What Is Can of Worms About?
The premise of Can of Worms in 360 words, with nothing given away. The full story follows below.
In a world where the extraordinary can erupt from a simple teenage impulse, a high‑school junior finds his ordinary life upended the moment he fires a desperate broadcast into the cosmos. The message, sent from a makes‑do satellite dish on a quiet suburban night, promises more than a fleeting glimpse of starlight; it opens a doorway for beings from far beyond Earth’s atmosphere to step into his world. The tone blends off‑beat humor with the restless energy of adolescence, setting a stage where teenage worries collide with intergalactic curiosity.
Mike Pillsbury is a lanky, introspective teen who’s never quite felt at home on the football field or in the expectations of his former‑star father. He spends his days wrestling with the feeling that he belongs among the stars rather than the bleachers, and his nights haunted by a vision that hints at something larger. Across the hallway, Katelyn Sandman dazzles as the popular girl who reaches out with a genuine invitation to help with school festivities, offering Mike a brief respite from his inner turbulence. Their budding connection hints at the possibility of grounding amidst the chaos that threatens to spill over their small town.
When the cosmos finally answers, the first visitor is an eccentric alien canine named Barnabus, who communicates through a quirky translating device and claims to represent a galaxy‑wide relief organization. He arrives with a bewildering entourage: a no‑nonsense alien lawyer demanding compensation for Earth’s “substandard living conditions,” and a laid‑back alien who offers to act as Mike’s interstellar representative. Their presence is both absurd and oddly sincere, infusing the story with a playful sci‑fi charm while underscoring the teenage protagonist’s struggle to make sense of a universe that suddenly feels far closer than ever.
The film balances earnest teenage coming‑of‑age moments with a light‑hearted, otherworldly spectacle. It teases the wonder of a stargate opening over a quiet suburb, the strain of parental expectations, and the thrill of unexpected companionship. Amidst the laughter and looming uncertainty, the story invites viewers to wonder what happens when a teen’s cry for connection echoes across the stars, and whether the answer will reshape his place on Earth—or beyond it.
What Happens in Can of Worms?
The complete story of Can of Worms, from the first scene to the last, in 731 words (about 3 minutes). Spoilers throughout.
Spoilers ahead
Mike Pillsbury [Michael Shulman] is a teenage boy who believes that he is an alien and does not belong on Earth. He is injured during a football game and has a vision of an alien, which makes him question whether football is the right fit for him. His father, a former football star, urges him to persevere, adding pressure to conform to expectations even as Mike feels out of place.
Katelyn Sandman [Erika Christensen], a popular girl at school, reaches out to Mike for help decorating the upcoming Halloween dance. Their budding connection lightens Mike’s mood, but trouble arrives when his rival, Scott Schriebner [Marcus Turner], a football teammate and Katelyn’s friend, sabotages the dance’s light and music setup. The party falls into mayhem, and a frustrated Mike storms off, sending a desperate message into space via a satellite dish in hopes of being rescued. A bolt of lightning then destroys the dish, leaving his plea unanswered and isolating him further.
The next day, an alien dog named Barnabus [Malcolm McDowell] appears, speaking through a translating device. He reveals that, because of Mike, a stargate door has been opened. Barnabus explains that he represents a galactic disaster-relief organization and that he has arrived to take Mike off Earth. He warns that time is limited, as other aliens with ulterior motives are traveling through the stargate in search of Mike.
Mike’s reality becomes even stranger when The Bom [Bruce Lanoil], an alien lawyer, materializes with a blunt demand: sue Earth for millions of galactic credits for pain and suffering due to the planet’s alleged substandard living conditions. During a phone call with Katelyn, Mike finds himself distracted by The Bom’s odd eating habits, which convinces Katelyn that he’s not listening to her. The Bom leaves in a fury after Mike refuses to pursue a lawsuit. Nick [Adam Wylie], Mike’s friend, becomes convinced that his buddy is losing his grip on reality, especially as more alien visitors arrive.
