Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! 2012
Directed by
Debbie Isitt
Made by
Mirrorball Films
Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! Plot Summary
Read the complete plot summary and ending explained for Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! (2012). From turning points to emotional moments, uncover what really happened and why it matters.
Donald Peterson is an anxious teacher who has just moved to a new house with his pregnant wife Sarah Peterson. He accepts a teaching job at St. Bernadette’s primary school, taking over the class formerly taught by Mr. Maddens, who has left for the United States; in the interim, the enthusiastic and childlike teaching assistant Mr. Poppy has been guiding the class on his own. The children dream of entering the competition called A Song for Christmas, a national contest where each school produces a Christmas song, with the winner earning £10,000 and a shot at becoming a Christmas number 1. Yet headteacher Mrs. Bevan refuses to authorize the entry without a qualified teacher and worries that her nephew, Mr. Poppy, may not be able to keep a steady hand on the reins.
Behind Donald’s quiet demeanor lies a weighty family dynamic. He lives in the shadow of his domineering father and his twin brother, world-famous composer and conductor Roderick Peterson, who is a prominent figure in the music world. When the decision to enter the competition is discussed, Mr. Poppy persuades Donald to sign the entry forms, and then, in a bold turn, abducts him for an impromptu road trip toward Castell Llawen, a fictional Wales locale home to the Christmas Castle where the show will take place.
Meanwhile, the rivalries and ambitions broaden. Roderick is competing on the other side, mentoring the choir of the prestigious St Cuthbert’s College, and a separate rivaling class under Mr. Shakespeare Mr. Shakespeare from Oakmoor School has its own entry. Donald and Mr. Poppy lead their class through the wild terrain of Wales, pushing through fatigue, rushing rivers, and even handling a baby smuggled into the group in the form of a tiny passenger, all while scaling a mountain to reach the castle in time for the performance.
When at last they reach the venue, a series of reconciliations and revelations unfold. Donald is reunited with Sarah Peterson, and Mr. Poppy is reunited with Mrs. Bevan. Yet the competition’s drama intensifies as Roderick, determined to claim victory, steals the baby and a portion of Mr. Shakespeare’s song, and in a bid to ruin the chance for Donald’s group, traps Mr. Poppy and the class inside a giant snow globe and disqualifies them. The resilience of teamwork, however, shines through as Mr. Shakespeare’s class and others step in to help, while Mrs. Bevan retrieves the baby and St. Bernadette’s delivers two heartfelt songs, even if they momentarily pretend to be Oakmoor in order to keep hope alive.
The story culminates in a dramatic and joyful turn of events. As they prepare to leave, Sarah goes into labor, and the family finds shelter in a barn where Donald assists in the birth of twins. The moment is intimate and triumphant, with the new babies signaling a fresh page for the family. Back at the castle, Oakmoor’s performance is declared the winner, though the members of St. Bernadette’s feel the show belongs to them, especially after the inspiring moments they shared. In the final act, Mr. Shakespeare and Roderick arrive at the barn, and as Mr. Poppy and the class sing another Christmas song for Donald, Sarah, and their newborn sons, the two brothers reach a quiet, meaningful reconciliation, deciding to bring the family together more often in the future.
Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! Timeline
Follow the complete movie timeline of Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! (2012) with every major event in chronological order. Great for understanding complex plots and story progression.
Donald and Sarah move to a new home
Donald and Sarah relocate to a new house, starting their life together while awaiting the baby. The move underscores Donald's anxious temperament and the fragile balance of the family.
Donald begins teaching at St. Bernadette's
He accepts a teaching post at St. Bernadette's Primary School, taking over the class formerly taught by Mr. Maddens. The headteacher Mrs Bevan is wary about the plan and worries that a smooth, qualified hand is needed to manage the entry to the competition.
Mr. Poppy guides the class in the interim
Mr. Poppy steps in to guide the class during the transition. His enthusiastic, childlike approach endears some students to him while unsettling the headteacher.
Dream of A Song for Christmas and the entry decision
The children dream of entering the national contest A Song for Christmas, hoping for prize money and a shot at Christmas number one. When the decision to enter is discussed, Mr. Poppy persuades Donald to sign the entry forms.
Donald's family shadows and Roderick's fame
Beneath Donald's quiet exterior lies a domineering father and his twin brother, Roderick, a world-famous conductor and composer. Roderick's prominence makes him a formidable rival in the music world.
