The Next Best Thing

The Next Best Thing 2000

Test your knowledge of The Next Best Thing with our quiz!

Plot Summary

Read the complete plot summary and ending explained for The Next Best Thing (2000). From turning points to emotional moments, uncover what really happened and why it matters.


The film features Madonna in the role of Abbie Reynolds, a dedicated yoga instructor residing in the bustling city of New York. Alongside her is Rupert Everett, portraying Robert, her loyal gay best friend. The narrative takes a surprising turn when Abbie unexpectedly finds out she is pregnant, and she chooses to raise the child in partnership with Robert. Their profound friendship forms the foundation of this unique situation.

As Abbie’s relationship with Ben begins to blossom, Robert confronts a whirlwind of emotions including loneliness, jealousy, and confusion. His long-standing affinity for Abbie complicates their friendship, causing his feelings to teeter on the brink of romantic love. The shift in their dynamic creates a rift as Robert grapples with the fear that he is slowly losing his place in Abbie’s life, now that she is stepping into a traditional romantic role with Ben. The bond that they once cherished feels threatened, leaving Robert in a state of upheaval.

The emotional strain manifests in several conflicts, as Robert wrestles with his complicated feelings for Abbie combined with his own self-identity. He is left questioning whether he is merely a “second choice” in her life and if his love for her will ever be fully recognized or reciprocated. Meanwhile, Abbie faces her own struggles, torn between her new responsibilities as a mother and her longing for a conventional family life with Ben. She strives to maintain the cherished connection with Robert, a friendship that has always been a source of stability, while navigating the evolving dynamics that come with her new reality.

Amidst these complexities, the heart of the film remains focused on the enduring bond of friendship and the challenges it faces when confronted with love, family, and personal desires. Abbie and Robert’s journey serves as a poignant exploration of the intricate balance between companionship and romantic love.

Timeline

Follow the complete movie timeline of The Next Best Thing (2000) with every major event in chronological order. Great for understanding complex plots and story progression.


Abbie's Yoga Class

The film introduces Abbie Reynolds, a yoga instructor based in the bustling city of New York. She is passionate about her work and enjoys a fulfilling life as a single woman. Her world revolves around her career, yoga classes, and her close friendship with Robert.

New York City

Unexpected Pregnancy

Abbie’s life takes an unexpected turn when she discovers that she is pregnant. This news shocks her, as it changes her dynamics with those around her, especially with Robert, her best friend. The pregnancy presents new challenges that she must face.

New York City

Decision to Raise the Child with Robert

After careful consideration, Abbie decides that she will raise the child alongside Robert. Their deep bond of friendship gives her the confidence that he will support her through this new journey. Together, they contemplate how they will navigate the challenges of parenthood.

New York City

Abbie's New Relationship with Ben

As Abbie prepares for motherhood, she begins a romantic relationship with Ben. This new relationship adds complexity to her life, as she seeks balance between her feelings for Ben and her longstanding friendship with Robert. The emotional stakes get higher as her relationships evolve.

New York City

Robert's Feelings of Loneliness

With Abbie becoming more entwined in her relationship with Ben, Robert starts to feel isolated. His once close connection with Abbie begins to shift, leaving him grappling with feelings of jealousy and loneliness. He questions his place in Abbie's life as she embraces her new family.

New York City

Conflict of Affection

Robert's emotional turmoil grows as he wrestles with his feelings for Abbie. Conflicted between friendship and love, he feels sidelined as Abbie's bond with Ben deepens. This conflict forces him to confront his own desires and his fears of being a 'second choice'.

New York City

Abbie's Struggles as a New Mother

As she embraces motherhood, Abbie finds herself juggling her responsibilities while maintaining her connection with Robert. She faces the challenge of creating a traditional family unit with Ben while trying to keep her friendship with Robert intact. Abbie wrestles with her dual role as a mother and a friend.

New York City

Robert Questions His Role

Engulfed in confusion, Robert starts doubting if his love for Abbie will ever be reciprocated in the way he hopes. His inner dialogue reveals his struggle with self-identity and the societal expectations tied to his feelings. He searches for answers about where he fits into Abbie's new family dynamic.