Barnabus informs Mike that he opened a “can of worms” by sending his space message, signaling that Earth has progressed technologically and might lose its protection as a primitive planet. Despite the danger, Barnabus offers to take Mike somewhere far away to be alone, but first Mike tries to repair things with Katelyn. The Loafer Alien [Wally Wingert] interrupts this moment, proposing to act as Mike’s galactic representative and even suggesting a reality-TV future for his life as an immigrant. Mike declines the offer.
A flood of alien visitors arrives with offers for Mike, disorienting him further. Katelyn visits him and learns about the strange visitors, and Mike becomes determined to find a way off the planet. Just then, a Thoad — a dangerous alien known for capturing specimens — approaches, complicating matters. Nick’s younger brother Jay [Andrew Ducote] is suddenly pulled into the stargate and taken to the Thoad’s home planet, triggering Barnabus’s warning that the Thoad will keep abducting beings until he finds the perfect specimen.
To protect Mike, the children enlist Scott as bait to lure the Thoad through the stargate. Scott is initially skeptical, but the kids convince him that he’s the key they need. Barnabus and the others manage to slip through the stargate along with the three children, landing in a cave that houses the Thoad’s zoo of captured species from across the galaxy. Among the captives is an alien that resembles the ones Mike had imagined, hinting at a shared memory or knowledge he didn’t fully understand.
The Thoad, in his human guise, confronts Barnabus and the group. He shifts into his frog-like alien form but is briefly contained within a cage. Mike uses the Thoad’s key to release the imprisoned specimens, including Scott and Jay. Barnabus and the kids return to Earth, but the stargate remains open long enough for the Thoad to pursue them. Barnabus calls in intergalactic police to arrest the Thoad. As the police arrive just before the Thoad can drag Mike into the stargate, Barnabus emits a decisive bark that signals the moment of capture.
Back on Earth, during a football game, Barnabus informs Mike that the transmission he sent was deemed accidental and Earth regains its status as a protected planet. Though Barnabus offers to take Mike with him, Mike chooses to stay on Earth, saying farewell to his unusual but enduring friend and returning to the life and home he loves.
Can of Worms Timeline: Every Key Event in Order
14 key events in the order they happen, from “Football injury and alien sighting” to “Homecoming and choice to stay on Earth”. 14 events name a place, across 11 locations.
- 1
Football injury and alien sighting
During a high school football game, Mike Pillsbury is injured and briefly sees an alien figure as a hallucination. The sighting unsettles him and fuels his belief that he doesn’t belong on Earth. His father urges him to stick with football despite the doubt.
When:During the game Where:High school football field
- 2
Halloween party setup and sabotage
Katelyn Sandman asks Mike to help decorate the upcoming Halloween dance, pulling him into school social life. Scott Schriebner sabotages the light and music equipment, ruining the party mood. Mike leaves the event frustrated, questioning his place on Earth.
When:Halloween party night Where:School gym
- 3
Distress call to outer space and dish destruction
Upset about the party, Mike uses a satellite dish to send a message to space asking to be rescued. A lightning strike soon afterward destroys the dish, leaving him without a way to contact the stars. The incident deepens Mike’s isolation and desperation.
When:The day after the Halloween party Where:Mike's home
- 4
Barnabus arrives and explains the stargate
An alien dog named Barnabus appears and speaks through a translating device. He explains that Mike’s message opened a stargate and that a galactic organization handles disaster relief and rights violations. Time is limited as other aliens begin moving through the gate to find Mike.
When:Shortly after the dish incident Where:Earth (Mike's location)
- 5
The Bom demands a galactic lawsuit
The Bom, an alien lawyer, insists Mike sue Earth for millions of galactic credits for pain and suffering. Mike is wary and refuses to cooperate, angering The Bom. The encounter highlights how alien interest in Mike’s situation is multiplying.