A daring road trip to Castell Llawen
Mr. Poppy persuades Donald to sign the entry forms and then abducts him for an impromptu road trip toward Castell Llawen, where the Christmas Castle hosts the show. They set off with the aim of reaching the castle in time for the performance.
Rival choirs and the competition field
Roderick mentors a choir at St Cuthbert's College, while a rival class from Oakmoor School led by Mr. Shakespeare prepares its own entry. The stage is set for a high-stakes national contest.
Welsh journey and baby as passenger
Donald and Mr. Poppy guide the group through the wild Welsh countryside, facing fatigue, rushing rivers, and a baby smuggled into the journey as a tiny passenger. The journey tests their resolve and teamwork.
Arrival at the Christmas Castle and reunions
The group reaches the castle in Castell Llawen in time for the performance. Donald is reunited with Sarah, and Mr. Poppy is reunited with Mrs. Bevan.
Roderick hijacks the competition
Roderick steals the baby and part of Mr. Shakespeare's song, and traps Mr. Poppy and the class inside a giant snow globe, attempting to disqualify them. The sabotage tests the group's resilience and unity.
Allies step in and two songs lift spirits
Mr. Shakespeare's class and other students step in to help the stranded group, and Mrs. Bevan works to recover the baby. St. Bernadette's delivers two heartfelt songs, even when briefly pretending to be Oakmoor to keep hope alive.
Birth of twins and family shelter
Sarah goes into labor, and the family finds shelter in a barn where Donald helps bring the twins into the world. The birth marks a joyous turning point for the family.
Final acts and quiet reconciliation
Oakmoor is declared the winner at the castle, but the St. Bernadette's team feel the show belongs to them because of the moments they shared and their resilience. The crowd's goodwill and emotional triumph linger after the announcement.
Reunion and reconciliation
Mr. Shakespeare and Roderick arrive at the barn, and Mr. Poppy and the class sing another Christmas song for Donald, Sarah, and their newborn sons. The brothers reach a quiet, meaningful reconciliation and vow to keep the family together more often.
Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! Characters
Explore all characters from Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! (2012). Get detailed profiles with their roles, arcs, and key relationships explained.
Donald Peterson (David Tennant)
An anxious but dedicated teacher who has just moved to a new home with his pregnant wife, hoping to provide stability for his students. He carries the weight of a domineering father and the shadow of his famous twin brother, Roderick, which fuels a quiet inner conflict. Throughout the journey, he learns to trust his colleagues and the students, balancing professional responsibility with family duty.
Sarah Peterson (Joanna Page)
Donald’s pregnant wife who anchors the family with warmth and resolve. She supports Donald through his anxieties and plays a crucial role in keeping the family united as everything unfolds. Her presence grounds the chaos of the adventure and highlights the resilience of family life during Christmas-time.
Mr. Poppy (Marc Wootton)
An enthusiastic, childlike teaching assistant who brings joy and spontaneity to the class. His exuberance sometimes leads to impulsive decisions, like orchestrating the spontaneous road trip, but his heart is in the right place as he inspires the children to believe in themselves.
Mrs. Bevan (Pam Ferris)
The headteacher who guards the school’s discipline and tradition. She worries about Mr. Poppy’s ability to keep order but ultimately supports the kids’ creative spirit, recognizing the need for courage and responsible leadership during a high-stakes competition.
Gordon Shakespeare (Jason Watkins)
A world-famous composer whose fame looms large as a rival, fueling the competition against Donald’s class. He embodies the pressure of prestige and the desire to win, acting as a foil that tests the other characters’ loyalty and creativity.
Mr. Shakespeare (Jason Watkins)
A rival teacher from Oakmoor who leads his own choir and represents the formal, rule-bound side of the competition. His presence heightens the stakes and pushes the others to prove themselves, emphasizing discipline and teamwork.
Roderick Peterson (David Tennant)
Donald’s twin brother, a world-renowned conductor whose success casts a long shadow. His confidence and competitive drive drive the rivalry, creating tension within the family while also providing a powerful motivator for Donald to rise to the challenge.
Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! Settings
Learn where and when Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! (2012) takes place. Explore the film’s settings, era, and how they shape the narrative.
