Wrong Missy

    Missy (Lauren Lapkus)

    Played by Lauren Lapkus

    Missy is the unpredictable and wild romantic interest who brings chaos into Tim's life. Her outrageous actions, from confronting strangers to unexpected antics at the company retreat, showcase her eccentric personality. Beneath the hilarity, Missy reveals a deeper side, prompting both Tim and the audience to appreciate her uniqueness.

    • 👩‍🎤 Eccentric
    • 😂 Hilarious
    • ❤️ Unconventional
  • Molly Sims as Melissa (Molly Sims) in The Wrong Missy

    Melissa (Molly Sims)

    Played by Molly Sims

    Melissa is introduced as Tim's initial ideal partner, perfectly aligning with his lifestyle. However, her role highlights the theme of how surface-level connections often fall short. She serves as a contrast to Missy, prompting Tim to reconsider what he truly desires in a relationship.

    • 💁‍♀️ Ideal Partner
    • 💼 Professional
    • 🥂 Classy
  • Jackie Sandler as Jess (Jackie Sandler) in The Wrong Missy

    Jess (Jackie Sandler)

    Played by Jackie Sandler

    Jess is portrayed as Tim's competitor and ex-fiancée, adding layers of tension and jealousy to the narrative. Her presence serves as a catalyst for Tim's self-reflection and ultimately helps him realize what he values most. Jess embodies the complexity of past relationships that can influence new romances.

    • 💔 Ex-fiancée
    • 🏢 Colleague
    • 😒 Competitive
Setting

Where and When Is The Wrong Missy Set?

The Wrong Missy is set in Hawaii, Airport and Credit Of America. Here is why the place matters to the story.

When

The events unfold in contemporary times, reflecting modern social dynamics and work culture. It explores the challenges of navigating personal relationships during significant life changes, such as workplace mergers. The characters are relatable, facing issues like jealousy, self-discovery, and the comedic chaos of romantic entanglements.

Where

Hawaii, Airport, Credit Of America

The movie takes place in various vibrant locations, starting with the chaos of an airport where Tim meets two Melissas. The beautiful backdrop of Hawaii serves as the primary setting for a company retreat, filled with amusing mishaps, including shark tank dives. Additionally, the high-stakes environment of Credit Of America adds a layer of tension as Tim navigates his professional life while dealing with personal drama.

  • 🏝️ Hawaii
  • ✈️ Airport
  • 💼 Office
Themes

What Are the Themes of The Wrong Missy?

3 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Love, Comedy and Jealousy.

  1. 01

    Love

    The evolving relationship between Tim and Missy centers around the theme of love and acceptance. Despite the initial chaos and misunderstandings, Tim finds himself attracted to Missy's unique personality. The movie emphasizes how love can develop in unexpected circumstances and the importance of recognizing true feelings.

  2. 02

    Comedy

    The film is rich with comedic elements driven by Missy's outrageous behavior and Tim's reactions to her antics. From wild scenes at the airport to bizarre escapades in Hawaii, the humor unfolds in a chaotic yet entertaining manner. It highlights how laughter can emerge from uncomfortable situations.

  3. 03

    Jealousy

    Jealousy plays a significant role in the plot, particularly as Tim grapples with his feelings for Missy and the reappearance of his ex-fiancée, Julia, who is now dating his colleague. This emotional turmoil fuels the narrative, leading to moments of introspection and growth for Tim.

Tone & mood

What Kind of Film Is The Wrong Missy?

Light in tone, with fast pacing and a straightforward story, going by the plot summary.

Tone
Light
Pacing
Fast
Story
Straightforward
Intensity
Medium
Ending
Happy

A fast-paced and chaotic romantic comedy that delivers constant cringe humor and slapstick antics as a man's professional life unravels due to a disastrous case of mistaken identity.

  • chaotic
  • hilarious
  • embarrassing
  • awkward
  • cringe comedy
  • slapstick
  • mistaken identity
  • romantic comedy
  • workplace embarrassment
  • personal growth

Content notes: embarrassing situation.

Quiz

How well do you remember The Wrong Missy? Test yourself on the story.

Take the quiz
Loading streaming availability…
Read next

Movies Like The Wrong Missy With a Plot Summary

6 films close to The Wrong Missy in story and themes that have a full plot summary here: Mr. Wrong (1996) and Mischief (1985) lead.

All plot summaries

Missing a Movie Plot Summary?

Tell us which film you want explained next: the full story, the timeline, the characters and the ending.

Request a summary
FAQ

The Wrong Missy Plot Questions

5 quick answers about The Wrong Missy, taken from the plot summary, character guide and setting on this page and the film’s credits.

What is The Wrong Missy about?

In the glossy world of a high‑stakes corporate merger, Tim has meticulously plotted a weekend‑long surprise on a sun‑drenched island, intending it to be the perfect setting for the biggest question of his life.

Read the full plot summary

When and where does The Wrong Missy take place?

The Wrong Missy is set in Hawaii, Airport and Credit Of America. The events unfold in contemporary times, reflecting modern social dynamics and work culture. It explores the challenges of navigating personal relationships during significant life changes, such as workplace mergers.

The setting explained

Who are the main characters in The Wrong Missy?

The story follows Tim Morris (David Spade) (played by David Spade), Missy (Lauren Lapkus) (played by Lauren Lapkus), Melissa (Molly Sims) (played by Molly Sims) and Jess (Jackie Sandler) (played by Jackie Sandler).

All the characters

What are the main themes of The Wrong Missy?

The summary picks out 3 themes: Love, Comedy and Jealousy.

The themes explained

Who directed The Wrong Missy?

The Wrong Missy (2020) was directed by Tyler Spindel and runs 1 hour 30 minutes.

Tyler Spindel’s films

Coming soon to your phone

The Plot Explained Movie Summary App

From blockbusters to hidden gems: plot summaries, endings explained and timelines on your phone. Save your favorites and never miss a twist again.

Be the first to know when it launches. Your email stays private, always. Learn more about the app