When:Following Barnabus' arrival Where:Earth
- 6
Friends' disbelief and Katelyn's awareness
Mike's friend Nick worries that he is going crazy after hearing about aliens. A telephone call with Katelyn makes her realize that Mike is distracted by real extraterrestrial activity. The normal life at school and home feels increasingly fragile.
When:After The Bom's visit Where:Mike's house / school
- 7
Earth's protection status threatened
Barnabus informs Mike that opening the message has signaled Earth’s advancement and, as a result, Earth is no longer eligible for intergalactic protection for primitive life. Mike faces a hard choice about leaving or staying. He weighs the safety of the Earth against his own need for escape.
When:After The Bom encounter Where:Earth
- 8
Loafer Alien offers a deal
The Loafer Alien arrives and proposes becoming Mike’s agent, potentially letting him star in a weekly TV show about his life as an immigrant. Mike declines, preferring to stay grounded on Earth. Barnabus and the others watch, signaling a shifting dynamic in the alien offers.
When:Shortly after Barnabus' warning Where:Earth
- 9
Aliens arrive with options; Katelyn learns
Several aliens materialize, each offering different terms for Mike’s future. Katelyn visits Mike’s house and becomes aware of the extraterrestrials, complicating his desire to disappear from Earth. The scene builds tension as Mike contemplates an escape.
When:Following Loafer's appearance Where:Mike's house
- 10
Thoad arrives and uses Scott as bait
A dangerous Thoad appears and hunting for specimens. The kids urge Scott to act as bait to lure the Thoad through the stargate, convincing him he’s the perfect target. Scott agrees, sealing another stage of the plan to reach the alien world.
When:Moment the Thoad arrives Where:Earth
Show the other 4 events of Can of Worms Hide the last 4 events
- 11
Stargate voyage and Thoad's zoo
The stargate opens and pulls in Barnabus, the three children, and Scott as they pass through to the Thoad planet. They arrive in a cave where the Thoad keeps a zoo of captured species, including an alien resembling Mike’s imagined creature. The tension rises as the group confronts the Thoad.
When:Across the stargate opening Where:Thoad planet – cave
- 12
Mike frees the captives
The Thoad fights back, but Mike uses the Thoad’s key to release the captured specimens, including Scott and Jay. The freed aliens and humans join the effort to escape. Barnabus monitors Earth’s response as the group edges toward home.
When:During the confrontation on Thoad planet Where:Thoad dungeon
- 13
Intergalactic police arrest the Thoad
Barnabus contacts intergalactic police, who arrest the Thoad before he can capture more specimens. The stargate threat to Earth is neutralized, and the barrier of protection seems to be restored or reset. The team begins their journey back to Earth.
When:After the rescue on Thoad planet Where:Earth and Thoad planet
- 14
Homecoming and choice to stay on Earth
Back at a football game, Barnabus informs Mike that his transmission was accidental and Earth is again classified as protected. Barnabus offers to take Mike away, but Mike chooses Earth as his home and says farewell. The story closes with Mike embracing his life on Earth.
When:End of story Where:Football stadium
Who Are the Main Characters in Can of Worms?
18 characters, among them Mike Pilsbury (Mike Pillsbury) — Michael Shulman, Barnabus and The Bom: who each one is and the part they play in the story. Every profile links to the actor’s page.
- MP
Mike Pilsbury (Mike Pillsbury) — Michael Shulman
Played by Michael Shulman
A teenage boy who feels alienated and questions his place on Earth. He triggers the central conflict by signaling for rescue, forcing him to confront his identity and home. He must decide whether to flee or stay connected to his friends and life on Earth.
- 👽 Alienated
- 🧑🎓 Teen
- 🏈 Football
- 🧭 Identity
-
Barnabus
Played by Malcolm McDowell
An alien dog with a translator who arrives to respond to Mike's plea. He represents a galactic relief organization and explains Earth’s temporary status in intergalactic protection. He provides guidance while navigating the complexities of alien bureaucracy.