Time period
Contemporary
The events unfold during a modern Christmas season, with the everyday pressures of school life, family dynamics, and community competition. It blends present-day family relations with a traditional holiday quest, giving the story a current-but-festive sensibility. The journey to the castle is paced to fit a contemporary family adventure, complete with a countdown to the performance.
Location
St. Bernadette's Primary School, Castell Llawen, Wales
The story centers around a small-town primary school and a magical-sounding Welsh setting. Castell Llawen becomes the destination for a high-stakes road trip to a festive castle, turning rugged hills and rivers into a dramatic backdrop. The school environment contrasts with the grand Christmas Castle, highlighting how a community pulls together for a common goal.
Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! Themes
Discover the main themes in Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! (2012). Analyze the deeper meanings, emotional layers, and social commentary behind the film.
🎄
Family
Family bonds drive the narrative, from the struggle between Donald and his father to the reconciliation with his twin brother. The pregnancy and birth of the twins anchor the emotional arc, grounding the film in love, responsibility, and growth. The story shows how family members pull together, even when tensions rise.
🧭
Adventure
The journey to Castell Llawen throws the group into a series of tests—rushing rivers, rugged terrain, and time pressure—to reach the Christmas Castle. The adventure emphasizes teamwork, improvisation, and resilience as the class and volunteers push through fatigue. The road trip becomes a catalyst for character development as they rely on one another.
🏆
Competition
A Song for Christmas frames the central contest, pitting St. Bernadette's against rival groups. The stakes bring out ambition, clever tactics, and rivalries among teachers and choirs. The competition tests integrity and cooperation as the characters navigate sabotage and pride.
🤝
Reconciliation
Despite tensions, the narrative builds toward reconciliation—between Donald and his brother, between Mr. Poppy and Mrs. Bevan, and within the extended family. The climactic revelations and the birth of twins catalyze a renewed sense of unity. The final songs affirm that collaboration and forgiveness can triumph over rivalry.
Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! Spoiler-Free Summary
Discover the spoiler-free summary of Nativity 2: Danger in the Manger! (2012). Get a concise overview without any spoilers.
In the sleepy town of St. Bernadette’s, a modest primary school prepares for its most ambitious undertaking yet: the National “Song for Christmas” competition. The contest promises fame, a cash prize, and the coveted spot at the top of the holiday charts, turning an ordinary school term into a whirlwind of rehearsals, decorations, and seasonal anticipation. Against this backdrop of jingling ambition, the school’s community buzzes with the kind of chaotic energy that only a Christmas project can inspire.
Donald Peterson arrives fresh from a nervous relocation, clutching a teaching contract and a bundle of hopes for his new role. By his side is his expectant wife, Sarah, whose growing belly mirrors the school’s swelling excitement. Their unlikely ally, the exuberant teaching assistant Mr. Desmond Poppy, brings a childlike enthusiasm that borders on reckless, while headteacher Mrs. Bevan watches the plans unfold with a blend of cautious oversight and hidden delight. Adding further intrigue, Roderick, Donald’s celebrated twin brother, looms as a contrasting figure of success, and Mr. Shakespeare, a rival educator from a neighboring school, quietly sets the stage for friendly competition.
The story’s heart beats in the adventurous “road‑trip” that beckons the class to Wales, where the competition’s final showdown awaits. What begins as a simple entry into a festive contest quickly blossoms into a journey filled with unexpected hurdles, comedic mishaps, and moments that test the courage of both pupils and teachers. Along the way, the group discovers that the true challenge lies not just in hitting the right notes, but in uniting a diverse cast of personalities under the warm glow of Christmas spirit.
Amid the frosty hills and twinkling lights, the narrative promises a blend of heartfelt humor and seasonal wonder. Hints of a memorable birth and a very special donkey add a whimsical touch, ensuring that the film’s tone remains light, hopeful, and unmistakably festive, inviting audiences to revel in the chaos and charm of a holiday adventure that’s as much about family and friendship as it is about music.
Featured on this page
What's After the Movie?
Not sure whether to stay after the credits? Find out!
Explore Our Movie Platform
New Movie Releases (2025)
Famous Movie Actors
Top Film Production Studios
Movie Plot Summaries & Endings
Major Movie Awards & Winners
Best Concert Films & Music Documentaries
Movie Collections and Curated Lists
© 2025 What's After the Movie. All rights reserved.