New York City

Abbie's Dilemma

Abbie finds herself in a constant emotional tug-of-war between her responsibilities to her child and her desire for a conventional relationship with Ben. She values her longstanding bond with Robert, but her emerging family dynamics complicate her feelings. The pressure to conform to what she believes is an ideal family weighs heavily on her.

New York City

Confrontation of Feelings

The tensions between Abbie and Robert reach a boiling point as they confront their feelings for one another. This pivotal moment forces both characters to articulate their desires and needs. It becomes clear that their friendship may be irreversibly changed as they navigate these deep emotional waters.

New York City

Resolution of Emotions

By the conclusion of the film, Abbie and Robert come to terms with their emotions and the complexities of their relationship. They realize that their bond has evolved and that they must define their relationship in the context of Abbie's new life. Acceptance and understanding become the new foundation of their friendship.

New York City

Characters

Explore all characters from The Next Best Thing (2000). Get detailed profiles with their roles, arcs, and key relationships explained.


Abbie Reynolds (Madonna)

Abbie Reynolds is a yoga instructor who finds herself unexpectedly pregnant, igniting a journey of self-discovery and emotional conflict. She is portrayed as both nurturing and independent, eager to embrace motherhood while facing the complexities of her romantic life. Abbie’s character embodies the struggle between personal aspirations and the responsibilities that come with raising a child.

🧘‍♀️ Yoga 👩‍👧 Motherhood 💖 Friendship

Robert (Rupert Everett)

Robert is Abbie’s gay best friend, whose deep affection for her complicates their friendship when Abbie's life takes a romantic turn with Ben. He embodies feelings of jealousy and loneliness, struggling with his identity and unreciprocated love. His character's emotional complexity adds depth to the film, highlighting the challenges of navigating friendship and personal feelings.

💔 Unrequited Love 🤷‍♂️ Identity 😔 Loneliness

Setting

Learn where and when The Next Best Thing (2000) takes place. Explore the film’s settings, era, and how they shape the narrative.


Time period

The movie doesn't specify a historical time period but takes place in contemporary settings that reflect modern societal norms. It captures the essence of current relationships and challenges individuals face in their interconnected lives. The film's themes resonate with contemporary issues of love, friendship, and family dynamics.

Location

New York City

New York City, often referred to as NYC, is a bustling metropolis known for its vibrant culture and diverse population. It's a center for art, fashion, and business, where people from all walks of life come together. The city's dynamic lifestyle provides a rich backdrop for personal stories and complex relationships.

🌆 City 🧘‍♀️ Yoga ❤️ Friendship

Themes

Discover the main themes in The Next Best Thing (2000). Analyze the deeper meanings, emotional layers, and social commentary behind the film.


💔

Unrequited Love

The theme of unrequited love permeates the narrative, particularly through Robert's character as he navigates his feelings for Abbie. His emotional struggle highlights the pain of longing and the complexities of friendship when love is involved. This theme resonates deeply as it showcases the often-unspoken conflicts between affection and platonic relationships.

👶

Parenthood

The challenge of parenthood significantly shapes Abbie's and Robert's relationship. Abbie's unexpected pregnancy thrusts both characters into a new family dynamic, forcing them to reassess their roles. The complexities of raising a child as friends and the balancing act between parenting and personal desires are central to the story.

🤔

Identity

Themes of identity are explored as Robert grapples with his feelings for Abbie while questioning his place in her life. His journey reflects the struggles many face when defining their self-worth and identity in relation to their friendships and romantic interests. This theme enriches the emotional depth of the film.

Movies with Similar Twists and Themes

Uncover films that echo the narrative beats, emotional arcs, or dramatic twists of the one you're exploring. These recommendations are handpicked based on story depth, thematic resonance, and spoiler-worthy moments — perfect for fans who crave more of the same intrigue.


© 2025 What's After the Movie. All rights reserved.