- 🐶 Alien
- 🧭 Protector
- 🌌 Intergalactic
- TB
The Bom
Played by Bruce Lanoil
An alien lawyer who insists on having Mike sue Earth for galactic credits. His presence introduces legalistic coercion and the satirical critique of entitlement. He departs after Mike refuses the demand, highlighting competing motives among aliens.
- ⚖️ Lawyer
- 💰 Exploitation
- 👁️🗨️ Manipulation
-
Katelyn Sandman
Played by Erika Christensen
A popular school girl who asks Mike for help decorating the Halloween dance, drawing him into the social centerpiece of teen life. Her perspective shifts as she becomes aware of the aliens and the danger surrounding Mike. She embodies the tension between teen romance and extraordinary events.
- 👩🎓 Popular
- 💃 Social life
- 💖 Teen romance
- N
Nick
Played by Adam Wylie
Mike’s friend who doubts his sanity but remains supportive at times. He reacts to the alien happenings with fear and skepticism, acting as a counterbalance to Mike’s earnest belief. His reactions help ground the story in a teen friendship dynamic.
- 🧑🤝🧑 Friend
- 🧭 Skeptic
- 🕵️♂️ Loyal
- SS
Scott Schriebner
Played by Marcus Turner
A football teammate and friend who initially becomes involved in the chaos surrounding Mike. He embodies peer pressure and the desire to fit in with a crowd while facing extraordinary circumstances. He helps drive the plan to use bait for the Thoad.
- 🏈 Teammate
- 🧭 Loyalty
- 👀 Observer
- J
Jay
Played by Andrew Ducote
A younger friend whose sudden entrapment by the Thoad escalates the stakes. He’s an innocent casualty in the galaxy-spanning pursuit, prompting the others to act. His capture intensifies the urgency of the intergalactic conflict.
- 👦 Young Friend
- 💥 Catalyst
- TL
The Loafer Alien
Played by Wally Wingert
An extraterrestrial agent who proposes himself as Mike’s agent, offering a glamorous but uncertain future in the galaxy. He embodies temptation and the lure of escape from Earthly life. His presence adds a layer of risk and speculative entertainment.
- 👽 Alien
- 🎭 Illusion
- 🕴️ Agent
- TT
The Thoad
Played by J.D. Hall
A dangerous alien predator who captures specimens, including Scott and Jay, and pursues Mike. The Thoad embodies threat and exploitation, acting as the primary antagonist within the intergalactic plot. His human form transitions to an alien in pursuit of worthy specimens.
- 👹 Predator
- 🗃️ Captor
- TM
Thoad Man
Played by Hrothgar Mathews
The humanoid persona of the Thoad, portrayed physically by a separate actor who embodies the menace of the creature. The dual nature of the Thoad emphasizes disguise and danger across forms. His confrontations with Barnabus escalate the crisis.
- 👾 Villain
- 🪰 Transformation
- TJ
The Jarm
Played by David Coburn
A mysterious alien figure whose presence adds to the intergalactic intrigue. The Jarm communicates the broader politics of space and the varying motivations of extraterrestrials in the story. His role contributes to the sense of a larger universe beyond Earth.
- 🛸 Enigma
- 🗳️ Intergalactic politics
- DP
Dana Pillsbury
Played by Garrett M. Brown
Mike’s father, a former football player who urges Mike to stay with the sport. He represents parental influence and the pressure to conform to family expectations. His stance anchors the domestic side of Mike’s life.
- 👨👦 Family
- 🏈 Sports culture
- PP
Pamela Pillsbury
Played by Lee Garlington
Mike’s mother, part of the Pillsbury household, who interacts with the family during the unfolding events. She provides a domestic vantage point amid intergalactic chaos. She helps illustrate the ordinary life Mike would risk leaving behind.
