City of Ashes 2019

Clary returns to the Institute after a distressing text from Isabelle “Izzy” Lightwood, and discovers that Jace has angered the Inquisitor, Imogen Herondale, landing him in the Silent City and awaiting a trial by the legendary Soul Sword. The Sword, one of the Mortal Instruments alongside the Cup and the Mirror, is a weapon that compels truth from those it touches, while Valentine’s ruthless pursuit leads him to kill the Silent Brothers in his bid to obtain it. The setup hinges on a dangerous test of loyalty: is Jace really aligned with Valentine, or is there another truth waiting to be uncovered?

A rescue squad forms quickly. Clary, Izzy, and Alec rush to the Silent City only to arrive after the critical moment passes. Clary’s desperate bid to release Jace succeeds when she uses an amplified opening rune that she sees in a sudden surge of panic. The Inquisitor arrives on the scene with a unit of Shadowhunters and accuses Jace of aiding Valentine, intensifying the stakes of the confrontation. In this tense moment, Magnus Bane is called to help, and he offers a practical solution—keep Jace as a prisoner in his apartment while the team uncovers Valentine’s broader plan. Magnus and Alec have grown closer, even sharing a date, a development noted as part of the Bane Chronicles, a companion book that expands their story.

Political intrigue and uneasy alliances surface. Jace then receives an offer from the Queen of the Seelie to visit her court, where the group hopes to win her aid against Valentine. The Seelie Queen hints at hidden knowledge and secrets about their parentage, suggesting that Jace and Clary might be the products of their fathers’ experiments. The group leaves, but Clary’s faerie encounter changes the course of their journey: she is tricked into eating faerie food and can only depart by kissing “whom she most desires.” Simon offers to kiss her, but the Queen reveals he is not the person she desires most, a revelation that hurts because Clary has been wrestling with her growing feelings for Jace, even as she tries to date Simon to move on.

A charged moment shifts the relationship. After a tense debate, Izzy encourages Clary to consider a kiss from Jace as the one she desires, and in a pivotal, charged moment, Jace kisses Clary. The kiss is powerful enough to free Clary from the Seelie influence, triggering a cascade of emotions: Jace and Clary confess their love, while Clary grapples with the taboo of their sibling bond. The emotional tension is thick, and the idea of keeping their relationship a secret is weighed against the risk of exposure to their friends and family.

Vampires, wolves, and demons crash the scene. The crisis deepens when Raphael the vampire arrives with a gravely injured Simon, who had previously ingested vampire blood as a rat, leading him to a terrifying delusion of turning. Simon’s mortal peril ends with his turning into a vampire, and a grieving Clary must face the reality of his new, daylit condition. The defense of their home becomes a shared task as Maia the werewolf arrives badly wounded, and Luke is left to contend with demons that attack the Institute. Magnus heals Maia, while Luke investigates outside and is attacked himself. The demons retreat only after Clary’s rune on her forearm—gained in a dream of her mother blessing her—signals their power.

A mysterious rune and a dangerous plan unfold. The group gathers to discuss the meaning of Clary’s formidable rune and the possibility that runes must be angel-crafted, which leads Clary to attempt another new rune, this time a “Fearless” rune inspired by Jace. They test it on Alec, and the family arrives—Alec’s dating of a Downworlder becomes a topic of quiet suspense as Magnus defuses the moment. The night ends with a decision to sleep, but Jace secretly takes Raphael’s motorcycle and rides to a ship where Valentine waits, offering protection for his loved ones in exchange for Jace’s return to Idris.

A deadly trade and a high-stakes rescue. The next morning, the Inquisitor, aware of the secret meeting, imprisons Jace again and lays out a plan to trade Jace’s life for the Sword. Jace insists the plan won’t work, but the Inquisitor remains determined to exact revenge on Valentine, who killed her son, Stephen Herondale. Meanwhile, Maia is abducted after Valentine’s demons attack her, and Clary, with help from Magnus, rescues Maia. Valentine drains Simon’s blood, and Jace uses his own power to revive him by giving him his blood, restoring life to Simon just as danger closes in again. The Inquisitor appears once more but dies heroically, her change of heart evident in her last act to shield Jace from a demon.

A father’s threat and a fateful confrontation. Valentine’s demons capture Clary at his boat, and on the ship he taunts her with the Soul Sword. Jace and Simon mount a daring rescue, and Valentine concedes a painful truth: Jace chose to fight on Clary’s side because of his love for her—love that transcends the familial bond they share. The demon that appears to Jace as what he fears most—in this case, Clary dying—drives him to continued action and killing. Clary’s improvised opening rune etches across the ship’s metal, causing the ship to implode. Clary falls into the river but is saved by nixies sent by the Queen to aid them. The group escapes in a truck, and Simon learns that Jace’s blood has transformed him into a Daylighter, able to withstand sunlight.

Love, risk, and a difficult truth. A reflective conversation with Luke about love and the pain of not confessing his feelings to Clary’s mother complicates the emotional landscape. Clary resolves to tell Jace of her love for him and her willingness to pursue a relationship despite the consequences, only to be met with a painful honesty from Jace: he will only act as her brother from that point on, effectively ending their romantic possibility and leaving Clary heartbroken. The story closes on a haunting note as a mysterious woman appears, claiming she knows how to wake Clary’s mother, Jocelyn, hinting at future twists and unresolved secrets in this tangled world.