- 👩👧 Family
- 🏡 Home life
- JP
Jill Pillsbury
Played by Brighton Hertford
A member of the Pillsbury family who contributes to the school and home environment. She represents the extended family’s role in Mike’s life. Her presence grounds the story in a familiar family unit.
- 👧 Family
- 🏡 Domestic life
- CT
Coach Trembly
Played by Terry David Mulligan
The football coach who embodies sports discipline and the pressure to pursue athletic success. His interactions with Mike highlight the conflict between ambition and personal well-being. He serves as a figure of authority in Mike’s school life.
- 🏈 Coach
- 👨🏫 Authority
- IC
Inter-Galactic Cop
Played by Peter Kelamis
An officer who enforces intergalactic law and coordinates with Barnabus to resolve the crisis. He represents order and regulation beyond Earth’s borders. His presence signals a higher authority overseeing the interstellar events.
- 👮♂️ Authority
- 🛰️ Intergalactic law
- MN
Mrs. Nickerson
Played by Marie Stillin
A teacher or community figure who contributes to the school’s social fabric and student concerns. She helps depict the environment Mike operates within beyond his family and friends. Her role reinforces the everyday setting of the story.
- 👩🏫 Educator
- 🏫 School life
- NF
Nick's Friend (Jessica Murdoch)
Played by Jessica Murdoch
A friend of Katelyn’s who becomes aware of the alien happenings and supports the group’s awareness. She represents the other teens who are drawn into the extraordinary events by proximity and curiosity.
- 👭 Friend
- 🧭 Discovery
Where and When Is Can of Worms Set?
Can of Worms is set in Earth and Thoad's home planet (Late 1990s). Here is why the time and place matter to the story.
When
Late 1990s
The events unfold in a present-day timeframe consistent with late-1990s teen life and technology. A satellite dish and ordinary school life anchor the story in this era, while sci-fi elements intrude. The blend creates a contemporary backdrop for extraordinary encounters.
Where
Earth, Thoad's home planet
Most of the story takes place on Earth, in a suburban setting centered on a high school and a football environment. The Halloween dance and Predator-like interludes bring a sense of everyday life punctured by science-fiction events. Intergalactic travel occurs through a stargate, revealing a separate alien world—the Thoad’s home planet.
- 🌍 Earth
- 👽 Alien contact
- 🗺️ Intergalactic travel
What Are the Themes of Can of Worms?
3 ideas the story keeps returning to, among them Identity, Friendship and Power & Exploitation.
-
01
Identity
Mike grapples with belonging and self-definition, torn between feeling human and believing he is alien. The alien visits and the stargate force him to question what 'home' really means. His choice to remain on Earth at the end underscores a reconciled sense of self.
-
02
Friendship
Katelyn, Nick, and Scott anchor Mike during chaotic events, offering support and loyalty under pressure. The relationships are tested when extraordinary forces pull the group in different directions. Trust becomes crucial as aliens make offers and promises, challenging genuine connection.
-
03
Power & Exploitation
The Bom's push to sue Earth for galactic credits highlights manipulation and coercive power in a moral vacuum. Alien politics and protection status hinge on leverage and negotiation. Earth’s interaction with intergalactic authorities becomes a battleground between exploitation and defense.
What Kind of Film Is Can of Worms?
Whimsical in tone, with fast pacing and a moderate story, going by the plot summary.
- Tone
- Whimsical
- Pacing
- Fast
- Story
- Moderate
- Intensity
- Medium
- Ending
- Happy
A quirky and lighthearted sci-fi adventure that follows a misfit teen's whirlwind encounter with eccentric aliens, blending high school drama with a playful, low-stakes galactic rescue mission.
- whimsical
- quirky
- lighthearted
- adventurous
- silly
- nostalgic
- coming of age
- aliens
- first contact
- friendship
Content notes: child endangerment, mild peril.
Quiz
How well do you remember Can of Worms? Test yourself on the story.
